Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Council Information Memorandum 07-06-2017
CITY OF PLYMOUTH rp) COUNCIL INFO MEMO JULY 61 2017 EVENTS / MEETINGS Environmental Quality Committee Agenda for July 12th...................................................Page 2 Official City Meeting Calendars......................................................................................................... Page 3 Tentative List of Agenda Items........................................................................................................... Page 6 CORRESPONDENCE 2017 Drop -Off Day Statistics.............................................................................................................. Page 9 Municipal Separate Storm Sewer (MS4) Annual Report for 2016 ................................................... Page 12 Water Efficiency Rebate Program -Final Results............................................................................... Page 36 Request for Reguiding, Rezoning, Preliminary Plat and PUD General Plan for Development of the "Speak the Word Church" Site Located East of County Road 101, Between County Road 47 and State Highway 55 (2017032).................................................................................................................................... Page 38 REPORTS Et OTHER ARTICLES OF INTEREST Landfills Sue State over Push to Burn More Garbage, Star Tribune ................................................ Page 39 As Road Funding Dries Up, State Agencies Face Dilemma: Patch or Redo?, Star Tribune ............ Page 41 ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE AGENDA July 12, 2017 WHERE: MEDICINE LAKE ROOM Plymouth City Hall 3400 Plymouth Boulevard Plymouth, MN 55447 CONSENT AGENDA All items listed on the consent agenda* are considered to be routine by the Environmental Quality Committee and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Committee member, or citizen so requests, in which event the item will be removed from the consent agenda and considered in normal sequence on the agenda. 1. 7:00 P.M. CALL TO ORDER 2. 7:00 P.M. PUBLIC FORUM — Individuals may address the Committee about any item not contained in the regular agenda. A maximum of 15 minutes is allotted for the Forum. 3. 7:20 P.M APPROVAL OF AGENDA - EQC members may add items to the agenda for discussion purposes or staff direction only. The EQC will not normally take official action on items added to the agenda. 4. 7:25 P.M. CONSENT AGENDA* A. Approve June 14, 2017 EQC Meeting Minutes (Asche) B. Approval of Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan (Asche) 5. 7:30 P.M. GENERAL BUSINESS A. Organics Recycling — Service Types and Collection Methods (Asche) 6. REPORTS AND STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS A. 7. FUTURE MEETINGS: August 9, 2017 • TBD 8. 8:00 P.M. ADJOURNMENT Page 2 rCity of Plymouth Adding Quality to Life July 2017 Page 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 5:30 PM - 10:30 PM INDEPENDENCE Music in Plymouth DAY Hilde Performance Center CITY OFFICES CLOSED 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 7:00 PM NO REGULAR ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL MEETING QUALITY COMMITTEE (EQC) MEETING Medicine Lake Room 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 7:00 PM PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING Council Chambers 26 27 28 29 5:30 PM SPECIAL COUNCIL 7:00 PM MEETING HOUSING AND Lodging Tax REDEVELOPMENT X3Y25 Medicine Lake Room AUTHORITY 7:00 PM REGULAR (HRA)MEETING COUNCIL MEETING Medicine Lake Room Council Chambers Page 3 rCity of Plymouth Adding Quality to Life August 2017 Page 4 1 2 3 4 5 7:00 PM 5:30 PM - 8:30 PM PLANNING Kids Fest COMMISSION Hilde MEETING Performance Center Council Chambers 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 7:00 PM 7:00 PM REGULAR COUNCIL ENVIRONMENTAL MEETING QUALITY Council Chambers COMMITTEE (EQC) MEETING Medicine Lake Room 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 6:00 PM 7:00 PM SPECIAL COUNCIL PLANNING MEETING COMMISSION Budget and CIP MEETING Medicine Lake Room Council Chambers 20 21 22 5:00 PM 23 24 25 26 SPECIAL COUNCIL 7:00 PM MEETING HOUSING AND Budget and CIP/Review REDEVELOPMENT Future Trail Projects Medicine Lake Room AUTHORITY (HRA) 7:00 PM MEETING REGULAR COUNCIL Medicine Lake Room MEETING Council Chambers 27 28 29 30 31 6:00 PM SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING Budget and CIP (if needed) Medicine Lake Room Page 4 r�Plymouth Adding Quality to Life September 2017 Page 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 7:00 PM PLANNING LABOR DAY COMMISSION MEETING CITY OFFICES Council Chambers CLOSED 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 5:30 PM SPECIAL COUNCIL 7:00 PM 7:00 PM 4:00 PM - 8:00 PM MEETING ENVIRONMENTAL PARK Et REC ADVI- Best of the West Median/Beautification QUALITY SORY Local Business Projects COMMITTEE (EQC) COMMISSION Sampler Medicine Lake Room MEETING (PRAC) Hilde Performance 7:00 PM Medicine Lake Room MEETING Center REGULAR COUNCIL Park Maintenance MEETING Council Chambers 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 7:00 PM 10:30 AM - 3:00 PM PLANNING Plymouth on Parade COMMISSION Celebration MEETING City Center Area Council Chambers 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 5:30 PM SPECIAL COUNCIL 7:00 PM MEETING HOUSING AND Consider minimum age REDEVELOPMENT to purchase tobacco AUTHORITY (HRA) Medicine Lake Room MEETING 7:00 PM REGULAR COUNCIL Medicine Lake Room MEETING Council Chambers Page 5 Tentative Schedule for City Council Agenda Items July 25, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room • Lodging Tax July 25, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers • Announce Kids Fest on August 3 • Adopt Ordinance amending Chapter 11 of the City Code concerning solicitors and peddlers • Approve PUD amendment to increase the number of care units within The Waters of Plymouth located at 11305 State Highway 55 (2017036) • Approve Variance to the rear yard setback for a porch addition on property located at 5144 Black Oaks Court (Rosalind and David Ward — 2017047) • Approve Conditional Use Permit for a sports and fitness club on property located at 2800 Vicksburg Lane (Tiger Athletics — 2017058) • Approve Sub -grant Agreement with the Bassett Creek Watershed for the Plymouth Creek Stream Restoration project (16007) August 8, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers • Discuss crosswalks for the Schmidt Lake Road from Peony Lane to Fernbrook Lane Mill and Overlay project (ST 179002.001) • Consider Ordinance amending Section 1201.49 of the City Code regarding hours of operation for on -sale liquor establishments August 15, Special, 6:00 p.m. Medicine Lake Room • Budget and CIP August 22, Special, 5:00 p.m. Medicine Lake Room • Budget and CIP • Review future trail projects August 22, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers August 29, Special, 6:00 p.m. Medicine Lake Room (if needed) • Budget and CIP September 12, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room • Median/beautification projects September 12, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers • Announce Plymouth on Parade on September 23 • Approve 2018 proposed budget, preliminary general property tax levy, HRA levy and budget hearing date September 26, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room • Consider minimum age to purchase tobacco Note: Special Meeting topics have been set by Council; all other topics are tentative. EDA refers to the Economic Development Authority Page 6 September 26, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers October 10, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers October 24, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers November 14, Special, 5:30 p.m. Medicine Lake Room • Budget November 14, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers November 28, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers December 12, Regular, 7:00 p.m. Council Chambers • Public hearing on 2018 budget, general property tax levy, HRA levy, and 2018-2022 Capital Improvement Program • Approve 2018 Target and Trap Shooting License renewal • Approve 2018 Amusement License renewals • Approve 2018 Tobacco License renewals Page 7 Budget Calendar 2018-2019 Biennial Budget Preparation & 5 -yr Capital Improvement Plan Date Category Description April 17, 2017 Budget Departments receive budget instruction May 23 at 5:30 p.m. Budget Council Study Session — Financial Plan & Budget Goals April —June 2017 Budget Departments prepare budgets June 2, 2017 Budget Personnel changes submitted to HR June 12, 2017 Budget Budgets submitted to Finance June 26—July 14, 2017 Budget Department meetings August 4 Budget Council receives budget materials for upcoming meeting August 15 at 6 p.m. Budget & CIP Council study session (Budget & CIP meeting #1) August 22 at 5:30 p.m. Budget & CIP Council Study Session (Budget & CIP meeting #2) Council Regular Session (Financial Overview & Audit Presentation) August 29 at 6 p.m. Budget & CIP Council Study Session (Budget meeting #3) (if needed) September 12, 2017 Budget Council adopts preliminary levies & budget (Budget meeting #4) October 4, 2017 CIP Planning Commission public hearing November 14 at 5:30 p.m. Budget Council Study Session (Budget meeting #5) (If needed) December 12, 2017 Budget & CIP Budget Public Hearing, CIP, Budget & Levy Adoption December 26, 2017 Budget Levy is certified with Hennepin County Page 8 To: CIM rp) City of Plymouth From: Derek Asche, Water Resources Manager Adding Quality to Life Date: July 3, 2017 Memorandum Item: 2017 Drop -Off Day Statistics Drop -Off Day is an opportunity for all residents to dispose of unwanted items with the goals of preventing illegal dumping and providing education on proper disposal of waste items and facilitating environmental awareness. The 2017 Drop -Off Day was held on April 291h from 7:30am to 12:30pm. There was no charge to drop off paper, bicycles, batteries, bulbs, or textiles. A fee of $20 per vehicle load was charged to drop off electronics, mattresses, metal, municipal solid waste (MSW), construction and demolition (C&D) debris, and tires, which was an increase from $15/vehicle in 2016. Over 900 vehicles attended the event, which is a 38% increase from 2016 and most material collection categories also saw increases each year since 2015. After hearing feedback from those that attending, the 2017 event had wait times of 1.5-2 hours and peaked with approximately 250 vehicles in line at one time. To improve traffic flow and reduce wait times, staff is considering options in 2018 including changing the event layout, hosting more than one event annually, increasing the duration of the event and costs, finding an alternate location, and hosting a drop off for free items at a separate location. Page 9 2017 Drop -Off Day Summary Saturday, April 29, 2017, 7:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. Weather Cloudy, 38 degrees. New Variables • Increased charge ($20 per vehicle per trip). • Site footprint changed, so collection was moved to the east side. Vehicles 2017 2016 2015 Free Line 1 337 128 266 Disposal Line 576 533 370 Total Vehicles 913 661 663 1In 2015, 27 vehicles entered and exited without using the event. Drop -Off Day Actual Costs 2015-2017 Revenue 2017 2016 2015 Receipts $11,520.00 $7,995.00 $7,500.00 Steel Recycling $429.25 $418.95 $0 Total Revenue $11,949.25 $8,413.95 $7,500.00 Expenses' Appliance recycling $1,700.00 $1,549.00 $1,173.00 Bank and credit card fees $5.39 $131.34 0 Electronics recycling $9,631.20 $7,257.50 $2,227.53 Food for workers $344.84 $472.89 $656.58 Labor & benefits $4,437.82 $6,433.95 $9,951.71 Mattresses recycling $2,920.00 $1,390.00 $1,150.00 Metal recycling $350.00 0 $450.00 MSW and C & D disposal $7,351.04 $7,092.06 $3,537.51 Paper shredding $1,200.00 $600.00 0 Print & mail City newsletters 0 $1,273.50 $1,437.50 Supplies 0 $92.82 $428.30 Tire recycling $508.85 1 $158.30 $114.65 Total Expenses $28,449.14 $26,292.03 1 $21,126.78 Revenue Less Expenses -$16,499.89 -$17,878.08 1 -$13,626.78 1 2017 Expenses for Municipal Solid Waste and Construction/Demolition materials will be finalized after all expenses are accepted. Page 10 Material Collected 2017 2016 2015 Appliances 229 181 115 Batteries -households (gallons) 240 144 60 Batteries - vehicles 103 45 5 Bicycles and parts 87 53 88 Bulbs 1,086 1,778 1,651 Donated goods (pounds) 0 1,500 3,991 Electronics (pounds) 39,119 25,680 7,789 Mattresses and box springs 129 62 46 Metal (tons) 10.10 3.99 8.42 Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) & Construction and Demolition (C&D) (tons) 53.02 44.83 18.38 Paper shredded (pounds) 16,511 6,594 5,436 Textiles 2,776 0 0 Tires 174 101 48 Materials above are measured by item (i.e. 229 appliances), unless otherwise noted parenthetically. Other notes: • Appliances are estimated at 95 pounds per appliance. • Vehicle batteries are estimated at 15 pounds each. Page 11 To: CIM City of rp) Plymouth From: Derek Asche, Water Resources Manager Adding Quality to Life Date: July 3, 2017 Memorandum Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) Item: Annual Report for 2016 The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) requires the City of Plymouth be permitted to discharge stormwater to lakes, rivers, streams, and wetlands through the Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) Permit. The primary goal of the MS4 permit is to improve water quality by reducing the discharge of pollutants from an MS4. There are six main components of the MS4 Permit: • Public Education and Outreach • Public Participation • Illicit Discharge Detection and Elimination • Construction -site Runoff Controls • Post Construction Runoff Controls • Pollution Prevention and Municipal "Good Housekeeping" measures The MS4 Permit also includes additional requirements for impaired water bodies and water bodies with approved Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDL). Attached is the City's required annual report to the MPCA on the status of our compliance with the MS4 Permit. 1 Page 12 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 2 of 16 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Reporting period: January 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016 Due: June 30, 2017 Instructions: Complete this annual report to provide a summary of your activities under the 2013 MS4 Permit (Permit) between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016. MPCA staff may contact you for additional information. Fillable document available at https-.//viww.pca.state.mn.us/sites/default/files/w strm4-06a.doc (for personal use only, not for submittal). Questions: Contact Cole Landgraf (cole.landgraf@state.mn.us, 651-757-2880) or Megan Handt (mega n.handt@state.mn.us, 651-757-2843) MS4 General Contact Information Full name Derek Asche Title Water Resources Manager Mai ing 3400 Plymouth Blvd. address City State Zip code Phone Email Plymouth MSF 55447 763-509-5526 dasche@plymouthmn.gov Preparer Contact Information (if different from the MS4 General Contact) Full name it e Organization Mailing address City State Zip code Phone Emai Page 13 https:Hsurvey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 3 of 16 MCM 1: Public Education and Outreach The following questions refer to Part III.D.1. of the Permit. Q2 Did you select a stormwater-related issue of high priority to be emphasized during this Permit term? [Part III.D.1.a.(1)] © Yes O No Q3 What is your stormwater-related issue(s)? Check all that apply. ® TMDL(s) ❑ Local businesses ❑ Residential BMPs ❑ Pet waste ❑ Yard waste ❑ Deicing materials ❑ Household chemicals B Construction activities 0 Post -construction activities ❑ Other Q4 Have you distributed educational materials or equivalent outreach to the public focused on illicit discharge recognition and reporting? [Part III.D.1.a.(2)] ® Yes O No Q5 Do you have an implementation plan as required by the Permit? [Part III.D.1.b.] * Yes O No Q6 How did you distribute educational materials or equivalent outreach? Check all that apply and provide circulation/audience associated with each item. [Part III.D.1.a.] B Brochure 0 Newsletter B Utility bill insert ❑ Newspaper ad ❑ Radio ad ❑ Television ad 0 Cable access channel B Stormwater-related event 0 School presentation or project ® Website 0 Other (1) ❑ Other (2) ❑ Other (3) Other (1), Social Media describe: Page 14 https://survey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3 731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Q7 Intended audience? Check all that apply Page 4 of 16 M Enter the total circulation/audience (if unknown, use best estimate): Brochure 15,000 Newsletter 134,061 Utility bill insert 24, 000 Local Cable access channel 50, 000+ Residents Businesses Developers Students Employees Other Brochure © © ® ❑ ❑ ❑ Newsletter © ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ Utility bill © ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ insert Cable access © ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ channel Stormwater- © ❑ ❑ ❑ related event School presentation ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ or project Website ❑./ © 0 ❑./ © ❑ Other (1) © B ❑./ 0 ❑ M Enter the total circulation/audience (if unknown, use best estimate): Brochure 15,000 Newsletter 134,061 Utility bill insert 24, 000 Cable access channel 50, 000+ Stormwater- related event 3000 School presentation 1850 or project Website Other (1) 1397 124,586 Provide a brief description of each activity related to public education and outreach (e.g. rain garden workshop, school presentation, public works open house) held and the date each activity was held from January 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016. [Part III.D.1.c.(4)] Q9Date of activity Date 4/8/2016 (mm/dd/yyyy) Date 4/22/2016 (mm/dd/yyyy) Date 7/28/16 (mm/dd/yyyy) Date 1 6/29/16 (mm/dd/yyyy) Q10Description of activity Plymouth Home Expo Earth Day / Arbor Day Presentations for 3rd Graders in the Elmentary Schools Plymouth Kids Fest Music in Plymouth Page 15 https://survey.mn.gov/siamJsurveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 5 of 16 CLIMB Theater hosed water quality Date 1/1/16 educational plays (Toadilly Turtle) to 640 (mm/dd/yyyy) Kindergarden - 2nd grade students at area schools Date l= (mm/dd/yyyy) Date (mm/dd/yyyy) Date lh= if (mm/ddlyyyy) Q11 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you modify your BMPs, measurable goals, or future plans for your public education and outreach program? [Part IV. B.] O Yes Oe No MCM 2: Public Participation/Involvement The following questions refer to Part III.D.2.a. of the Permit. Q12 You must provide a minimum of one opportunity each year for the public to provide input on the adequacy of your Stormwater Pollution Prevention Program (SWPPP). Did you provide this opportunity between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016? [Part III.D.2.a.(1)] © Yes O No Q13 What was the opportunity that you provided? Check all that apply. 0 Public meeting ❑ Public event ❑ Other Q14 Did you hold a stand-alone meeting or combine it with another event? ❑ Stand-alone 0 Combined Enter the date of the public 5/11/2016 meeting (mm/dd/yyyy): Enter the 0 number of citizens that attended and were informed Page 16 https://survey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 6 of 16 about your SWPPP: Q17 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you receive any input regarding your SWPPP? O Yes O No Q19 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you modify your BMPs, measurable goals, or future plans for your public participation/involvement program? [Part N.B.] O Yes Q No MCM 3: Illicit Discharge Detection and Elimination The following questions refer to Part III.D.3. of the Permit. Q20 Do you have a regulatory mechanism which prohibits non-stormwater discharges to your MS4? [Part III.D.3.b.] O Yes O No Q21 Did you identify any illicit discharges between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016? [Part III.D.3.h.(4)] © Yes O No Q22 Enter the number of illicit discharges detected: 3 Q23 How did you discover these illicit discharges? Check all that apply and enter the number of illicit discharges discovered by each category. 0 Public complaint © Staff Q24 Enter the number discovered by the public: i Q25 Enter the number discovered by staff: 2 Q26 Did any of the discovered illicit discharges result in an enforcement action (this includes verbal warnings)? O Yes O No Page 17 https:Hsurvey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... -6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 7 of 16 Q27 What type of enforcement action(s) was taken and how many of each action were issued between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016? Check all that apply. ❑ Verbal warning ® Notice of violation ❑ Fines ❑ Criminal action ❑ Civil penalties ❑ Other Enter the number of notice of violations 13 issued: Q28 Did the enforcement action(s) taken sufficiently address the illicit discharge(s)? G Yes O No Q30 Do you have written Enforcement Response Procedures (ERPs) to compel compliance with your illicit discharge regulatory mechanism(s)? [Part III.B.] O Yes Q No Q31 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you train all field staff in illicit discharge recognition (including conditions which could cause illicit discharges) and reporting illicit discharges for further investigations? [Part I II.D.3.e.] O Yes Q No Q32 How did you train your field staff? Check all that apply. ❑ Email 0 PowerPoint ❑ Presentation ❑ Video ❑ Field Training ❑ Other The following questions refer to Part III.C.1. of the Permit. Q33 Did you update your storm sewer system map between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016? [Part III.C.1.] ® Yes O No Q34 Does your storm sewer map include all pipes 12 inches or greater in diameter and the direction of stormwater flow in those pipes? [Part III.C.1.a.] ® Yes Page 18 https://survey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer. asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 8 of 16 Q No Q35 Does your storm sewer map include outfalls, including a unique identification (ID) number and an associated geographic coordinate? [Part III.C.1.b.] * Yes O No Q36 Does your storm sewer map include all structural stormwater BMPs that are part of your MS4? [Part III.C.1.c.] O Yes O No Q37 Does your storm sewer map include all receiving waters? [Part III.C.1.d.] Q Yes O No Q38 In what format is your storm sewer map available? 0 Hardcopy only ® GIS O CAD O Othe Q39 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you modify your BMPs, measurable goals, or future plans for your illicit discharge detection and elimination (IDDE) program? [Part IV.B.] O Yes s0 No MCM 4: Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control The following questions refer to Part III.D.4. of the Permit. Q40 Do you have a regulatory mechanism that is at least as stringent as the Agency's general permit to Discharge Stormwater Associated with Construction Activity (CSW Permit) No. MN R100001 (http://www.pca.state.mn.us/index.php/view- document.html?gid=18984) for erosion and sediment controls and waste controls? [Part III.D.4.a.] ®O Yes Q No Q41 Have you developed written procedures for site plan reviews as required by the Permit? [Part III.D.4.b.] © Yes O No Q42 Page 19 https:Hsurvey.mn. gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3 731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 9 of 16 Have you documented each site plan review as required by the Permit? [Part I I I. D.4.f.] © Yes O No Q43 Enter the number of site plan reviews conducted for sites an acre or greater of soil disturbance between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016: Q44 What types of enforcement actions do you have available to compel compliance with your regulatory mechanism? Check all that apply and enter the number of each used from January 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016. B Verbal warnings ® Notice of violation ❑ Administrative orders 0 Stop -work orders ❑ Fines © Forfeit of security of bond money ❑ Withholding of certificate of occupancy ❑ Criminal actions ❑ Civil penalties ❑ Other Enter the number of verbal warnings E;` issued: Enter the number of notice of violations 49 issued: Enter the number of stop -work orders I 1 issued: Enter the number of forfeitures of security bond money issued: Q45 Do you have written Enforcement Response Procedures (ERPs) to compel compliance with your construction site stormwater runoff control regulatory mechanism(s)? [Part III.B.] O Yes O No Q46 Enter the number of active construction sites an acre or greater that were in your jurisdiction between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016: 64 Q47 Do you have written procedures for identifying priority sites for inspections? [Part III.D.4.d.(1)] Pae 20 https:Hsurvey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... /30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 ® Yes O No Q48 How are sites prioritized for inspections? Check all that apply. ❑ Site topography ❑ Soil characteristics ❑ Types of receiving water(s) ❑ Stage of construction ❑ Compliance history ❑ Weather conditions ❑ Citizen complaints ❑ Project size B Other Other, describe: Page 10 of 16 All commercial development, residential development, city construction projects and grading permit sites are inspected weekly. Grading permit sites under an acre are inspected less frequently, but are still inspected by staff. Q49 Do you have a checklist or other written means to document site inspections when determining compliance? [Part III.D.4.d.(4)] © Yes O No Q50 Enter the number of site inspections conducted for sites an acre or greater between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016: 1345 Q51 Enter the frequency at which site inspections are conducted (e.g. daily, weekly, monthly): [Part III.D.4.d.(2)] Weekly Q52 Enter the number of trained inspectors that were available for construction site inspections between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016: 1 Q53 Provide the contact information for the inspector(s) and/or organization that conducts construction stormwater inspections for your MS4. List your primary construction stormwater contact first if you have multiple inspectors. (1) Inspector name Organization Phone (Office) Phone (Work Cell) Email bscharenbroich@plymouthmn.gov email Page 21 https:Hsurvey. mn. gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer. asp?sid=746D70776834776F3 731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Preferred contact method (2) Inspector name Organization Phone (Office) Phone (Work Cell) Email Preferred contact method (3) Inspector name Organization Phone (Office) Phone (Work Cell) Email Preferred contact method Q54 What training did inspectors receive? Check all that apply. Page 11 of 16 B University of Minnesota Erosion and Stormwater Management Certification Program ❑ Qualified Compliance Inspector of Stormwater (QCIS) ❑ Minnesota Laborers Training Center Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan Installer or Supervisor ❑ Minnesota Utility Contractors Association Erosion Control Training ❑ Certified Professional in Erosion and Sediment Control (CPESC) ❑ Certified Professional in Stormwater Quality (CPSWQ) ❑ Certified Erosion, Sediment and Storm Water Inspector (CESSWI) ❑ Other Q55 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you modify your BMPs, measurable goals, or future plans for your construction site stormwater runoff control program? [Part IV.B.] O Yes ® No MCM 5: Post -Construction Stormwater Management The following questions refer to Part III.D.5. of the Permit. Q56 Do you have a regulatory mechanism which meets all requirements as specified in Part III.D.5.a. of the Permit? .O Yes O No Page 22 https://survey.mn. gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 12 of 16 Q57 What approach are you using to meet the performance standard for Volume, Total Suspended Solids (TSS), and Total Phosphorus (TP) as required by the Permit? [Part III.D.5.a.(2)] Check all that apply. Refer to the link http://www.pca.state.mn.us/index.php/view-document.htmI? gid=17815 for guidance on stormwater management approaches. f -i Retain a runoff volume equal to one inch times the area of the proposed increase of impervious surfaces on-site ❑ Retain the post -construction runoff volume on site for the 95th percentile storm ❑ Match the pre -development runoff conditions 0 Adopt the Minimal Impact Design Standards (MIDS) ❑ An approach has not been selected LI Other method (Must be technically defensible--e.g. based on modeling, research and acceptable engineering practices) Q58 Do you have written Enforcement Response Procedures (ERPs) to compel compliance with your post -construction stormwater management regulatory mechanism(s)? [Part III.B.] O Yes Q No Q59 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you modify your BMPs, measurable goals, or future plans for your post -construction stormwater management program? [Part IV.B.] O Yes Q No MCM 6: Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping for Municipal Operations The following questions refer to Part III.D.6. of the Permit. Q60 Enter the total number of structural stormwater BMPs, outfalls (excluding underground outfalls), and ponds within your MS4 (exclude privately owned). Structura stormwater 1124 BMPs Outfalls 1967 Ponds 413 Q61 Enter the number of structural stormwater BMPs, outfalls (excluding underground outfalls), and ponds that were inspected from January 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016 within your MS4 (exclude privately owned). [Part III.D.6.e.] Structural stormwater 124 BMPs Page 23 https:Hsurvey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 13 of 16 Outfalls 125 Ponds 96 Q62 Have you developed an alternative inspection frequency for any structural stormwater BMPs, as allowed in Part III.D.6.e.(1) of the Permit? O Yes No Q63 Based on inspection findings, did you conduct any maintenance on any structural stormwater BMPs? [Part III.D.6.e.(1)] ® Yes O No Q64 Briefly describe the maintenance that was conducted: Maintenance of rain gardens is done 8-10 times throughout the growing season by a hired professional contractor. Sediment and dead vegetation are removed and new mulch and plants are added on an as needed basis for each rain garden. If any erosion at the inlets is discovered, sediment and rip rap are typically added to prevent further erosion. Maintenance of sump manholes, ponds, storm sewer flared end sections and underground chambers/separator devices is done by City of Plymouth Public Works crews. Sediment and other materials that are removed from the maintenance activities on these BMPs are disposed of properly. Q65 Do you own or operate any stockpiles, and/or storage and material handling areas? [Part III.D.6.e.(3)] © Yes O No Q66 Did you inspect all stockpiles and storage and material handling areas quarterly? [Part III.D.6.e.(3)] O Yes ® No Q67 Based on inspection findings, did you conduct maintenance at any of the stockpiles and/or storage and material handling areas? O Yes O No Q69 Between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2016, did you modify your BMPs, measurable goals, or future plans for your pollution prevention/good housekeeping for municipal operations program? [Part IV.B.] O Yes .O No Discharges to Impaired Waters with a USEPA-Approved TNiDL that Includes an Applicable WLA Page 24 https : //survey. mn. gov/s iam/surveylanding/printerviewer. asp? sid=746D 70 776 83 4776F 3 731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Page 14 of 16 You must complete the TMDL Annual Report Form, available at: http://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php/Upload page with TMDL forms. Attach your completed TMDL Annual report form to this Annual Report as instructed below. [Part III.E.] Q71 Click the "up arrow" icon below to upload your TMDL Annual report form. When it has uploaded successfully, a unique ID will appear in the box. Only files less than 10 MB in size will upload. ref:0000000012:Q71 Partnerships Q78 Did you rely on any other regulated MS4s to satisfy one or more Permit requirements? Q Yes ® No Additional Information If you would like to provide any additional files to accompany your annual report, use the space below to upload those files. For each space, you may attach one file. You may provide additional explanation and/or information in an email with the subject YourMS4NameHere 2016AR to ms4permitprogram.pca@state.mn.us. Q80 Click the "up arrow" icon below to upload a file. When it has uploaded successfully, a unique ID will appear in the box. Only files less than 10 MB in size will upload. t_f Q81 Click the "up arrow" icon below to upload a file. When it has uploaded successfully, a unique ID will appear in the box. Only files less than 10 MB in size will upload. Q82 Click the "up arrow" icon below to upload a file. When it has uploaded successfully, a unique ID will appear in the box. Only files less than 10 MB in size will upload. Q83 Optional, describe the file(s) uploaded: Page 25 https://survey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer. asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... 6/30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Owner or operator Certification Page 15 of 16 The person with overall administrative responsibility for SWPPP implementation and Permit compliance must certify this MS4 Annual Report. This person must be duly authorized and should be either a principal executive (i.e., Director of Public Works, City Administrator) or ranking elected official (i.e., Mayor, Township Supervisor). I certify under penalty of law that this document and all attachments were prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance with a system designed to assure that qualified personnel properly gathered and evaluated the information submitted. Based on my inquiry of the person or persons who manage the system, or those persons directly responsible for gathering the information, the information submitted is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete (Minn. R. 7001.0070). 1 am aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false information, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment (Minn. R. 7001.0540). 0 Yes By typing my name in the following box, I certify the above statements to be true and correct, to the best of my knowledge, and that information can be used for the purpose of processing my MS4 Annual Report. Name: Derek Asche Title: Water Resources Manager Date- 06/30/17 (mm/dd/yyyy) When you are ready to submit, you must click the 'Submit' button at the bottom of this page. Provide the email(s) of the individual(s) you would like to receive the MS4 Annual Report for 2016 submittal confirmation email from the MPCA. After you click the Submit button below, please allow up to three business days to receive this email. Email dasche@plymouthmng.gov (1) bscharenbroich@plymouthmn.gov Pae 26 https://survey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3731... /30/2017 MS4 Annual Report for 2016 Email (2) Email (3) jrenneberg@plymouthmn.gov Page 16 of 16 Print or save a copy of your completed MS4 Annual Report for 2016 for your records. The IVIPCA will email a PDF of your IVIS4 Annual Report for 2016 information in a confirmation email within three business days after you submit this form to the email(s) you provided above. You may print a copy of the MS4 Annual Report for 2016 for your records by pressing the `Print' button at the bottom of the page. Additionally, it is possible to save a PDF copy of the MS4 Annual Report for 2016 if you are working on a computer with OneNote (a program often included in Microsoft Office packages). Detailed saving instructions are available at stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php/Guidance_ for saving_ MS4_ annual_ reports. If you have any questions, contact MPCA staff Cole Landgraf (cole.landgraf@state.mn.us, 651-757-2880) or Megan Handt (megan.handt@state.mn.us, 651-757-2843). Page 27 https:Hsurvey.mn.gov/siam/surveylanding/printerviewer.asp?sid=746D70776834776F3 731... 6/30/2017 Minnesota Pollution TMDL Annual Report Form Control Agency Municipal Separate Storm Sewer Systems (N'iS4) Program 520 Lafayette Road North St. Paul. MN 55155-4194 Doc Type. Annual Report Form Information This form is to be completed annually by MS4s in order to track the completed BMP activities and to calculate the cumulative loading reduction for specific pollutants of concern associated with each applicable WLA. Navigate through this form using the tabs at the bottom of the page. All information is collected in accordance with Part III.E of the MS4 Permit. Grein Tabs (REQUIRED): user -input worksheet 6,ue Tabs (hidden*): optional user -input worksheet Tabs (hidden*): reference worksheet *Reveal hidden spreadsheet tabs by navigating to Home ->Cells ->Format ->Hide & Unhide->Unhide Sheet Please refer to the Guidance for Completing the TMDL Reporting Form in the Minnesota Stormwater Manual for additional assistance and instructions. Sections of the guidance are hyperlinked throughout this spreadsheet. User Information Date Updated: 6/27/2017 Permittee: Plymouth City Permit ID: MS400112 Contact Name: Derek Asche Contact Phone: 763-509-5526 Contact email: dasche@plymouthmn.gov Mailing address: 3400 Plymouth Blvd, Plymouth MN 55447 Reporting Year Data Entry Date Entered by Notes 2015 ######## Ben Scharenbroich 2016 ######## Derek Asche Page 28 BMP - Activities Completed Spreadsheet I Re,p red: Place an -X- in a ,If if the SMP applies tp the TMDL shown in the column For MPCIk use only Required Optional Required Optional Cedar Island, Pike, and Cedar Island, Pike, and Sdtmidt, Pomerleau sdlmidt, Pomerleau Schmidt, Pomerleau Eagle Lakes Nutrient Eagle Lakes Nutrient and Bass Lakes and Bass Lakes and Bass Lakes shingle Creek Chloride TMDL TMDL Nutrient TMDL NutrlentTMDL NutricnlTMOL TMDL Reporting _ration and l0 y-coord flat. e.g. -pard llcns. Coordinate system le.R. tat Who ownsthis f�,p�.icable name other year when BMP was =aele Lake- -iu lave- I4vnerleau Lake- �hmldt Lake- Shingle Creek Chloride It ID Permittee M54 iD YeMP BMP Dezcrlotlon information Needed? BMP10 4498661 eg_:93.25811 TM BMP/activilYl implemented Nates Phosphorus =.ke take - Phosphorus hpsphorus Phosphorus '",Php s PMOL -Chloride Compl ee H % % M5400112-1 Plymouth City' MS400112 2014 Cprtstrudd basin Wet pond/wet detention pond ShtrgumlKumns 04244-NU01 45.059881 -93.474021 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA r-- M5400112-2 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Constructed_hasln Wet pond/wet detention pond CompShrp lete columns H hK 04241-NU01 45.06139 -93.472123 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA rn.wax.. X X M5400112-3 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Constructedbasin Wet pond Complete columns H thl- K 04165-NU01 41060438 -93,471063 fat -long Permittee (you) NA X % M5400112-0 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 constructed basin We[ pond/Wet detention pond Complete columns M thr K 04411-N1I01 45.057945 -93.462656 La[ -long Permittee (you)NA dims. wpm, % % Complete mlumns H % % MS400112-55 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Constructed _basin Wet pond/wet pond dy K 04411-NU02 45,057009 -93.462934 Lat-long Permittee(you) NA laam w.�. CompletemlumnsH PrivMP 00 X X M54MS400112-6Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Filter Permeable pavement with underdraln L)'K _B 02 45.3486 -93.27707 Lat -long Other NA 2014 O.r+lw b, Tr�rm wins Complete columns H Priv X X MS400112-7 Plymouth City M5900112 2014 Filter Permeable pavement with underdrain LhrG K -�BMPW 45.3527 -93,27819 Lat-long Other NA 2014 Trel wna4a Complete columns H Juneau Ridge % % M5400112-8 Plymouth City MS700112 2014 Constructed basin Wet pond/wet detention pond throughK Pond ID to be 45.3545 -93.28077 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA 2014 determined M8400112-9 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Filter Blpretention with underdrain (talo garden) Complete columns H thr" K Priv BMP -Do -� 45.3521 -93.28053 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA 2014 i,a un n.x.�Naaer..lerr.n,-eaenP...�r.aa, 4,. sono % X Complete mlumns H Prlv_BMP_00 X % M5400112-10 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Filter Biarelention with underdrain (rain garden) WGu K 04 45.3207 -93,27644 Lat-long Other NA 2013 Complete mlumnsH Priv_BMP_00 % % M5400112-11 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Filter Bipretention with underdraln (talo garden) K 45.3233 -93.27683 Lat-long Other NA 2013 Complete mlumns H Prlv_BMP_00 % % MS400112-12 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Filter Bloretentlon with underdrain (rain garden) throw K O6 45.3269 -93.27681 Lat-long Other NA 2013 Complete columns H Prlv_BM P--OOM5400112-13 X X Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Filter Bloretentlon with underdraln (talo garden) ihrpu h K Q7 45.060726 -93.46836 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA 2013 Complete columns H PrivBMP_00 X X MS400112-14 City Plymouth Ci M5400112 2014 Filter Bioretention with underdrain rain ( garden) pyo hK pg 45.3633 -93,28519 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA MS400112-15 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-16 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain inlet insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS400112-17 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS400112-18 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee (you) NA 2011 % % M5400112-19 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 Is X X MS400112-20 Plymouth City lvl 0l12 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 5N4tLAMr3911 % % MS400112-21 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 .r.. avrrrrs•• rUis X X MS700112-22 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain inlet insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-23 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain Inlet insert No IO Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS100112-24 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device - Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 rs,va 52rrrYerake lrw aP - % % MS100112-25 Plymouth City MS40D112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-26 Plymouth City M540D112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 senam X X MS100112-27 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS100112-28 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No 10 Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 woa+ewv ra,w:u.+:ar X X MS400112-29 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 �sd�vra� % % MS100112-30 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 !� �e.e„..yr Y*are.r % % MS400112-31 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS100112-32 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400I12-33 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS100112-34 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 auW ru,d Sc+ fir. % % MS400112-35 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 iFlnrm .+ % % MS400112-36 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 �. w,.Vura hula wen ScMAHler�x! - X X M5400112-37 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-38 Plymouth City MS700112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 lirnriar Lkr rym RCl - X X M5400112-39 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 ManuNctured_devlce Drain Inlet Insert No IO Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % Fd,e wehra'anlu y . n MS400112-00 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-01 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 Mallanh X X MS400112-02 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-03 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 w w N d uvf: trem,�,wdSrhNh Jae X X MS400112-44 Plymouth City MS400I12 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 Wnrwrrr.-w - % % MS400112-05 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 uMWlmawrJitlrm Lke % % MS400112-06 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 A:r X X MS400112-47 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 tl5 hN3tW.hmr I % % MS400112-48 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 nlx�rccrml ,Ira H % % MS400112-09 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 W�Fer•]C] Rale X X .... MS400112-50 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 MNIo ib,im ar X X MS400112-51 Plymouth City M5I00112 2014 Manufactured -device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-52 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 nee vrCr Lerlmam�M Y.mii I.ke twin % % MS100112-53 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 �9r�n�n % % MS400112-54 Plymouth City M5900112 2014 Manuhctured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee )you) NA 2011 sr4mG � r % % 'age 29 Entry lD Permittee M541D Reporting year P amp 04,crition 1vt4llon llAd lti Information Needxd7 OMP y—ord llat, e3 49.98661 x-coord llonsa. e3. -93 259 Coordinate system(e.R. lat- ip UTM1 1Vhp owns this BMP/acnv,ty fa licable name other gwnelj Yearwhen BMPwas Isemented -ogle Lake Notes ='tosohoru 2� Lake- t'.ke Lake - Phosphorus PhoS�horus Pomerleau Lake- Ptrosphoru .' rtmidt Lake ANosohoru5 Lh—le Creek Chloride TMDL- Chloride MS400112-55 Plymouth City M54OD112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 7ewa+wq X X MS400112-56 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS100112-57 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 o-+u w� wJnransr� X X MS300112-58 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Dain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X M5400112-59 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 -.avN�a X X MS400112-60 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS700112-61 MS400112-62 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2014 2014 Manufactured device Manufactured device Drain Inlet insert Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Per Ittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 2011 Mrt r�.xv. M+n wef. twl Iae.!-a•. xett xss X X X X MS400112-63 MS400112-64 Plymouth City Plymouth City M5400112 -5400112 2014 2014 Manufactured device Manufactured -dxvice Drain inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 2011 �aCn r.W sa+++P smeee.k. � mta X X X X MS400112-65 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 'wra lwW. +.+rim X X MS400112-66 ympu City Plymouth Ci M5400112 2014 Filter Bloretention with underdraln rain ( garden) Complete columns H Lt" hY 5T8MP0022 45.039125 -93.427403 Lat-Ipng Permittee (you) NA 2010 % % MS100112-67 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Filter Bioretention with underdrain(rain garden) Complete olullmns H SrBMP0023 45.036944 -93.436323 Lat-long Permittee(you) NA 2010 X X MS400112-68 Plymouth Cty M5400112 2014 Filter Bioretention with underdraln (rain garden) C..=ns H SfBMP0024 45.036736 -93.43594 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA 2010 X X MS700112-69 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Filter Bioretention with underdraln (rain garden) Compe ml ns M STBMP0016 45.050995 -93.427633 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA 2010 X X MS400112-70 Plymouth City M540D112 2014 Filter Bloretention with underdraln (rain garden) Comp�e columns H SrBMP0017 45.050586 -93.430808 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA 2010 % X M5400112-71 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Filter Bioretention with underdrain (rain garden) Com= ns H STBMPOD18 45.050214 -93.435296 Lat-Ipng Permittee (you) NA 2010 X X M5400112-72 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Supplementaloublic education_outreach Workshops/Clinics No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % % X X X M5400112-73 Plymouth City M54OD112 2014 Supplementaloubllc_education_outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X X X % MS400112-74 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Supplemental employee education training Stafftralning No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % % X % X X M5400112-75 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Supplementaloubllc_educatlon_outreach Publlcallons No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA X X % X X % MS400112-76 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Eliminate_ illlcit_discharge_connectlon Increased implementation of illicit discharge detection and elimination ordinance No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X % X % MSI00112-77 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Supplemental_ street_ sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee )you) NA X m+•.4 X X % X X MS400112-78 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 5upplemental_street_sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X % X % % MS1D0112-79 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Supplemental_ street_ sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X % X X M5400112-80 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Enhanced_ road_ salt_ management Calibration of spreaders No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X • M5400112-81 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Enhanced_mad _salt _management Salt storage No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA sxalr+bunalnawlm. rdbm.vh ue,.p.,..mw.�+.wa....m X M5400112.82 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Enhanced_road salt_management Road temperature sensors No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X M5400112-93 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Enhanced road salt_ management Use of treated salt No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X MS400112-94 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Enhanced road salt management Salt brine No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X M5400112-85 Plymouth Cty MS400112 2014 Enhanced road salt management AntWcing No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA X M5400112-96 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Enhanced_road salt management Winter maintenance education No lD information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X MS400112-87 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 5upplementaloublic_edumtion outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % % X X MS400112-98 MS400112-89 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2014 2014 Supplementaloublic_education outreach Supplementaloublic_education outreach Publications Publl.d.ns No 10 Information needed No 10 Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permiltee(You) Permittee (you) NA NA X hTlaa rh a.l 4mf.n MNnw++- aR+r- % X x X X % X X X MS400112 90 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Supplementaloublic_educatlon outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % +raJJm f:JWvr X X X X % MS400112-91 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 5upplementaloublic_education outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Perrnittee(you) NA X X X X X MS400112-92 MS400112-93 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2014 2014 Supplementaloublic education outreach Supplementaloublic education outreach Publications Publications No ID Information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee(you) NA NA % ]Nn ThivMH.tl.e n+rri SNubaMA % % X x X X X X X MS400112-94 MS400112-95 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2014 2014 Supplementaloublic education outreach Supplementaloublic education outreach Publications Publications No ID information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permtttee(you) Pernlid-(you) NA NA X rr MWr�- rew % X % X X % % X X X X MS400112-96 Plymouth City M5400112 2014 Supplemental oubllc education outreach Presenations No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee(you) NA . ow.wr nla.re- W.teMM VRI xrranvewmaN swtr % X X X X MS400112-97 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Supplementaloubllc_educatipn_outreach Presenations No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X X X X M5400112-98 Plymouth City MS400112 2014 Supplementaloubllc_education outreach Presenations No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee(you) NA mgM.mNm-aro pwd.sr„e+..n+bw+ X X X % % MS400112-99 MS400112-100 MS400112-101 Plymouth City Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 M5400112 2015 2015 2015 Manufactured_ device Manuactured_devlce Manufactured_ device Drain inlet Insert Drain inlet Insert Drain inlet insert No ID information needed No ID Information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee lymu) Permittee (you) NA NA NA 2011 2011 2011 1N+v l wra s..w+.,r,d xmm�t t,r.4oq x Ince: rvtesrl all X X X % X % MS700112-102 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X % MS400112-103 MS100112-104 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2015 2015 Manufactured device Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 2011 kJr n-errf/w .NOW nmOs+Lvldraate lmm X X X --. X MS400112-105 MS400112-106 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2015 2015 Manufactured device Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 2011 crvr+Jau 1n+J old b++W rwr4 X X X X MS400112-107 MS400112-108 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2015 2015 Manufactured-device Manufactured-device Drain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 2011 arrh WYw+muM X X X x MS400112-109 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_devlce Drain inlet insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 o-lr hwn..avw ShmWt lot. X X MS400112-110 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured-device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 Inlprvranl ^+Vw X X . -5400112-111 Plymouth Cty .5400112 2015 ManuaRured_devlce Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee lyau) NA 2011 Jm..m.Y 52mHr.lmm rAt t -1411 % X .5400112-112 Plymouth City .5400112 2015 Manufactured_device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Infprmatiom needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 W.rrrmrvcmn X X 'age 30 Enta'C Permittee MS410 Repprnn¢ year MP ActIW BMP DesRlotlon Location and Information Needed] BM71D y-coord Rat, e.g. 44-9_866) oord llong, e.g_,9kj25811 -oa_rdlnate5'sl—rem leg let- Sprta. UTM) Who owns this if—l—be 0MP/111 I I n Bother. wn s) Yearwhen BMPwas imDlementetl Notes Csale Lake- Phosphorus ssa Lake- Pike Lake - Phosoh phosphorus /pmerleau Lake- Schmidt Lake- �in¢Ie Creek Chloride ahosphorus os horns rMDL- Chloride MS400112-113 MS400112-114 Plymouth Uty Plymouth City M540D112 MS400112 2015 2015 Ivanufactured_device Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 - 2011 X X % % MS400112-115 MS400112-116 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2015 2015 Manufactured_ device Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permlttee(you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 va+rme am.asrmvar we Mxt t • xss 2011 X X X % M5400112-117 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 �a�oN gYevLh paha Nrnae 1- X % MS400112-118 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 X X MS400112-119 Plymouth City MS400112-120 Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2015 2015 Manufactured_ device Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permlttee (you) Permittee(you) NA NA 2011 n�erOSWeWrlaka hen m! - 2011 X X X X MS400112-121 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No 10 Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 wet-s-xtt a^ X % MS400112-122 Plymouth City M54OD112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 X X MS400112-123 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No 10 Information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee (you) NA 2011 rueW' w. }an ]gtr X % MS400112-124 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X X MS400112-125 Plymouth City MS4D0112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 �.�sc•.rx�aa. X X MS400112-126 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % X MS400112-127 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 dk Se4Ytr lase bwv t X X MS400112-128 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % % MS400112-129 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 zblaasvd SaYPubate bn X X M5400112-130 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X % MS400112-131 M5400112-132 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 M5400112 2015 2015 Manufactured_devlce Manufactured_d.vice Drain inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed No 10 information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 vs�a heY oTr YrW r� Srh+�aC las. 2011 % X % X MS400112-133 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 InLr rvarbrlneu vrerlvYn.•=xtl Sr"uMlat 5..e X % M5400112-134 Plymouth City M$400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert N o ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X % M5400112-135 MS400112-136 Plymouth City Plymouth City M5400112 M5400112 2015 2015 Manufactured_ device Manufactured_ device Drain inlet Insert Dminlnletinsert No ID Information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 MMxvnrmlmrMNl nrrh YYna•wrtl 2011 webm• X It X X MS400112-137 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured device Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permit -(you) NA 2011 be! X X MS700112-138 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 % X M5400112-139 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA 2011 X X M5400112-140 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee(you) NA 2011 tvY.ee�.e sdwm wa.yr rw X X M5400112-141 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Drain inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee (you) NA 2011 X % MS400112-142 MS400112-143 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS400112 2015 2015 Manufactured_ device Manufactured_devlce Dain Inlet Insert Drain Inlet Insert No ID information needed No ID information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 InrdrbW:rvYfr!W.r-av 2011 X X % X MS400112-144 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured -device Dain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 kilvo�recYw MNI vrh WY�urr%arN+Yy Lka rm^r % % M5400112-145 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 ManufaRured_devlce Dain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X % MS400112-146 MS100112-147 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 MS40DI12 2015 2015 Manufadured_device 7.71_ Drain inlet Insert Dain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee (you) NA NA 2011 w.. . t. ev o¢nt,.atw,mrae snm• 2011 X It X % MS400112-148 Plymouth City MS40DI12 2015 Manufactured_device Drain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 a>V r � N as wrh!¢Yv amrM Sa5^+4r L X % MS400112-149 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Manufactured_ device Dain Inlet Insert No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 2011 X % MS400112-150 M5400112-151 Plymouth City Plymouth City MS400112 M5400112 2015 2015 Supplementalyubllc_educatlon_outreach Supplemental_public_educe[lon_outreach Workshops/Clinics Publications No ID Information needed NO ID Information needed NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) Permittee )you) NA NAnuel Gnern WvlJmv slaw a4ruwJ /vWd Enwmnmenol e.va mxiletnrld..uM.a�+m mvun lm.s % % X X X % % X % % % X MS400112-152 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplemental_publlc_education _outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X X % % M5400112-153 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplemental_employee_eduutlon_tralning Stafftaining No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA nw• X X X X X % MS400112-154 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplemental_street_sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X % X X % MS400112-155 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplemental street_sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA ...mea X % X X X X MS400112-156 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplemental street_sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X % X % M5400112-157 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced road salt management Calibration of spreaders No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA r...wv X MS400112-158 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced road salt management Saltstorage No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Perni(you) NA X MS400112-159 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced road salt management Road temperature sensors No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X MS400112-160 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced -road _salt _management Use of treated salt No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X M5400112-161 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced -road _salt _management Salt brine No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % MS400112-162 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced_ road_salt_management Anti -Icing No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % MS400112-163 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Enhanced_mad_salt _management Winter maintenance education No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee )you) NA X MS400112-164 Plymouth City M5100112 2015 Supplamentaisubllc_education _outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA gkv XX % X X M5400112-165 Plymouth Ury M5400112 2015 5upplementalyublic educatlon outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA It % X X % - MS400112-166 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalyublic educatlon_outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA S—e Wetls Na , X % X X X MS400112-167 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Supplemental_public education outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X It X X MS400112-168 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Supplementalyublic_educatlon outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA 91ua1Mmrk: meSvers�¢✓N IaMry arWv X X X X % .._ —__—__ MS400112-169 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalyublic_education outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X % % M5400112-170 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalpublic_education_outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA erN.dwr Bron ..n X X % X X _ gage 31 Page 32 Reporting Lxation and ID ycoord(lat. e.g. x coo,d llong, Cocrdlnatesystem les. lab Who owns this I l applicable. name me, rear when BMP was ;aarle Lake- Bass Lake- Pomerleau take i,hmidl Lake Se-nale Creek Chloride Fgnwle _ttge MS40 3Mn/A ,,, SAAP ice! !Q 449865: S.y--332581! .11.c&yIMJ PN➢lacuv0 pW lsl Imyler^enmd hotels) Yho�oho^ Pile Lake-Phosphorus Phosphoru Phosphorus =•=•os NDL-Chloride MS400112-171 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplemental_publlc_educatlon outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA rl % % % % % % MS400112-172 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalsubllc_educatlon outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % X X X % MS400112-173 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalsubllc_educatlon outreach Presentations No ID Information needed NA NA NA Nn Permittee (you) NA W..I q.now.u.uu.ro-wr..,n.n rwce v,.vn�..�. »bsr.d. % X % X % MS400112-174 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalsubllc education outreach Presentetlprss No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NAS SaIMw % % X X % X MS400112-175 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalsubllc education outreach Presentations No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permlitee(you) NA mgMe,pNm-ab pveesn,du,u.6ws % X % X X MS400112-176 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalsubllc education outreach Presentations No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA rarN wy/umov elminuuuentl..��mvrvs4op. wvWvarly % X X % % Cr„N/mmpmr bue, b .uimnuro 4^dupn N^4 nen pMm MS400112-177 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Supplementalsublic_educatlon outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA wxsrnop,w.ur muauvo. ^.e.. p.m via pdu mvu,e Adm, X % % % % % - rnme W hvn einem, rtom cion dvrvn/'>vrlm.l^vse nw.s r^+s MS100112-178 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Constructed basin Wet pond/wet pond Complete Acolumns H 09241-NU01 45.046418 -93.47243 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA % MS400112-179 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Filter Blore[ention with underdrain (rain garden) car g Complete columns H Private _BMP Lablang Permittee (you) NA _ X M5400112-180 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Filter Perimeter sand filter Complete colons H 05412-NU01 45.056816 -93.48484 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA �. % X M5400112-I81 Plymouth CityM5400112 2015 Constructed basin Wet pond/wet detention pond Complete columns H �. K 05412-NU01 45.056816 -93.48484 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA X % MS400112-182 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Constructed basin Wet pond/wet detention pond Comp.1,r[pecpluN aH 05414-NU01 45.056147 -93.48235 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA % % MS400112-183 Plymouth City M5400112 MS400112 2015 Filter Perimeter sand filter columns H � K 05414-NU01 45,056147 -93.48235 La[-long Permittee (you) NA X X M5400112-184 Plymouth .1 M5400112 2015 Filter Bioretention with underdrain (talo garden) thrpu Complete columns H K Private BMP WIG 45.040745 -93.448852 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA a•te.m X X M5400112-185 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Filter Perimeter sand filter Compleettee columns H 09212-NU01 45.050224 -93.475076 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA % % M5400112-186 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Constructed basin Wet pond/wet detention pond Complete columns H 09212-NU01 45.050224 -93.475076 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA X X M5900112-187 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Constructed basin Wet pond/wet detention pond Com�plete columhCns H 01311-NU01 45,02277 -93.4460 La[-long Permittee (you) NA X3 M54OD112-188 Plymouth City MS400112 2015 Filter Perimeter sand filter Cpmpletecolumns H drr K 01311-NU01 45.02277 -93.44603 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA rtiw .._ % M5400112-189 Plymouth City M5400112 2015 Infiltrator Bioretention with no underdrain (rain garden) pletecolumns H ComK Priveate BM P mi+ 45.043932 -93.402401 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA c� % M5400112-190 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Filter Media filter Complete colons H —ShMS400112-191 STBMP0076 45.049395 -93,482299 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA g Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Constructed_ basin Wet pond/wet detention pond Complete rn,H 03314-NU01 45.055594 -93,452781 Lat-long Permittee(you) NA MS400112-192 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Constructed_ basin Wet pond/wet detention pond Complete columns H 03341-NU01 45.054333 -93454109 Lat-long Permittee(ypu) NA M5400112-193 Plymouth City M5400112 2016 Constructed basin Wet detention pond Complete columns H m Y 03342-NU01 45,053496 -93.455822 Lat-long Permittee (you) NA MS400112-194 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplemental _public _education outreach Workshops/Clinics No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA Mnuel Reio p•avr'a•IvnoP P�mue ev ra.no elou�lr,od.aMd+ nor X % X % X X MS400112-195 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 5upplementalsublic_education-outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA .bxm4 FnNmn�+nvl F.v.l..4ory 41nugruromau.ury neve X % X X X X MS400112-196 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic_educatlon putreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA urcmpaar aea.venq.mruMad M'm^t rmm ev a.ag % % % % % % MS400112-197 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplemental_employee_education training Employee education No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % X X X X MS400112-198 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplemental_street sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA �' �""om.mnm .min vvepn ivs aryor.M.b % X X % X X MS400112-199 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplemental street sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % X X % % MS400112-200 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplemental street_sweeping Vacuum sweeping No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X % X X X M5400112-201 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Enhanced road salt_management Calibration of spreaders No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA "noun®°r'er°"h'n•vE°u'^•"'Iry"'a"^"wrv'°"p�o�e e" % M5400112-202 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Enhanced road -salt_m nagement - Salt storage No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA ur:uaa % MS400112-203 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Enhanced road salt_m nagement Road temperature sensors No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % M5400112-204 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Enhanced-road salt_management Use of treated salt No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA % M5400112-205 Plymouth City M5400112 2016 Enhanced road salt_management Salt brine No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % MS400112-206 Plymouth City M5400112 2016 Enhanced road salt_management Anti-icing No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % MS400112-207 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Enhanced road salt_management Winter maintenance education No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % MS400112-208 Plymouth City M5400112 2016 Supplementalsublic educatlon_outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % X % X MS400112-209 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic educatlon_outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X X X % % MS400112-210 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic educatlon outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NAnsr4w % X % X X M5400112-211 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsubllc education outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA •__rte X X X % % % M5400112-212 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic educatlon outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % X X X X MS400112-213 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic_education outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA w r...a SYu6. N'me X % % X % MS400112-214 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic_education outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA s.re^rsr-w % X X X X MS400112-215 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsubllc_education outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA % % % % % X MS400112-216 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic_education_outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % % % X X MS400112-217 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsubllc_education_outreach Publications No 10 Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA • w.u.Aearo. w.v,ua vxv nvmoevuma,e r».• X X % X X MS400112-218 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalsublic_education putreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA X % % % % X MS400112-219 Plymouth City MS400112 2016 Supplementalyubllc_education outreach - Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permlttee(you) NA Me in..n muodep•e.�msb p.a..mmv.iwe .wwMwa.. �n X X X X X M5400112-220 Plymouth City M5400112 2016 Supplemental subllc education_outreach Publications No ID Information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee (you) NA raM o.r/alev o.y e.emvamearamn.vrvsu�ml•e.u�e"• X X X % % bmUmr.gmr Hrq b mNmnro lanampn�pa?n, nH prtn MS400112-221 PlymouthCiry M5400112 2016 Supplementalsubllc_education outreach Publications No ID information needed NA NA NA NA Permittee(you) NA .vk4.y..+re rmnwwu. ^.er. pam viq pe¢ouu,e.eaem X X X % X % - mr,.wwm., mnm...am drpn de+Nn/.mgem.ime+.. Page 32 Cumulative Reductions Spreadsheet Page 33 Category 1: Su_mm_ary of quantitative reductions (Annual Pollutant Load Reduction . Optional Permittee MS4 ID TMDL protect Units 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Calculation methou Notes Plymouth City MS400112 Eagle Lake - Phosphorus pounds reduced 2.328 2.328 2.328 Plymouth City MS400112 Pike Lake - Phosphorus pounds reduced 2.328 2.328 2.328 Plymouth City MS400112 Bass Lake - Phosphorus pounds reduced 86.452 133.235 133.235 Plymouth City MS400112 Pomerleau Lake - Phosphorus pounds reduced 43.013 43.013 43.013 Plymouth City M5400112 Schmidt Lake - Phosphorus pounds reduced 41.314 41.314 41.314 Plymouth City I MS400112 IShingle Creek Chloride TMDL - Chloride Category 2: Summary of qualitative reductions # of BMPs). Optional Permittee MS4 ID TMDL proiect 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Notes Plymouth City MS400112 Eagle Lake - Phosphorus 20 21 21 Plymouth City MS400112 Pike Lake - Phosphorus 20 21 21 Plymouth City MS400112 Bass Lake - Phosphorus 20 21 21 Plymouth City MS400112 Pomerleau Lake - Phosphorus 20 21 21 Plymouth City MS400112 Schmidt Lake - Phosphorus 20 21 20 Not cost effective to continue Plymouth City I MS400112 IShingle Creek Chloride TMDL - Chloride 27 27 27 We have found that by pre - Page 33 Non -Implemented activities (aivir Inventory) IPlace an ''X" in a cell if the activity applies to the T MDL shown in the column Permittee IMS4 Q BMP description Status Reporting year Notes (Optionai) Eagle Lake - Phosphorus Pike Lake - Phosphorus Bass Lake - Phosphorus Pomerleau Lake Schmidt Lake - Shingle Creek Chloride TMDL - Chloride Phosphorus Phosphorus Plymouth City MS400112 Development and Redevelopment Regulations Planned 2015 Redevelopment plays a big role in improving water quality as new regulations are more stringent. X X X X X X Plymouth City MS400112 Development and Redevelopment Regulations Planned 2016 Redevelopment plays a big role in improving water quality as new regulations are more stringent. X X X X X X Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Plymouth City MS400112 Page 34 Provide an UD -dated narrative describing any adaptive management strateeies used (including projected dates) for making progress toward achieving each applicable WLA The city has written and now implements standard operating procedures and enforcement response procedures to comply with the terms of the new permit. The city continues to evaluate it's progress towards meeting the WLAs of each of the TMDL's w thin the city and has reported our progress on our TMDLs in this annual report. Our surface water management fee along with outside funding sources from MPCA and Watershed Management Organizations will help to fund projects and programs that will be used to meet the WLAs. More stringent new and redevelopment rules that are now in place will also be used to help improve water quality on sites being developed. Page 3 5 To: rp) City of Plymouth From: i Adding Quality to Life Date: Memorandum City Council Ben Scharenbroich, Senior Engineering Technician July 3, 2017 Item: Water Efficiency Rebate Program — Final Results The City of Plymouth supports water conservation practices that help to reduce the water demand from municipal water supply customers. A rebate program was developed by the City of Plymouth, with financial help from the Metropolitan Council, to focus on improving the water efficiency at residential and commercial properties throughout the city. Rebates were offered to residential and commercial customers of the water utility, to replace old, inefficient toilets, urinals, washing machines and irrigation controllers with new, WaterSense® or EnergyStar rated products. Rebates reimbursed property owners for 75 percent of the cost of the device — up to a maximum of $50 for WaterSense® toilets, $100 for EnergyStar washing machines and $200 for WaterSense® irrigation controllers. The rebate program originally was funded $25,000 of which $18,750 was a grant from the Met Council with $6,250 in City matching funds. Rebates were awarded on a on a first come, first served basis. Payment was made upon successful completion of work and submittal of the rebate request form and original receipts. The program was originally scheduled to run from March 1St, 2016 to June 30, 2017, however, initial funds were exhausted in October 2016 due to large demand. Additional funding of $6,500 was awarded to the city in May 2017 from the Met Council and was combined with $2,170 of City funds. The additional funding has been exhausted and the rebate program closed on June 23rd 2017. City staff estimated before the rebate program began that if 100 of each product was installed, the city and its residents, would save an estimated 3,000,000 gallons of water annually. The results of the rebate program as of July 3, 2017 are shown in Table 1 below. Table 1: Water Efficiency Rebate Program— Final Results 1 Page 36 Devices People Estimated Gallons Estimated Gallons Rebates Installed Benefited Saved Annually Saved per Device Funded Toilet 175 267 1,228,048 7,017 $8,740.76 WaterSense® Washing Machine 122 323 628,252 5,150 $12,200.00 EnergyStar® Irrigation Controller 83 605 5,750,771 69,286 $14,394.63 WaterSense° Totals 380 1195 7,607071 20,019 $35,335.39 1 Page 36 Water use in the City of Plymouth can go from just over 150 million gallons per month in February to nearly 450 million gallons per month in July and August. This dramatic jump in water consumption is attributed to outdoor watering by residential and commercial property owners. Staff found that all residential and commercial property owners who received a rebate through this program were overwatering their lawns significantly. The rebate program provided property owners the incentive to replace old irrigation controllers with WaterSense® Certified irrigation controllers, which will result in a dramatic decrease their water usage going forward. It is important to note that irrigation controller replacement accounted for 21% of the devices receiving rebates, but accounted for 75% of the estimated annual water savings. Water savings through upgraded WaterSense® Certified irrigation controllers, sprinkler heads, moisture sensors and pressure regulators provide a significant benefit to both residential and commercial properties as shown in Table 2. Table 2: Water Efficiency Rebate Program — Irrigation Controllers *10 Irrigation Controllers installed at commercial properties where the number of benefited people is unknown. Funding for each rebate was split between the Met Council and the City of Plymouth. The Met Council funded 75% of the rebate, while the City of Plymouth funded 25%. The grant agreement with the Met Council allowed for up to $25,250.00 in rebate funding with the City of Plymouth covering the remaining rebate amount. The City of Plymouth funded $10,085.39 in rebates for this program for a total of $35,335.39 in rebates issued to residential and commercial property owners. It is also important to note that residential and commercial property owners have invested over $153,000 in upgrading the water efficiency of homes and businesses through this program. Overall, the rebate program has been a success and the improvements will save the city and its property owners an estimated 7,600,000 gallons of water annually. Staff has proposed in the draft 2018-2019 biennial budget $12,000 annually to continue this program for only irrigation controllers. In addition, staff will also explore additional funding sources such as the Metropolitan Council's Green Infrastructure Grant Program. Page 37 Estimated Devices People Gallons Saved Rebates Installed Benefited Gallons Saved per Device Funded ($) Annually Residential 73 617 3,974,727 54,448 $12,434.13 Commercial 10 Unknown* 1,776,044 177,604 $1,960.50 *10 Irrigation Controllers installed at commercial properties where the number of benefited people is unknown. Funding for each rebate was split between the Met Council and the City of Plymouth. The Met Council funded 75% of the rebate, while the City of Plymouth funded 25%. The grant agreement with the Met Council allowed for up to $25,250.00 in rebate funding with the City of Plymouth covering the remaining rebate amount. The City of Plymouth funded $10,085.39 in rebates for this program for a total of $35,335.39 in rebates issued to residential and commercial property owners. It is also important to note that residential and commercial property owners have invested over $153,000 in upgrading the water efficiency of homes and businesses through this program. Overall, the rebate program has been a success and the improvements will save the city and its property owners an estimated 7,600,000 gallons of water annually. Staff has proposed in the draft 2018-2019 biennial budget $12,000 annually to continue this program for only irrigation controllers. In addition, staff will also explore additional funding sources such as the Metropolitan Council's Green Infrastructure Grant Program. Page 37 r uCity of 9)p lymouth Adding Quality to Life July 7, 2017 SUBJECT: REQUEST FOR REGUIDING, REZONING, PRELIMINARY PLAT AND PUD GENERAL PLAN FOR DEVELOPMENT OF THE "SPEAK THE WORD CHURCH" SITE LOCATED EAST OF COUNTY ROAD 101, BETWEEN COUNTY ROAD 47 AND STATE HIGHWAY 55 (2017032) Dear Property Owner: Pursuant to the provisions of the Plymouth Zoning Ordinance, this "letter is to inform you of a request by West Plymouth Development Inc., under File No. 2017 032, for approval of three items for proposed development of the roughly 120 -acre site presently owned by Speak the Word Church, as follows: 1) reguiding of a portion of the site from P -I (public/institutional) to LA -2 (living area 2); 2) rezoning of portions of the site from FRD (future restricted development) to P- I and PUD (planned unit development); and 3) preliminary plat and PUD general plan for a new public elementary school in the south area to be rezoned to P-1, and for 111 single-family lots in the central area to be rezoned to PUD. A map showing the location of the subject property is provided below. Hennepin County records indicate your property is located within 750 feet of the site of this proposal. You are hereby notified of, and cordially invited to attend a public hearing to be held by the Plymouth Planning Commission at 7:00 p.m., on Wednesday, July 19, 2017, in the Council Chambers at Plymouth City Hall, 3400 Plymouth Boulevard. The public will be invited to offer questions and comments concerning this application at that time, or feel free to call the city planning department at (763) 509-5450 for more information. You may also submit comments in writing. All written comments will become part of the public record. INFORMATION relating to this request may be examined at the community development information counter (lower level of City Hall), on Mondays and Wednesday through Friday from 8:00 a.m, to 4:30 p.m., and on Tuesdays from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., except holidays. Sincerely, F) awl, %t01 Barbara G. Thomson, AICP Planning Manager 3400 Plymouth Blvd • Plymouth, Mi LOCAL Landfills sue state over push to burn more garbage Major trash firms challenge the push to burn waste for energy instead of landfill burial. By Eric Roper(http://w .startribune.com/erie•roper/62906482/) Star Tr bune JULY 5. 2017 — 7:31AM Landfills owned by the nation's two largest trash firms have sued the state over a push Io burn as iruchRa[hage (http://www.startribune.com/mpca-pushes-to-keep-twin-cities- trash-burning-at-capacitv/411420465/) as possible, rather than burying it. Four landfills serving the metro area, owned by Waste Management and Republic Services, filed suit in May against the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) alleging that it is misinterpreting a decades -old Minnesota law that prioritizes burning the metro area's garbage to generate energy. The agency fined the landfills $20,000 each this spring for accepting garbage that could have been burned at a local incinerator. One plant in particular, owned by Great River Energy in Elk River, regularly receives far less trash than it can handle. About 20 percent of the seven -county metro area's garbage was dumped in landfills in 2016, while 25 percent was burned to make energy. The remaining 55 percent was recycled or composted. Waste -to -energy facilities generally pull recyclable materials from the trash and grind it up before sending it into a giant fire, sometimes at a different location. Hennepin County's downtown Minneapolis facility burns the waste whole and removes metals afterward. The resulting ash, which is sent to landfills, is about a tenth the volume of the original garbage. Yet controlling the flow of garbage is no simple task, because haulers typically choose where to take their loads. A 2012 MPCA report said haulers decide where to travel based on facility prices — the fee to drop off a ton of trash — as well as distance and company preference. The MPCA announced its intent to begin enforcing (httr)s://mmw.psa.state.mn.us/sites/default/files/Irw-sw-4syl2.t)df) the 1980s law several years ago after the Legislature asked for a report on how to achieve compliance. Waste Management challenged the enforcement in 2013, arguing the agency hadn't followed the correct procedures, but lost its case at the Minnesota Court of Appeals. The landfills have now asked the courts to toss the MPCA's penalties. They argue the law is being misinterpreted to primarily hold landfills accountable, and that compliance is impossible without overhauling communication between landfills, haulers, incinerators and other trash -related companies. Trash in the metro area is certified annually by counties as "unprocessible" based on the ability to sort and burn it. Waste Management said that means their workers don't learn whether a load of trash could have been burned until long after they accepted it. "[Waste Management] is being penalized for a prior year's activity as measured against the operating capacity of a [garbage burner] over which it has no control," the suit said. MPCA planning director Sig Scheurle declined to comment on the cases due to the pending litigation. In a response filed in a Waste Management suit, the agency said it regularly provided the company with updates on their "likely compliance status." An attorney for Texas-based Waste Management also declined to comment. Kevin Bremer, area president at Arizona -based Republic Services, said in a statement that the company believes it is in compliance with the law. "We've been working cooperatively for a number of years with MPCA on this issue, but we currently have a difference of opinion regarding compliance with the ... statute," Bremer said. Bremer added that the publicly owned facilities are running at capacity. (htlp://stmedia.startribune. com/images/1499217063_08+100285726 LEILA NAVIDI. STAR TRI8UNE Tim Steinbeck, director of Great River Energy's Elk River Resource Processing Plant and Recovery Station, peered into a boiler burning Page 39 Processing generally costs more than dumping in a landfill, so public subsidies have helped keep some fees lower. Ramsey and Washington counties once used subsidies to lure business to a private processing plant in Newport, but recently bought it with the intent of requiring trash to be taken there. Republic's lawsuit, filed through its subsidiary BFI Waste Systems of North America, says the MPCA is trying to unfairly benefit Great River Energy. It notes that the Elk River facility's fee perton is higher than the market rate. "the MPCA's enforcement action is being taken only to allow a private entity to command, at the expense of its private competitors, a larger share of the market than it has been able to obtain in the competitive marketplace," the suit said - Great River Energy once benefited from Anoka and Hennepin County subsidies to help lower tipping fees, but no more. The company's director of resource recovery, Tim Steinbeck, said the waste -to -energy facility is among the pricier renewable powersources the company's member owners purchase. He has previously said they are losing millions a year on the Elk River operation. `Thus we need that $75tipping tee,"Steinbeck said. Burning garbage itself is controversial because of the air pollution emitted by the facilities. Hennepin County's downtown facility is among the largest point -Source emitters of nitrous oxide, lead, particulates and carbon dioxide in the county, according to MPCA data. Emissions were far below the agency's limits, however. The petitions to review the MPCA's penalties were pled in May by landfills in Inver Grove Heights, Burnsvilte, Ell. River and Glencoe. Three filed by Waste Management have been consolidated, with a hearing expected later this month. Twitter: a@StribRoper eric.ropo4stadribune.mm 612-673-1732 stfibRoper Page 40 �StarTribune LOCAL As road funding dries up, state agencies face dilemma: Patch or redo? I-94 buckles, highlights MnDOT's tough choices on how to fix roads. By Tim Harlow Star Tribune JULY 5, 2017 9:44AM The old concrete bubbled up under a new layer of asphalt last month during repair work on Interstate 94 in Minneapolis. The joints had been fixed and fresh asphalt laid over 40 -year-old concrete on Interstate 94 between downtown Minneapolis and Brooklyn Center. But before traffic even started to roll over the new multimillion -dollar freeway, the pavement buckled in five places from the 90 -degree June heat, leading to higher costs and more delays. Page 41 The incident highlights a wrenching debate that is playing out among state officials trying to stretch limited transportation money to fix or replace as much roadway as possible. In Minnesota and in many other states, transportation funding has lagged as road conditions have deteriorated. "We are undercapitalized," said Minnesota Department of Transportation Commissioner Charlie Zelle. He has said the state is in "patching mode" because of the funding shortfall. In fact, Minnesota is facing a $2.8 billion transportation shortfall over the next four years, according to TRIP, a national transportation research group. The Legislature this year authorized $600 million in new funding for roads and bridges. The national report said 44 percent of major metro -area roads are in poor or mediocre condition due to lack of funding. Roads in poor condition are projected to increase from 535 miles to 963 miles by 2020. The report also said MnDOT needs $1.8 billion to $2.5 billion to move forward with projects to reduce congestion and improve traffic safety. In many cases, the debate comes down to this: an asphalt patch or a concrete overhaul. Zelle said he'd like to redo I-94 and other heavily traveled roads with concrete. But the decision to patch joints and cover concrete with asphalt is a matter of time and resources. The asphalt overlay on I-94 will last as long as a full concrete rehab, he said. "If you close 94 [and do it] with concrete the whole way, that would be a two-year project," Zelle said. "We are keeping traffic open, and even though it is pretty disruptive, it is going to be done in a year. If faced with completing this in a year, getting the same life duration and we can do it with less traffic disruption, that is a pretty easy choice." Asphalt as `Band-Aid' Matt Zeller, executive director of the Concrete Paving Association of Minnesota and a former MnDOT employee, has a problem with the state's "Band-Aid" approach to fixing its highways. Instead of ripping out old concrete and laying new — a costly proposition, Zeller acknowledges, but one that would last another 30 to 40 years the state routinely has covered up its aging concrete with asphalt, which is cheaper but likely to last only 12 to 15 years. Page 42 "The problem is they are not addressing the root cause of the concrete deteriorating," Zeller said. "The concrete below is starting to break down and it has very little support. When the blacktop is put over the top, there is nothing to hold the asphalt up. It is a very expensive Band-Aid fix." Asphalt is a feasible and economical solution, even if it means going back and doing the work sooner than if new concrete were put down, said Adeel Lari, a research fellow at the University of Minnesota's Humphrey School of Public Affairs and a former senior manager at MnDOT. "You can build with concrete to last a very long time, but it is very expensive," Lari said. "You have only so much money. It's like our personal budget. You can buy a new car, or fix the one you have and have it last another three years. Those are the kinds of decisions MnDOT is making." To rebuild I-94, the agency would need $1 billion, or the cost of a Vikings stadium, MnDOT's Zelle said. He acknowledges that by opting for the patching and reconstruction in bits and spurts, motorists likely will experience construction some place on the metro area's I-94 corridor annually for the next 15 years. MnDOT resurfaces I-94 between the downtowns of St. Paul and Minneapolis about every seven years. The Paving Association's Zeller points to other projects where MnDOT has taken the asphalt Band-Aid approach, only to be back redoing the work sooner than planned. In the 1990s, MnDOT applied asphalt over concrete on I-394 after neighbors complained about the whine created by the concrete pavement. The asphalt began to break apart a decade later, exposing chunks of concrete. MnDOT applied another thin layer of asphalt in the 2000s. Two years ago, when I-394 was rife with potholes and divots, the agency stripped off the asphalt, dug out deteriorating joints, replaced them and shored up the concrete around them. The agency then smoothed out the surface using a process called diamond grinding. MnDOT's Zelle called it "the best road in the state" and a freeway that won't need major attention for another 25 years. Aside from building a new freeway from scratch, a better solution, the Paving Association's Zeller said, would have been for MnDOT to do a concrete overlay, meaning placing new concrete over the existing concrete. That would provide structural integrity for years to come, he said. `This is not a perfect fix' Page 43 With the I-94 issues last month, MnDOT sent the contractor back to make fixes to the road it had just repaired. MnDOT pavement engineer Tim Clyne said concrete bubbled up June 3 and June 4 in at least five locations between 26th Avenue N. and West Broadway — two on the westbound side and three on the eastbound side. Contractor PCi Roads had to grind out the distressed concrete below the surface that caused the problems and then patch the 9 -inch holes with asphalt, not concrete. "That should hold up to the traffic load," Clyne said. "This is old concrete, and every summer it gets hot and joints lockup and pop." Road buckles occur most often at joints in concrete that are old and weak. Project manager Tim Nelson said that the asphalt made the pavement hotter and contributed to the blowups, but that once traffic returned, it helped to keep it cooler, lessening the chances of more buckles on the newly paved lanes. As work proceeds on I-94, will the freeway continue to buckle? "It's possible we will see more bumps in the road," Clyne said, at least until the final 2 -inch layer of asphalt is applied later this summer. But he added: "The risk of this continuing should be significantly less. This is not a perfect fix. It won't last another 100 years. We are trying to keep an old road in good condition." harlow@startribune.com 612-673-7768 timstrib Page 44