HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 06-28-1989CITY Of PLYMO T1
COMMISSION MINUTES,
JUNE 28,E 1989
The Regular Meeting of thetyof #annng
omm ssion MeeI way called to order at 7 30 p.m,
MEMBERS PRESENT* Chairman Richard Plufkaf tomalissionem Joy
Tierney, tarry Marofsky, Michael Stulberg,
Dennis Zyllaj Hal 'Pierce, and John Wire.
MEMBERS ABSENT tone..
STAFF PRESENT: cord'Inator Charles O llerud, City
Eng i neer DanFaulkner,Public
D11 r ctorredMoore, and Senior
gClerk/Type st Denis #y : La i err.
N by , oirir isn loo r Tic n;y, second -ed by ; o -Mi s igner MOTION, T APPROVE
Marofsk, to approve the, Minutes for the dune 14, 1989,
Planning Commission Meeting with the following changes. - hanges:
OnOn, .page 8, paragraph 8 the MOTION to recommend approval of
the Sketch Plan-for Leluer Property" wasmad y
y
The /
xi+Etkt/##) i[.4it 3:.f±tw:9+by Cil,i t&§...
On page 8 paragraph 4, the MOTION to recommend approval of
the Preliminary Plat for Bremer Addition was made by
Commissioner Zyllla and seconded by Commissioner Marvf y
On page 2 paragraph 10, the last sentence is to read, "Mr.
Sather Mated uld 90 alongthatthedeveloperwowith the
Brockton .arse access ; f the a.sed access fiom County Road P,
24 was denied." Tne word "proposed' is to be inserted
before the word "access."
o Ayeshsta'ned CARRIEDrMTItote
carried,
Chairman Riufka introduced the request of Robert Larsen ROBERT LARSEN PAPTNERS
Partners for a prelim nary plat and general development plan 89817
for Plymouth plaza S Shopping Center to he located at the
southeast corner of West Medicine Lake Drive and State
L
I
Highway SS,
Planning Commission Minutes
June 28 1989
Page 180
by Commissioner Zylla, seconded by Chairman Plufka to MOTION TO APPROVE
recommend that the City council order a transportation study
of the quadrant south of West Medicf e Lae Drive and State
Hi ohway .55, with Particular analysis to the location of any
south' extension edit ne 1*Ae Drive access to State
Highway 55 west of the proposed center at goldenrod Lane
tbrough the industrial area; the need for, and location of,
frontage roads south of State High"ay 55, the fut,A
location of County Road 3a and the planned extension of 6th
Avenue forth and.. County Road 73, _ with the objective to
confirn1 or change the Thoroughfare Guide Pian
Roll CallVote, 6 Ayes. Commissioner Wire Nay, MOTION VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
carried
Cbalrman P of ka introduced the request of Russel souiey for RUSSEL OULEY (89026)
a ,onditional use permit,and site Pian for Haul Building
Center 1 o).ated at 1871-0 State Highway 55 to construct an
accessory storage structure,
Cliairman Plufka. wawed the overview of the dune 19, 1989,
staff report.,
Cha*reran Plufka introduced Russel Boulley, the petl:tioner.
Mr. Gouley, stated he was in agreement with the ,dune 19,
1989, staff rep<art
Chairman Plufka opened the Public Hearing* There was no one
to speak on thea issue.
Chairman Plufka closed the Public Hearing,
MOTION by Commissioner Wire, seconded by Comtil ssiover MOT IO TO APPROVE
Tierney, to recommend approval of the conditional use permit
and site plan fors° Hamel Buff l d%ng Center to construct at,
accessory' storage structure consistent with conditions noted
in the staff report of dune t9, 1989.
Rol i Call Vote. Ayes:, MOTION carried. VOT1UTCH C.r'.4
Chas reran Plufka introduced the request of Stuart Erickson STUART CR%CXSCN (89042)
for a conditional :use permit to allovi a Class 11 Restaurant
5obway Sandwich) in the 1.1 District located at 14505 21st
Avenue North.
Chairman Plufkaa wa r ved the overview of the ,dune 19, 1989,
staff report.
Chairman Plufka introduced Stuart Erickson, the petitioner.
Planning Commission Minutes
erne 28, 1-989
Page 183,
MOT 10N by Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by omni goner OTO OV
Stu! berg, to recommend approval of the conditional use
ermlt to allow aGlass II Restaurant in the 1-1 District
subject to the 1.0 conditions set forth by staff in the
report dated dune 19, 1989;
LOTION' by Commissioner Marofskyll seconded by 0ommissioner MOTION TO AMEND
Pierce to amnd condition to provide that hours of
operation be l im * ted to 10, a «JtI to 7 WO R,,m. , Monday.
through Friday, 10:30 am. to 3,00 P.m,, Saturday*
Poll Call 'Vote, 6 Ages, ommissroner, Wire 14 ay MOTION VOTE MOTION CARRIED
carried.
Chairman Pluf a stated he feels the Class It Restaurant
would bo located in an inappropriate territory. for the
reasons that it would be detr tent ,l to the public welfare-
it would impede traffic, and it would affect property values
wrth1n the neighborhood.
MOTION by 'Commissioner Marofsky, seconded by Commissioner MOTION TO AMEND
tulberg, to 1rmit seatin0 to 24.
doll Call of Ayes{ MOTION carried. VOTE - MOTION' CAR I D
Roll Call Vote on Maln Motion. 3 Ayes, Commissioners qlre, VOTE MAIN MOTIONFAILED
yl l a, Tierney, and. Chairman Pl ufka Nay,., MOTION failed.
MOTION by Chairman Plufka,' seconded by Commissioner Zyll , MOTION TO DENY
to rdcommond dere al of the conditional use permit' to allow a
Class 11 Restaurant in the 1-1 0istrict stating that it
falls to meet the ', conditional use permit criteria,
specifically, 2, 3, and 4..
Ral 1 Ca 1 I Vote. 4 Ayes., Commissioners Pierce, Marof , VOTE MOTION CARRI E
and Stulberg'Nay,, MOTION tarried,
Charman Pluf a called a recess at 1:0:00 p,m.
Cra rman Pluf a reconvened the meeting at 10 09 pmR
Chairman Pltuf a introduced the request of Oarlock Equipment GARLOCK, EQUIPMENT,189041
for amended conditional use permit and site plan for an
enlarged oc is l de storage located at 2001 141 a ara Large".
Cabman Plufka waived the overview of the June 1 , 1989,
staff report,
3fYi
Commissioner Marofsky questioned Coordinator 011lervd if the
10 foot fence is normal size for the Industrial District.
Planning Commission Minutes
June 28, 1989
Page 18
t.00edinator Dillerud me:)ponded that he could not find a
prohibition to the 10 foot fence, but did find that the
height of the fence could be set by a conditional use
permit
Commissioner Marofsky questioned Coordinator Dillerud- if the
conditional use permit should have a criteria pertaining to
the s;.
Coordinator Dillerud responded that if Commissioner Marofsky
so wished, it could be stated in the resolution.
Chai r"gan Vl ufka introduced- Dick Garlock, the petitioner.
Mr. Gaclof- stated he was in agreement with the June 19,
1989, staff report.
Cha i rplan Plufka opened'` the 'Public Hearing. There was no one
pres ent to speak on thu issue
Chairman- Plufka closedthe Public Hearing
MOTION by, Commissioner Stul bergseconded by Commissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Wire to recommend approval of the amended conditional use
permit and site plan for an :enlarged outdoor storage for -
Garlock Equipment consistent with the conditions in the
staff report of June 19, 1989.
Roll Call Vote. 7 Ayes. MOTION carried. VOTE - MOTION' DOIRIED
Chairman Plufka, introduced the request of the City of CITY OF PLYMOUTH (89045)
Plymouth for a conditional use permit for exceeding height
standards for a water tower located east of County road 101
approximately 1 f 4 mile north of Medina Road'
Y
Chairman Plufka waived the ove 4 i w for the ,dune 19, 1989,
staff report
Chairman Plufka introduced Keith Bachmann of Donestroo
osene, Anderl i k, & Associates, Inc., representing- the City
of Plymouth.
Commissioner Wire questioned Mr. Bachmann what type of water
tower is being proposed.
Mr. Bachmann responded "ice cream co -one.. `
Coordinator Dillerud explained that the t4 rm F,:pideIke
means "i.oro pillar", and -f'he tanrte "icp cx* am cxolle , trol n}
flutedolulin'n" and tbat "I"h "fluted c tnll
style
100, 000 inure th rl the tel o 1A l l at #
a .. <..:e d: -,s.. .n .. .n..: 4 ..e M.i<im .w.rx .,s:. ...xxA::.::., ..., rv. . ..:. ...a .. .... ..>U %
4..
t' x - !-.h.:J.
aiYflMti"_ 4 -V!• .4
Plannilno,omirrlssion Minutes
Julie 28 1989
Rage 18
immediately to the east of t4e water tower. He also stated
that water damage is highly unlikely.
Chairman Rlufka closed the PublAc Hearing.,
MOTION by Commissioner Wire, seconded by Comnmissioner MOTIO4 TO APPROVE
Rierc., to recomiltend approval of the conditional use. permi t
for exceeding height standards for a water tower subject to
the two criteria listed by staff in the report of Jane I9,
X 9, excprat eban ing the criteria of the design to be "the
Lost cost effective.."
MOTION by Chairman Plufka, seconded by C.mmissioner~ Stulberg MOTION TO AME14D
to strike criteria n the motion to substitute ' in the
draft resolution.
Ro11Call 'Vote, Ay Commissioners 4're and yl la Nay* VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
QT ION carried.
MOTION by Coixmissioner. Zylla, seconded by Com issioner MOTION TO AMEND
Marofs y, to amend the motiob to add- that the City do
whatever is necessary to put itself: in confo roan e with its
own policy on landscaping,
Roll Call Vote, 7 Ayes. MOTION carried., VOTIP MOT, ON, CARRIED
Roll Call Vote on Main Motion# 7 Ayes. MOTIO carried, VOTE a, MAIN MOTION CARRIED.
Coordanalor leruct reg Tided the Commission that the next
Planning Commi.ss11 on Meets nq will be can duly 11, 1.989.
Comms ssioner T, arjtey stated she would be absent froth that
meet in X
Chairman Rlufka requested a short discussion regarding the
memorandum Cotlimiss ones 1ylla submitted to the City,
Commissioner Zylla commented on three main issues of his
memorandut, 1 make staff reports tio understandable to
the applicants* 22N wants more of an explanation fc!r the
Lundgren proposal from, staff and ) wants to ra se an
awareness of transportation,,
i hai moan pl ufka commented he agreed to the more simplified
staff reports and also wants to see the rest utions reworded
regarding the City Engineer's Memorandum. He asked staff to
set as'de time to look at the philosophy supporting
transportation for the City, planning
Chairman Plufka, adjourned the meeting at 10:50 p m.