HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 10-14-1987CITY OF PLYMOUTH
PLA ING COMMISSION MINOTES
OCTOWR14, `1987
The Regular Meeting of the Plymouth Planning Commission was `
called to order at 7:30 r . M.
QRS PRESENT. Vice Chairman Pauba.; Commissioners,
Wire, Stul.berg, Zylla and Marof sky
t MNERS AUSENT; Chairman Steigerwald and Commissioner
Plufka
STAFF ':PRESENT. Planning Director Blair Tremere
Community Development Coordinator
Ray Anderson
Assistant City Engineer John Sweeney
Planning` Secretary Grace Wi.neman
MINUTES
MOTION` by Commissioner Zylla seconded by Commissioner Wire ` MOTION TO APPROVE
to .approYe the September 2211987 Planning Commission
Minutes as submitted.
VOTE 5 Ayes. MOTION carried,` VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
CONSENT AGENDA
MOTION by Commissioner Zylla, seconded by Commissioner 'Wire MOTION TO APPROVE
to; approve the Consent Agenda, Item 7-C Site Plan for
ghat-. McNeely, Pheasant Trai.l Townhouses for 24 multi.-
family Units, sub eCt to the conditions listed in the Octo--
ber 7,: 1987 staff report.
VOTE S' Ayes,, MOTION carried. VOTE - MOTION CARRIED
Coordinator Anderson explained that Mr. and Mrs. Robert
McAuliffe,'have again-req uesteddeferral, of their request to
the meeting of October 28, 1957. A letter confirming their
request is en file,
He also explained that a Public Hearing Notice was published
in the legal newspaper for Northwood Homes., for considera-
tion of a Conditional Use Permit by the Planning Commission`
on October 14, 1987, The application was temporarily with-';
drawn by flair &'Associates, the petibonert s consultants, in
their October 8 1987 letter,
PUBLIC HEARINGS
Vice Chai.rma Pauba introduced the .request and an. overview MARY' SCH(,ENZ
Gf the October i, 1987 staff report was presented by Co- COMITIONAL USE
ordinator, Anderson. PERHIT FOR A
Vice Chairman Pauba called on, the petitioner, she was not
CLASS IY REST RAW
Present.
233-
ommiss on`Minutes
S'Ptober 1. '1987
lam open-ed the Public Hearn there was
no 'one- present to, speak cn the item, fie Pub ie ear nq < ,
ensenss of the cmmson `totake acta.oh on the
etust»
OTIO by omissioner Zyl a, seconded by Commissioner TIO " 'Afli?tt VF
roc mmen.d royal fir th e :Conditiotial Use Pt 'for ;
Mary " ch en t operate: a HCl ass it est a tx*a a t b
Zor ;nq tract c ted In the 06ttonw od Plaza` at the
o the b cnrner of bounty Rioa -9 and V newco.d sane North,
scb`ect to the conditions llstedin the Gatober 7.,97
staff report,
sionera s aotaieRoaVote. ydm
MOTOR .carr .ed O
ce Cha .rman Pa.uba ` n troduced the request and an o verew , f1RN.
tt;bdr 198-7of sas fproent y TWNT
ordnarorntawriT'+
f ALAN AND
a e la m ' Pauba introduced Mrs oht oce x Mutual ' I'ION V
IryO tment. Prope c w o had nn' ban c nmmeAts anal PERiMO (8 1U5)
sated would answer any gstior s frc.m ss" ion
aotheree ordteommissonelqurtN,oageareaandthefence00nsO''a"
Mr# tencel` .stated the fence woad be an alternatIng board
Which meets, th,e rct u.a.rerp+ent for 9 c
tfen
Loe
yopacity--,
t-H4v ik11Sir J.',S 4.F.4',C 4r` 7i ,iot" "'*r f'!.'r.6.d': 4 fa ,.7A: .,t£ir:}.
ommissI ones' Marefsky inquired if, the fence will be .at. th.e ,
97k. elevation and. he confa.rmed tha they would , grade to. the
silt fencer the northeast canner the oW, wet are up to
Lyle fence.'
vi .oe ha rman Pauba read t e .otter submitted by Louis 0.
Wet'neke., Ws -0 Werneke company, who opposed. to the
oults:vr-aq"e 'proposed e.
Pomm, iss"ioner ZZ a ;inqu,.;ra about 'the location of .: lk
Werneke's bvsILne s relative, t6the propos ed sues Ccc cd nam
tot Anderson s.ttecC Mr, Werneke' s busaness is ontot , west
of the- proosed site:-.. .
nimer dire inquired about the bulgy din material s: and
stated r et erthepantedaccentcolors, Mr Stencel
tri 1 Ytol f `" c! at,u a t{Ci cul long W b a ,
II
natural concrete color, and, ;anodized bronze WIJl be used At
the, entralc6
Planning Commision. 14ih t
ott ber
Yfe ,^}(^
jj-
y'5. h ]iYi Y'f N4 2'(} }q'/Y Y'j.-
yy1l J. v ,le y1 e»'aT tdc n, ..:8t $:kdl .} oui. a.r :SRT I.f ,SA S/4 * :»in l f TJi7. ri Ta'+?ad'
building unpainted' Mr, Stengel Mated h i s, was an arohi-
teotura decision tlbe ownor had been given other aIterna
t F :s^;Y stated that t1k S bu nld ,ng be ml ,ar to t,
Jude Candy, bUll^ding at Highway 55 and Niagara, Lane,,
Gommiss,loner, Yl a stated his oonoern regarding an unpainted
building where-adj'aoent 611dings ar, painted and fInIshed"
Re, could not support a Proposal with an,, un. in shed. un-
a need bul, 'oa ng wh,
t
c ou.d ,not bo Gompa b e With- other
buil d ungn the area .e sugge ted a bre ok front ' He
not that paln,t:ls a m,I al e penso and pa nting th
bn onu,lding wo keghboring
V de, Cha 'rma.n Pauba opened 'Ix Puk, o, bear r g
Henriksen, ake'vIlle$ MND, owner ofi ' -M> r'k, across
from: too pr.oposedlte ompt all the mportanoe o pan
ung the bit ld ng:Ne inquired,,', about thy; type of rooftop
e u p to tt .propped - CoordInator Ander on e pla nod h-,
would be air conditioning dor the build!
Vloo Chairman pauba olosed the Public Hearing,,
MO L i_, '4tS++ `4ri ii+ W". M l r t i '11 r +i ,;'aJl x# l»_•Rx4 717 11ij 1U,
to reoond approva..l for the 1 e plan and, Conda tlwal $e
permit :,for Mutual Tnves<tmen t'ropertos, subljeq`t -to the
ondx°tlpns lis od n the 3ctnber 7 `l 8 ataff epo t add-
reg° Cor clition No, w, The build ng,shal; be painted and
inlshed o be com' tibl,e, wi h, buy ld ng the arca
MEC I ON b 00flvi asioner, Marofsky, : seor nded b CommissiOher Di N i0 `A 1=nN
Ire, to amend, the Motion It add Condition No T, # The fence,
hlaw/y1y
ryrye
p .ayce$d a t e o a/t .on`[ oft 984 t' pro ode ac egu.ate
I,
yas
s++d».4rL+fening .h 0 es"t , `de 117: bob , *ito
l .,al,l Vote on Atnendmen ,^ A e$MOTION "carried. VOTE - A 1
CARRIED,
Coq %7
slora}/ry SJtulbe g r cygc
w
ner clod. ay g'
otpextrual
ryo
dit
fr
Cor dat. on tl.Y.+t' L' s ,,
yR ryollo
s+ iYli'ii 4 C1 .Y. '. Al#$
y+".
1:',
g .y , 5 # q.
1yi;4,
yg 6y.{
hly'
gf
3. -ua,;, t7R #t b.rrkr L'^ p VS.+, . P,gi
f)
i
Ct,
i
Ty.+. ty'+r.
jya} 3wood
7#i7t^it dC+1le +.e'uil, buil, :]'f poi+ ding,
MgMI b.y 'ommi$sjor er Marof Y,* $eo r dod b c s loner AW- W
St ub t add C ndlt bn o, ' , ` Th developer shall
nz
a w area .r. un the-A, f iter lev tion on,,
the n'o the 's to,.or A er o -the ' _ to toprovide Add ti nal
from 'the and i tf sa I t fenceoreeaRg :east snort ase,; .and,
shall b coved beyond that area 7:
gage '236
Planning Commission Minutes
October 14.1 1"7
11r Str~ce3' con firxried- that the arta 'fo?' of-asidestorage -will ;
be reduced in size; and, the trees will be'retained.
Roil Call Vote on second Amendment. Ayes MGA1GN VOTE AMUVWNT
carried, MOTION CARRIED
Roll Call Vote on Main Motion as twice mended Ayes. VOTE ON AIN MOTION
MOTION carried. AS A"DED MOTION
CARRIED
Vice Chairman Pauba introduced the request and an overview AMOCO OIL COWANY,
of the October 7, 198*7 staff report was presented by Co- REZONING, GENERAL
ordinator Anderson. DEVELOPMENT PLAN
PRELIMINARY PLAT
Commissioner Zy la inquired about the location of the 10-` FINAL PLAT
ft. setback for the free standii g sign. Coordinator CONDITIONAL USE
Anderson explained the signage proposal. PERMITy SITE PLAN
AM VARIANCES R7062)
Commissioner Marofsky stated he represents, persons w:th
interests In surrounding property, and if the Commissioners
or the petitioners determine til: -s could be a conflict he
would step down. He was not asked to step down by either
the Corrnnissioners or the petitioner's representative
Commissioner Marofsky inquired aboL.jt the tempo-ar holding, y y
pond that appears, ori the plan- but is not referenced in the
Engineers Memorandum.
oordinafor Anderson statod that, per the Director of ,Public
Works, it gay rro t .be necessary to provide the temporary pond
on this site,
Assistant City Eng :neer Sweeney strted that a. permanent pond
is proposed for the Cottonwood Plaza site so that the to
nary pond on this site would not be necessary.
Commissioner Marofsky noted that, this pond is proposed, but
not approved, nor, according to what he understands has it
been acquired.. if the ponding area is not acquired by`the
time this site is ready for development,. would it not be
necessary tri provide the temporary pondl
Engineer Sweeney stated that negotiations are taking place
and an agreement has been reached on a number of the>
conditions. The owner is in the process of providing the
required area for ponding and has applied for the liability
insurance policy.
Sherman Goldberg,, consultant -for the developer of Cottonwood
Plaza, stated, that the City Council will be addressing this
At their meeting on October 19, 1987,
Mr.
I
Fillippi stated that the stacking plan showing six cars
Page Z42
R nning, tommis.sion Minutes
14 196-7
t i ss i r ` L a C ,igq' '. T `4 pet t nUr. tTie r
p ns. for a C, lzed. `ick ht i rte W t rle ghbor' , g property,
owners to, ascertain f the bu ,ding vi 11 bo 000patz bl,e wit
other buildings inthe area
V ° Com . avb -oalle in-te,eol s,; ; P
w W$IWSS
dice' Chap -m n p"auba introduced the request and an ovezvitw BOULDER PROPMES
othe October: 7 staff repot way Prov, dod by Coord%n- N .; TE PLA" Ate '
ator Anderson.
c Chairman Pauba introduced. Mrs George`Oaniels, Boulder-
pro ertio , Trac,. who had no. quostionalcr 'comments.
MOTIOR key Cbr mi sign r tuTber , seeor ded <by 1 ce Ila. r.man h.TION TO AUP'ROVE
Pauba to re ommend apprcYa fcr' the Site Plan and.. Var.ance
for the bandity to beoated at the' southeast comer
c ,County Road _ and inewood La e, subject to the ccndi-
tiens listed :gin the October 7. 1987 staff moor i
Mote, Ayes. Commissioner Marof sky, jabs`alned VOTE -- TION CARRIM
MOTIOby Commss Ones Ua seconded Gomm ss oner Wire CHAEL _"_ CNC EY
tc recommend approv i ` th to -Plans` sub pct to _thy P"AMS" TRA
ti ns listed in the October 7y 19K staff report* TO*N"OWS/SITE KLAN
07011)
There- waY ~11one present to represent 'this, consent agenda MOTION TO: ,APPROVE
atom#
vote Ayes, MOTION carr%ed. VOTCH NOTTON , AR Ml
O oto " r mer° sbbWod .61 des df real estate siogns ,seen VFW OF '1;MPOR.ARY
broo blot the G ty,;:some of which were in the public ri ht' tEAL tSTAT'E SIGNS
of ray, O. ec or Tremer ,noted that ah informational letter
way sent to area read tdr on ep eer, 1 1987,, explai.z 1.1.9.
the wse and placei)ient. of to +}aczrar real l estate signs* Ho
stated 'that moi t o the realtos.bo called_. 4n tier_ s'tat d
prt)bia . . a se kV t s ,.g is pliao e I n the ` pub!, s +qht 0 -
r ay laby co i dec[ a need to ereot signage, .`t4 aireot the dome
hovers ``fie their p cduet d°ff the sue t the- to se for ai
lated the problems of City manpower to fully enforce
these sign rego,14 t e s and, '-that no permit is required, for
te pora y rave l statigns Th, lounex1 ba,`d r,eo.ted
that tie issue f off it rea e tate, , gi?a e be d., t with
and that a Pb 1 Neara n be held se that real tors and other
n° .erosted p Ar, t-ll-es ado aJ l iwo f .to speak oti this item.