HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 07-07-1987OF PLYMOUTH.,
SS a 14NUT STN
1 Y 198
IRThe z ar' , e the l ou h la, n Comm. lonWa
oallod to order 7130 p:,
WHO-MM, PR NT Chairman `Stelqerwald and Commissloners
a ,. Cwass'.FJs «F
ST NTS Planning D re for Blair Tre mar
City Engine$hers
C r'am n y D to ent Chord n r
Ray Anderson
Ion b" Commissioner W1, seconded by Cu isslon r
lbr nut ude, X987 a TT+C T APi'RQ1
su d
µysto.narrld. VOT i T
S
Chalt114 1.6. e eG.E +
y}.#
d.. V±lhF.d 4d4 %a! Y:4,F" i,,`l i4. atlo . -by, V kiyt 4yys F,* 14}Y +
c
t x##i
y
i' nutellvc f A -Pro-$ U,i.P#kaln.%SIle'C3.+1«TA :U ziR4'd iis. -,'
j
4i a-fi'
ff r oor Was waived
p.s iINUT," - 7 ,i
NTERNATI NNL
h a Irmaq Steig rwald opened the. publi he rin , as there s,, CONDI T10KAL 0
the p blic he nnonnehnrlhdospeakcoq %has,Item, r P RNTT -JTE
Way PWS: INTERNATIONAL
RQ7U
0,TIUN ' .by Com ssl 6er " ubaf .00 nd,ed by n rils goner MOTION, TO',APPRt.V
lea;: a. re 6mend .ppr a ; u the Condit n Use Rarmi
for _'UMOA, F * -M3 nei etl1 n Press Fl. t .A sub jeqt to
tte.,.000ditions Su 1,9ta
Ll call Votes eye carri6d.. V iT(:4 ON A IEN.
Planningtommiss'too m1au es
1' X967
Chairman St6igerwald introduced the request by Dennis DEMIS OA
ovthwood_ Ho .na-- - ani `-W 0W- S, I
tie burse 1,9$ staff epor by i re or ; re , e., P IK IY
MO ANCE P
a UrectorTrereemphasized- zed that .ot" Block POM-S-T'
northeast, corher, of th ; development, oo; d e' allowed' only, ,
ori fIrm. assurance by the petitioner- that tie land :will be
consolidateG Y3 i s h east.,1 {iisC Iao .
should or c rre pip e deveiopmen and Firvai ' At
approval for this sie*
ommissl ones Mar fsky stated '; that; .e _under stands, the filing
of cond i ium with the C' my does no. e a
subdivision of Viand.
Director Treme stated that each bui dig must I _ft site,
plant =appr6val and the A t of ereaa in a oondomanit, is
not 'viewed as a land sobdivisico % bode tete p1, at,
has approv d y thu 'City,.
a ss o0er Pldfka 'dated .a con exv n o e' d f the .
p f ' land- th--oonneota with Orleans - La andr- ark
he er the' City should fake oontrol 'of this strip w- h h Is
ler, than necessary; for ;the trail prcposod•
Commissianer Marofsky es to ed whether the park land
should referred p as lot and b oak,,,
Dare"ctor Tremere sated t h a , the park land should Ve '
desc ed as an o and tftis woo d tae changed her
final plat,
Chairman e t 4r S,A. d .7..fA i/C.i,AS+=i.r'}.2 1..41h. L7 .i: '. 02, a I. i,+'"e .
p tt roc represents p tion r, Mrs Gain then I ro-
diced e pe er e I s 'S'a ,ke
r, Gaed: x ire pe' o#. er h developed s illi
real. `in r+,.e 'and,er. ¢e}l tsiey:s) *f..oh ..;# ~,"^dieys 'r}o,ryepts
tMap1e
a y
Gelt
l f'.?..kti fit tkJ f.',i. 3!° i'a"Iw.4f'.A.+.R.t 3.t4`Y,5+t.A.Y}it.4!A"
Plymouthou will-, j ,4, An''Upscale* d vo opment. 44 th doOle
ara s`
Mrs Lair snarled t 0e deve :erW1e :.doge Jj
ses ire 0has r W i e ,as r i o rs .gook o #
ock 11 Lot 1j, Blodk I Lot aid oek 2 t Lot I
for Gain stated ha;t Vie, park design and topotiraphy Were
w s e for, dedication',s a p.oblicv p rl nc din t)
pa s. vd recreational features*
I
Planning
opo Pluf staltedhe "_otoaood about tb
Areas,im a0t ;; upo xi t , ome
Stu' lberg, stattNaatj,the more approp At
Pro - .that L t UIL+ , -
p o .a , -' t t 4 of 1 rector,,
q
3 Ju a , ' Co l A.a r ed *
00 soml0 1 a a c WI -MOTION failed*
R-O, Call 41z .% t, oa(6Ty Me's$ionersM T
R(
y'
1.8 i'
@ajl
y }++% 'j
yMain-
4},}
t '[ .} i ll .. 4P L iia. Ci eigY R R, man
Wive and Plufka,„' 10T ON carried
hai ma t a. eO,'! introduced A oo m of No. a opened NT
the Public Hoy
p Wino au t o An: i t o ,
ponditions,,Inventory and the Impact it would,have po the
olr 'cost*
DirectorTr-emereed 110n Qage of 'th6op[` he
jeter
y
rte 1; #'R 'r 6A d {7};
yk..}
kT71clarified,
Vat6
theSi'.+°'l+
jP.
y+ `
a Iy
1
x(+
4b+?,
q.
i '
y } j j
1ywK,ii
y;,.. j[
yf+
i
4y+.'('
ja}#
yj' He was,
F 4€i,E zrr l.k A^i 4'} '4k 4Lr k}+4a[ii A. 7 W ?h The 4FA.F J : J.. ±,4not,
yd#j{
J141,.
t-.erL
MQTT by o. m .o r Plu a . ,; o ,OR od b o n7 0 0 T ' t? #
atm ' Moffits.lftd t Oval craft&mr ,o¬a No ,
c
math $kjbolvi ion tole) as- drafted a tbo staff report*
Rolf call voto 6 a.yea.. VOTE-"OTIN, CAWMI
hat. toa,rwa.. at odcoaa1 t Am.mdmoot oto. aR T i I.
a cmc to arl o'Vor iovy by Director Team .
c o o P-I. a ;Sugge t d that a, comma and tiho wo
otic : 'a, Ort b{e ayo .. i a a
y
t.a
yy
b
y (`.}
a}
4 )
quid
4' ilt4i3i sli.F ie to $M:}Sk4jon, 1), ub4.4.f..Y+hi7-,Riom3
omm s i o n Wir- objected- to draft Amadmot o e
believes it gives staff tile discretion'' to , appy ve al
al build' noted. a.no}
y .
o tyy gyy{{
yyt++
g[
t tyg y
P {o mmfl{l / {j]
rroo4h1,1.{.E ` d isovsS«o 2s n . ei+i7: fiq LtU e i artd 4w ; the, `iR
thebmi lds- ion t have the oppt t: ,Lty t , ev evY theoy1bulIdi4. .iyRKk t.i» e3., To
m ug para.-rapRew
1oyo{
p
tjjhay{.t
t`1
tod a3 y{
f aQ +
jjr [ ({
c -
and,,
rA b LF %' +.F d pi 4K LF T a5.h' .' Ci i I', With, # A S.7 $. 4, +w 4 !\'le 4F i.7iParagraph
1. b. ro u bo d to”, Pa a apb d 1 The ae pa
or theComm alty DevelopMentgraphWcread,The, pplboant
D Ireetor may s0mit the ,app Loata.on to the Plapninq Commil s4i.;
cion and to,, the CitotiRoil for disposition "at a tem "
Page 156
Planning Commission Minutes
8uly 71 1987
C al -r an Steigerwald opened the public hearing..;
Burger, President of the Plymouth Development CounQi
t d; that agrees with the proposal and feels it .is a;
nod progr,.,M, It responds to the intent to streamline
alopment review process for applications which are in
Chai rroan Steigerwald closed the public hearing.
MOTION by Commissioner Plufka, - seconded: by Commissioner NOTION TO APPROVE
Ma,rofsky to recommend approval of proposed draft Amendment
No. 2 with the change as proposed by Commissioner Marofsky.
Roll call vote., 6 ayes, MOTION carried. VOTE-MOTIOR CARRIED
4OTI~DN: by Commissionet Pauba seconded by Coortissioner Wire MUTTON To AI.DPROVE
to recommend that the Council direct staff to return to the
Planning Commission after six months with a list of all
applications that have been approved by these procedures so
the process can be evaluated.
a{ moll call vote. 6 ayes. MOTION carried. VOTE -MOTIONTION CARRIED
Chairman Steigerwal:d introduced draft Amendment No. 3 and AMENDMENT NO. 3
requested an overview by Director Tremere.
Commissioner Wire objects to No. regarding funeral .homes
and mortuaries 'allowed as a permitted ,use in the B-1 and R-
oni og Districts.,
Director Tremere statedthat the issue, is, what conditions
should be or would be required of mortuaries and funeral
homes if they are considered as conditional uses?
Commissioner Wire cited concerns with traffic and proximity ,
to residential neit;hborhoods.:
Chairman Ste aerwal d stated that, ,if Commissioner Wire t s
objections are valid) then the Commission should be looking
at whether funeral hones and mortuaries should be allowed in
a --1 or 3--2 District) at all..
Discussion °i contLnued regar ing ,locations of existing funeral
hones in the Metropolitan area,
Chairman Stelgerwald opened the public heeringi as there was
no one who, wished to speak on this item, the public hearing
was closed.
NOTION by Commissioner Stulbex91 seconded by _ Chairman MOTION TO APPROVE;
Stkgerwald to recommend approval of draft Amendment No. 3
as stated v
Roll Call Vote. 5 Ayes. Commissioner Wire) Nay. MOTION VOTE - MOTIOH CARRIED
carried
Plannihqoft mi s on Ra Mutes
t y 7,. 87 .
chairman Stelgerwald introduced Rend No and opened the
ent-req aeosted to, speak on "Ufte-
item, the Poll- h rin was lose o
MOTION by Commissioner,-, Wire,, seconded by Commissioner, ' MOTION, `O MPROVE
Stulberq to recommend, approval of draft Amendment Mo ,as
Roll a , Ayescarried. VOTE - WT ONJRRJ:D
Chairman to ger a d introduced, draft Amendment No., 54 AWNDWNT N -Q. 5
Chairman Steiger raI d o,ened the p bliO earI.
Burger g president of: he P y oath Jav; gyp ent Council
agreed wItb the proposal.
Chairman Stei erw d closed the public, heap~ nq4
TIO y Comm s Caner W r, seconded bar Commissioner auba OVE
to recommend approval Of draft Amendment NO 5 as proposed.
Roll call vote. a s.. NOTION carried*
n"}.r
pr S d' d drat Amendment . 4 iNY NO. 6
ba.irmtan Ste g-er+ d Goene d oubli : heari _ as er ' gas
no one Who wished to; speak on, this teml, the pub .io hearing
was closed.
MOTION b Commissioner ` lre seconded by C,ommilssa,one ` Piz ka C%TION, TO APPROVE
to recommend a pro n o drab` Amendment o4 as proposed.*
o ff: oa11 vote., ales. MOTIOk carried, V 1 4-t T ON CW, IE;
Charman Stel er ,ald Introduced, dr at Amendment ;No-. tea r i N. '
Chairman Steiger wa,Id opened the puUlc hearing; as there was
no one who wished to speak on this. ltpMj,the publichearinq
eras, chosen*
Commissioner "Wire expressed concern for public safety lith
this prpposa . ,
to milssioner Ma ul=s y agreed and "stated bis concern regard-
lnaeSthetas fence 3:n front yards' and safety for"
ch dren) In terms of sight distance r strioted by' fences
enoes can also be conducive to persons lurking In yards..
sousson:ensdett on this tem Chain Steerad stated
ghat ,Many people need. fences for privacy and for securltyl
gage
luly j . 19
Director Treere stated that the reason for this amendment
as s. .".y.:+. _ _ •sr..#tiiiY.a- a. .`f'-f`i_ tea. 'idS1$t. _'"
vs ,+,:.f"4...Y..i. . r i&{1: «& ' :G$Riivjl,r" iA.t is Ti '4"-w*F." i•v h
v% lve% ,.i fenoos do not,require r lt,and
nsotten discovered after construoti nP his Is
true,for Berner lots*
He :. e'. :and 4.t1lL:c' ee :. ,ro L.r MA.i - the _. p< %3'it ki
enees He responded questions as to where eche Or dinanee
neer ergs --fone s
Commis oner u a exp' ciined has oneern ha Alo
o d e addressed a different definition. offront
Yard's Relate it t0 the, er enta-t or. the access to, .
the hnluse-
MOTION , by o m s n'er ara s , seeQ tc ed b cbtmm s ener 1011 t T e ffiU ,
Wire o recommend approval of dra=ft Amendment Na, 7, wi h the,
del n of he rc v sion for fences In she rant yard' as
deserl ed in Para gra hs Neo and L
T n tend the am motion bCommissioner 'l a, WW
secondedf ti s nor Wire ` ha -for,puqe t7 rh.5
ecions -the de n.t en o a front yard be ehan ed to de Ino
e0rner let front Ford as, " he s de the lot tnva rd
h e t e house faces the street and/car the side of the ink
e h -o the drive a . exits ono the street;
cu e on a endmen P .naves. omm ssioners- ca and )Yreg VOTE- ?T+Nhi --
ay, MOTION, f ailed*.
OTIO SY e#mmissionor ulberq seo6nded.; by emm,ssloner 1Oi3ON TO, A
rens deser bed n Paragraphs and ` a ar draf
endmenr bio '
o m e e dmen .. 4 nays Commis" inner tvilberq, a e t T^l4UT (J
aneie,ed*ha rm
fete on Main: { .: 4- ayes. Commissioner berq. za. t T 1 C I i
Cha -rMan e ger va d nab# MOTION, earrieds
ha rmar " e ,gerwa d n r t c d Amendment ' . i t ; NO .
ha rman-Steilger ald opened the nub ja Orinqjas ther-e, ,gas.
no, one wno wished to sea on this item, the ubiio hearlo
was 016se.
d -d by Chair man TO APP
j weld' o recommend a roval o ra Lme dment e as
roposeS
Rollca11 Y oto :: A W+J 4 A"OT1'4JN iF.ar
i
i d,.- TTiJ R 4+,. fI