HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 06-11-1986CITY OF PMl-
PLAN"INC COWISSION MINUTE
The Regular fleeting of the Pl mouth Planning om i slon wKIS
m
Called to order At 7Z10PJL1 `
W.-MBERS PRESENT: Chairman Steiqerwald, Commissioners;
Magnus, Stu lber) Plu ` a and Pauba
Coiwlssioner. Wire arrived ' 07 PUNS
WHBERS,ET* Commissioner Mellen
STAFF PRESENT. Community Development Coordinator
Sara McConn
Casty Engineherm t l ber
Planning, Secretary Cr .ee lineman
SERF ACENDA
MOTION by Commissioner Pa be seconded by Commissioner, SENT AMNDA
t lberg to adept the Consent Agenda inoludinq the May Z 1, MAY 21, %
1986 Planning om ris ion R n t s MINUTES
MOTION APPROVE
The 1 21), 1966 Minutes wi tl he oorr eotea.. letln hair-
mant 1 eNwall**s, name from the first para r,, h under Pull icy:
Hearings., ce;Chairman Pauba chaired the meeting, as noted.
T . 4 Ayes. Chairman Steigerwalld and Commissioner Plufka
from the Vote the M nut MOTIO a le E MOTI? IMabstipner'. . .
Chairman tei erwa d iritroweeo the application Mr. 1 e n
a
IYEAR E lu l
El m fora ,Conditional lyse Permit to operate barber/CON01-TIONAL USE,
beauty shop At 3001 Harbor Lane Ithe -1' Zoning tillstri t a `1
Reading of the May 1986 Planning Staf f Report was
N alve - Chairman Steigerwald inquired if Mr. idem had
questions cox eats on the staff reports 1r, ider bad no
Comments and stated: be would answer anof tete Commission's
Chairman Stelgerwald opened the Public Hearing, as there, was
no one Present; to speak on this item., the Public Hearing was,
closed.
MOTION,by Commissioner Pl.0 `ka seconded b Commissioner O SPP0VE
Pauba to recommend approval of the Conditional Use Perris
for Mr.. bean Eidem,subjeet to the conditions as listed in
the la 1 staff report
Pall, all Vote. Ayes4; =10TION carded. QED
Page, 109
1
i
tanning Commission Minutes
uta
Chairman Steigerwald lhtrnd-iced the request , by Paul and CAUL RENEE UARTHANK
Renee Hartmann for a Home,Occupation Conditional Use Permit HOW OCCUPATION
to, allry, nail manTouring services frost their resid nca, CONDITIONAL
PERMIT (136056)
ad n a , 1986 Plan n Report was
waived
hairman StelgerwaId introd-,iced Mr. Paul Hartmannann Ivi'd 1,* :
f
questions or oommeAts, Chairman ;4teiger Bald the
h.' aF, - lieara,s9;.F',as, t -fa r :. was 1 n st;n to speak. ='s :''"k,g2
I
Item,.. the Public Heartag was closed.
Commissioner auha Inquired approximatelyximately huts many customers
I
would be expe-oted,to visit the Hartmann residence daily.
Mr. Hartmann Stated that his wife could sea=s a customer in
One to One and one -h ,lf hours and there may he- 4 to 5 cstn-
raexs per days However, stated this would be a parttime,
uftdertaking as Mrs. Hartmann is busy with their children.,
Commissioner Pauba, confirm d It would not be a high volume
service and if It became so the Hartmann's would mt e the
service into a commerciallyiall ,coned area:.
Commissioner Pl f a Inquired if Mrs,, Hartmann, would he the
only one t onduotinq the service to the custom r,, r,.art -
mann . rid a f rmativ ly. alssion r Plaa a Inquired
be A.M* if V .--,mars of operationHartmann y jy
ya psV+
y
stat ed,}`}.,0
Y}{
ya
il
andC3Y.F fiY J,2 it+*
i i't i% Sr iaSti4A 1i 1. A4tiF#iLN'4 TW 4.f } F ,A„ b14a '+r r f . k .. answered
re atd that there would be dais tar a 'there anuld he no
rs Commissioner P1 -- a confirmed that the r d ts
sold with the service aro only or thus customers receiving
the nail. Manicuring service.
MOTION by :Commissioner to lher , seconded by, 'omm ass on r NOTION TO APPROVE
Magnus to recommend approval of the Home Occupation
ondit tri r l Use., ermit for Paul and Renee Hartmann, suh e t
to the oondit ons gas .l * in the May , 1986 staff report
add Irig Condition No. 9. that the business hours, will be
9100, M. o a* , Monday through: Saturday*,
Roll Call Vote Ayes. MOTION, carried. VOTE MOTION CARRIED
hairman t a t aId ntrod uoc d the request by LeRoy onsnle E + S01 .
for Rezoning, Conditional Use Permit, Preliminary Plat RUONINCI PRELIMINARY
Final Plat, erequested an overview of the May 22 *, 1986,, C0NDITIONAL U -SE
Planninq Staff Report by Coordinatnr MoConn. PERMIT., PLAT AND
FINAL PLAT (8605,81
Comm ssionar Wire Inquired 'what the Comprehensive t id Ryan
shows for that area,,, Coordinator McCo n explained the area
is, coned FRD (future restricted d velopme t d1str ct) with
Inning umi.. 14inutes
lune 11,
Coordinator Mcconn stated a Hotion, should be made to direct
staff to, prepare information, to review and r axtaly the-
Landand lis ui di.ftg of the,Comprehensive Plan,
MOTION'by mmissioner Wire,, seconded by Commissioner Magnus WITION
to recommend that staff prepare ' information, 4 review, and
reanalyze the Land Use Guiding of the City, of Plymouth
Comprehensive Plan for this neighborhood.
VOOIt , inmmissiun r Stu berg N * iiQcarries.g i CARRIED,
ission r Stvlberg stated he co t urrt d with ,the Guide:
Pian as it t today.
Chairman Steigerwald verified that the area of concern is
south of County'Paad 15 and west of County Road 61. ii
Mr. Weasole inquired, iF this would delay his application.
was assured this was not aseo r. 1 onsol stated be
understands the neighbors" bi:tt rness with the problems
caused by the Carlson developments.,'
hairman toi.g rwal i int*,oduoad the request v Prudential
Insurance, Company of America- and requested an overview of
RUDWTIAL N$URA
C-OMPANYIPUD PLAN
the May 221, 1986 Planning Staff Report by CoordinatorAW-.NDHENTAND, SITE
Mc'Cn - 6606
Chairman Steigerwald introdu ddo w z (if Prudential; `
and, Mr. far ogel, Ariohit. Mr* Vogel presented their.
proposal and explained ' the bull11R, type,, screening' and
landscaping.
Commissioner Magnus inquired if they were proposing a
contrasting . colored band around; the building.* Mr, Vogel
answered affirmatively.,, Commissioner Magnus :suggested that
perhaps , the calor should blend rather than e0otrast., Mr.
P ntz: stated they do not I
feel this istori r t rasting and
I
adds building interest; however, Mr. Pert'? fir. Vogel'
stated that the actual colors have not" t ii dot mind at
this time,
Mrr. Wentz stated they aro looking at the overall building
types in the Northwest Business. Campus and aunt conti.nui,ty,
Commissione 14agnus, inquired about the lighting plass. Mr4
Vo-gel explained, they will hada the source of the :light
ixtur s and glare will be, reduosd so as not to impact the
page i 117
Commission Hinut
Oune 1986
thaIrman ` i 'r a.ld stated as they have heard from Mr
t ar n l, the-Harland lightinq is notas it should and
these ligating plans d be compared.
Vir zl arch Inquired It there are no people,in the building
at Harland from 8:00 P.M. t 6.00 A.H4, whjs this amount'
of lighting, e sary - € hairman Steig r, ald,rt the
problems,Nvith vandalism and safety, MW4 Ziebarth agreed
with this but,stated the lights could be subdued as they are
told to a# ordlna orcConn Mated, that the contractor
whQ Installed the lights may have -not been made aware of the
speo'Alf to I ighting plan. $he statedthe Harland Cheek
Company Avo Id be conta t d to sae if this problem can, be.
resolved
Mr. Pentz In gird if the submission, of mor ` detail -led
l htl , In rmat:i n wi .. delay this oject,, Chairman,
Stelgerwald stated tela *old not be the oases but staff i
directed to tookat more, information :relatlng to the
lighting for this proposal and for tete area of ti-tNorthwest
Basin-Busioell s Campus that is near 'residential property
MOTION by vil zon r Vire, ,seconded o-mmission r Plu ka N V
to recommend a re a r the PUSPlan Amendment and Site
Plan for Prudent LaI Insuraric Company, subject to the
conditions a li t d .n the May , 198 ann n aff
cora
Commissioner Plufka requested staff keep tete Commission
Informed o f the steps o be taken to subdue parking iot.
lighting in this area.
M3TION , Commissioner aqn ,, seconded om , loner Wire MOTION
to AMEND the MAIN, NOTION to, add a coridit on
I
that tate.
contrasting, n band of color on time bul Idinq ',Will Vie- a
narrower design,
Roll Call Vote- on the Amendment to, the Notion,, Z Aves.,. VOTE 09 AW-HOWENT
Chairman t l rwa, d) Coniiissioners , r # lufkal and WNL A1L
ava a1 `all.
o,11 Call Vote on Main go on e 140TIONN tarried. TE . Oar MAIN MOTION
MOT.l q
Planning mmion Minutes
W BUSINESS
Site Plan for Robert Vetter t .ohnson Co nstrUc t -iof), 30MISOM CONS".
Company for an approximate ,,"9 0 c t'. o war house STE PLAN (86053)
ccl I ity at 1" 11 16th Avenue North approved the Cancent
Aqenda.
VIOTTON by Co -1 Pauba" seconded by commis XMION TO APPROW,
VOTE 5 dyes. NOTIOR carried. VOTE - MOTION `ION CARRIED
S5
Chairman Steloerwald i tr d d the reOuest 'John Duffy MRK DUFFY
for Site an .end Variances c r the r truot n an PLAN AND,
g X - immission con, Idered this VARIANCES ($61M)
request at the May, 14, 1986 meeting and deferred, actlO with
irclot 1011 for re-dl-siqn. Reading of the May Z, 19$6 a -
nin Staff Report was waNed,
Chairman t r d c ds 'John who revieiy
ed CowoissionorWireg kd tnat, Mr. his
1)uffy ()Int out the specific ehdnqe,,s made from Cum ls Ion
der t.fon. Mr* Duffy stated the buildinq haseen rotated
somewhat to reduce the setback variance,. and the arki q
variance has been ' reduced. He reviewed the plan and
v rt ao * Commisaioner Wire Inquired if they had
cod, id r ` reducing thesize, o ; the building,' ttr. UUTT7
d'they do,,not Feel this,building, , excessive and 1
designed to east the tenaift needs., He stated the number of
parking spaces required by t , City are not needed by the
t nant t howevert the on-site parkinq Is designed to meet
the Ordinance standerds,
The Commission. . nqui.r d what percentagethe parking r l
be utilized., Mrs Duffy stated there will e two tenant n
the building, Oris* tenant will use staff. t , the other
tenants 15 stabs, and guest pdrktnq Is not a larqe need»
Coordinator Ncoon stated the petitioner was advised of the
Op t t reduce the size of the utldin and that the 1981,
approvals for this site % r ihle aid realistic. She
statedsmall property rld t u,i dinq & heldtatedjthi
yya
400 yy#11no th.e dimk:*nns .
In response to questions from the Corm sort, Mr. Duffy
ra or- stated he contactedted the Minnesota Department of Transpor-
t t on (Mfor their piatonon thea fLon of r-ight- tation
of-way. They stated there, was little Ohanoe of them givit1q,
f
r
G
1ge
1", 986
iup anyright-of wuntil the traffic oirculation needs for
this =re=rea are COOT i"med* City, n or Co, I d b e rq concurred
stat u it oyyan be- eco that'! the State l iv k
4„Rii F ds y `A% —FSC" ?i bd 4F F ' V X1111,.` VXAA F rxill i 'M1+F $ 1.fiir& #kT%b `
construction c Improvement eoi ons.
WTION by Commissioner Wire, seconded by Cormissioner MOTION TO APPROVE
Stulberg, to recommend approval for tete S1 to n and ktari-
ances, for uffy. The variances are approved n the
basis that the ioner, has made reasonable efforts, to
reduce the var liance request,.,, as directed,-' The
recommendation Is meds subject, to- he conditions as Jsted,
I the May U, 198 staff report.
Roll Al Vote. 6 Ayes., MOTION carriLed.VOT MOTION CAME
OTHER 13USIWSS
Coordinator Mtrt Inquired-, whother thert Nye.r e schedul"ing
Iproblems for any of the upcoMing meeting dates Commis-
sioner Wire stated he will be absent f rom,e, meetinq
3une 1986 Commissioner Stulber stated fie would
lite. It %as, the oonsen t s of h mi ion, to change the
first. Irkeeting date In luly to f dar I u , J 5
s ora dum-111 be sent to e c% Commissioner iiiind the
of this, Chanqe.
The meeting dc - urn t 9 -*35 P.