Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPark and Recreation Advisory Commission Packet 11-12-1987Regular Meeting of the Park and Recreation Advisory Commission November 12, 1987, 7:30 p.m. Council Chambers AGENDA I. Call to order 2. Approval of Minutes 3. Visitor Presentations a. Athletic Associations b. Staff c. Others 4. Report on Past Council Action a. Reject Bids on Parkers Lake Pavilion, b. Trail and Sidewalk Standards 5. Unfinished Business a. Lions Park Play Equipment b. Parkers Lake Pavilion Del Erickson c. Neighborhood Parks Update d. 1987 Trail. Projects Update e. Timing of 1988 Construction Projects 6. New Business a.. Review Park Usage and Cost Study Report- b. eportb. New Plats 7. Commission Presentation 8.. Staff Communication 9. Adjournment Next Meeting - December 10 0 i Minutes of the Park and Recreation Advisory CommissionMeeting October 14, 1987 Page 32 Present.- Chair Edwards, Commissioners Reed, Anderson, Beach, Rosen, Bauman and LaTour: staff Blank and Pederson; Councilman Sisk and Del Erickson 1. CALL TO CKER: Chair Edwards called the October meeting to order at 7:37 p.m. in the Council Conference Room. 2. APPROVAL OF MINUIS; A motion was made by Commissioner Beach and seconder by Commissioner Rosen,to approve the minutes of the September meeting as presented. The motion ,carried with all ayes. 3. VISI'J C t ENrATI( U a. Athletic Assgr.,iations. None were present at this meeting. b. Staf No recreation staff were present at this meeting. C. Others. Trkere were no visitors. 4. REPMT ON PAST CCUWIL ACTICIN Council authorized staff to go out for bids on the Parkers Lake Pavilion. 5. IR EUNISHED BUSINESS a. Parkers Lake Eyi ign Review Bids. Director Blank reviewed for the commissioners the bid results and indicated his disappointment at how high they were. Architect Del Erickson stated that he spoke to the contractors about why their bids were high, and he also talked to contractors who did not bid. Their main reason for not bidding was that they had work this time of year and simply did not need the business. Director Blank and Mr. Erickson indicated that one of the options available at this gime would be to have the project re -bid in January, when the bidding climate is generally better. There is a possibility that bids could crane in even lower then. Areas where bids were higher than estimated include: site work, general conditions, masonry, carpentry, mechanical and electrical. CoL.n.cAlman Sisk suggested doing the construction of the Pavilion in phases, as was once discussed by PRAC earlier in the year. PRAC indicated that was not practical now, because the building had been redesigned, and the new design wasn't suitable for building in two phases. PRAC Minutes October 14, 1987 Page 33 Based on Mr. Erickson's original estimate of $330,000 for the building alone, it was Commissioner Feed's opinion that the Council would never approve any of the bids received. He would bike to see costs reduced in.an effort to get bacxc to the original estimate, although he isn't. sure how or if that can be done. Mr. Erickson stated that to reduce the costs by $80,000 would substantially change the structure and design of the building. Commissioner Rveen wanted to know who decides that the costs are too much and who established the original budget of $380,000? Director Blank stated that that was the early projection by the architect. Director Blank had suggested that $180,000 be taken from park dedication and the rest of the financing was to come from revenue sharing. Councilman Sisk reminded PRAC though that the revenue sharing money could'be.used for other City projects, too. It's not necessarily promised to park and rc,:reation. Director Blank indic+.ted that his recommendation at this time would be:to reject all bids and redesign the project and then re -bid it in January, when contractors are more likely to be looking For work. Chair Edward asked Councilman Sisk if the Council realizes that this building is more than a bathhouse, and if they understand just how important it is to PRAC that the facility be ofgood quality? She stated that Parkers Lake is our most visible park in Plymouth seen by residents as well as people not living in Pllmauth who use Co:mty Roed 6 on their way to and from work. She feels that the pavilion should be just as unique as t`!e park. Other commissioners agreed with. Chair Edward can this,. Councilmen Sisk responded that the Council does realize that this facility is more than a bathhouse. He also stated that he could tei' how strong PRAC feels about this facility, buthe thinks PRAC deeds to be more verbal. about their feelings with the rest of the Council. He urged PRAC members to attend Council meetings more often to make their desires known. He stated that they should nod always rely on Director Blank to be their sole spokesman. A M7tICN WAS MAM BY OC MISSICNR ROAN AND SECx'UM By OCMISSICNER ANDERSON REO"INDING 7NAT ALL BIDS BE 'D AND THAT PRAC RE- EVALUATE THE ALTERNATIVES. The motion carried with all ayes. Director Blank pointed out to the ccnmissioners that in re-signing this facility, they should keep in mind that the Council recently approved a firestation to be built in Plymouth, and that the main purpose of this facility is to keep firetrucks out of the snow and Train. With the possibility that 30,000-50,000 Plymouth residents will use the Parkers Luce Pavilion on a yearly basis, shouldn't it also be built with a quality equal to the fire station? 1. 11&te Phase II Construction. The ornamental lights for Parkers Lake Park have been shipped and are expected to be installed by October 23, and the by-pass lane along County R01d 6 is almost completed. PRAC Minutes October. 14, 1987 Page 34 Commissioner Roam wondered about the placement of the picnic tables in this park. Director Blank responded that they have been situated in the large open grassy area west of the playground equipment, but that they are not anchoreddown in any way. He indicated that he wanted it that way, so that people could move them around to suit the size of their group. b. Neighk&rbggd ParhamJWae. Director Blank indicated that construction is 95% c+amplete on the three newest parks. Seeding and sodding is finished at Rolling Hills and County Road, 61, with just a small amount of sodding remaining to be done at AaOurst. C. 1987 _Trail Projects [Iodate. Trails along Zachary Lane north of the e1cvmtary school, and along Fernbrook Lanae from County Road 9 to Road 6 are finished, and the trail, along Highway 101 :is 85% cm,plete. Co issioner Rosen. tasked: 3.f the 101 trail would c -o as far north as County Road24;. Director Blank stated that it goes to only 24th Avenue. He did indicate, that when PRAC begins stuaying the 89- 93 CTP, the issue of running that trail up to County Road 24 could be discussed at that time. d.. Lions Park Play Dau nmMt. Director Blank reviewed with the Commissioners the request from the residents regarding the installation of new -playground equipment in Lions Park. He stated that he had met with Mrs Schmidt and Mrs. Bruzek and had shared fear catalogs with them on various playgrc and pieces. lie also indicated that several letters hadbeer, received from residents offering their suggestions for which pieces to buy. Mrs, Bruzek was present at the meeting and stated her prefere-:6ce for the Durascape piece, which is geared primarily to pre-schoolers, with some features for older children. Director Blank stated that he was comfortable with the Durascape equipment, but that BigToy tends to e a little less expensive. He also stated that the budget established for this equipment was $10,0000 but that it could be increased if the Lions Club is willing to contribute to the project in 1988, Canniss overs then discussed,if it would be better to buy two pied, one for:.` pre-schoolers and one for older children, or to buy one large piece that would be suitable for several ages. Director Blank responded that either choice was okay, but he pointed out that the equipment isri t built for age levels, but rather for different skill levels. After some discussion on who should make the final decision on which pieces to purchase, it was the consensus of MW, to let staff choose the equipment based on the suggestions of the residents incl the opinions of the commissioners. Director Blank said that he would keep in mind that the emphasis should be primarily on pre -schoolchildren with some features for older children also included. He will have a recommendation by the November PW meeting. The equipment -would then be ordered in January or February, with installation sometime in the spring of 1988. 1, PRAC Minutes, October 1.4, 1987 Page 35 e;RP sidam k an Trait Standards. Director Blank stated that the City s engineering department has a book on the standards established for streets, trails, sign poets, etc.., including a standard design for sidewalks He reminded PRAC that this item was referred to them by the City Council, and that they would like PRAC to review our standard. Director .Blank pointed out to the Commission that the City has no sidewalk plan, only a trail plan, and that developers pat sidewalks in at their own choice. If sidewalks are going to be installers in developments, they should all be the same, width in order to avoid confusion. He further irklicated that it is his rec amendation, as well as the rec talation of Fred More. and Blair Tremere, that sidewalks be 5' in width in residential areas and 6, in width in ecamercial areas, with trails reiasining 8` in width. It was the general consensus of PRAC that they do not wish to get involved in the ,planning of sidewalks, and although.Director Blank understands that opinion, he .feels that as a an advisory board to the city Council, they shculd snake a recimmmdation on a 'sidewalk width standard. COMMISSIONER REE AWM A MOTION TO RBO"END THAT SIDEWALKS BE INS. UXZD AT A WIDTH OF 5 .r=- The motion died on the floor for lack of a second. A NOTION WAS MADE BY CMMISSICNER LA=R AND SECMM BY OCp"ISSjCt4M BFACH To RB004 END TMT THE CITY COLMIL APPROVE STAFF'S RB= 4NUATICN THAT SIDE A SCS IN RESIDENTIAL AREAS BE 5 IN WIDTH, IN =44E RCIAL AREAS 6` IN WIDTH AMID 'THAT TRAILS SMD REMIN 8` IN WIDIN AT A MINIMI. The motion carried with all, ayes. a, Ngiahborhood park gitina North Sglection. Director Blank indicated: that a developer has come in with a plan for a residential development north of County Road 9, east of Fernbrook Lane and Vest of 2-494. This area has a lot of natural forest and marsh land, and the developer agrees with DirectorBlankthat some of their site in this even should be preserved as park. Director Blank reviewed an aerial photograph of this area with PRAC and has chosen a preliminary site for the neighborhood park, and will keep PRAC: informed on its proposed location and size as further development plans are forthcoming. b, Petitics from Dis rict 284 Youth HoGkev, Tbe,City Manager has received a petiticxi frcm residents involved with the District 284 Youth Hockey program, requesting that the City construct a ccmnunity center with a facility for indoor hockey. Jt,is Director Blank`s recc mendation that before PRAC proceed on this matter, they wait until after the commmity attitude survey is completed which. is scheduledfor this fall. He stated that theme attitude surveys are done about every two years and have, in the past, included questions on the ccmm,mity s desire for such a facility. Commissioner Bauman asked if he would see a copy of the questionnaire being prepared. FRAC Minutes October 14, 1,987 Page 3 councilman Sisk didn`'t knr-, if the current questionnaire would be available to him, but he might be able to look at al previous survey. Director Blank indicated that he would send Gcnmiss,oner Bauman a copy of an earlier questionnaire. C,. Mgt MWir rn rake Drive Trail St&W from Strvar-Director Blank stated that this was going to be a very large issue to research, because cost estimates range anywhere from $275,000 to 1.6 million. He suggested that FRAC should incorporate the: planning for this trail into their, 1989-93 CIP. Commissioner Reed asked if the trail, along Vit Medicine rake Drive could be divided into segmits rather than being done all at once, and if so, could the portion on the north end of wmt Medicine;Lake Drive be done first? Director Blank resperxied that it could be done that way. Chair EAerds asked if this item will be on future agendas, and Director Bunk indicated that it will appear on all agendas unt?l the trail is decided on definitely, d., latter frau Elsri,taae HCaA - County RQasl 61 Park. Director Blank stated that the City Manager, Mayor Schneider and he would be visiting with Merilee,Riley sometime during the week of October 19 to review with her the concerns raised by the Heritage Homeowners Association regarding this park. e. Tamino of 1988 Work Plan. Director Blank stated that the St. Mary s neighborhood perk is proposed ,for construction in 1988 and that in order to follow a timely schedule, 'the design consultant should be hired in Dec er, with neighborhood m-etings scheduled fcr Januar! 7.. COMMISSION MENTATION Chair Edwards mentioned that she did not find anything in the annual MPA f conference: schedule specifically -,)r board and commission meters to attend. Director Blank said t1W, he had 'been so busy, he hadnt had a chance to look at the schedule himself, out that the Annual Conferences was in progress and. was hoeing held at the North Hennepin Community College. It is scheduled to conclude on Friday, October 16. Commissioner Rosen indicated that h felt very strongly about PRAC members attending City Council; meetings in the future whenever any item on their agenda deals with park and recreation issues. Director Blank. responded that he and Chair Edwards have discussed this and concur with Commissioner Root. A K)TICN WAS MADE: BY CO MIS5ICNER ROSEN AND SECMW BY C"ISSICNM BNp." REM4#EMING THAT *EWARMW IS AN ITEM ON THE CTX Cao WT11 AGUCA DEALING WITH' PARRS APII? RWtE.ATIC>N, PRAC MAKE EVERY UTWr TO ATTE'D, AND BY EVERY ETTORT SCMEONE SHl7IW BE APPOINTED TO BE 11"E. Chair Edwards indicated that she did not care for the wording of the motion, specifically the part about appointing someone to attenxd. She stated that it has been her practice in the past to inform members PRAC Minutes October 14, 1997 Page 37 whenever an issue about parks is going to be on the Council agenda and to ask if any members will be able to attend. A MOTION WAS MALE BY COMMISSIONER ROSF'N AND SECONDED BY CCWISSIONER LAIUM TO AM0 TETE MAIN MOTION BY DELETING TES PART ABOCTt APPOINTING A FRAC M9§NFV TO ATTf-M COUNCIL MEETINGS. The amendment carried with all ayes. The rain nation as amended was then voted on.and carried with all ayes. Commissioner Room indicated that he would attend the Council meeting on Monday, October 19. 8. STAFF WOHN LCATICN There were no comixmications by star. 9. ADJOURNMENTTr The meeting adjourned at 10:55 p.m. CITY Of °LYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD,, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800 DATE; November 5, 1987 MEMO TO: PR 0 C2 PRAM: Eric: Blank, SUBJECT. PARK USAGE AND COST SUZY RE7M As part of the 1,988 City Manager's goals and objectives, I was responsible for preparing a park usage and cost.study report for the City Manager: This report was presented to the City Manager and the City Council at a Council meeting on October 26th. Upon review of the contents of the report, the City Council has sent the report to the Park<and Recreation Advisory Commission for review and possible action. I have attached for your information the minutes of the Council meeting regarding this item. It is my understanding that the City Council would like the Park and Recreation Advisory Commission in early 1988 to look at any possible cost saving measures or revenue enhancing measures which could be undertaken during 1988 or subsequent years. The Commission could consider any number of possible alternatives including additional user fees.for youth athletic associations, The Council saecifically asked that the Commission conduct some type of public information meetings in January, February and March to gather additional information on such a proposal. WN CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD., PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA. 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 5$9-2600 DATE. CG1987 MEMO October 2, TO: James G. Willis, City MwvWr FROM: FXIC J. Blank, Director of Parks and Recreation SUBJECT: REVIEW OF PARK. USAGE AND MAINTfl9 XM LEVELS As part of the 1987 Performarm Standards and Measures for the City Manager I have been asked to prepare a review of the appropriate park usage and current parr maintenance levels for our park system. In the following pages, I have attempted to review for you and. the Council:, the following items; Cur current park system plan, which identifies our park standards and park usage philosophy. A. summary review of the Task Force Report on Park and Recreatia'I Financing for Facilities and Program. The growth in the park system in; terms of acres, programs, and other information since 1980: Park maintenance costs for neighborhood parks, camwnity playfields, city parks, and costs per facility such as: ice skating, soccer, softball, etc., After you have had a chance to review this document, I would be happy to meet with you: and further review and analyze the information that I have provided here. In 1984, the City Council charged the Park and Recreation Advisory Commission with the task of preparing a ccoprehensive park system plan for the City of Plymouth. After a Mr and a half' in the development process, this plan was adopted by the City Council in February of 1982. Contained within this plan, is the philosophy, rationale and procedures by which the City of Plymouth has chosen to acquire,developand maintain a variety of park facilities. Inherent in developing this document was the process of developing a variety of stan3ards that the City should strive to obtain. As an example, standards for neighborhood parks were; ora:: park per neighborhood 2.5 to 3.5 developed acres per 1,000 population five to 21 acres in size. For community playfields, the standards developed were; one playfield per c c m unity 2.5 developed acres per 1,000 population 20 to 65 acres in size. For city parks, the standards developed were; four to five parks disbursed throughout the City, with a 20 acre minimum or large enough. to encompass and protect a natural resource. The Park System was also reviewed for what we refer to as its "functional standards." The integrity and flexibility of the entire park system can be monitored through the use of the following functional classifications. There 9s no one "correct" mix of functional components, but it is nevertheless imperative that each component be represented within the system in order that. the system can be balanced and that it demonstrates its long-term viability. The five functional classifications are; QXM2rvaticn - the preservation of significant natural amenities such as lakes, creeks, wetlands, prairies, woodlands, unique and significant iandforms, vegetative comaunities and views, flood plains, etc. Conservation, in this sense, means protection frari destruction by all forms of urban encroachment. the decorative, aesthetic aspect of the park system. ornamentation is usually provided through the development and maintenance of natural amenities, either formally or informally. Q lt= - refers primarily to the non -recreational programming of the parks and, as such, usually represents a small percentage of land area, though freq%mtly a large part of programming. Culture encompasses historicall places, public amphitheaters, museums, educational programs and so on. MtiW - includea participatory activities, active and passive, intensive and extensive, for all age groups in the community. unity. R—n— - perhaps the most important, yet most frequently overlooked function of a park system is its reserve --its ability to expand and be flexible in the face of future growth and development, as well as changing recreation demands and opportunities. At this time, the two arems that we would appear to be the weakest in are ornamentation and cultural facilities. The fountains and featured gardens at Parkers Lake are our first attempt to promote these areas within our park system. The rAxt phase of the development plan was to review the Plymouth corm mities. A study was done of the population, household size, employment growth, and other trends by walking neighborhoods and driving neighborhoods. Population by neighborhoods was the driving factor creating the demand for acres of neighborhood park and conmunity playfields. Facility standards were also analyzed. In this process, we are able to c "re ourselves now and in the future. to national norms with regard to the number of, tennis courts per 1,000 people, the number of softball fields per 1,000 people, the number of baseball/softball fields per 1,000 people, etc.. The next part of our development process was a park needs analysis. The park needs analysis for neighborhood parks: is also included in the appendix of this report. Within the park needs analysis, we looked at the ultimate population of each neighborhood, the existing park acres within that neighborhood, con"red that to our standard of 2.5-3.5 acres per 1,000 people and were able to determine which neighborhoods at that time had a deficiency in park acreage` This allowed us to set =p a plan by which parks would be acquired in future years. This has continued to be the guiding force in our annual development of the capital improvement program.. The next step in the process was perhaps the most important. This was the future park identification phase. In this phase, the consultant, was charged. with the reepcnsibility of locating within the community a variety of options that would: meet, the standardsfor the various park types that had been set out earlier in the report. Each site was compared against other sites in. its ability to provide the ccigx rents that would allow each park to function properly in providing the desired experiences to the park visitor. So=mme of the items that were numerically scored in ranking these facilities were: location within the walking or driving neighborhood relationship to the thoroughfare guide plan vegetation surface water conditions existing ownership and use adjacent proposed land use proximity of se,.er and water wetlands and soil conditions. Each of these factors has a different importance to each different type of park For example, a central location is much more important to a neighborhood park that people walk to than it is to a playfield to which most people may drive. It was this type of analysis that allowed the Park Oa mission and planners to take the prototype standard of a neighborhood park and oonpare it to specific sites in the field throughout the community. The end result is what we know today as the comprehensive park system plan; a detailed mapping of all future park sites to be acquired by the City of Plymouth.: The final part. of the park:: system plan was the setting of priorities based on the current demand s determined by populations within neighborhoods. Included in the appendix are the priorities developed in the 1982 plan and an analysis of the perk acquisition that has taken place between 1982 and 1986 to mmt the priorities that had been established. Next. I will touch very briefly on the results of the Task Force on Park and. Recreation Program Financing. In January of 1982, the Mayor and City Council charged a task force to study and report on the guiding philosophies that would be used in preparing future financial programa; as they relate to the park and recreation component of the City budget. Jim Rice, Chairman of the Park and Recreation Advisory Commission at that time, was chosen to chair this task force. On May 2, 1993, the City Council. passed a resolution endorsing the findings and concepts as developed by the Task, Force. This resolution is also included in the appLv4ix of this report. The findings of the task force are contained for the most.part within the five major funding philosophy statements that they prepared as part of the report. These funding statements as taken from the report are.- A. re: A. Research and Planning The majority of all research and planning should be underwritten by tax -supported resources. This deals with the long-range planning for the total park and recreation system. B. Construction of Facilities The City shall use- endowments, grants, gifts, etc., whenever possible to underwrite facility construction.: When these sources of fends are not available, the taxpapr should underwrite the capital cats of such facilities. New construction should inch a forecast of operating costs no construction should start until the City has agreed to pay the operating costs. C. Maintenance of Facilities The City's financial resources shall be used to maintain the basic level of maintenance necessary to maintain in a reasonable manner, all parks and recreational facilities within the system. We believe that the everyday,` ongoing maintenance, e.g., mowing the grass, is inherent with the City-owrship of any and all parks and should not be cost -associated with special user groups. user groups shall pay the majority of costs necessary to cover extra- ordinary maintenance associated with their group's use of special facilities. D. Development of programs Because recreation is important to all segments of our population including Ow young, old, gifted and handicapped; the taxpayer should underwrite the cost of the research and development of program to meet the needs of all segments of the amity. E. Operation of Program Program participants should pay the direct costs and some administrative costs &ssociated with participating in any given activity. Special consideration will be given to underwriting some costs for the mentally and physically hardicapped and elderly populations. In preparing our annual City budgets and the capital improvement budget, we have tried to prepare our finau-rcial programs based on these five funding philosophy statements. cne example of this is the fee policy we have that requires the Wayzata Youth Soccer Association to pay approximately a $1,000 user fee for the rental of our soccer facilities during their annual invitational soccer tournament. The Association on the other hand does not pay a rental fee for our facilities for their in-house soccer program which is gcaerecd toward the basic Plymouth youth recreational pa.ticipanto ;Another example is the fees charged for adult softball participation which includes coats associated with field maintenance and energy costs for night play. Ther. type of management practices directly resulted from the philosophies put forth in the Task: force report. The next area that needs to be reviewed in this r rt is the subject of growth, Growth within the City of Plymouth has been driving us in two ways. First, new people :have created a depend for additional neighborhood parks throughout the comnulitye In the, last seven years, the City has mealy developed neighborhood parks at Timber Shores, Mission, Schmidt bake, Rolling Hills, Amturat, County Road 61, and Maple Creek. our total park acreage has increased from approximately 275 acres to approximately 600 acres between 1980 and 1987..our city population has increased 130% frcai 1980 to 1986. A dramatic increase has occurred in the number of participants in programs during the same time frame. Increases in our program participation far exceeded the rate of population growth &&ring the last six years. Listed below is,a 9", ary of sane of this participation growth. IM 1 r of programs 121: 779 461% increase Pa:t.icipation in fee supported 4,132 17,443 422% increase general recreation program Adult team sports 137 492 352% increase Individual sports 11322: 1,664 126% increase Use of playfields (1981) 1,021 3,197 313% increase Population 31,615, 41,207 130 increase These figures do not include Wayzata Recreation programs provided on a contractual basis in 1,,986 & 1987.) Of the figures above, the most .important statistic to this review is the 300% increase in the use of tl* community playfields. The. jump from 1,000 games per year to over 3,000 games per Year is a direct result of the increasing program demands not only by adult athletics, but mare likely from the various youth athletic associations that continue to grow and expand programs within our City. As people beck more wellness conscious, we will, see more people staying active later ih their lives. The young soccer player of today will wait to participate its adult leagues as they 9et older. Later in this report you will see the hours associated with maintaining individual sport facillties. Had we not developed an appropriate community playfield system, the neighborhood park system would have seen a dramatic increase in. inappropriate uses and a much higher maintenance cost associated' with that usage. Problem 'with parking, noise, trash, etc., would be very ccolmn, i Rick Busch, of our staff is assigned the responsibility of working with the youth athletic associations and our adult sports program. It is his job to attempt to balance the needs of the users versus the ability of the playfields to withstandextremely heavy user occasions. we have in the past said "no," and we will say "no" in the future when it is necessary. The continued growth of all of our sports user groups will be ore of the most important determining factors on the timing of the development of the: Hass bake and Parkers Lake cc m mitt' playfields. Without a doubt, the most startling figure within the Park and Recreation budget has bow the dramatic increase in the park maintenance budget, which was $256,810 in 1981 and is projected to be $796,200 in 1988. Our highly maintained acres have increased from about 100 acres to about 350 acres between 1981 and 1987.Luring this time we also have added.four additional year-round shelters, for a total of 5. The park maintenance division will have grown frau five full-time employees in 1881 to 10` full-time employees in 1988.. Cur pert -time or seasonal work.for us has also increased from approximately 7,000 hours to 14,500 hours annually during this same time period. Since 1984, the park maintenance division has had available a computer on which all of our maintenance time care could be entered. Based on an analysis of the last three years, we have estimated that average maintenance hours per acre for neighborhood.parks is approximately 41 hours per acre per year. she average time for our beach facilities is between 80 and 90 hours per acre per year. The average time for commmity playfields appears to be between 80 and 83 hours per acre per year. Themajor items of the maintenance program for the neighborhood park system lied. in four areas. (This example is Green Oaks Park excluding new construction.) A. Mowing and trimming 45% B. Play structure repair 6% C. Rink flooding and cleaning 14 D. Garbage pick-up 1.0 75% Other components of our neighborhood park maintenance work make up the remaining 25% of the annual cost.. Examples of this are: fertilizing, broadleaf weed control, signage, tree planting, trail maintenance and repair, etc. We have designed, our new neighborhood parks in an effort to keep park maintenance costs down. The three new parka developed in 1987 total 45..8 acres in size. of this amount, 9.13 acres or 20% will be high maintenance or mowed area. The remaining 36.67 acres or 80% will be very low maintenance, natural area. Attached in the appendix is a detailed end of year summary for 1986 showing costs for the various parks within the City. Tasted below is a summary report of a review of the Park maintenance hours for neighborhood parks, beaches and playfiel,ds for the year 1986 along with a sum ary .report for the years 1984 and 1985. Park Maint2a= HoursReviftof 1986 Neighborhood Parks 7.0 Acres Schmidt Lake. 239 Hours 5.0 Acres. Queensland 190 Hours 6.8 Acres Green Oaks 308 Hours 3.0 Acres Lions 401 Hours 8.0 Acres Mission Hills 227 Hours 2.2 Acres Circle 200 Hours 13.0 &M Shiloh 303 Hours 45.0 Acres 1,868 Hours 45 41.5 Hr/Ac 1986 Beeches 10.8 Acres East Beach 913 Hours 3.0 Acre Wot Beach 390_ Hoffa 13.8 Acres 1,303 Hours 13.8 = 94.4 1986 Playf ields 24.0 Acres Plymouth Creek 1,757 Hours 5.0 Acres LeConpte 706 Hours 14.0 Acres Plymouth Jr. High 1,417 Hours 18.0 Acres Oakwood 1,328 Hours 33.0 Acres. Zachary 2,566 Hours 17.0 Acres Ridge aunt 931 Hours Playfields in General 385 Hours 111.0 Acres 9,090 Hours : 112 = 81.89 Neighborhood Parks. playf ields Summary 1904 41..0 Hours/Acre 79.0 Hours/Acre 83.5 Hours/Acre IT - 41;.:00 Hours/Acre 94.00 Hours/Acre 81.16 Hours/Acre nese figures do not include any "new construction hours. The park maintenanoe work associated with the oomnn ty playfields is much broader and more time cavo ng than the maintenance required for neighborhood parks. Items stch as irrigation maintenanoe, building cleaning and repair, line painting, infield maintenance, top dressing, and seeding and sodding add to our other maintenanoe areas to, in effect, double the average hour per acre cost for community playfields. The most time consuming are: mowing/trimm ng 12% line painting 8% seed/sWrepair 9% building/repair/maint. 6% rink maintenance 16% irrigation 4% garbage 51 60% One should remember that the average neighborhood park runs between two and approximately 13 acres in size. The community playfields on the other hand run between 17 and 33 acres in size. This factor alone dictates by their very size that they will require more work per site each year. Contract maintenaime cn such things as plumbing, electrical, irrigation and lighting are not reflected in these hour per acre costs. The special nature of these systems requires either special training or special equipment that at this time is not practical for the City to provide on an in-house basis. In an effort to quantify our overall maintenanoe effort, I'would suggest that on a scale of 1 through 5 our overall. ranking perhaps could be rated as a 4-. While there are some areas such as trimming, weeding and misoeilaneous repairs where we could improve, there are other areas such as field dragging and lining, snow plowing and rink flooding where our level of service could be somewhat decreased'. One means of gauging the st=ess of the maintenance service provided would be feedback from the conmxunity. During the last five years, we have received high marks from both the community survey .instrument and from the athletic associations and the adult sports community. in 1979 and 1980, the City was being critic zed for poor maintenance on many of its facilities. At the time of my hire, it was made clear to me that part of my responsibility was to make improven-ants in this area in an effort to turn around the perception of the community of our poor maintenance. Hopefully, we have been able to meet this goal. Just as notr all parka are created equal, not all athletic fields are created equal. Some programer by their very nature require more sophistication and more maintenance than other programs. Outlined below are our best estimates of the amual cost for the maintenance on one hockey rink, one softball field, and one wooer/football field. Because our recording system is based on hours worked on projects by site, Mark has had to estimate as best he can some of the hours associated with each of these cost estimates by facility. Light Bulbs. Irrigation Equip. Fertilizer Chemicals Paint Electrical AgLme Lime Grand Total 8375 400 300 80 20 300 1.00 1,825 X4,727 Mowing Hours Full -Time. Hours Part -Time 260 E Mowing 26 480 411 260 Painting 10 Turf Renovation 160 100 Irrigation 13 8 208 65 Turf Renovation 5 80 100 Spray & pert. 8 128 56 Electricity 8 128 40 Garbage 22 110 55 Miscellaneous 16 256 80 Trimming 10 50 50 Infield Mint. 29 4$ 3_ZQ Q 1:06 UNiMWt 80 and 1, 856 a teria" 1, 046 Light Bulbs. Irrigation Equip. Fertilizer Chemicals Paint Electrical AgLme Lime Grand Total 8375 400 300 80 20 300 1.00 1,825 X4,727 Mowing 26 416 260 Painting 48 768 480 Irrigation 13 208 65 Turf Renovation 70 1$120 1,400 Spray & Fert.. 8 128 56 Electricity 8 128 40 Garbage 22 110 55 Miscellaneous 189 $3,134 $2,99 Light, Bulbs Irrigation Equip. Fertilizer Chemicals Faint. Sod Seed Top Drees Mix Electrical (Cont.) Grana Total 375 400 300 so 353 500 490 250 M 2,958 8,528 Booming S6&T1W1 45.75 R 732 457.50 Shoveling 1:22.75 1, 9$4 660 Blowing 15 240 30 Flooding 69.25 1,108 690 Board Repair 7.25 116 35 Line Painting 8 128 20 Garbage 5 80 25 Berme AQ 1,957.50 Light Bulbs X44 Grand Total $6,553 In our Estimation, one of the beat things we have going for us with regard to cur park meintermu a is the fact that we have very few soocer/football fields laid over softball/baseball fields. Wp currently maintain 18 softball/baseball fields and 11 poocer fields. Of this amount, only three sites have a eoocer/'football laying over the top of the softball/baseball field. We are also fortunate in nwt cases we do not have pleasure skating rinks laid out on top of any of our athletic surfaces. Whenever you try and maintain ice rinks on top of grass surfaces, you end up with weeds. This would necessitate a total renovation and reseeding project every spring in those areas. Klaprich Field. in Wayzata is a classic a aMle of this. Because their entire surface is flooded in the winter time; during the summer months they do not have an adequate turf surface to play field games on. As we build other facilities in the future, these are items we will keep in,mind, so we are sure we have the easiest, maintainable surface. Because of the high expense of maintaining soccer/football fields, we are researching the capital its associated with using an artificial turf surface to determine if, in the long rum, there would be a cost savings over our grass surfaced areas. We have a new soccer field at Plymouth Creek in the capital improvement budget for 1988. our analysis of this life cycle cast will be prepared in conjunction with that project. Ufm In conclusion, what we have tried. to ao=Tli.sh as our overall philosophy can be summarized as such: A. Build the appropriate facilities in the appropriate locations to meet the need in that population or attendance area. B. Design the facilities in such a manmr that they can be maintained in a reasonable fashion based on appropriate use. In new parks, create: the smallest, possible areas that will require high maintenance. C. provide safe, attractive facilities to the public that present a good image for the City of Plymouth. Because wet athletic turfs are most susceptible to damage, we closely monitor all of our facilities for the necessity of cancelling games in order to protect the surface. D. Make the necessary repairs and maintenance to our facilities as quickly as possible, so that unsafe conditions are corrected and further deterioration, and a poor public image is not created. Finally, we must continue to provide motivation and training to our maintenance division so that they can most effectively and efficiently carry out their duties and responsibilities in these areas. with a continuing spirit of cooperation and understanding between the City Council, Park and Recreation Advisory Commission and our user groups, 1 am confident that we can continue to provide safe, clean, and fun recreational experiences to the citizens of Plymouth. np Attachments: Neighborhood Park Needs Analysis Funding Task Force Resolution Development Priority List from Comprehensive Plan Park Acquisition, 1982--86 Park Maintenance Hourly Detail Reports f -I"OR i30D PARK NEEDS - ULT IM&TE 9 10 1,116. 4,096 1,066 spl(w lmun reco"rwndeQ it:• 5 acres 5 10-14 5 11 Actuel Nr igh- E.Ist lnq Pork (hods Ul t Imato for the population, ewcppt for Mr bor- oohd Ultimate Ns19Osb'.rhood Population Perks/Acres at 2.5-3.5 Acro/1,000' 0oflciency IAcros) Corrents (e« *is* Took 2 - Inventory) 1 1,778 - 5-6 None primarily office Industriet; population 1-12.`5 Club can, provide some neighborhood is 1,677 estimate probably im h19A 2 0 - 0 None entirely office -Industrial 3 2,219 - 5.5-8 5..5-6 could be provided by Mspio Grove 1 1 • could,be prowled by Mss OP Grove; see, 0 19 1,709 e i so comonts for 5 end 6 S 3,123 - iT 1.5-S2 Gan Park 120.7 •e1 could be deveiopod 21 4,"4 as nal hborhood pork to serve neighbo r 663,79" - 11.5-20 11.5-20 hoods ,5 end 7 3,880 - 9.5-13. ! 9.3-13.3 a ne l ghbor hood perk: at romor l eau Lake 9.5-12 24 2,821 could serve neighborhoods 7 and 6 r 33 34 3536' 37 38 39 0 41 1,519 Groontrse Mast/1005 Green Ooks;/6.6 Aeadowood/10. 1.893 Imperial Nllls/9.1. 1,946 3,255 - 1,320 lions Park/3.,1 1,150 Gloenioch/6.9 3,191 80 e3 s-7 11.5 5-5 3-5 11 0 9 10-14 None 3-7 11.9 None 1-12.5 S-615 14-20 None 5-6 7.5-10.5 11.5-16 5 9.9-12 None None 7-11 1.5-r None 6.5-9 None None Zachary Lane Elem. could ba developed as neighborhood park, but location is poor primarily Industrial could be provided In Central Park could be provided to Control Park Should be forth of crook; peputatlon estimate probably too high requires additional development way reauire addltlonal Icctilties erosion problems erlst 23rd and E.N.L. needs developiaant' pert of M. Medicine Lsko Park (3.5 ac) functions as neighborhood park entirely Industrial outiots In Mrple Crook eddIf1cn require considerable devslopmont 22 out of 33.6 acres at the identified parks or* credited toward neighborhood recreation, thor belancw is storm water retention or otherwise unusable though elmssitled as coTmunity pl yfleid, Greenwood Is not devolc4"d as, such. Con serve neighborhood rMsds unless end_ until dcvoloped as ployfleld Green Oaks adequately serves nelgkborhood perk needs. Green- tree Vest end Mesdowood are Special use perks None 9 10 1,116. 4,096 1,066 Timbershores (pert)/S 5 10-14 5 11 2,021 5-7 12 3.297 for the population, ewcppt for Mr 0-11.5 five -acre minimum Stipulation 13' 2,732 Scheidt Lek*/6.9 7.0-9.5 11 3, 604 Vest Wdiclne Leks Park end/or Community 1-12.`5 Club can, provide some neighborhood is 1,677 3-6.5 None -5 1.6 5,613 11-20 17 1,179 5 1 • s/2 0 19 1,709 3-6 20 2.999 7.5-10.5 21 4,"4 Central Pork(part)/15 11.5-16 22 1,102 23 3,130, 9.5-12 24 2,821 Mission Wlils/19.3 7-10 25 5,331 four Seasons/28.3 13.5-19.5 26 4.076 Kl imor/1.3 10-11 23rd l E.M.0/1.9 E._Medicino Lek* port)/17 27 2,265 Hemlock/0.3 3.5-6 V. Medicine Lake rpart)/3.5 29 0 0 29 2,519 Unnamed park/22 . 6.5-9 30 1, •00 Sh l l of%/ 13.3 3-6.5 Ponderose/1.9 f ezond ln/ 12.2 Olfve Lane Pond/32 31' 2,557 6.5-9 32 1,030 Greenwood E 1 ens( Par t) /6 3-6.5 r 33 34 3536' 37 38 39 0 41 1,519 Groontrse Mast/1005 Green Ooks;/6.6 Aeadowood/10. 1.893 Imperial Nllls/9.1. 1,946 3,255 - 1,320 lions Park/3.,1 1,150 Gloenioch/6.9 3,191 80 e3 s-7 11.5 5-5 3-5 11 0 9 10-14 None 3-7 11.9 None 1-12.5 S-615 14-20 None 5-6 7.5-10.5 11.5-16 5 9.9-12 None None 7-11 1.5-r None 6.5-9 None None Zachary Lane Elem. could ba developed as neighborhood park, but location is poor primarily Industrial could be provided In Central Park could be provided to Control Park Should be forth of crook; peputatlon estimate probably too high requires additional development way reauire addltlonal Icctilties erosion problems erlst 23rd and E.N.L. needs developiaant' pert of M. Medicine Lsko Park (3.5 ac) functions as neighborhood park entirely Industrial outiots In Mrple Crook eddIf1cn require considerable devslopmont 22 out of 33.6 acres at the identified parks or* credited toward neighborhood recreation, thor belancw is storm water retention or otherwise unusable though elmssitled as coTmunity pl yfleid, Greenwood Is not devolc4"d as, such. Con serve neighborhood rMsds unless end_ until dcvoloped as ployfleld Green Oaks adequately serves nelgkborhood perk needs. Green- tree Vest end Mesdowood are Special use perks None the best swisting naighborhood park In P 1 ymout h 5-7 11.! Nona -2' lions Pork functions as a neighborhood perk and would otherrlsp be adequate for the population, ewcppt for Mr five -acre minimum Stipulation None acreage is adequate, but acquisition of Cloomloch would be desirable for feel - titles expansion Ii Vest Wdiclne Leks Park end/or Community Club can, provide some neighborhood functions None entirely Industria None -5 swa11 neighborhood, could be served by St. Louis Pork NE1"OltlOOD PARK WEDS - ULTIMATE Ment*d1 6mlolTum rocommomdsd-slxe 9 acres Acue! t Neigh- EW.IstIng Pork Needs UliIWO or- Ultimate; Neighborhood at 2.5-3.9 Ooflclency hood Populatlon Parks/Acres Acre/1.000• Acres) Comments - 42 773 9 9 tsCompt• could function as neighborhood park, but Is designed as playfleld' 43 1 9 9 omell neighborhood, could be served by Minnetonka Ii 19 1,407 2,969 Sunset MIAs/20.6 Circle Park/2.2 9 7.9-10.9 None None also wets needs of neighborhood /50, irchvler/13.6 although elrchvier Woo functions as community plejfleld 16 1,640- 9-9.9 5-9.9 47 1,102 Queensland/7.1 5-6.3 Nona ret I served 66 436 Ferndale No./9.3 9 tbne good site; needs developmwnt 49 338 S None small neighborhood, could served by Wayzata or by Queensland Park 50 313 S lion* could be served by Birchvtew and Circle Park In neighborhood /Ii Pursuant to due call and notice the City Council of the City of 2nd day of May were present:Myor Davenp— ort,C The following members were abse 4*# YMOUTH thereof, a renu1awl meeting of Plymouth, Minnesota was heldon the 19 Th1 o11 win$mb r unci me er en;"Reils, c re er renin. t: none . Councilmember Tnreinen introduced the following Resolution and moved its a opts on: RESOLUTION NO.. 83-246 A RESOLUTION ENDORSiNG THE FINDINGSOF THE MAYOR'S TASK FORCE ON PARK AND RECREATION PROGRAM FINANCING. WHEREAS. the Task Force on Park and Recreation Program Financing has completed their review of this matter and subrjjtted a report to the City Council dated July 19, 1982, and WHEREAS, the Park and Recreation Advisory Commission has reviewed said report and is in concurrence with its findings, and WHEREAS, the opportunity has been given to various community groups to review and comment on said report, and WHEREAS, the City Council has reviewed and accepts the contents of said report, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PLYMOUTH, MLNNESOTA, that the recommendations brought forth in the report from the Task Force on Park and Recreation Program Fihancing be hereby approved, and further, that said recommendations will be used to help guide the City Council in development of future Park and Recreation budgets and Capital Improvement budgets. The motion for the adoption of the foregoing Resolution was duly seconded by CouncilMtMber Moen , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following vote n favor thereWmor Davenport, Counci I members Moen, Neils$ Schneiger,and Threinen The following voied itgainst or abstained: none Whereupon the Resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. TABLE 4 Priori ty J - Developed Neighborhoods Neighborhood Deficiency Proposed Acquisition 26 7-11 ac. 7.5 ac. 27 1,.5-4 ac. 5 ac. 35 5-7 ac, 2 ac. (special use) 39 8,-11 ac. 5 ac. 42 5 ac. lone 43 5 ac. 12 ac. 46 5-5.5 ar.. 6 ac. Subtotal - Priority 1 36.5-49.5 Acres 35.5 Acres Priority 11 Developing Neighborhoods (pre -1990) Neighborhood Deficiency Proposed. Acquisition 9 10-14 ac. 10 ac. 11 5-7 ac. 6 ac. 12 8-11.5 ac. 10 ac. 14 9-12.5 ac. 18 ac. is 5-6.5 Mr . 5 ac. 16 14-20 ac. 9 ac. (additional) 17 5 ac . 5 ac. 20 7.5-10.5 ac. 6 ac. 21 11.5-16 ac. 10 (in. Plymouth Creek Park) 22 5 ac. none 23 8.5-12 ac. 9 ac. 29 6.3-9 ac. 11 ac. 31 6.5-9 ac. 8 ac. 36 8-11.5 ac. 6 ac.— Subtotal- Priority 11 109.5-149.5 Acres 113 Acres Priority 111 Developing Neighborhoods (post -1990) Neighborhood Deficiency Proposed Acquisition 3 5.5-8 ac. none 4 5 ac. none 5 8.5-12 ac. 14 ac. 6 14.5-20 ac. none 7 9.5-13.5 ac. 10 ac. e 5 ac. none 19 5-6 ac. 9 ac. Subtotal - Priority 111 53-69.5 Acres 32 Acres TOTAL 1.99-267.5 Acres 180.5 Acres w PARKS ACQUISITION 1982 -'1986 Acres Park Site Conditions 35 Central Park Southern border settled. Plymouth Creek Park) Location of 34th Avenue. 8 Rolling Hills Moved south a few hundred- feet over original desig- nation, 9 Sunrise Neighborhood Developed and in operation. Park 29th b Orleans Lane. 45 West Medicine lake Acquired all except one residence on south side in holding). 11 St. Mary's Moved east 1 to 2 hundred yards. N.E. corner of 4 -CP. 6 Maple Creek Park Developed and operating. Mapledel l) Switched to north over original proposal. 29 Workhouse Neighborhood park at mica- point of south. Pl_ayfield per Brauer b Associates proposal. 4 Amhurst N.P. 3/4 mile north of Central Park. 2 Swan Lake M.P. 1/4 mile north of French no name) Reg. Park. S.W. of Schmidt Lake:. 2 Northeast N.P. Due east of Bass lake. 19 Bass Lake Pl'ayfield Site Owe in its entirety by 1967. 19 acres plus! N.P. of 1 acres south of the western 112 of play - field site. Dream Pomerleau Lake Shot out of the water. Effort transferred to Mud Lake. 25 Parker's Lake In planning for First Phase Development. 15 Co. Rd. 61 Site Proposed for 1966 develop- ment. CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD., PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 550-2800 MEMO. DATE: July 9, 1986 TO: Dale Hahn, Financial Director FROM: Mark S. Peterson, Park & Forestry Supervisor SUBJECT PARK MAINTENANCE PER ACRE TIME SUMMARY cc: Eric Blank PLAYFIELDS ACRES 1984 HRS. 1985 HRS. 2 YR. AVERAGE ZACHARY 33 3,179.50 3,1.79.50 3,179.50 PLYMOUTH CREEK 25 1,485.22 1,255.75 1,370.49 PLYMOUTH 14 1,290.00 1,620.00 1,455.00 OAKWOOD 18 1,217.50 1,616.00 1,416.75 LACOMPTE 5 812.25 650.75 731.50 RIDGEMOUNT 15 11090.00 965.00 1,02.7.50 110 9,074..00 9,287.00 9,180.74 MAN HRS./ACRE 82.50 HRS./ACRE 84.50 HRS./ACRE 83.50 HRS./ACRE NEIGHBOTHOOD PARK SCHMIDT 6.9 162.00 133.00 147.50 QUEENSLAND 5.1 148.25 110.00 129.13 GREEN OAKS 6.8 274.75 11099.00 673.38 LIONS 3.1 118.00 134.50 126.25 MISSION HILLS 8.0 213.50 146.50 180.00 CIRCIE 2.2 114.75 595.v0 354.88 SHILOH 13.3 191.50 281.25 236.38 45.40 1,222.75 2,499.25 1,847.52 MAN MRS. /ACRE 26.93 HRS./ACRE 55.00 HRS./ACRE 40.69 HRS./ACRE BEACHES EAST BEACH 10.8' 830.00 788.25 809.13 WEST BEACH 3.0 242.25 321.50 281.88 1,072.25 1,109.75 1,091.01 MAN HRS./ACRE 77.7 HRS./ACRE 80.40 HRS./ACRES 79.06 HRS./ACRE cc: Eric Blank CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD.. PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800 MEMO DATE: January, 1987 TO: Eric Blank, Director FROM: Mirk Peterson, Park i Foreatry Supervisor SUBJECT END OF YEAR 1986 REPORT tree planting 6.0 001 CITY HALL garbage pickup 17.75 trimming 4.0 special events 1.0 aeration 4.0 park 6 rec. equip. 4.0 broadleaf weed control 3.0 1,041.5 cleaning building 1.0 003 GREEN OAKS down time 1.5 mow 91.5 irrigation maint. 54.0 trimming 50.5 trail maint. rep. 34.5 in'.'iieAd saint. 18.0 tree i shrub saint. 13.5 f4,,tilizing 3.0 tree planting & shrubs 8.0 broadleaf weed control 6.0 garbage pickup 36.75 7 _..play structure repair 20.0 safety meetings 45.0 snow plowing rinks 5.0 training 33.0 3 ^brooming rinks 18.25 deliveries 26.25 flooding rinks 2.1.5 special events 17.0 new construction 446-.-6- park 6 rec. equip. 2.0 signs 4.0 planting beds 4.0 equipment maint. 4.0 staff meetings 10.5 trail saint. repair 30.0 poise. 10.25 tree planting 3.0 308.25 4 _.. garbage pickup 33.25 494.0 s'?y 002 QUEENSLAND 004 LIONS sowing 45.25 mowing, 53.5 trimming 8. trimming 14.5 line painting S0 line painting infield saint. 2..5 26.25 sodding 35. sodding 12.5 fertilising 1.5 fertilizing 1.75 broadleaf weed control 4.5 broadleaf weed control 6.0 play 'structure repair 12. play structure repair 3.0 snow plowing rinks 4.25 plumbing repairs 4.0 brooming rinks 19.5 snow plowing rinks 2.75 snow blowing rinks 2. brooming rinks 18.5 flooding rinks 21.75 flooding rinks 17.75 mise. rink maint. 5.0 mise. rink mains. 3.0 new construction 726. fence repair 1.0 signs 4.25 new cosntruction; 69.5 trail saint. rep. 120. signs 2.0 tree b shrub 3.25 x END OF YEAR REPORT CONTINUED 2- 004 LIONS CONTINUED trail maint. rep. 97.0 equipment maint. 75 tree planting; 24.0 5.S trail maint, rep. 138.0 garbage pickup 389.5 tree 6 shrub maint. 1.0 00$ IMPERIAL HILLS garbage `pickup. 19,25 69.0 bleachers 3.:0 mowing trimming. 7.5 special events 50 line painting 1.0 401-.0 sodding 14.0 005 CIRCLE fertilizing 1.75 mowing 54.0 broadleaf weed control 4.0 trimming 2.75 play structure repair 11.0 fertilizing 1.5 snow plowing rinks 3.75 broadleaf weed control 6.5 brooming rinks 16.75 play structure repair 28.0 flooding rinks 19.75 snow plowing rinks 6.25 mise. rink maint. 3.0 brooming rinks 20.5 nes construction 515.75 snow shoveling - 4.0 signs 11.75 snow blowing rinks 2.0 electricity- 3.0 flooding rinks 14..25 equipment maint. v downtime 2.0 trail saint. repair 41.0 misc. rink saint. 8.0 tree 6 shrub maint. 3.0 new construciton 301.75 garbage pickup 18.5 signs 12.75 goals b posts 24.0 tree planting 6.0 769.5 garbage pickup 2S.25 010SHILOH goals 50 mowing 109.25 sidewalks 1.0 trimming 13.0 497.0 infield saint_. 1.0 006 KILMER topdressing 2.0 mowing' 34.25 fertilizing, 3.0 trimming 16.50 broadleaf weed control 12.0 fertilizing 1.50 play structure repair 61.0 broadleaf weed control 4.0 snow plowing rinks 4.0 play structure repair 28.0 brooming rinks 16.25 snow plowing rinks 3.25 snow 'blowing rinks 2.5 brooming rinks 20.0 flooding Brinks 25.75 flooding rinks 12.25 new construction 7.5 mise. rink saint. 40 signs 8.5 tree b shrub saint. 12.5 tree 6 shrub maint. 12.0 garbage. pickup 15.5 tree plainting 7.5 151.75 garbage pickup 18.5 007' 4 SEASONS 303.25 sowing 191.0 011 HEMLOCK trimming 14.75 moving 32.50 topdressing 3.0 trimming 4.5.1 sodding 18.0 broadleaf weed control 4.0 fertilizing 3.0' play- structure repair 29.0 snow shoveling 1.0 tree 6 shryb maint. 2.5 flooding rinks' 7.75 garbage pick up 13.0 board repair 6.0 misc, 4.5 downtime 4.0 90.0 fisc. rink saint. 13.0 new construction 1.0 signs 25 I?wmi FSD OF YEAR REPORT COKINULD 3- 013 MISSION HILLLS fence repair 28.0 ne7,0 construction 11.8.0 mowing 111.05 signs 18.0 trimming, 8:50 equip, saint. 2.0 line painting 150 trail maint, repair 27.,50 infield maintenance 3.5 tree b shrub maint. 42,0 fertilizing 2.0 tree planting 1.5 broadleaf veed control. 20.0 garbage pickup 145.75, signs 14.0: beach saint.. 153...50 F equip. saint. 1,.`s deliveries 1.5 trail saint. repair 12.0 special events 2.5 tree S: shrug saint. 13.5 park & ret. equip. 7.0 garbage pickup 22.25 planting beds 15.0 bleachers 4.0 mist, 1.,0 docks 6 walks Co 913.2.5 special events 2.0 planting beds 1.75 018 PARIERS LAKE 227.7575 014 GLEANLOCi1 broadleaf weed control 18.5 mowing 33.,0 plumbing 10..0 trimming 1.75 downtime 1.0 fertilizing 1.0 mist. 1.0 broadleaf Weed control 4.0 fence repair 29.5 play structure re' -44r 10.0 new construction 139.0 trail saint. repair 25.0 signs, 1.0 arbage pickup 15.50 trail maint. 68.0 90.25: tree b shrub maint. 2.0 016 NEST MEDICINE tree planting 22..0 sowing 94.0 tree inspection 1.5 trimming 14.75 garbage pickage 16.0 disc. 12..25 beach saint. 20.5 fertilizing 1.0 mist. 4.5 broadleaf weed control 1.4.0 334.5 play structure 42..0 019 TIMBER SHORES plumbing repairs, 2.0 mowing 78.5 mist. bldg. saint. 4.0 tr-t,.ning 6.0 snow plowing rinks 2.,0 infield saint. 14.5 brooming rinks 20 topdressing 4.0 flooding rinks. 11.5 fertilizing 1.5 downtime i'•0 broadleaf weed control 5.5 fisc. rink saint.. 24.0 play structure repair, 8.0 fence repair 1.75 flooding rink 2.0 signs 5.0 new construction 32.0 garbage pickup 110.75 signs 17.5 beach saint. 48.55 equip. saint. 2.0 390.5 trail saint., 127.50 017 EAST'MEAICINE LAKE tree b shrub 26.0 wowing 158.5 tree planting 2`•0 trimming 27..50 tree inspection 1.0 fertilizing 2.0 floral arrangement 2.0 broadleaf weed control 14.0 garbage pickup 23.5 play structure repair 1,8.0 bleachers 10.0` painting 6 staining 32.0 mist. 16.0 cleaning bldg. 6.0 docks 6 walks 239.75. plumbing repairs 35.0 deliveries 3.0 mist. bldg. saint 46.50 622.25 downtime 50 I?wmi VD. OF YEAR REPORT CONTINUED 4- 020 PLYMOUTH CREEK fertilizing, 5..0 mowing 232.0 broadleaf weed control 10.0 trimming 59.5 play structure repair 9.0 line painting 62.0 painting staining 18.0 infield maint, 180.25 cleaning, bldg, 47.5 aeration 14.-0 plumbing. repairs 3.0 topdressing 4.0 electrical repairs 10.0 seeding 22.5 misc. bldg. saint., 12.0 sodding 6.5 snow plowing rinks 6.5 fertilizing 8.0 brooming rinks 49.5 broadlesf weed control 12.0 snow shoveling 131,.5 play structure repair 12.0 snow blowing rinks 27.0 painting 6 staining 25.0 flooding rinks 65.0 cL?aning building. 40.0 board repair 7.0 plumbing repairs 6.5 downtime 1.0 electrical, repairs 41.0 misc• rink saint. 40.0 misc. bldg. saint'. 10.75 irrigation maint. 37.5 snow plowing, rinks 16.75 signs 3.5 brooming rinks 78.75 electricity 6.0 snow shoveling 179.00 tree 6 shrub 4.5 snow blowing rinks 25.25 garbage pickup 36.75 flooding rinks 74..0` deliveriev 12.25 board. repair 9.5 special events. 75 downtime 1.5 park 6 rec. equip, 1.0 misc, rink maint, 56.,0 706.5 irrigation saint. 102.0 023 PLYMOUTH PLAYFIELDS fence repair 31.0 sowing 168.0 new construciton; 59.50 trimming 33.75 signs 11.0 line painting 89.0 electricity 8.0 infield saint. 144.75 equip. saint_. 8.0 aeration 7.0 trail saint. repair 219.75 topdressing 38.0treebshrubmaint. 4.5 seeding 36,0 gree planting 6.0 sodding 4.0 garbage pickup 63.25 fertilizing 6.0 bleachers 2.0 broadleaf weed control 13.0 tennis.courts 20 play structure repair 2.0 docks 6 walks; 2.0 painting b staining 18.0 goals 2.0 cleaning bldg. 54.0 misc.:1.0 plumbing repairs 10.0 deliveries 25.0 electrical repairs 43,0 special events 29.0 misc. bldg. 21.0 park b rec.. equip. 5.0 snow plowing rinks 11.5 1.757..75 brooming rinks 73.75 snow shoveling 152.75 021 EGAN snow blowing rinks 38.0 Disc. 5;25 flooding rinks 102.75 5.25 hockey rink lines 6.0 board repair 7.0 downtime 2.0 022 LACOMPTE misc. rink saint. 48.5 moving 80..0 irrigation maint. 66.50 ts::mming_ 13.5 fence repair 3.0 line painting 40 signs. 5.5 Infield maint. 52.75 electricity 13.5 aeration 2.0 equip. saint. 2.5 topdressing 4.0 tree 6 shrub maint. 8.0 seeding 6.0 END OF YEAR REPUT CONTTt tP 023 PLYMOUTH PLAYFIELD-CONTINUED garbage pickup 66.75 bleachers 1.5 tennis courts 53.5 windscreens 33.0 docks & walks 1010 goals 7.0 deld,veries 12.25 special events .50 park & ree. equip. 2.0 street department 2.0 1,417,5 024 OAKWOOD mowing 38.1 trimming 27.7 line painting infield maint. aeration 24,0 topdressng seeding C51.Osodding fertilizing broadleaf weed control 4.0 painting, & stei.ning 33 cle4iing buil0i-k Q 46. plumbing repair a 11.0: electrical repairs 46.75 misc. bldg. maim., 29.25 snow plowing 9.75 brooming rinks 4 ,75 snow shoveling 122.75 snow blowing rinks 15.0 flooding rinks 69.2 board repair 7.25 downtime 33-.-50 irrigation maint. (.'5 fence repair 4.0 signs 12.5 electricity 15.0 equipment saint. 1.5 trail saint. repair 14.0 tree 6 shrub maint. 5.5 garbage pickup 4. tennis courts 36.5 docks &. walks 2.0 goals 8.0 mise 2.0 deliveries 17.0 park, & rec. equip. 3.0 1.328.0 025 ZACRARY mowing trimming line painting infield maint. aeration topdressing 259.25 28.0 108.5 109.50 18.0 35.0 seeding. sodding fertilizing broadleaf weed control plat* structure repair painting b staining cleaning bldg, plumbing repairs electrical repairs misc. bldg. maint. snow plowing, rink brooming. rinks snow shoveling. snow blowing, rinks flooding rinks hockey rink lines board repair downtime misc. rink mains: irrigation maint, fence repaid new cosntruction signs electricity equipment maint.. trail maint. repairs tree & shrub maint. garbage pickup bleachers tennis courts windscreens ducks 6 walks goals 6 posts misc. deliveries special events park & rec. equip. planting beds 026 GREENWOOD mowing trimming infield paint.. 027 RIDGEMOUNT mowing trimming line painting infield maim... aeration seeding; sodding fertilizing broadleaf weed control play structure repair cleaning building plumbing repairs S t0.0 19.0 29.0 1., 5 47.50 17.0 68.50 1.0 55.5 58.50 25.0 74,25 1.45.0 43.75 149.75 11.0 8.0 3,0 611.5 80.0 16.0 561.-0 1.4.0 11.0 12.0 84.75 18.0 113.75 54.0 52.0 51.50 4.0 14.0 1.0 57.0 20.75 9.0 6.0 2,566.75 5..0 1.0 2.0 8.0 138.0 18.75 133.0 21.0 4.0 3.0 3.0 12.0 3.0. 20 4.5 1.0 END OF YEAR REPORT CONTINUED 027 RIDGEMOUNT CONTINUED. electrical repairs, 15.0 mise, bldg. saint. 4.5 snow plowing rinks 11.0 brooming rinks 63.0 snow shoveling 159.25 snow blowing rinks 1.9.0 f loodtig rinks 68.25 board repair 6.0 downtime 1.0 mise. sink saint. 48.75 irrigation saint. 64.50 new construction 2.0 electricity 2,.0,. equipment saint, 1.5 tree 6 shrub saint. 1.5 garbage pickup 35.0 bleachers 7.5 tennis courts 35.:0 goal, a posts 2.0 1.0 deliveries 18.5 special events .50 park 6 rec. equip. 1.0 931.0 028 FERNDALE NORTH stowing 5.5 infield main.t 2.25 mise, rink maint. 1.0 trail. saint. 8.0 16.75 030 GREENTREE WEST sowing sodding mise. 031 AMBER WOODS sowing equip. saint. trail saint. special events 032 FAZENDIN mowing trimming fertilising roadleaf weed control new construction signs trail saint. tree 6 shrub maint. garbage pickup docks 6, walks 2.0 25 1.0 3.25 2.0 25 2.0 5.0 2.0 4.0 13.0 63.50 5.0 50 2.0 53.0 1.0 135.50 9.0 2.0 1.0 272.25 033 PONDEROSA Mowing broadleaf weed control equip.: maint. 03.4 OLIVE POND mowing trimming lertilia ng broadleaf weed control snow plowing rinks brooming rinks snow blowing rinks flooding rinks sign:-. equipment saint. 035 23RD.. a E. MEDICINE. mowing miss:. 037 OAKVIEW POND rowing trimming broadleaf weed control garbage pick up 038 BIRCH PARK mise. 041. MEADOWOOD rowing trimming fertilising broadleaf weed control mist. snow shoveling downtime signs 042 34TH. 6 E. MED. LAKE mowxng, trimming misc -. fence repair trail Maint. repa. 043 CEMETERY mowing trimming topdressing sodding fertilizing broadleaf weed control a- 37,0 6,0 1.0 44.0 30,5 1.0 75 5 1.75 14.25 2.50 19.5 1.0 1.0 73.75 a.a 8.5 16.5 39.50 3.0 4.0 2.0 48.5 8.5U 6.50 8.50 35.0 3.0 25 4.0 1.0 1.0 3.0, 1.25 48.50 9.111 3.75 50 6.0 1.75 21.50 82.50 29.0 8.0 20.0 1.5 22.0 163:0 END OF YEAR REPORT CONTINUED 7- 045 SUNSET HILLS 053 PUBLIC WORKS play structure repair 3.0 mowing 1,29.5 snow plowing rinks 1.5 trimming 25.0 brooming rinks 18.25 seeding 1.0 snow shoveling; 1.0 fertilizing 7.0 snow blowing rinks 50 broadleaf weed control 14.0 flooding rinks 1.1.25 play structure repair 62.25 mise rink maint. 5.0 painting S staining 12.0 new construction 11.0 cleaning building 202.0 garbage pickup 1.5 plumbing repairs 6.0 53.0 electric repairs 2.0 047 PILGRIM LN. ELEM. mise. bldg. saint. 48.5 mowing 51.50 snow plowing rinks 1.0 trimming 10.0 snow shoveling 2.0 infield maintenance 25 downtime 40.5 broadleaf weed control 3.0 mise. rink saint. 10.5 risc. bldg, saint. 1.0 irrigation saint. 10.0 snow plowing rinks 8.5 view construction 285.5 brooming rinks 46.0 signs 118.5 snow shoveling 97.25 electricity 1.0 snow blowing rinks 18.75 equipment saint. 889,50 flooding rinks 35.75 trail maint. 12.0 mise.. rink maint. 26.50 tree planting 6 shrubs 26.5 irrigation saint. 16.0 tree inspection 16.0 fence repair 2.5 garbage. 6.0 new construction 2.0 tree rimoval 7.5 trail saint. repair 35.0 safety meetings 5.5 tree 6 shrub 4.0 training 24.0 tree planting 33.5 bleachers 67.0 garbage pickup 16.25 tennis courts 6.0 403.75 d,cks 6 walks 2.0 049 12TH. AVE, POND goals 6 posts 8.0 snow plowing rinks 50 beach maint 1.0 brooming rinks 24.75 deliveries 91.0 snow shoveling 3.50 special events 13.5 snow blowing rinks 12.50 park 6. rec. equip. 13.5 flooding rinks 22.50 planting beds 2.0 63.75 staff meetings 32.25 M0 INDUSTRIAL STRIP street department 12.0 sowing 4.0 water department 12.0 4.0 2,227.50 051 EIRE STATION #1 054 SUNRISE irrigation saint. 28.5 sowing 122.5 tree i shrub 50 trimming 9.5 special events 75 fertilizing 3.5 street departfient 3.00 broadleaf weed control 5.0 32.75 play structure repair 14.5 052 FIRE STATION 02 mise. 2.0 mise. 1.0 fence repair 15.0 electrical repairs 50 new construction 18.0 Irrigation saint. 6 repairs 18.0 equipment saint. 7.0 equip. saint. 122.0 tree 6 shrub maint. 16.0 mise. 4.0 tree planting 3.5 tree b shrub saint. 6.5 garbage. 17.25 deliveries 2.75 233.75 special events 75 155.50 a END OF YEARS REPORT CONTINUED g~ 056 SCHMIDT LADE PARK flooding rinks 4.0 sowing. 69.5 dourntime 2.0 t.riaming 8.5 miss. rink maint. 31.0 seeding 10 irrigation maint. 5.0 sodding 2.;0 fence repairs 8.0 36.0 fertilizing, 2.0 signs i.Q broadleaf weed contrai: 3.0 tree inspection 92.25 play -structure repair, 14.0 garbage pickup 81.0 new 'construction 2.0 bleachers 10.0 equipment suint.. 4.0 tennis courts 16.0 trail 'saint.: 80.Q; goals b posts 10 tree b. shrub saint. 1.0 mise. 58.0 tree planting b shrub 8.0 deliveries 4.0 garbage pickup 36.75 park b re.c. *quip.. 8.0 bleachers 4.0 planting beds 385..5 docks a walks 1.0 deliveries 2.0 061 SIDEWALKS 34.75238.75 sowing, trimming 13.50 057 LIFT STATIONS broadleaf weed control 1.5 sowing 15.0 snow blowing 6.,0 trimming 1:,0 mise. 2.25 broadleaf weed control 7.0 tree b shrub paint. 21.,75 19.0 garbage pickup 2.0 058 TRAILS deliveries 8.0 sowing, 5.0 89.75 trimming sodding 13.5 5.0 062 NEIGHBORHOOD PARK broadleaf weed control. 12.0 mowing 11.0 1,0 downtime 50 broadleaf VO4 gohtrol new construciton 108<0 play structures 105.50 4.0 signs 2.0 snow plowing rinks quip. saint. 2.5 flooding rinks 17.0 1.0 trail saint repair. 441.0 mise. rink saint. 28.0 tree b shrub saint;. 14.6.0 signs 2.,5 tree removal 1,110 tree planting; deliveries 3.5 garbage pickup 25 170.256--6165 05.9 INSPECTIONS 063 MPLE CREEK 46.25 play structure repair 47.0 mowing1U.50 now shavelingg 8.0 trimming 1.10 mise. rink.saint. 4.0 fertilizing 4.5 tree 4 shrub saint. 8.0 play structure repair 1.0 tree planting 7.0 snow plowing rinks 11.25 weed itai4peciton 1.5- brooming'rinks 50 ZQrb:ge 9.0 snow blowing rinsk beach saint. 1.0 flooding rinks 31.0 dock i walks 2.0 misc< rink saint. 1.0 1-73 fence repair lo. 0 060' PLAYFIELDS IN GEN. new construciton 4-•5 11.25 line painting 15.0 signs. 14.0 infield saint. 23.0 trail maint. repair, 7.5 play :structure repair 29.0 tree & shrub, saint. 10.5 cleaning building 4.0 tree planting b shrubs 19.75 electrical rapsirs 3.25 garbage pickup 128.50 mise. bldg. saint. 18.0 snow plowing rinks rte.: 5.0 A a a END OF YEAR REPORT CONTINUED p- 064 AREAS OUTSIDE CITY training 50.50 deliveries 90.0 special events 2.0 t 4 142.5 100 NORM DONE FOR OTHERS line painting 3.50 dcvntts 2:0 nev construciton 4.5 trail saint. repair. 2.0 deliveries 20 park & rec. equip. 4.75 street departuent 56.50 water depertaent 95.00 sever department 2 204.25 Special Council Meetlhq October 26, 1.987` Pa9e 329 Motion carried, five ayes. IP Mayor Schneider suggested ::hat the distance of liquor establish-- LIQUOR POLICY meets be 500 feet from residential areas to be consistent with Item 74G the City Code rather than the 750 feet listed. Counclimember Crain stated he did not see a problem with a bar in an office complex situation and. asked thatthe policy allow It. NOTION was made by Mayer Schneider, seconded by Councilmember, RESOLUTION NO. 87-717 Sisk, to adopt RESOLUTIONNO. 87-717 ADOPTING A REVISED POLICY AMENDING POLICY; N-' RELATING TO THE ISSUANCE OF ON -SALE INTOXICATING LIQUOR LICLN- SALE LIQUOR LICENSES SES changing the distance to 500 ft., and deleting the "x" for Item 7-G Liquor bars In office complexes. MOTION to amend was made by Mayor Schneider, seconded by Coun- cilmember Ytur,, to add hotels and motels to the description of free standing" facilities. Notion to amend carried, five ayes. Motion as once :mended carried, on a Roll Call vote, five ayes. Counciimember Sisk asked if PRAC had seen the review of park PARK USAGE REPORT usage and maintenance levels. Item 7-H Director Blank stated they had not,. Council*--moer Sisk asked about the time allocated to mowing. Director Blank: stated part of the time includes time on the road; to get the m;"wer to, the park which would amount to approximately 10% of tho time. Councilmember Sisk, asked whether user groups would pay the majority of the cos" or if the City will pay, Counclmember Crain stated the user groups will pay extraordi- nary casts of tournaments or leagues but not for normal use. Counciimember Vdsiliou stated the City cannot continue to grow at this rate and pay for all. the park maintenance She Is grateful for the report but doesn't know if user fees are real- istic. Jim Olson, Northwest Soccer Club, stated they pay $15 per game or the facilities. Thi,-, is one of a few communities that charges. Special Council Meeting October 26, 1987 Page 330 Councilroember, Sisk asked that this report be brought back at budget and god.l setting time in June or July to look again at. it to determine where the Council wants: to go during 1989. FRAC should respond with recommendations in the meantime.. MOTION was made by Councilmember Sisk, seconded.by Councilmember Crain, to receive the report and direct staff to move It along to PRAC for study, the study to include user fees and levels of maintenance and If riser fees are contemplated. PRAC should hold a hearing to: obtain comments from concerned citizens and athlet- ic groups and report back by March so anything other than user fees can be implemented In the spring of 1988 and user fees take effect in 1989. Motion carried, five ayes. MOTION was made by Counc imember Sisk, seconded by Councilmember RESOLUTION NO. 87-718 Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 87-718AUTHORIZING STUDY OF ZON AU H R ING S U Y ING O iDINANCE RETAIL PARKING STANDARDS BY BARTON-ASCHMAN ASSOCI- RETAIL PARKING ATES. Item 7-1* Motion carried on a Roll Cali vote, five ayes. Counciimember Vasiliou stated she has trouble with 8 ft. widths as being wise from a cost standpoint. Mayor Schneider stated there is a legal reason to give room for bikes to pass. Director Moore stated 8 ft. Is the minimum standard recommended for a two way bike trail. Director Blank stated' the issue is whether to prohibit bikes from sidewalks. The system of removing bikes from sidewalks is a factor of the amount of traffic on a street. Sidewalks should be used primarily for walkers and bikers belong on the street. Because cars don't typically park on the streets, bikers are relatively safe. Discussion followed on which streets are considered residential and the difference between sidewalks and trails. Director Moore stated each area of the City will be different as residents view what it Is safe for them to do. Director Tremere stated, with the exception of the 6 ft. stan- dard In downtown Plymouth, the standard is 5 ft. for sidewalks and 8 ft. for trails. He doesn't believe there Is a downside to keeping those standards. Manager Willis stated the function of a trail is one thing If the intent is for pedestrians and another If it is for a bike. TRAIL & SIDEWALK STANDARDS. Item 7-3 CITY Or PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800 BATE, Novenber 5, 1987 MEMO TO FROM, Eric Blank SUBJECT; pA0M LAKE ;PAVILICIV In oorv-urrence with PRAC''s reoam enation, the City Council officially re- jected all bids for the Parkers Lake Pavilion. C)amissioners Edwards and Rosen were present at the Council meeting when this action was taken. Chair- man Edwards indicated to the City Council, that the staff and commission would be re-evaluating this building proposal and bringing, it Lack to the City Council, at theappropriate time. As we begin this re-evaluation process, I believe it is imorant that we consider the following three issues: 1. What the need of the amity are at this time with regard to park and recreation facilities. I have attached a memo from Mary Patterson, Superintendent of Recreation, which addresses the issue of our current program :spaice constraints. 2 If we proceed with the building project, Vhat is the quality of the project that the community expects, deserves, and the commission feels is necessary 3. Haw much are you willing to pay for this quality and quantity? What effect will this project have on the other projects the Commission has currently included in their five year capital improvement budget? Attached to this report is a copy of the CIP for the years 1988-92. My belief with issue no.. 1 is that it is the City's obligation to: 1. Acquire park land as.necessary to assure that the: property is secured prior to development. I believe we have adequately addressed this issue in that we own the next two communityity playfield situ that will need to be developed, and we are progressing with the acquisition of two or three neighborhood park sites that will be developed during the next five years. 2. Develop neighborhood park sites on an on-going basis to keep up with current development trends: 3. Develop indoor recreational space to be used for a number of recre- ational programs. A multi, -purpose room within the Parkers Lake Pavilion, in, my mind', starts to meet this kind of facility need. As a sidenote, I would suggest that if the Wayzata School District is currently proposing the construction of two new elementary schools within the City of Plymouth, I believe it is important that we cum- Parkers take Pavilion Page; 2 municate with them that the design incorporate features that would allow for easy public acres for recreation programa. SSuch things as the right size gymnasium, multi purpose erocx,; exit doors, etc., would' be important in this type of facility design. The issue of quality is more of a subjective nature. I believe it was the intent of the Park Commission to strive for a high, level of quality that would reduce the long-term need for maintenance and repairs of the structure:. Com missiorver Rosen also noted that because of the high qual.it.y, of the park grounds, he felt it was appropriate that any structure built there should be of a high quality to ocupliment the turn of the century theme we've developed with the stone bridge, lighting, etc:. The park maintenance division has strongly supported the concept of using as much brick and hard surfaces as possible throughout the structure. A9,1 mentioned at the last Park Commission meting, the new fire station will use only high duality materials. I believe that this structure deserves the same duality we build into our fire stations, city halls, etc:: How much are we willing to pay for this facility? This is the issue I think we need to discuss, specifically, with the architect, Del Erickson. Dei and S have met a couple of tki um on this subject since our last Commission meet Ing, and I have attached for your review`a document he has put together outlining possible changes that could be made to the structure to facilitate cost reductions. In my meetings with Mr. Erickson, I have stressed to him that I r did not feel it was appropriate at this time to down size the main facility structure in that it was such a small size to begin with. it may lose much of its usefulness if we attenpt to cut the square footage. we, therefore, directed our attention to thopoe items that could be changed but would not affect the functional. use of 4,,1-.a, building, nor greatly increase the operating cost of the structure. I believe, based on the information that Mr. E icks-M has supplied us, that we will be in a position to recommend to rebid this project in a January/February time frame that would allow us to secure the lowest poeeible bid for this structure. The Commission must address the issue of whether or not they're willing to recaimmd t1v expenditure of that anount, vl wtever it may be. I should also add that we have not reviewed the poasibil ity of trying toconstruct the facility in phases. We believe this would simply add to the overall cost of the facility and would really serve no pur-- pose in the long run, np Attachments CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD„ PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 5.5441 TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800 DATE: October 22, 1987 MEMO TO. Eric Blank, Director of Parks and Recreation FROM; Mary Patterson, Superintendent of Recreation 7 I SUBJECT: PROGW SPACE CC[MRAINIS Wayzata District 284 currently uses all elementary school cafeterias directly after school for the. Home Base Program. in previous years four of these cafeterias were used for ,after-school activities on various days. Those activities. are now being held in elementary gyms, howeuer, there is always a conflict with youth basketball from November through March. In some cam, this has been overcome by moving a program from the gymnasium to the cafeteria after 6:00 when Hare Base closes. Also this fall, elementary schools have changed their guidelines on starting times for outside programa. programa can no longer start 15 minutes after the close of school, but now must wait a minimum one -.half hour. This means that children can no longer stay after school and go directly to a program that we offer, but must go home and then return at the starting time for the class. In previous years, we have not used any schools outside the boundaries of the City of Plymouth. More recently, because of space constraints, we have begun using Widsten Elementary and Wayzata West Junior High in the city of Wayzata. Moet of the programa that have been moved to these locations have boon moved because of additional time conflicts at Greenwood or Oakwood Elementary Schools. Greenwood Elementary in particular holds so merry school related activities that it beoa, very difficult to hold.a program consistently on the same day of the week Because of sckdtol closings and other demands on school space, District 281 Coma mitt' Education has begun to use their priority to move into time slots at Pilgrim Lane Elementary. Zachary Lane Elementary is also very tight in space, partly because other communities have scheduled space for their use. It has been the policy of both school district 281 and 284 to not allow use of the senior high schools for park and recreation programa on a consistent basis, because of conflicts with after school activities. The exception to this rule has been our gymnastics program on.Saturdays at Wayzata Senior High, the karate program in the wrestling room on Tuesday and Thursday evenings from 5:30-6;30 and our use of one classroom at the senior high school for either youth drama or magic. There has been some discussion with both school districts to try to loosen this policy to allow at least some more consistent use of senior high school space. As you also know, summer indoor classroom apace is extremely tight; with r+c3 space available after 3:30 in District 281, and only Wayzata Senior High available for ming use in District 284. Daytime space in both districts is also somewhat limited because of summer cleaning schedules and summer school.. We haVe also used some somewhat less conventional spaces for recreation programa. The senior citizen programa have been able to use free of char9e the Wbet;Medicine Lake Community Club, St. Mary's of the Lake Church, and Messiah Methodist Church. Vision of Glory Lutheran Church, St. Phillip the Deacon Lutheran Church, and Redeemer Lutheran Church are all rented on a regular basis for recreation activities. St. Phillip the Deacon has cut back the space available for our programs by two days a week for specific time slots. Peace Lutheran Church and the Churchofthe EpiVmy have also been ueed'on a short term basis .for recreation, programa. City facilities at fire station ##2 and the City Center have been used for meetings or to fill in when other spaces have not been available. Meeting space at the City Center is also in high demand, and at times booked solid. West Medicine Lake Ccemmity Club has been considered as a space for several different programs. Unfortunately, its sanswhat gloomy deoor aril the :stale odor of cigarette smoke makes it som=ewhat undesirable as a location. All of the church locations mentioned do charge a rental fee, some of which have been prohibitive. A number of other church locations have been contacted about possible space rental. Many of them are not available because of heavy use for their own programa, or a hesitancy to have outside groups use their space. Rental fees for there church location vary from $10 an hour to $25 an hour, or in sane casee, 20% of class fees charged. Moat of our use of church facilities has been concentrated to daytime hours when church staff is avail- able to open the building. Some church locations have been willing to allow oocasicnal evening use but they find it inconvenient to provide the staff r ee+ded to secure their building. In discussions with cammianity education staff and other community facility users, it is very apparent that there is a great deal of competition for space and very little, if any, new space; available for programming. We have found that on the contrary, in many locations the space available is being reduced because of school.: or church. related demands. DELANO ERICKSON ARCHITECTS k C I x7416 WAYZATA BOULEVARD MINNEAPOLIS MN 85426 417 - 644-6370 MEMORANDUM TO; Eric Blank, Plymouth. Park Commissioa FRCM: Del Erickson DATE. November 4, 1981 SUBJECT: Parkers Lake Pavilion Comn. No. 8708 Rebid.and Cost Reduction Based can the bids received, which ranged from $412,600to $538,089 and the bidding period for fall construction, it appears that a lower cost may be passible by rebidding the project in January for spring/summer construction. To establish anew budget: we have used the low bid figure of $412,600 and: deducted the alternates which would be recommended and the contractor proposed reductions as follows: Base Bid - $412,600 Alternates 26,450 Reductions - 18,E Net Bid $368,150 This figure was approximately 10% over our previous estimate. If we rebid project the low bid may be higher, however, other bidders will be lower and we can take: advantage of other reductions in quality and scope of project as follows Proposed. changes to bid documents and related cost estimate: Div. 1 General Conditions $50000 $15,000 a) Omit temporary toilets, trailer, telephone, power temp. heat. - 3,500 b) Omit/reduce performance bond, - 10,000 c) Unit permit (city charge) - 3,000 Div. 2 Site Work $19"000 a) Omit lake, excavation & rip rap - 7,000 b) Mack top path (NIC) - 2,000 c) Sod & black dirt: (NIC) - 2.2500 d) Omit soil excavation costs - 5,000 3) Omit pavers (add alt.) - 2,500 a t HMORAI`" ovem er 4, 1987 Page 2 Div. 3 Concrete $ 6,500 a) Omit. fireplace, hearth - 5,500 b) Raise ftgs/omit dew.ter 11000 Div. 4 Masonry 14,500 a) Omit masonry above upper floor 5,000 b) Omit burnished block 71000 c) Woad sill in lieu of concrete 2$00 Div. 5 Metals 0 Div. 6 Carpentry 4,000 a) Use 'D" grade cedar in lieu of clear - 2,000 b) Reduce framing size & insulation RS) 2,000 Div. 7 Moisture Protection/Insulation 41000 a) Omit metal ridgeroll & finial - 2,000 b) Use 3" koppers in lieu of 4" nail deck - 2,000 Div. 8 Doors & Windows 13,000 a) Use snap -in grids on windows - 5,500 b) Omit two windows on west. - 1,000 c) Omit round top window (alt.) - 1,500 d) Omit divided lite doors - 2,500 e) Omit divided lite borrowed lite - 1,000 f) Omit high performance glass - 1,500 Div. 9 Finishes 5,000 a) Omit QT & Cr (use SH. vinyl) - l,500 b) Omit studded rubber floor (vinyl)- 1,500 c) Reduce painting - 2,000 d) Omit skate tile(not recommended 10,000) Div.10 Specialties 9,000 a) Delete all upper cabinets and reduce lower cab.. & casework - 7,000 b) Omit gates (alt.) - 2,000 Div.15 Electrical 15,200 a) Pad mount transfonner - 4,500 b) 400 amp service/leave existing - 1,800 c) Omit fire & security alarm - 6,500 d) Reduce circuits, omit hand dryer - 1,700 e) Omit baseboard heater . - NO MEWRANDUM ovRm r , 1987 Page 3 Div.16 Mechanical $ 1,800 a) Galvanized duct in lieu of PVC - 1,000 b) Omit booster heater - 800 TarAL CHANGES -- $ 96,000 Deducting this amount from a figure: of the average between the first and second bidder results in a net figure of - $355,500 490,469 + 412,600 : 2 = 451,500 Bid results in January less 5% $ 15,500 Net Budget figure $340,000 Area of building of 3,440 at $100 per s.f. $344,000 Additional cost item to consider is the use of a concrete slab on grade with a block retaining wall in lieu of the wood sun deck for a potential savings of $ 10,000 The add alternates for picnic shelters would be approximately the same as previous estimates as follcws Small shelter - $14,000 Large shelter - 33,000 The wood deck and clocks would not be considered at this time.. After review of the foregoing and decisions on changes to documents we would. propose issuing for rebid in January with contractor spring start and fall completion.. This will reduce usability of beach area and increase concern for liability at construction site. 1988 1992 CAP I` T AL t M P 10 V E 14 E A T S PA' 0 C A A if means Noxi decrKae i Federal revenue sAarfvrf fvW y3 Storm sew tar district Y E A P - 1 988 (! Public works reserve rwid S1 Tai locrswsnt fifM oei" d) Mater revenue Aoads Park Dedication fund COMMity State/ Special Assessments a., Estimated Utility M.S.A.(lSAPlytlds Iktgwrw Ity/ G. 0. flo. Mejact Dwri to " Cost _ raa a era o e fund 11Fund i Trails Parks Federal ponds Otter t ee rails 75.660 u creeklar i`ilJtira- iy4 r b ,t r Y ti l t is r K u i s Mtn s r n u u w n n ( 21 f,Niera! revenue sbarlM /WN Y C A a - 1 9 !9 ( l Stan suer tax district i) f4,blie works reserve fund S) Tax Iacremat finand" i) Mater revrwe bands Park Dedication Fund COPWAMItr state/ Special AssessmAs Utility M.S.A. Plyf)ds MelyAbrlld County/' G. 0. Est3wated i Trails Parks Federal Project ! Dods Otherfund NO. o 'ect wscri tion Cost res stere oto fund 1 park- 11 kg DAWAI so mo esa r. e I ti • means •vrA increase C A I t T A L i' it / A 0'M F N E N T 5 P A 0 G A' A M ' jeans fund dec:'ease 1 2 Federal revenue sharing fund C f A A 1! h 4 Storm mssetax district Ij Public warns reserve fwW16) Tax incr~t financing 6) Yater revenue bonds rte®® wr®ter® 19bu — t'19C i A v ! T A L SMF'- R 0 Y E M E M 1 S P R O G R A M 2j federal revenue sharing feM YEAR - 1 9 13L I) Stere serer tax district a) Public works reseree fund a DRAFT' Sj Tax incrsemt, flnanc ag 6) Miter menue bonds F mom r® iii®® itlii2i — {`1 1? L A F t 4 A 1. l n e K u Y C n t n { e K 1t 6 K A R..a* V% •`•• a te Feral revenue shartny fund1231 A A - 1 9 2 Stora serer tax district 4) Public works reserve fued IP DRArT (S Tax iecromot financing 6) Water reveme bunds; Park Dedication Fund Special Asxesswents Commity State/' 1,P, Estiwted Utility k.S.Ati Plyiids NeighbrW County/ 8, 0. No, Project Description Cost sea atera ota FLn6 1 Funct a Trails Parks Federal fonds Other 120,000 r- o 170 -120,000-- T Inke Ph. I ISO CITY OF PLYMOUTH 34.00 PLYMOUTH BLVD., PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800 DATE,ovemheVr 5, 1987 MEMO T0: PRAC FROM; Eric Blank SUBJECT; TIMING OF 1988 CCW1P=ICN PROJE= I believe it is neoessary for the Commission to make a reccamwwdation to the council if they wish to proceed during 1988 with.the St. Mary of the Lake neighborhood park and the soccer field at Plymouth Creek. '.These two items need.to be presented to the City Council for approval, so that we may begin the process of selecting consultants to work on these projects. If a neighborhood park is going to be built in 1988, we need to have the neighborhood information meetings. during January and February, so that we can get out with a bid package early enough in the year to be attractive. The same thing.will be necessary for the design and construction of a soccer field. so that we may have this facility available to us by the fall of 1988. I would recommend we down in-house feasibility study and cost estimate for the construction of a natural turf soccer field and an artificial turf socoar field. A cost analysis would be prepared to show both the capital cost and. the long-term operating cost of theme two Facilities. This would be brought back before the Commission and the City Council: with a recommendationendation as to which type of facility would be appropriate for us to consider. hp 10-24-87 Mayor Virgil Schneider City of Plymouth 3400 Plymouth Blvd. Plymouth MN, 55447 Dear Mayor Schneider, I regret to inform you that. I will be unable to complete my term as commissioner on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission. I have accepted a position with a new company that will necessitate relocating to the Seattle/Tacoma area in Washington. I would like to thank you for the opportunity to serve on FRAC. I found it very rewarding to be a part of the park development effort in Plymouth and to work with such a fine parks and recreation staff. Sincerely, 4 Bruce D. Bauman CC: Eric Blank Barbara Edwards 487 XYLON ^VKNut NORTH . NaW NO", MN s"31 • 533J 0708 October 23, 1987 Rick Busch City of Pl.aouth Park and Recreation Department 3400 Plymouth. Blvd, Plymouth, MN 55447 Dear flick, On behalf of the NHPAA Soccer Committee, I want to thank you and your staff who worked so hard to provide and maintain the facilities for- our fall soccer program. Please extend our thanks to all who were involved with our program. I would also like to thank you for putting together the fall schedule for our program.: Sincerely yours, NEW HOP E%PUMOUTH ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION Rc-naldC. Ko is 1987 Fall Soccer Chairman 11MMU an C01NII==, IDICE 000M MM SAFETY DIREM MMOSIAAIWE AMUS ANT r PM MWISSIGN IM ATTORNEY t CITY CSF PLYMOUTH 3,400 PLYMOUTH BLVD,, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800 DA f'E . November 6 1987 MEMO TO PRIG FROM, Eric Blank F.5 SUBJECT: ,LICKS PARK - 'SE"cJ+7 ICN OF PLAYCRCXND ElQUIR NI'' Since our last meeting, I have spent a number of hours reviewing possible pieces of play equipment, including reviewing with our park maintenance division their thcxhts with regard to the various manufacturers. I have gone. to Crystal to review the new playground equiprrnt that GameTime has supplied at Becker Park. I also reviewed the results of the qurvey which showed that. the citizens were most interested .n the following item: spiral. slide creative climbing; apparatus rope walk. tire swing tube slide, Wehave been verbally told by the other residents we discussed this with that they would like the addition of springed animals andsand diggers.. Therefore, it is my recommendation that we select a BigToy P5-12AB pre-schooliece forp Lions Park to meet the needs of pre-school children, and that we Select a Bi.giby Pfd -37 with the substitute of a tube slide for the normal, slide for the elementary age children. We would also use a.free standing spiral slide from Miracle Playground Equipment, ohne sand digger arx one springed animal. All of this can be purchased for approximately $9,400. A combination of these two pieoee gives us all of the pieces as requested by the survey. For ease of installation and long term meinterAncethis is the choice of our parks maintenance division If the commission concurs with this recommendation, a motion would be in order to recommendmend to the city Cotxncil that we proceed with these purchases and the installation in the spring of 1988 at Lion Park. nP Attachments tllhMwirld SIMS Moder Number lie 122 Ground 5paefShippi ht 12'0" diameteO00 lbs, 121" diameter/1,200 lbs, Wit . t/Platform Height. 11'9.17'6" 1419"10'6" Protective. Area 28'0" diameter 29'0" diameter Sorel Bw" Section Material 18 gauge, die -formed, stainless steel w 19 ga e, die -formed, stainless steel Platform Material 11 gauge, die -formed, galvanized steel 11 gauge, die -formed, galvanized. steel i Slide Nrtopy Material Step Assembly Material 14" reinforced, fibe lass with got coat finish gauge, die -formed, galvanized, dimpled, non-skid steel VA" reinforced, fiberglass with gel coat finish 16 gauge, die -formed, galvanized, dimpled, tr non-skid steel eMer Column Material 4'/z" O.D. galvanized, schedule 40 steel pike 41W O.D. galvanized, schedule 40 steel pipe Handrail Material 17 O.D. die -formed, galvanized! tubing t 6" O,D, die -farmed, galvanized steel tubing Whirlwind Slide Foi, a slide the kids won't forget, it's the Whirlwind Slide from Miracle. The colorful fiberglass canopy pprreevents hazardous "stand-up" sliding while a deep bedway cross section Is designed for a safe ride down, Available in two sizes, the Whirlwind is a rug- ged piece of equipment ideal nor high traffic play- grounds. Select from a variety of highly visible colors,, NOTE: Standardd lkeck tend to ground, im shown) not to a For added protec- tion against falls on the way up, Miracle has designed a 2 -stage step assem- bly, as an option, for slides with a platform height of 8` or higher. Cyclone Slide Ride the wind on one of Miracle's new Cyclone Slides. There are two versions of this slide, each with a different deck height, Every Cyclone Slide is made of durable Rockite'" Engineered plastic and has a color- ful fiberglass canopy to prevent "stand up" sliding. The top platform is completely enclosed for safety. cyclone slide Model Number 7j-32--37— 32-3GroundGroundSpace/Shipping Weight 5'11"x 10'4"/1375 lbs. Overall Hei ht/Plafform Height 1177611" Protective Surfacing Area x00" x 26'0" Model Number 132-5 Ground Space/Shipping Weight 6'0" x 125"0800 lbs, Overall Height/Platform Height 14'0"/94" Protective Surfaci2q Area 2210" x 29'0" Platform Material 11 Gauge die -formed galvanized steel Center Column Material 41/2" O,D. Galvanized Schedule 40 pipe A popular structure, the PR -37 has incorporated some favorite activities. Lots of climbing is available along with a S6dechute, Treswing and Angled Poiynet. Also included is aa a lower deck, enclosed for quiet play. 2 Decks 3; Solid Log Malls Tireswing Tireswng Catwalk 3' x 12 Slidechute Panel t .ro.aSlidepole aigWheel 2 Climbing Tires 9 x 9 Poiynet 1 symbol indicates equipment that encourages access by Y :o children with varying degrees of disability, A 43 4 x. 3'COoc a a ! l CCS t, Y pr4:A w µ 4. Es 4 Fi 1`Ll 9 :•i'.. Y 1, 4 c w \faA1G :, ..a'j y" 'b.`4, lk L 4 , M. w.ak e+ a. 1ip+.+i S'°""'rsi `•^:a'r'.:w /r"w'!, A. a.. c'. ivt. ° a " vtdA aYFLkw. M nx mow.'\ Ff..'iWaVr, M' y k. Y•K: W .. yR . RYMu + 4y:11+3. ~ k: v4 6 a. Caw+c. sP+i+-' .bdy1.M .i w+K' yi'. 4 0._ s3" +'W'1" iC 4 f awa y 4Cw ye„ k fY+a af I M4. `. Y1 4 ti F x 4 y. r Yn.., i ori 7s_:4i te..v * ,.$ 1c" y_.>. y Z ` __ `* e w , h .' ` ,. a..i1i 4br t r 4 i t .R a a "til ` ,,,o, . r + ' rsa? ,,.,r.s c, z ."'• is ay 4 4!r ti• _, .w i" zh i t i .. y ° M t y,,, { .. M . r PROPOSED USES FOR THE PARKERS LAKE BATHHOUSE Teeny Tumblers Playtime Discovery Over 50 & Fit Day Camp School release activity days Warming house Arts and craft classes Meetings Workshops Exercise classes Dance classes Special events Triathlon Distance races Rentals Seniors City events Employee training Luncheons Activities Support for water related activities Art gallery and/or displays Banquets i ,