HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 09-12-1990CITY OF PLYMOUTH
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 12, 1990
The Regular Meeting of the City of Plymouth Planning
Commission was called to order at 7*.00 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Richard Plufka, Commissioners
Michael Stulberg, Larry ft-ofsky, Hal
Pierce, Joy Tierney and Deqnis ZY11a.
MEMBERS ABSENT: Commissioner John Wire.
STAFF PRESENT.- Coordinator Charles Dillerud, City
Engineer Can Faulkner, Public Works
Director Fred Moore and Planning
Secretary Jackie 4jatson..
BDDM
MOTION by Commissivier Tierney, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Zylla to approve the Minutes for the Aigust 22, and August
27, 1990 meetings.
Vote., 5 Ayes, Commissioner Stulberg abstained. MOTION VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
carried.
Chairman Plufka introquced Public Works Director Fred DRAFT 1990-1995 CAPIT&
Moore to discuss the Draft 19914-1995 Capital Improvements 114PROVEMENTS PROGRAM
Program (CIP)
Director Moore reviewed the Draft CIP for s%reets.
Commissioner Marofsky asked why Medicine Ridge Road was
going to be completed only to 26th Street as the stretch
of road beyond 26th Street is an access to the road around
Medicine Lake.
Director Moore statea that the portion of road beyond 26th
Street may be completed at a later time. It may not be
needed in the future.
Director Moore reviewed the Draft CIP regarding sewers,
water, drainage, parks and buildings.
Chairman Plufl,,a opened the Public Hearing.
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 146
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Greg Leuer of 4475
Urbandale Court,
Mr. Leuer asked when the Medina Road Project would be
completed.
Director Moore stated that the completion date was 1991.
Chairman Plufka introduced: Mr. John Grigg of 3180
Queensland Lane.
Mr. Grigg wanted to know when the Public Hearings had been
held regarding service to Sewer District 23
Director Moore explained the past hearing was held in
October, 1989 and also explained the procedures followed
for "apical Impro4,aments Program review.
Chairman Plufka introduced Ms. Marilyn Thompson of 11018
Old County Road 15.
Ms. Thompson stated she was interested in roadway plans
for County road 73..
Director Moore stated that funding for this project will
cn,me partly from the County, the Developer and the City. it The County has not included their share to the County CIP
yet, but the administrator has stated a willingness to
recommendthe project on certain conditions.
Commissioner tierce asked when Sewer District 13 would be
completed,
Director Moore stated that the contract for this project
would be awarded in the fall.
MOTION by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by Commissioner MOTION: TO CONTINUE
Pierce to continue the Public Hearing on the Capital
Imprn.ements ;Program to the October 10, 1990 Planning
Commission meeting, and to renotify those persons who
spoke at the Public Hearing.
Roll Call Vote. 6 Ayes. MOTION carried.
Chairman Plufka introdut..4 the request of hlareham Sporting
Goods for Rezoning, Cc, *+ional Use Permit, and. Variance
from the Urban Deve cp.w« ,,it Policy for property located
north of Highway 55 and -.,:st of Peony Lane.
Coordinator Di'llerud reviewed the September 6, 1990 Staff
Report.
Commissioner Pierce asked when sewer would be available to
this site.
VVE MOTION CARRIED
MARKHAM SPORTING GOODS
90041)
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 147
City Engineer Faulkner responded that public sewer would
be available in 1995.
Commissioner Marofsky stated that part of the business was
used as a private residence and questioned whether that
would be possible if the petition was approved.
Coordinator Dillerud responded that it could, as a
nonconforming use.
The Commissioners read two letters regarding this petition
that were handed out at the meeting.
The Markham 14-^Cter stated that they would like the Public
Hearing delayed and had offfered to notify property owners
within 500 feet of the rescheduling of this petition..
Commissioner Stulberg asked if any of the property owners
were so "etified.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Richard Bloom. who was
representing -the petitioner.
Mr. Bloom stated that property owners were not notified of
a rescheduling of the petition.
Chairman Plufka opened the Public Hearing.
Chairman Plufka reintroduced Mr. Richard Bloom, who stated
that the request to provide U -Haul services would have no
impact on the demands of sewer and water in tht-, area.
Mr.. Bloom stated that some, changes in the zoning of the
property throughout the years has been a problem for this
site. He said that the property had been zoned as
commercial in the beginning. It was then rezoned to FRO
Future Restricted Development) and in tne future is
scheduled to be zoned as commercial property onCe City
utilities are available. He suggested that he would like
to discuss other options available to Mr. Markham with the
City Attorney.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Joe Rupar of 13040 Highway
55.
Mr. Rupar stated his concerns were that if the Markham
site was rezoned, would the entire area be rezoned.. He
stated that his and the neighbors access through the
easement on the Markhaam property was not accessible at all
times. He said that the U-14aul trailers blocked the viv,-
and the driveway.
Commissianer Marofsky asked Mr. Rupar whether the Markhavi
site used more water, on the site for the washing of the
trailers, or if traffic had increased.
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 148
Mr. Rupar stated that he had not noticed. an increase in
water usage or traffic on the Markham site.
MOTION by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by Commissioner
Tierney to continue the Public Hearing to the October 10,
1990 Planning Co,maission meeting.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that the renotification of the
property owners within 500 feet must be done by the City
so that the City can certify that the notices are mailed,
but that the petitioner will be responsible for supplying
the mailing labels. He stated that any change in the
plans must be submitted by September 21, in order for the
Development Review Committee to review them.
Roll Call Vote. 6 Ayes, Commissioner Stulberg, Nay.
MOTION. carried on a 5.1 vote.
Caiairman Plufka introduced the request of Richard Deziel
for Rezoning from FRD to R -IB and: a Final Plat for the
Oxbow Ridge 9-nd Addition" looted south: of the south
terminus of 46th Avenue North west of Vicksburg Lane.
Chairman Plufka waived the review of the September 7, 1990
Staff Report.
Chairman Plufka introduced fir. Richard Deziel of 16100
46th A4enue North,
Commissioner Marofsky asked if the, shortening of some of
the *tots on the west side of 46th Avenue North Mould cause
the future cul-de-sac to come further to the south.
Mr... Deziel stated that tie planned to extend the cul-de-sac
to the south.
Chairman Plufka opened the Public Nearing. There was no
one present to speak on the- issue. Chairman Plufka closed
the Public Hearing.
MOTION by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by Commissioner
Marofsky to recommend approval of the petition by Richard:
Deziel for Rezoning from FRD to R -IB and a Final Plat for
the "Oxbovi Ridge 2nd Add'ition's located south of the south
terminus cf 46th Avenue North gest of Vicksburg Lane.
ROTI CallVote. 6 Ayes. MOTION carried unanimously.
Chairman Plufka introduced the request by Super Valu
Stores, Inc. for an Amended Mixed Planned Unit Development
Plan for "Cub Foods" regarding wall signage, proof of
parking, sidewalk construction, and trash facility
screening in the Rlymouth Hills Addition located at the
southeast corner of 36th Avanue North and Vicksburg Lane.
2
MOTION TO CONTINUE
VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
RICHARD DEZIEL (90077)
MOTION TO APPROVE
VOTE WTION CARRIED
SUPER VALU STORES, INC.
90079)
Planning Commmission Minutes
September 12, 1.990
Page 149
Coordinator Dillerud reviewvd the September 6, 1990 Staff
Report.
Commissioner Marofsky asked if the easterly portion of the
site where deferral of the sidewalk construction was
requested was a separate lot and block.
Coordinator Dillerud responded that it was not.
Comii,issioner Tierney questioned whether there would be
s1dewalk from the cul-de-sac westerly to Vicksburg Lane.
Coordinator Dillerud responded that the Plymouth Hills
Plan specified one but the petitioner proposes it not be
constructed. I
Commissioner Plufka asked whether the site across 35th
Avenue North had sidewalks at the present time.
Commissioner Pierce asked where the access from the
southerly property would be to this site.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that there is sidewalk on the
site across 35th Avenue North that is planned to be
extended westward to Vicksburg Lane as the property is
developed.
Chairman Plufka introduced Ms. Pat Moen represent-nq the
petitioner.
Ms. Moen stated that Super Valu Stores, Inc. is working on
a plan to develop the easterly portion of the property and
that they wish to delay the installation of sidewalks
along Plymouth Boulevard so that the developing party on
this site would be responsible for the sidewalk. She said
she felt the sidewalk past the cul-de-sac westward was
premature and could be installed in conjunction with the
developer of that area in the future. She stated that
unnecessary cost could result from sidewalk construction
in advance of site development.
Commissioner Marofsky asked whether the grades on the site
will screen '-he trash enclosure,
Ms. Moen stated that they would.
Chairman Plufka opened the Public Hearing.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. George Wilson of 17140 14th
Avenue North.
Mr. Wilson stated that he received the incorrect Public
Hearing Notice is the mail. He was aware of the Public
Hearing though and was present to listen to the
Manning Commission: Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 1150
presentation for the Peppermint Fence Nursery School for
which tae is a property owner within 500 feet..
Chairman Plufka closed the Public Hearing,
MOTION by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Stulberg to recommend approval of the Amended Mixed
Planned Unit NeveEopment Plan for `:Cub Foods in the
Plymouth Hills Addition, located at the southeast corner of
36th Avenue North and Vicksburg Lane for signage, trash
compactor screening and parking Werral
MOTION to amend by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by MOTION TO AMEND
Commissioner Pierce to review compliance in regard to the
trash compactor enclosure again when the Easterly portion
of the property is developed.
Roll Call Vote.; 6 Ayes. MOTION carried unanimously.. VOTE MOTION CARRIED
Roll Call Vote on Main Motion. 6 Ayes. MOTION carried `COTE - MOTION CARRIED
unanimously.
MOTION by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Stul.berg to recommend. deferral of construction of the
sidewalks on Plymouth Boulevard and 35th Avenue North
until construction takes place on this easterly portion of
the property or the southwest corner of Plymouth Boulevard
and 35th Avenue North. Sidewalk shall be constructed
with*n two years
Commissioner Zylla stat2d that tie could not support the
portion of the notion stating that sidewalks shall be
constructed wi'0in two years on Plymouth Boulevard: and
35th Street North if no other development takes place on
that easterly portion of the property.
Commissioner Marofsky responded that the petitioner could
conte back to the Planning Commission and ask for a
deferral on the sidewalks on the easterly portion of the
property if no construction took place in two years.
Roll Call Vote.. 5 Ayes, Commissioner Zylla, Nay. MOTION VOTE - MO(ION CARRIED
carried on a 5-1 vote.
MOTION by Commissioner Pierce to defer sidewalk MOTION TO APPROVE
construction from the west end of 35th Avenue North to
Vicksburg lane for two years.
MOTION failed for lack of a second, MOTION FAILED
Chairman Plufka introduced the request of Linda Hopkins to LINDA HOPKINS {90083}
is Amend the Existing Conditional Use Permit for the
Peppermint Fence Nursery School" at St. Philip the Deacon
Church to change the name of the school operator located.
at 17205 County Road 6.
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 151
Chairman Plufka waived the review of the September 5, 1990
Staff Report.
Chairman Plufka introduced Ms. Linda Hopkins.
Ms. Hopkins stated that she was in agreement wit 4 the
September 5, 1.990 Staff Report.
Chairman Plufka opened the Public Hearing.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. George Wilson of 17140 14th
Avenue North.
Mr. Wilson asked whether all conditions for the nursery
school would remain as they were. He also asked what will
happen to the school when the church rebuilds next spring.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that there were no changes in
the conditions for the nursery school.
Ms. Hopkins stated she did not know what will happen if
the church rebuilds.
Chairman Plufka closed the Public Hearing.
MOTION by Commissioner Zylla, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Tierney to recommend approval to Amend the Existing
Conditional Use Permit for the "Peppermint Fence Nursery
School" at St. Philip the Deacon Church to change the name
of the school operator located at 17205 County Road 6.
koll Call Vote. 6 Ayes. MOTION carried unanimously. VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
Chairman Plufka introduced the request of U.S. Homes U.S. HOMES CORPORATION,;
Corporation/Thompson Land Development Division for a THOMPSON LAND DEVELOP -
Conditional Use Permit to permit stockpiling and land MENT DIVISION (90086)
reclamation at the southeast quadrant of Medina Road and
the Plymouth City Limits (Brockton Lane).
Coordinator Dillerud reviewed the September 7, 1990 Staff
Report.
Commissioner Pierce asked whether the trees on the
northwest were within the property line or outside the
property line and whether they were significant trees.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that the trees were within the
property, but that they were not significant by tree
policy definition.
A& Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Bill Pritchard representing
1W, the petitioner.
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 152
IdL
Mr. Pritchard stated that regarding item 4 of the
resolution the petitioner would like to use an erosion
barrier instead of snow fence to separate the trees on the
site which are to be prosarved.
Commissioner Zylla stated that he felt an effort should be
made to control the dust raised during grading and filling
along Medina Road.
Chairman Plufka opened the Public Hearing.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Steve Jacobitz.
Mr. Jacobitz stated his concerns were in riqad to
drainage from the development into the pnd BC-Pl, adiacent
to Amber Woods development.
City Engineer Faulkner stated that the drainage system
will be designed to handle the drainage.
Chairman Plufka asked what would be done to handle tiie
drainage in this area if the site development were not
done after the fill is placed.
City Engineer Faulkner stated that a BC -P! Pond will be
constructed at the same time the fill is brought on the
site and this will effectively handle the drainage on the
site.
Commissioner Pierce asked if there would be any effect on
the culverts under Medina Road to the north.
City Engineer Faulkner stated that the design for drainage
VIi 11 handle the runoff.
Fir. Pritchard stated that the grading and stockpiling
should be done per the plat design so that the dirt will
not have to moved more than one time.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mrs. Pat Raskob (lives on west
side of development in Medina, no address given).
Mrs. Ras%ob stated her coacern was drainage onto her
property.
City Engineer Faulkner stated that the drainage will be
monitored by the City and the developer is responsible for
any drainage problems. He said the direction of the flow
cannot be changed.
0,airman Plufka introduced Mr. Bill LaTour of 3525 Co my
Road 101.
Plannino Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 153
Mr. LaTour stated his concerns were the drainage and, the
necessity of an easement acress his property to resolve
the drainage..
Chairman Plufka introdziced Mr. John Grigg of 3180
Queensland Lane.
Mr. Grigg asked for an explanation of land reclamation,
and whether swamps are to be filled.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that land reclamation was
changing the grade level of the land, and that no wetland
will be filled.
Chairman Plufka closed the Public Hearirg.
MOTION by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by Commissioner
Pierce to recommend approval of the request of U.S. Homes
Corporation/Thompson Land Development Oivision for a
Conditional Use Permit to permit stockpiling and land
reclamation at the southeast quadrant of Medina Road and
the Plymouth City Limits (Brockton Lane), subject to all
of the conditions in the September 7, Staff Report;
changing item 4 of the resolution to include snow fence or
erosion control screen".
Roll Call Vote, 6 Ayes. MOTION carried unanimously.
Chairman Plufka continued the Public Hearing for the
Toning Ordinance Amendments regarding flood. plain
regulation, Planned Unit Development Attributes and
Temporary Real Estate and other Signs.
Chairman Plufka called a recess at 9.-35 pm. The
ommissiort reconvened at 9.-45 p.m.
Chairman Plufka introduced the request of Craig Scherber
for Reconsideration of PUD Concept Plan for "Stone Creek"
located southeast of Medina Road and Highway 101.
Coordinator Dillerud reviewed the September 7, 1990 Staff
Report.
Commissioner Marofsky asked if any of the park and open
space area of the site were below the ordinary high water
mark.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that the land below the
ordinary high water mark was incorporated in the single
family lots, and a small portion of the park not included
in the net park area calculation.
Commissioner Tierney stated that she thought -the location
of the twinhomes was better on the periphery rather than
MOTION TO APPROVE
VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
CRAIG SCHERBER (90037)
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 154
the center part of the development because of the
increased density and traffic which would result if they
were centrally located.
Commissioner Marofsky stated that the cul-de-sacs looked
to be longer than ordinance standards and suggested they
could be through streets.
City Engineer Faulkner said that the two cul-de-sacs could
be looped together.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Tcm Loucks who represented
the petitioner.
Mr. Loucks distributed letters from personnel at the
Cities of Apple Valley and Burt, -:Mlle stating their
approval of twin home developments, as those proposed, in
their cities,
Mr. Loucks stated that using open space for tot lois is
not desirable. He compared this development to the Seven
Ponds Development regardiig open space and transition. He
said that the twinhome design would not detract from the
single family homes. He stated that if the twinhomes were
to be placed in the center of the development they wo,,ld
40 create more traffic in the single family home area.
Mr. Loucks stated that a 100 foot buffer was planned to
screen the Leuer property on the west and that the
developer could remove two of the twinhomes in this area
until the Leuers decided to develop their property.
Regarding the trail along the east boundary from County
Road 24 north, Mr. Loucks stated that two residents
objected to the trail from County Road 24 passing Lheir
property, and he suggested that if this development was
required to install the trail he felt that the Seven Ponds
addition should also extend the trail in their
development. He sa"d that the Scherber development woulu
be wi l l iag to match the park land dedicated by the Seven
Ponds development. Mr. Loucks stated that they want to be
treated as the developers of Seven Ponds were treated by
the City.
Commissioner Tierney asked if there was any trail area in
the Seven Ponds de elopmvnt and the amount of park
frontage.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that there was no trail
dedication in the Seven Ponds development adjacent to the
west boundary, and that the park frontage was 60 feet.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Joe Domagala of 17705
County Road 24.
Planning Commission Minutes
September 124, 1990
Page 155
Mr. Domaqala stat,;d he was concerned about whether there
would be any land elevation changes for the site; the dust
problems, created by grading; and the west access road from
the site on the south to County Road 24. He said he would
like to see a through street between Seven Ponds and Stone
Creek developments that would come out onto Highway 101.
He stated that he does not object to the new location of
the twinhomes proposed; that twinhomes were more
appropriate near the industrial site to the north;, and the
lot sizes proposed for the twinhomes seemed larger on this
revised plan,
Mr. Loucks stated the average dimensions of the lots.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. John Grigg of 3180
Queensland Lane.
Mr. Grigg stated that the pond areas seemed smaller in the
new plan and asked if the wetland area in the southwest
corner was governed by the Army Corps of Engineers. He
asked when the City would develop the park area and
recommended that it not be done.
Coordinator Dillerud stated that the pond area was
identical to the previous plan and that the southwest
corner was governed by the, Army Corps of Engineers. He40saidthattheparkareawasplanned, according to the
Capital Improvements Program, to be, done in 1994.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Michael Halbach oll' 3185
Kimberly Lane.
Mr. Halbach stated that he felt the developer had done his
best to design the development. He said he did not think
the public wjuld drive into the park and that it would be
used only by the neighborhood. He said that the Seven
Ponds developers should also be required to install a
trail.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Steve Jacob-Itz.
Mr. Jacobitz stated that the twinhomes were bothersome to
the residents of Amber Woods but that :`e had researched
the, ordinance and he felt the twinhomes complied with the
ordinance.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Greg Leuer of 4475
Urbandale Court who was representing his parents who own
adjoining property to the east.
Mr. Leuer stated that his parents did not object to the
twinhomes, but they would like to develop their property
as single family homes. He suggested that Scherber keep
the twinhomes to the west of the most easterly north -south
public road and place single family homes to the east.
11
El
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 156
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Wayne Menge of 3190
Kimberly Lane.
My Menge stated that the revised plan was much improved
over the previous plan. He said he would like to see the
park remain but that it should be easily accessed and a
parking area should be provided, He said he would like to
see the density of the twinhomes lowered. He stat,.J he
was also concerned about the drainage in the area. lie
stated that the trail from County Road 24 will adjoin his
lot and he does not object to it.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Jim Stavros or 17430 County
Road 24.
Mr. Stavros stated that the cul-de-sac was located was too
close to his home and asked what the ordinance required as
far as distance from the property line for a cul-de-sac.
Mr.. Loucks stated that the cul-de-sac was specified by
Hennepin County to match the existing road intersection of
30th Avenue North and County Road 24.
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Bill LaTour of 3525 County
Road 101.
Mr. LaTour stated that it would be difficult for children
to cross County Road 101 to approacii Greenwood Elementary
School. He questioned whether two entries to County Road
101 had been approved by the County.
Mr. Loucks stated that the crossing for school children
would be the intersection ;A County Road 101 and Medina
Road. He stated the access points to County Road 101 had
been approved.
Mr. Steve Johnson, the project engineer, stated that the
pond for drainage on the northwest would convey drainage
to the north from ounty, Road 101 to the pond and across,
Medina Road. He said that if the cul-de-sac were looped
the drainage would require larger pipe.,
Chairman Plufka asked what quantity of landfill would be
needed and would egress from the site on Highway 101 be
acceptable rather than Co rity Poad 24.
Mr. Johnson stated that the grading plan has not been
determined but that no fill will be hauled in, just moved
and rearranged on the site. He said the County
determined the egress locations on Highway 101 and County
Road 24. He stated that the wetland prevent relocation of
the southern cul-de-sac.
Planning Commission Minut-es.
September 12, 1990
Page 157
Commissioner Marofsky :Aed if any of the lots will
contair, flood plain.
Mr. Loucks stated that some lots will be in the 100 -Year
flood plain but that no setback variances are being asked
for.
Commissioner Pierce asked if the density of Seven Ponds
was the same as Stone Creek. He asked if there was just
one access to the park,
C-oordinator Dillerud stated that the density of Seven
Ponds was somewhat lower than this development.. He said
there is one major access to the park, but two trail
accesses.
Commissioner Stulberg stated he recommend denial of the
petition when last reviewed, but he felt the revised plan
has responded to requests for a transition area between
the single family and twinhomes.
MOTION by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Tierney to recommend approval of the request of Craig
Scherber for a PUD Concept Plan -cor "Stone Creek" located
southeast of Medina Road and Highway 101 subject to the
conditions of the September 7, 1,990 Staff Report.
MOTION to amend by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by
Commissioner Tierney to recommend that the, petitioner pay
attention to the transition detail between the single
family area to the east (Leuer) and twinhomes at the next
stage of the project.
Roll Call Vote on Motion to Amend. 6 Ayes. MOTION
carried unanimously.
Roll Call Vote. 6 Ayes. MOTION carried unanimously.
MOTION to amend by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded. by
Commissioner Pierce to recommend inclusion of the trail
outlot on the east side of thepark both from County Road
24 north and Medina Road south, as recommended by the Park
Department, stating that 0e trail should be available to
all parts of the development includinq the property on the
east.
Roll Call Vote. 6 Ayes. MOTION carried unanimously.
Commissioner Zylla stated that he still felt the
development was deficient in the amount of open space
proposed, and he would, like to see lot siLes of at least
18,500 square feel-.
VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
is MOTION by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Marofsky to recommend approval of the request icy
Laukka/Parkers Lake North 6th Addition for a PUD Final
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 158
Commissioner Marofsky stated that the design does not fleet
the PUD attributes because there is not enough open space,
and it is not consistent with the Park and Trail Element.
Roll Call Vote on Main Motion. 3 Ayes, Commissioners VOTE - MOTION FAILED
Pierce, Zylla, and Marofsky, Nay. MOTION failed
MOTION by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by Commissioner NOTION TO DENS`
Zylla to recommend denial of the request by Craig Scherber
using findings I and 5 of the resolution as the reason fcr
denial.
Roll Call Vote. 8 Ayes. Commissioners Tierney, Stulberg VOTE - MOTICN FAILED
and Plufka, Nay. MOTION failed.
MOTION by Chairman Plufka, seconded by Commissioner Pierce MOTION TO AMEND
o refer the petition back to staff and the developer for
redesign.
Roll Call Vote. 2 Ayes. Commissioners Zylla, Tierney, VOTE - MOTION FAILED
Marofsky, and Stulberg, Nay. MOTION failed.
Chairman Plufka introduced the request of Laukka/Parkers LAUKKA/PARKERS LAKE
Lake North 6th Addition for a PUD f=inal Plan/Plat located NORTH 6TH ADDITION
at the northwest corner of 18th Avenue North and 90066)
Shenandoah Lane,
Chairman Plufka waived the review of the September 7, 1990
Staff Report,
Coordinator Dillerud stated that cot,! -'tion No. 4 from
Resolu-tion 90-291 should replace condition No. 4 listed
for the Final Site Plan..
Chairman Plufka introduced Mr. Miles Lindberg who
represented the petitioner.
Mr. Lindberg stated that he wished to discuss the prairie
grass versus sod issue. He said that the petitioner would
eliminate the prairie grass but that they would like to
seed the north edge of the property which is a
transitional area..
Mr. Greg Anderson representing the ,petitioner explained
the landscape plan for grass and trees.: Mr. Anderson
stated that 38 trees have been relocated but the
petitioners are not satisfied with the present prairie
grass and have contacted some experts at the university to
see if they can. create a better grass mixed with
wildflowers..
is MOTION by Commissioner Stulberg, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Marofsky to recommend approval of the request icy
Laukka/Parkers Lake North 6th Addition for a PUD Final
Planning Commission Minutes
September 12, 1990
Page 159
Plan/Plat located at the northwest corner of 18th Avenue
North and Shenandoah Lane subject to all conditions of the
September 7, 1990 Staff Report.
MOTION to, amend by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by MOTION TO AMEND
Commissioner Pierce to recommend that the entire property
be done with sod with the except -ion of seeding on the
northern edge of the site adjacent to Outlot A.
Vote. 6 Ayes. MOTION to amend carried unanimously. VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
Vote. 6 Ayes. Main Motion carried on a unanimous vote. VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
Item 6 C was not heard. This, item requires a Public
Hearing and will be heard at the September 26, 1990
meeting.
Meeting Adjourned at 11:55 p.m.
SWP:Resolutions :pcljw/9-12)