HomeMy WebLinkAboutCouncil Information Memorandum 05-17-2018CITY OF PLYMOUTH
COUNCIL INFO MEMO
May 17, 2018
EVENTS / MEETINGS
Housing & Redevelopment Authority Agenda for May 24th .................................... Page 2
Official City Meeting Calendars .................................................................... Page 3
Tentative List of Agenda Items ..................................................................... Page 6
CORRESPONDENCE
Preliminary Population and Household Estimates from the Metropolitan Council .......... Page 9
Police K9 Unit Earns Top Honors during Statewide Narcotics Certification ................ Page 13
City Accepting Applications for Public Safety Citizens Academy ........................... Page 14
Plant Swap Set for June 4th ...................................................................... Page 15
REPORTS & OTHER ARTICLES OF INTEREST
4 Economic Trends That Will Impact Industrial Real Estate, BisNow ....................... Page 16
Pentagon Park's Uncertain Future Could Be Decided This Week
at Edina Planning Commission, Minneapolis/St. Paul Business Journal ................. Page 20
Apartment Boom Reaches 7th Inning, According to Guy Who
Would Know, Minneapolis/St. Paul Business Journal ....................................... Page 22
Minnesota Legislation Would Cut Funding for Job Creation, Finance & Commerce ...... Page 23
Recycling, Once Embraced by Businesses and Environmentalists,
Now Under Siege, Wall Street Journal ....................................................... Page 26
Mosaic Co Moving Headquarters to Florida, Minneapolis/St. Paul Business Journal ..... Page 31
MEETING AGENDA
PLYMOUTH HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
THURSDAY, MAY 24, 2018 - 7:00 p.m.
WHERE: Medicine Lake Room
City of Plymouth
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, MN 55447
CONSENT AGENDA
All items listed on the Consent Agenda are considered to be routine by the
Housing and Redevelopment Authority and will be enacted by one motion.
There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Commissioner,
citizen or petitioner so requests, in which event the item will be removed
from the consent agenda and considered in normal sequence on the agenda.
1. CALL TO ORDER - 7:00 P.M.
2. CONSENT AGENDA
A. Approve HRA Meeting Minutes for April 24, 2018.
B. Plymouth Towne Square. Accept Monthly Housing Reports.
C. Vicksburg Crossing. Accept Monthly Housing Reports.
3. NEW BUSINESS
A. Project-Based Units – Request For Proposals. Award six project-based
units for the Sand Development, LLC project and ten project-based units
for the Beacon Interfaith project and authorize executive of HUD-52531-
A – Agreement to Enter Into Housing Assistance Payments Contract for
new construction.
B. Beacon Interfaith Housing Collaborative. Consider financial assistance
for the Cranberry Ridge development.
4. ADJOURMENT
Page 2
SUN MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
May 2018
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, MN 55447 OFFICIAL CITY CALENDAR Phone: 763-509-5000
Fax: 763-509-5060
7:00 PM
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
7:00 PM
ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY
COMMITTEE
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
7:00 PM
PARK & REC
ADVISORY
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
7:00 PM
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
7:00 PM
HOUSING AND
REDEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
SUN TUES MON WED THUR FRI SAT
MEMORIAL DAY
CITY OFFICES
CLOSED
5:00 PM
SPECIAL COUNCIL
MEETING
Organics
Recycling/Ramada Site
Medicine Lake Room
7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL
MEETING
Council Chambers
6:00 PM
Walk with
the Mayor
Plymouth Creek
Center
5:00 PM
SPECIAL COUNCIL
MEETING
Fire Dept. Update
Medicine Lake Room
7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL
MEETING
Council Chambers
10:00 AM Bark in the Park
Hilde Performance
Center
8:00 AM-12:30 PM Plymouth Crime & Fire Prevention
Fund
Waffle Breakfast
Fire Station III
Page 3
SUN MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20
7:00 PM
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28
7:00 PM
HOUSING AND
REDEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
29 30
June 2018
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, MN 55447 OFFICIAL CITY CALENDAR Phone: 763-509-5000
Fax: 763-509-5060
5:30 PM
SPECIAL COUNCIL
MEETING
TwinWest Up-
date/Budget Goals
Medicine Lake Room
7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL
MEETING
Council Chambers
7:00 PM
ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY
COMMITTEE
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
7:00 PM
PARK & REC
ADVISORY
COMMISSION
MEETING
Plymouth Creek
Center
7:00 PM
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
SUN TUES MON WED THUR FRI SAT
CHANGES ARE NOTED IN RED
5:30 PM
SPECIAL COUNCIL
MEETING
State of the Streets in
Plymouth
Medicine Lake Room
7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL
MEETING
Council Chambers
Absentee Voting
begins for State
Primary Election
Page 4
SUN MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT
1 2 3 4
INDEPENDENCE
DAY
CITY OFFICES
CLOSED
5 6 7
8 9 10
11 12
13 14
15 16 17
18
7:00 PM
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
19 20 21
22 23 24
7:00 PM
REGULAR
COUNCIL MEETING
Council Chambers
25 26 27 28
29 30 31
July 2018
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, MN 55447 OFFICIAL CITY CALENDAR Phone: 763-509-5000
Fax: 763-509-5060
7:00 PM
ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY COMMITTEE
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
CITY COUNCIL
FILINGS OPEN
Mayor, At Large,
Ward 2 and Ward 4
SUN TUES MON WED THUR FRI SAT
7:00 PM
HOUSING AND
REDEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
5:30 PM - 10:30 PM
Music in Plymouth
Hilde
Performance Center
Page 5
Note: Special Meeting topics have been set by Council; all other topics are tentative.
EDA refers to the Economic Development Authority
Tentative Schedule for
City Council Agenda Items
June 12, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room
•TwinWest update
•Budget goals
June 12, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
•Presentation on Emerald Ash Borer
•Announcement of Music in Plymouth and 5k Run
•Public improvement and special assessment hearing for the Troy Lane reconstruction project
(ST180002)
June 26, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room
•State of the Streets in Plymouth
June 26, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
•Appoint election judges for the 2018 Primary and General Elections
•Public improvement and special assessment hearing for the 2018 Mill and Overlay project
(ST189004.002)
•Public improvement and special assessment hearing for the Fernbrook Lane Mill and Overlay
Project (ST180003)
July 24, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
•Present 2017 Comprehensive Financial Report (Aaron Nielson, from Malloy, Montague,
Karnowski, Radosevich & Co., PA)
•Present Certificate of Achievement for Financing Reporting for 2016
August 21, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room
•Budget and CIP
•If necessary, conduct regular meeting at 7 p.m. and then recess back to study session
August 28, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room
•Budget and CIP
August 28, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
September 4, Special, 6:00 p.m. Medicine Lake Room (if needed)
•Budget and CIP
September 11, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
•City Manager’s 2018 Financial Overview
•Consider 2019 proposed budget, preliminary general property tax levy, HRA levy and setting
budget public hearing date
September 25, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
October 9, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
Page 6
October 23, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
November 13, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room (if needed)
•Budget and CIP
November 13, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
•Canvass 2018 General Election results
November 27, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
December 11, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers
•Recognize Police Citizen Academy graduates
•Public hearing on 2019 budget, general property tax levy, HRA levy, and 2019-2023 Capital
Improvement Program
Page 7
BUDGET PROCESS
Budget Calendar
2018-2019 Biennial Budget Preparation & 5-yr Capital Improvement Plan
Date Category Description
April 23, 2018 Budget Departments receive budget instruction
June 12, 2018 Budget Council Study Session – Budget Goals
April – June 2018 Budget Departments prepare budgets
May 7, 2018 Budget Personnel changes submitted to HR
June 11, 2018 Budget Budgets submitted to Finance
July 9 – July 13, 2018 Budget Department meetings
August 10, 2017 Budget Council receives budget materials for upcoming meeting
August 21, 2018 Budget & CIP Council study session (Budget & CIP meeting #1)
August 28, 2018 Budget & CIP Council Study Session (Budget & CIP meeting #2)
Council Regular Session (Financial Overview)
September 4, 2018 Budget & CIP Council Study Session (Budget meeting #3) (if needed)
September 11, 2018 Budget Council adopts preliminary levies & budget (Budget meeting #4)
October 3, 2018 CIP Planning Commission public hearing
November 13, 2018 Budget Council Study Session (Budget meeting #5) (If needed)
December 11, 2018 Budget & CIP Budget Public Hearing, CIP, Budget & Levy Adoption
December 26, 2018 Budget Levy is certified with Hennepin County
Page 8
May 11,2018
Dave Callister, City Manager
City of Plymouth
3400 Plymouth Blvd
Plymouth, MN 55447-1482
Dear Mr. Callister:
The Metropolitan Council has prepared preliminary population and household estimates for your community as of
April 1,2017. This is an annual process governed by Minnesota Statutes 473.24. Please note that these estimates
are different from the Council's local forecasts that your community has reviewed before.Forecasts look ahead to
the coming decades; the annual estimates communicated below look back in time to the previous year.
2017 Annual Population Estimate
The Metropolitan Council estimates that the City of Plymouth had 76,882 people and 31,207 households as
of April 1,2017.Household size averaged 2.425 persons per household.
How was this estimate calculated?
We estimate households and population with a housing-stock-based method, which involves three questions:
1. How many housing units did your community have?
2. How many households occupied these housing units?
3. How many people lived in these occupied housing units?
This letter includes an overview of our estimation method along with a report showing the data inputs and
calculations used to develop the preliminary estimates. For more information,visit
https:i'www.metrocounciLurgi populationesumate>,or contact me at 651-602-1513.
Can this estimate be compared to last year's estimate?
Each year,we update our data and refine our methods, so preliminary estimates from different years are not
directly comparable. We don't recommend taking the difference between the 2016 and 2017 estimates to calculate
growth between 2016 and 2017. Instead, we recommend examining growth since the 2010 Census,which you can
find in the enclosed report.
How can my community provide feedback on this estimate?
We welcome discussion of the preliminary estimates and invite you to review and comment on them. Please send
any written comments or questions to Matt Schroeder,Metropolitan Council Research, 390 Robert Street North,
Saint Paul, MN 55101; or by e-mail to ',Ian Schroeder‘ci mete.state.mn.0-. Under Minnesota Statutes 473. 24, we
must receive your comments, questions, or specific objections, in writing, by June 24, 2018.
What happens after my community provides feedback?
The Council will certify final estimates by July 15, 2018 for state government use in allocating local government
aid and street aid.
Sincerely,
44416A-viS4/1-4076&----
Matt Schroeder
Senior Researcher
390 Robert Street North I Saint Paul, MN 55101-1805
P. 651.602.1000 I TTY. 651.291.0904 I metrocouncil.org METROPOLITAN
An Equal Opportunity Employer COUNCIL
Page 9
Plymouth city, Hennepin County
2017 Annual Population Estimate
Published May 11, 2018 (preliminary; distributed for local government review)
METROPOLITAN
COUNCIL
Persons per Population Population in
Housing units Occupancy rate Households household in households group quarters Total population
2017 32,181 96.97% 31,207 2.425 75,667 1,215 76,882
Estimate
2010 29,982 95.60% 28,663 2.423 69,448 1,128 70,576
Census
The Metropolitan Council estimates population using the housing stock method,which answers three main questions for each
community as of April 1, 2017.
First, how many housing units did the community have?
We start with housing units measured by the 2010 Census. then add units built between 2010 and 2016, based on permits
reported to us by communities. (Permit data are available on our website
https://stats.metc.state.mn.us/data_download/DD_start.aspx).)
o We assume that 95% of single-family detached units and 90% of townhome/duplex/triplex/quadplex units permitted in
2016 were completed and occupiable by April 1, 2017; the remainder are assumed to have been completed after that
date and will count toward next year's estimates (for April 1, 2018).
o Multifamily units permitted between 2010 and 2013 are assumed to be completed. Units permitted between 2014 and
2016 are counted only if they were open by April 1, 2017; the remaining units will count toward next year's estimates if
they were open by April 1. 2018. According to our records, Plymouth permitted 0 multifamily units in 2014 or 2015 that
were not open by April 1. 2017, and 0 units permitted in 2016 that were not open by April 1, 2017.
o Manufactured home data comes from our annual surveys of manufactured home park operators and local
governments.
o Data on other housing (boats, RVs, etc. used as housing) comes from the most recent American Community Survey
data; this housing is included in the estimates only if occupied.
We also examine other housing stock changes reported by communities. These include demolitions, building conversions
units added or lost), boundary changes (units annexed in or out), and other changes reported by city and township staff.
Housing stock Permitted and Other changes Housing stock
April 1, 2010 built since 2010 since 2010 April 1, 2017
Single-family detached 16,068 1,624 128 17,564
Townhome(Single-family attached) 5,032 140 0 5,172
Duplex/triplex/quadplex 700 16 2 714
Multifamily(5 or more units)8,122 •552 0 8,674
Alternative dwelling units(ADU) 0 0 0 0
Manufactured homes 60 57
Other units 0 0
Total 29,982 32,181
Page 10
Second, how many of these housing units were occupied by households?
Each housing type has an estimated occupancy rate. These data come from the most recent American Community Survey
estimates for housing units and households, decennial census data from the U.S. Census Bureau, and the U.S. Postal
Service.
Multiplying the lumber of housing units of each type by the occupancy rate yields the number of households(occupied
housing units).
Third, how many people lived in these occupied housing units?
Each housing type has an estimated average household size. These data come from the most recent American Community
Survey estimates of households and population in households as well as decennial census data from the U.S. Census
Bureau.
Multiplying the Number of households in each housing type by the average household size yields the population in
households.
Households
Housing stock Occupancy Occupied Persons per Population
April 1, 2017 rate housing units) household in households
Single-family detached 17,564 97.59% 17,141 2.621 44,932
Townhome(Single-family 5,172 97.60%5,048 2.621 13,232
attached)
Duplex/triplex/quadplex 714 95. 88% 685 2.471 1,692
Multifamily(5 or more units) 8,674 95.42%8,277 1.896 15,697
Alternative dwelling units(ADU) 0 95.42% 0 1.896 0
Manufactured homes 57 97.43% 56 2.030 114
Other units 0 N/A 0 2.520 0
Total 32,181 96.97% 31,207 2.425 75,667
To obtain the total population, we also add the number of residents in group quarters facilities.
These are residences that are not part of the standard housing market, such as college dormitories, nursing homes, prisons and
jails, and group homes. Data come from the Metropolitan Council's annual survey and the Minnesota Department of Human
Services.
Population Population in Total population
in households group quarters April 1, 2017
75,667 1,215 , 82
Due to rounding, not all estimates can be reproduced exactly from the above inputs.
For more information, see our methodology document, available from https://www.metrocouncil.org/populationestimates.
Page 11
Z-a-O a)i-i)W a) ouicOJZNa) (3 O ZaLoa)-aOclaiNtc'a E co as o a) ° a) 7 '-7---H.C30d2a) E ~ R - O E n (15a, W W C Q o 0) c cn (n 0 - U L u) -CCD20 - som a) c a0 0 i) m N mt c _c v v 0) a) °Q d o E C _c co E .m ° a) (1":” (7) °01
actZ
Z L1J Z a vL.x o D E c a) o ° 0 a) uiW1.. = O 0 0 N .N a L O O aa' o 3 `n O — ° a) c a c ° co 03
J = 12 o o 0 a) =
0 =
as03
co 0 a'. _... }
c w - 0 E as
c O
a)
0 z
0
o o
c4 U
cz
O a)
c
a) o c6
6 c O () C 0)Q N U) 0)
O.
a) . cn E .0 c o E ° as
co 0 I— o , U N
0
ca a) E p o D o
Z J
W
Z cIS L. a) O > c o f N
G
o
M0
I-- _ m
m
co a) c ca ai E o
0
L11 cz
C CLVCZQ. j up u) cn C U O a)
m °
a) (n _c a) C
A3 CD M
O U = V
p .a O N c cA - p
Q V O
@ as E U
E
u)o 0
c Too c E U _c c v
coD
O Z m ° O D U 1)
o _0° °
O as3
H -
Q
1c ZV O
O
yX z O
y IIN
O r--- co
O c O a)
03lGcna) (6 O C 0•
0) O O c
c c U
a) . a)
ca `J
v H v a) co
L c`a iv
0Z = = I-- C
10
C O N °
C C p 'C O C
C t^
cti C ^ Z = C
co + 0
0 U L U N L- ..Y 73 C u Yp , O
O
Z
W
cn O v m o c a) ° N
j r+ C
a) a Q •--•
p O a3
OQ
0 v/ ti M C N N O 5 ON -0 ,_ U n w -
Q Q +
L Q Q N d °
m o c +'
000ccL13
oO
0
C O a) L.Page 12
City of Plymouth
News Release
For Immediate Release
May 14, 2018
Contact: Sgt. Robert Topp
Plymouth Police Department
763-509-5189
rtopp@plymouthmn.gov
Plymouth Police K9 Unit earns top honors
during statewide narcotics certification
Plymouth, Minn. – The Plymouth Police Department K9 Unit recently earned top honors during the
annual statewide narcotics detection certification process, sponsored by the United States Police Canine
Association.
Plymouth Police Officers Matt Gliniany and Bill Dane, with respective K9 partners Stryker and Odie, took
home the First Place Department Team award at the competition – for the second consecutive year.
Gliniany and Stryker also earned the Third Place Overall award.
Officer Steve Larson, with K9 partner Knight, was paired with an Edina Police Department K9 team and
received the Second Place Region Team award.
A total of 106 city and county K9 teams from across Minnesota and beyond participated in this year’s
event, hosted by the Wright County Sheriff's Office.
The Plymouth Police Department K9 Unit consists of three teams, which are certified in narcotics
detection, agility, obedience, apprehension and tracking. The annual narcotics detection certification
process includes indoor and outdoor searches for substances such as marijuana, methamphetamine,
cocaine, crack and heroin.
In addition to regular patrol duties and special assignments, the K9 Unit is deployed to several hundred
incidents each year and provides assistance to other area law enforcement agencies throughout the
metro. K9 teams are also a fan favorite during appearances at community events, such as Music in
Plymouth and Plymouth on Parade.
Cutline: Plymouth Police Department K9 Unit earned high honors during the annual statewide narcotics
detection certification process. The K9 Unit consists of three teams, which are certified in narcotics
detection, agility, obedience, apprehension and tracking.
-30-
Page 13
City of Plymouth
News Release
For Immediate Release
May 15, 2018
Contact: Jim Long
Community Relations Officer
Plymouth Police Department
763-509-5135
jlong@plymouthmn.gov
Plymouth accepting applications for Public Safety Citizens Academy
Plymouth, Minn. – Plymouth Public Safety Department is accepting applications for the Public Safety
Citizens Academy – a free 36-hour, 12-week course geared toward expanding public knowledge of the
Plymouth Police and Fire Departments.
The 2018 Citizens Academy meets 6:30-9:30 p.m. Tuesdays, beginning Sept. 11.
Each week, a different aspect of policing will be featured through lectures and hands-on
demonstrations; one week will be dedicated to Fire Department operations. Topics include:
•Overview of the Police Department, including a tour
•Patrol operations
•Police tactics
•Opportunity to ride along with an officer
•Narcotics enforcement and trends in the community
•Conducting investigations
•Crime prevention
•SWAT
•Tour of the Hennepin County 911 Dispatch Center in Plymouth
The academy helps strengthen the partnership between public safety professionals and the community
by sharing information and promoting a better understanding of public safety services.
Applicants must be 18 years of age or older and live, work or own a business in Plymouth. All
participants must undergo a criminal background check.
For more information or to apply, contact Community Relations Officer Jim Long at 763-509-5135 or visit
plymouthmn.gov/citizensacademy.
-30-
Page 14
City of Plymouth
News Release
For Immediate Release
May 15, 2018
Contact: Paul Buck
City Forester
City of Plymouth
763-509-5944
pbuck@plymouthmn.gov
Plant swap set for June 4
Plymouth, Minn. – A free plant swap is set for 4:30-6:30 p.m. Monday, June 4 at the Plymouth
Maintenance Facility parking lot, 14900 23rd Ave. N.
Participants are encouraged to bring perennials and swap them for plants shared by others.
To get involved, participants should place extra plants in pots and label them with their common names.
Seeds and plant wares – pots, tools, books and the like – are also acceptable swap items.
For more information, call City Forester Paul Buck at 763-509-5944.
-30-
Page 15
Page 16
Page 17
Page 18
Page 19
Page 20
Page 21
Page 22
Page 23
Page 24
Page 25
WALL STREET JOURNAL May 13, 2018
Recycling, Once Embraced by Businesses
a nd Environmentalists, Now Under Siege
Local officials raise fees and send recyclables to landfills
as economics erode
Workers at Cal-Waste Recovery Systems pre-sort raw recycling. The company has been struggling
to sell its mixed-paper recycling to its usual customer, China. PHOTO: MAX WHITTAKER FOR THE
WALL STREET JOURNAL
Page 26
WALL STREET JOURNAL May 13, 2018
The U.S. recycling industry is breaking down.
Prices for scrap paper and plastic have collapsed, leading local officials across the country to
charge residents more to collect recyclables and send some to landfills. Used newspapers,
cardboard boxes and plastic bottles are piling up at plants that can't make a profit processing
them for export or domestic markets.
"Recycling as we know it isn't working," said James Warner, chief executive of the Solid Waste
M anagement Authority in Lancaster County, Pa. "There's always been ups and downs in the
m arket, but this is the biggest disruption that I can recall."
U.S. recycling programs took off in the 1990s as calls to bury less trash in landfills coincided
w ith China's demand for materials such as corrugated cardboard to feed its economic boom.
Shipping lines eagerly filled containers that had brought manufactured goods to the U.S. with
paper, scrap metal and plastic bottles for the return trip to China.
As cities aggressively expanded recycling programs to keep more discarded household items
o ut of landfills, the purity of U.S. scrap deteriorated as more trash infiltrated the recyclables.
Discarded food, liquid-soaked paper and other contaminants recently accounted for as much as
20% of the material shipped to China, according to Waste Management Inc.'s estimates, double
from five years ago.
The tedious and sometimes dangerous work of separating out that detritus at processing plants
i n China prompted officials there to slash the contaminants limit this year to 0.5%. China early
this month suspended all imports of U.S. recycled materials until June 4, regardless of the
q uality. The recycling industry interpreted the move as part of the growing rift between the U.S.
and China over trade policies and tariffs
The changes have effectively cut off exports from the U.S., the world's largest generator of
scrap paper and plastic. Collectors, processors and the municipal governments that hire them
are reconsidering what they will accept to recycle and how much homeowners will pay for that
service. Many trash haulers and city agencies that paid for curbside collection by selling scrap
said they are now losing money on almost every ton they handle.
The upended economics are likely to permanently change the U.S. recycling business, said
William Moore, president of Moore & Associates, a recycled-paper consultancy in Atlanta.
Page 27
WALL STREET JOURNAL May 13, 2018
produce cleaner bales of recyclables. PHOTO: MAX WHITTAKER FOR THE WALL STREET
JOURNAL
"It's going to take domestic demand to replace what China was buying," he said. "It's not going
to be a quick turnaround. It's going to be a long-term issue."
The waste-management authority in Lancaster County this spring more than doubled the charge
per ton that residential trash collectors must pay to deposit recyclables at its transfer station,
starting June 1. The higher cost is expected to be passed on to residents though a 3% increase
i n the fees that haulers charge households for trash collection and disposal.
The additional transfer-station proceeds will help offset a $40-a-ton fee that the authority will
start paying this summer to a company to process the county's recyclables. Before China raised
its quality standards at the beginning of this year, that company was paying Lancaster County
$4 for every ton of recyclables.
M r. Warner may limit the recyclable items collected from Lancaster County's 500,000 residents
to those that have retained some value, such as cans and corrugated cardboard. He said mixed
plastic isn't worth processing.
"You might as well put it in the trash from the get-go," he said.
Environmentalists are hoping landfills are only a stopgap fix for the glut of recyclables while the
i ndustry finds new markets and reduces contaminants.
Cal-Waste Recovery Systems plans to invest more than $6 million on new sorting equipment to
Page 28
WALL STREETJOURNAL May 13, 2018
"Stuff is definitely getting thrown away in landfills. Nobody is happy about it," said Dylan de
Thomas, vice president of industry collaboration for the Recycling Partnership in Virginia. "There
a re very few landfill owners that don't operate recycling facilities, too. They'd much rather be
paid for those materials."
Pacific Rim Recycling in Benicia, Calif., slowed operations at its plant early this year to meet
C hina's new standard. But company President Steve Moore said the more intensive sorting
process takes too long to process scrap profitably. Pacific Rim idled its processing plant in
February and furloughed 40 of its 45 employees.
"The cost is impossible. We can't make money at it," Steve Moore said. "We quit accepting
stuff."
C hina stopped taking shipments of U.S. mixed paper and mixed plastic in January. Steve Moore
said mixed-paper shipments to other Asian countries now fetch $5 a ton, down from as much as
$150 last year. Other buyers such as Vietnam and India have been flooded with scrap paper
a nd plastic that would have been sold to China in years past.
Dave Vaccarezza, president of Cal-Waste Recovery Systems near Sacramento, Calif., intends
to invest more than $6 million in new sorting equipment to produce cleaner bales of recyclables.
"It's going to cost the rate payer to recycle," he said. "They're going to demand we make our
best effort to use those cans and bottles they put out."
Page 29
WALL STREET JOURNAL May 13, 2018
C hina stopped taking shipments of U.S. mixed paper and mixed plastic in January. Cal-Waste
Recovery Systems workers sift through recycled trash. PHOTO: MAX WHITTAKER FOR THE WALL
STREET JOURNAL
Sacramento County, which collects trash and recyclables from 151,000 homes, used to earn
$1.2 million a year selling the scrap to Waste Management and another processor from scrap.
N ow, the county is paying what will amount to about $1 million a year, or roughly $35 a ton, to
defray the processors' costs. Waste Management paid the county $250,000 to break the
revenue-sharing contract and negotiate those terms.
County waste management director Doug Sloan expects those costs to keep climbing. "We've
been put on notice that we need to do our part," he said. The county hasn't yet raised residential
fees.
Some recyclers said residents and municipalities need to give up the "single-stream" approach
of lumping used paper and cardboard together with glass, cans and plastic in one collection
truck. Single-stream collections took hold in the waste-hauling industry about 20 years ago and
continue to be widely used. Collecting paper separately would make curbside recycling service
m ore expensive but cut down on contamination.
"We're our own worst enemies," said Michael Barry, president of Mid America Recycling, a
processing-plant operator in Des Moines, Iowa, of single-stream recycling. "It's almost
i mpossible to get the paper away from the containers."
Even relatively pure loads of paper have become tough to sell, Mr. Barry said, noting the
domestic market for paper is saturated as well. He stockpiled paper bales at Mid America's
warehouse, hoping prices would improve. They didn't. He has trucked 1,000 tons of paper to a
l andfill in recent weeks.
"We had to purge," he said. "There's no demand for it."
Page 30
Page 31