HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 11-23-1988h X +Y v t
PLANNIK MISSION UTE
NM '* 19€3
The Regular Meeting of t.,e *-'Iymouth Planning Commission WaS
Called to order at 7-130 M
MEMBERS PRESENT t Chaffi,,man Fauba, Commissioners Marofsklyl,
lire, uer end
MEMBERS ARSENI one
STAFF P RES ENT Z Community,Developmelit. Director 81 ait
t
CommiAniDevelopmentCoordinator
Chuck04 11 crud, Associate Planner Al
Co n n A slist n it Manager Frank
Bayles and Council member Lloyd Ricker
t:.
MOT -T Caroti s orter Me ofs seconded by ml ss i oner 10" "Pt 10 X TO APPROVE
Tierney, to approve the t4i ues of the November 94" 11
ublished
Ql CarrkQ AR
C airitt n Paube introduced the request by, Charles Hensen for CHARLES N /RA '
TOWER (88137) Gond n ,Use Per - o all amatuer radio, towers. in
T1s rear yard' of 75 feed nd 25 feet n height (Ordinance
Standard -15 feet) Coordinator D4 I I erud provproIded a brief
overview of the flo e ber s f re r
informed aimis loners tbat subsequent to preparation
ftheff repor the goner has restated his
app I i1cati on, o Include a 11 tat, antentialladded to the tower,
proposed t o b 7 feed 1 n, e j b" b.e feet: i n, deo ;
Beem an enn n a igin- l -application.# aai'dtnaCoordinator
ridreed b. in Ills; nspecn f the,sight no
i l o, e, assumed that novwasy)
and '
pyo y}
therefore
Yya y `
jas
aym
gpign }
anu
yb
K {f 0.A4 i. f £i i.e.`t y 6 #.t c l udd &: 3 T 4k i h`bk •4 4Xbeam,d 111
i wottld, be necessary. to emend e last recommended
an s e resuandioninthep royal reso u of
dd do I Inf rma 'on supe 1* -a, ne poner.
CheI rm n Reub e e..ed the Pubs r e Head n . Steven ob,l 19
e# orb indicaed is general conr#ern with
is Ityp6 of tower, He inuired as to,, howxa6y otbor dowers
of bi Alpe ' are locited- elsewbe e within the 1 of
Plymouth., tie staged that the btam antenna was proposed for
the too of the foot tower was out of character with
e canoe of Abe balance *rV the neighborhood.
w
I
November 1,988
Page
m o r halt"o° reiterated b1 rrr about ho ..
could be qen rta_In rt r u uta11 ev toto
Cot
i l stated see err drawbacks,
for ezcbool 41 strtcts,h have f Inftlu boundariars
kited e s to, Control v r ecoln.Qmlc level rr't with"In t
Ictri ts.
rr" "?
f inancing improOments Ican benefit the nir(i C-0jilt'l-tunity,
Incl l e hool i rl rr
v l men oa r rr r e .l v l than i Otherwise
be, i r a tine public .
ar i S, s I 000er 11 nc r 1 th pot" Ial abuses
ba a r fi the City wb r 1' I' i.Opln sod to
expediteerr r.r 1 w4 uncia vatecoili"
another potential abase is tine utilization Of tax r lel
li fn Jio r o° rr h greats
r even,assessments-*
As loner MOTION TO ENDORSE
arcsky to endorse h restabl 1"hmen e oni
Df v el op-mentD iri c, t #7 on of plans for
various tax im'P Peen itanci r -r i outlined i n the
70ovember, 17, 19881 Stiff r rnor m`*
further discussion, ensued and Commissioner Wire, seated he
world spew a.in th trio I n because its pro Porvedwi de
erved as the clArrent 6th'District, Oxcept that it wou,14-
i t H r 1 1 offered mmme about Viet,
proposed district andellts purpose.
19 51- 11. 1 3 13 '} F kAdl lk . * C. voted ,1 4 i KIT10 VOTE MOTOR tARA
carri ed
The t Ission or re v {fir item' , page CONTINUED CONSIDERATION OF
pag
rr r r ttearneedstQ be24
i r ct o the g rr of Purpose. I w n 1 ° .
r ertak hind orderly, d v rir and
gp q
gmad-
e:'
ose X at t; -' 7 11 'Gff_!'Y' 4 L. "dn4 enc x
r a i ' housino and the desirabilitv to
reference, to, op portunitY.
TION by 'tmi s on r P t seconded Commissioner MOTION TO AMEND
lrol sky to a -mend the tot o strike Item L Ion
on., the atn td t : Mss i o r aro s y, VOTE MOTION, `O AMEND
and 'PT ufa vote . otlo a ed.FA
by ons r r of l seconded r "o r AMEN
o menJd Item B 3. 'by Su6stitaing, the, word `sndil
r the word, e rI t,x
ote. 5 Ayes Commissioner,Wire, . mend Afi
assd#
CARRIED
ha i man Pau e t t_ 11_
111211e,_
wim ssilon r Wire questioned tbe'purp.ose 0 Item E I.,H
and red wbo-would'doft and how, it would .fie 6ae
owilli ssianer a re orfted too 0410,
0TION, bOm sinner Wire, seconded 'by Commissioner MOTION TO, AMEND
t berg to delete Item * 3.
1
uns tad end D%rector 'wars Mated that
the i eoid assure i
re r r sa s .or, s 0 iiities, `.
0) i finer PlUfka staffed he saw Tneri in keeping item
un _ -e that the special study done for the City recently
nc erred with Wfilathl, $ Item states-*
to c ner t ` erq: Mated co l d sea masons odeete
he item.
4 Y i
a do .#'Isssl ner 'eer y staffed while tie Idem- eras vague;
Lt ad ri, es is i t wet r eit
ammi ss.foner Marofsky, 5 ate4that the mean, i ng of this item
loin -d -cari f d by lookink at I:ha Hfieriaas
q
lote Nays. Commissioners, Wiret StoWirelbengg'j, and ly I I a NOTE MO!TON TO,AMEND
entad Aye',., otI n to amend ai l ed A
commissionMinutes
November 2, 1988
Page 275
MOT 04 by Coin
I
issioner, Wided by Commissionery MOTION TO AMEND
to amend motion by striking, the word, "'adequate" and
addinv the word-, " eed," In Item
Vote.5 has C e Ave r INOT T AMEND
et to aillend, led f
LOTION", by Gomel i Ener ll t seconded, b Commissioner,MOT-IX ON TO AMEND
P110 ka t incItiding, sentence i ii, t s1section that
would state teat there is A sense of, support, for open spate
the o imn i t, tomiDs,,s I
oe, Plufka stated for example,,.
that It could beertedeet ire A o4
the ommp+`i 11 should,: t` er .. statedthat,}
y"j
Commissioner
yp}yy_^ ake4x^S,3il i'tides broadening l4TtiF # }+t st 4A %". statement 14 S. r o m
re ere ee to,,the tny i ronment open spac0t, and the, l li e.
emm ° i*ner Maro I y stated that pe rhap- env ronment"
should he a separatevL,* -rate Goad
oW*s e er Wir %eft the table.
Vote on. tile er d e t. Aye a Motions to ini ad passed. V Q" N T AMEND
CARRIED
Genet' s s i ever r re retro reed `t the table*
Vote mets e t e amended. /; Ae. VOTE ON IMAIN, MOTION-
MOTION CAR S
MOTION: byComm, screr TION
ornss` over Wire t h to t Objettive 1should read exaetl
stated I n, tete e mbl a on J,(and d
aPpIl'cable throughout for ae the Gears and Ob eetlie .
p iY` MOTION3-CARRI EDVO
MO TION t t ss ea er I re, seec ded e ttmi ss i deer a MOTIONTO APPROVE
aneve jee i e Cr, ter,(except for the part
n parentheses),, , and, ..
cyte. 7 oes 'Motion" Passed MOTION " CARRIED
i#sisFa}nnew t 1` irki$z- 3at;!M T 10 #€t APP t F
e e t h eet e , riteria -64 7af ,7 7d 7e, and
r t ria-,8,,, Nith, the ` 0,01 owl t1p changed.to Criteria 7h- End
the l.terl after °`houses e that it rear as follows.
spot,,".- de e e Mme t e a s artrltent nein interpreted as a
structure completely surrounded by -single am houses
Commissioner -Marofsky inquired hey Criteri7a I s ce .slsten
th Objet ve , Criteria 51. A discussion ensoed.
Planning Commi ss I on Minutes
November 93it 11988
Page 276
MO by Coanissiono, P I ar t, seconded by Cowiiss ion r MOTIONJOIA,
y o d tiro motion by s rIklieg
1 W 5 i r • berf ' C ` # i lretained.
es
i ricer' feces- r m s i o rr Tt
ftatu 6fthe tomoy and can raise Some
o d rro s' ed d b respect choir d o opme,
osorrAyrro w. s, a ptoio
r
yr .
o ro n tease and i rwwu1d make se o
inteDiroc° nm/rkeep
or `r ro col d o. brow : siori. b d
with the ri eerl by re-wording, thell rt s statement o
o rr bas o1 Ing, of, velopments,so thatthe-,Criteria
Were realized.
o od ys o ss orrery y ` "lot-
a
OT M MO T AMEND
dChairman ' ttv Aye do r o orad f i. od A LLED
F s«i RC3gm9@4S'q i sty k.+A ,Marr- ss P eft t i table,
Commr l " seconded, oWssion r MOTION. . `O 0D
ullbeo df ec tiff[ developr amendment to,by7
cyan
t _
p y
0'""7 & PM 4 # 9 5e } 1 { b 1 erd, 44' M'd' k 'S;w ' In t V. Y S - ,+ 1 a
rrk aro more an g orae od s guides rather than-
alsad-min'-st.rative directives,.
of e. o ti d Ciri a ba votedr VOTE MOTION TOAMEND
000 o amend passed. CARD
Vote on- ll, amendment once, amended Ayes M io MAi A
4 s s da.
o : ssi o rer aro y r t r i d t3 '' table,.
MOTTO by Co i si s'on r Wire seconded b M TIOT A P
or rrr s i on r to l b r o ro ed obj ctJ es ; error 4#
0WI ,T llr #
At
t TO r r or' d d ' ori d t ecti on 1.lr .
b o td
try' l l GoS sur d dib
y y i
10 me
MOTION,`- by oulIs been Zyl I seconded by Coo"M ssioner MOTION TO,, AMEND
a o end the ai ri= motion adding., m ria "
in Object i 4 Wr .
Vo.. Ayes* o° o arrrerrd passed* VOTE M1 AMEN
CARRIED
6bserdmmi-- e ment should
cors s ra y use Re. carat oo r ro a1 1,
Ott, the, tame
I
1
at tt -Comi'i ss n Mina-411,
ove'1988
page 277
I
MOTION b cost it ss i u er ar s amend tete main eta ' MOT
re s t'
a 'i b ih ""sets" and
s r t "per c h a Abe '" ' on ted T k )
for I ack of a seed
Vote On the mai a moton as once amended. 7 Ac;. Motion VOTE MAIN MOTION CARRIED
asse
PaaelMOTION ewt*ssiu ter We s ended b
SI
MOT ?t APPROVE
oner Sttilberg to approve'. objettive I, Objective
11 r "riteria 31 t where the
travelling'- sbeuId e deleted and, except for the
v era under e iv 31 whereby a
ba -ce to vail'ous Mid uses s u'd be utalTiained atttu tg, teteatt
resi de t 1 a a ?d utt res de acategories.
otmi ss ".ever exp a t ned h purposes o s.new
Cri. erla,., amiss one 'S a ber stated he "d not agreeI-rt
t h a-there was. a least an implied a rlbutinn o pro e is
to a hey o a sp it ; a
MOT - nt c ssioner P u a, s en eta b Oonum ssi n t MOTION TO AMC,Na
marofsky to amehd the motions by del et'i ng, Subitems ""a"f
through "ell, Object,ve, 3,; Orri eria 3 on eg 12,
c e Co'n ssoerulbergMoa TIGTO KKEND
passed tit
Com. ss i carter ul Borg ep 'a ped his vete b $ tating that
some n s suer as .se 'Should be spored o, ytt and, nils was,
an apprapr fate p ace to de I ,
MOTION, , to amend b Cunni ss c" n r ` Mar s seconded b OI} TOA D
Oer ssl 11 11a, :deie e Qb ee " Criteria ' ' , and
st bst tote b ovii g . "Re- uIting or remzoning of
and uses shoAd occur when adeqwite torted l and is
avai bl e in, serviced areas. of tho Clty `
otmti s', 1 a Ca stated he d sagreed the motion o
Wend tura tt utec-t e tent. b o' d be Fust R e
sated tie e i a a e s " re c e-ve pen areas.*
Commit
ssner aruzsa'ed be appred `atd the poet arra
yhetut'
et}
5'eey d ,e the t oncuryret ce t be seconder,, to
ytteyd; yWith,
av the, anqu.Fge "'f um e eve o S*SiiF#
Vote fl tete amendme 't Ayes Motibi to armed passed. VOTEMOTIONTO MEN
CARRIED
Vote tete to a moionen as amended Ades x Mei l ort passed. tT MOTION
MOT T I b cum ssl owr'Wire, second b MOTIO TO APPROVE
urtt t sstte fiarus, approve Oe yes. aid`
Planting Comission, Minutes
Xovtr 23, 1988
1R, by Commlsksione'r M rofs seconded b y oris i n r MOY AOR, TO, AMXND
Tierney I
to. , ti v 5,,t Criteria , dcr the rl
Wastei after the Word any and to de I ote the
Brat
11. nit,ary d 1 '# .
m rtd a-md SOT - T X 41TO AM E D
CARRIED
DW b ommii c er Mro seconded b, y Commissioner MOTIONITO AMEND,
ZY I I a to amend the motion deleting Obje t1ve 5, Criteria
that the crila belongs, under, Goal
Cowll 1 o r Wire 1 rrl l : d d. I o : wbetb 1
ho d remain inhi icy a a matter of safety.
e . Motion to amend passed. VOTE - OTIO T AMEND
CARRIES
on main motion as twi ce amended.. Ayes _ Motion VOTE MAI 0 MOTION CARRIED
d
OTTO MOT-ION TO APPROVE
by, C{I i 1 io11 r -berg approve Goll 0, except for the
d et* o he word l ar ll O ot11t Cmter*
10C.
Extensive d ensued regarding the v rio i eve
uner
MOTTi tli 11t#er M rof-sk y secooded by Commissioner MOTION TOIAMEND
a o Inert the word "ifli l r"
I
balers the ward
11 ` er l n the, O ctiv ri erg a , o ' insert
rd ` ` 1 t rd tr 3,l t r 11 i ij , ve
i peri a it I neem the card "ar greater"" after the
r Insertr"r; s"i nOd
ard "o 'ar r," after, the word larria " I Objective
Criteria ; , d d' re t staff t c1arifythe,, i anquage i
ye I
ote `A i ' amend a edv, O- MOTION T AMEND
CARRIED
i m 1 amended Ayes , . g o VOTE - MAIN, OTIO CARRIED
s y ,
on
r
The n adjourn tO
x