HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 05-28-1969R V 1969
ragaar Meeting Or the -PI&Ming Go=issioxx was called to o er by Chairman, %an
ut 8100 p.m.
1'res ztr Ch=4 gang Co=issioners Chapmaa, afne, Redtke, Ki rchoff`, rosk a, Pollock and i'rel*er.
of the r6 (uA a eetipg° of i' archx , 19 9, reVlaj meetltg of Apr1l 301969andSpecialkoetingofMar11;., 1`9692 approves detorred, to special mee'clofAwoU, 1969.
Pu IC'.
Ohm. F- an opened a -Pubs,'c k€wring to consider, xeno ng A,rom R-0 to R-- a C,LG
Property, as describedbed ixt tho Notice of Hearing and I oca ea :in the ioaxsw uxf. Co'
vicini
pl arxi tg Comlssioa Xllnu s - 6 page 2.
to get ApproVal of the preliminary plat before we cm grant the rezollijkgr requested
aIYz tiny page. looked at this plat a -ad we .fee: that we need, some. more time to
azn a?. ze -he zentire plan. P,-Irhaps at: our next zeet: Ft wec€il ;Ave a recon. aeudatiom I
on both the preliminary plat arad the rezorOng. Discussion wan held on the streets,
the proposed layout thO Ssrvf.ce station, the azatioipated type of businesses and
the laiA omers i.p.b Camra.; Egan stated that he thm ht there were enou questions
that they ,could nit answer all of thea* at this time. Rearing closed at 8-/+5 p.m,
by Com.. 12ol.l.ock that these be roferred to both the. I'l atti ng t'or rrittee and
th$ or~,tng U, Shea Com. Trekker seconded,.. notion " passed a unamitous aye 'rote.
GhmnA Egan opened a public hearing to censider rezonimg from R--0 and PX; RVOj; „IIL-1 to 1-1, 1-2 and IL4 on property in the vioinity south or tiL"'i 3' i
p forth ,f Go. Rd. 6 and. East of Niagara T a ae and West of NO. OF CO.IiD-AFirbrooktame.: 't. jar, Freund appeared .for the petitioners,,"T OF NIAG. . llan*aar bsrgly s} owed the people the area on the reap and explained MOT OF VERT` OOX
the deuotation tags Viae colors. Mr. Freund explained Vao plv.,zs for PKITIONERS Li HOWthedevelopmentofkheentiretractandpres(inted drawings to illus- & FWJ101Dtratohispresentation. He stated in part. Haat their plan follows -theplfuaofMidwest91sttotheletterlie; shoved where they propose ACTION P, MUM TOtolocateoneservicestation. one Testaurant and one motor ian Re 'CO TTEEdolloptedeplainl.zag `the l ocat ori of the vinage property and whir SEE pAOR 5. th.uy chose the ? z0"Ing in that area., Questions were asked ofMgr, yr e=1 by the Co tissioners as to pazt;icular zoning in particui, rareas. Also the traffic patters and the ti zixag of the upgrading ofthestreetsespeciallyFernbrookandthedemandforsailtiesetc.,
Opponents appeawinga Mr. Chester Logai), 15004, Gob Rd. 6., 1 -X * .;, 14912, Go. Rd. 6 who stated his pl.aco of residence in relation totheproposedsiteandgiest,oned the drainage problem. He o'ca%Ctcd to Cho ehangesforsevererrea.scns that the people in his area have everything to lose and nothingtogain,. Ahe„, are cauent in a squeeze between the high de.u,,t r and Vo. Rd. 6. He also va S 00'IcOrnod about the heavily wooded area which he thinks is among one ofthemostbeautifulinllymouth, He as.Led the Fl anning Ooaamis3lon to coarse out andlookatthearea..
Mr.. pinus Ouggisberg 14909 -Co. lid. 6, appeaxed stating his concert ab,,Itt the valueofthy. proporty .4f it is rezoaed, The six stox apartment will rise shamed" atelybehindourlotline. Discuss;%, on whether there would be assurance that this areadiscussedasB --I+ would rema tn as p?axmed«
Mr. Chester Logan, 15 704 Co. ,Rd. 61 Aipported ttze corxients of the other Fgntlemeaandaddedthathewasconcernedthattheer* IvIxe plan. wo:rle: 1a 4 oerried out.
Mr., Des Ras oba, 1:4816 Co. Rd. 6, was concerno,
road c% drai4:age
about bu."andfezdng placing of the
x. DOA begin4 14,520 G 17th. Ave., No conct.,,,ned about streets and buff er zones,
Ohm. 'an staffed in part tri he was certain that a decisioneision coul,a be reacheduUthismesting. Adiscussion followed on some assurance to the neighbors as toalaybuildiniaisgoinginrightontheendoftheirproperty. Hearing closed at045P. al"11
sa.
hmEgrui operisd a public hearing at 9:4 ,m to consider rezoning z MONING
from 0 to 1-.2 en. groporty asdeacribed in the, e t ar Rfearlug and HWY. 101 A CO. Fu').
located in the vicinity of State Ni& --Way No. 101 ana "INvuty fed b. iM,` & 001MA I,
rir. Tom Dougherty =d 1%Z, Kennetbamhicbe appeared foT,the. p,.Rtj41,jcnea%s.
1111r. Dougherty spoke aboutthe previous petition and the reductitc:.j is IC1',""'O.4 "IMIED
si,Ze Of the pro.osed buil,ding.. 0h=. %an. Fainted mt the site plrna and
the oomdssionls rico=aendation a:Zter the seac rid public hearing for 1vls
Fa tisk ar gropertty. The guide plan, was Plan - i jl t4 rye :zaz r;ig ajo i
WY. 1€1 and Co. 1d. 6 and: on to the church, property and allowing far
to develop in the remain g property
I)PPOnents* C`h=- Egan stated, it part; that we coiald go back and of a all the reasons
brought lipft)r and against the developmel. t but k eca sae there are more 1;ablia hearingshohoped, :hat the oomneatts could 'ba brief.
lir. Edgard b3.at°ma, 1325 tiiakv V4 ew Laney reaffi ed ilio p e,v .ous posItion.
fir. 0ordon Cttem appeared repre 5enting the arposition arc: asked for a show of hands
to reiterate what, O.,eyhad sa:d. hem"tare to s ouw they stay opposed. About 15 hands
were, raised.. Rearing cjosed, at, 9:5 p.m
MOTICH y Coma. Hedtke_ tto,dscy the .resazaing a$ the praponentt has reque,tted. Secondedb
by Com. «a ner. nh=. spoke aabot t t ao time spent studying the area and ad .ptinr
i
the -fide Plat. Motion passed by a u -.lam, ro''us aye vete.
hr.u.: Egon opened a public hearing at 9157 p.m. to ccansider rezoning 1t' UZOINING
from >r'...C3 to '16-3 ope3rty in, the vicinity (-if Dass Lake. Road ansa. Co. Fro,..
10. Mr. ha.rlow ,eterson BASS IAKEROS
appeared for the petitioner. He proposed Co.-RD.10
a -kpbrlor 400 station at Zachary Lam and 1 o. Rd. 10. Trier a are Hh` ITT L. PE` ET -SON
scsme other' plans being dz,-a gym. for t1aat whole are:j but at tali$ time,
we have not Ott -°n all the people together. Chea. questioned fir. ACTIONt Dr,a z;i
I etAlrsoa ah -,at a tim schcadile orany plain or the development of SE4 PAG 5
star E'u ts. Tanner hergly stated , hat in theirlast Lr'
1oniritg Committ:)eeetingthy:;. i7lan was not available ata therotore he had not seen its
prponen is NOne- Hearing Wlos at 1f e 0 ,,
Oh:, . X -aa opened a public hearing at 10103 to Con-ider rezoning, f'Ccx rO to !L4, on as described liear
E- REZONING
property in the: INatice of ITh AVS. INOti AND
and 1,00z—ted ;zit the vicinity of 18th xhve e Month and Forest ViewFGMTItane. Kr. Harry Deziel VTL19 LANE.
appeared for the Petitioners. Also Mr. tan, Bopezwk. lira Deziel :sta-red tFaat he thouglat they plans were pretty
OSCAR O NES, FRED
41NES 4 UNITED LANDs,sl .Oxplana.tory. Mr. Sopr mak expressed that the development will depend
on Vater, and that they h,, ve the financ:rg arranged for, Djisctassiou A TlaN: JE ERRED F R
as head On access and traffic a.,.d that our engineer should be FURMER STUDY
included in diScv.-s .ons on the situation. Chmn. Egan sta tad in, sm F'AGE 6
part that unere are a lot of details to hark out so th&A, there will
not be a1 lot of delays. A meeting, sat up between Planner x`-)rgiY,
and our ginaer and €a Member of. the zonJing comit°teapR+ g3 r,*,ii:..t... (t i l af rn professional Statusf3I1d iJ 4>'x 't 5f t67d E3 kl i Li 4e C .
POnG ii s. ^.tJ.. Warrenell hG..4tiA3an spea:dng separatefrsn the Gamission. 1 am an
officer in Vae Fest! A:ed,a ajne Laino 'Co=- unity Club and our only, feeling, on, it is wo
do not believe that the traffic shoule go out 18th or P'orestview.
n aam # esi sti- Xnutes pecia MaetiY- - X 191 69 4
Basica' tt:e dustri.aldart. Thero were no apparent pj oble s SOUTH OF 55,, NORTH
area ti'a minds: 01' the Co :ssion members. O -P Cts. 61 FAST OF 1+94•
Com. irohorr queatioaed the medium. density between Co. 15 =d the 11OU N OF NO. 6, VIrailroadtracks., 'Re' would not like to ,gee Pernbrook contimxe down WEA OF X94andori: ss the railroadroad txaacka sand suggested that tine area be deft aarami.ly.
XOTIOX B3". iICS . yIRCHO.,pI %f?Ei} i? tit , HEME TO RECM-IM THE IC,DaXA'TION CSEF'' 3CC} od " C ' .Ck 7 `R u X Piscussion followed on the motion andOilt»ae Interchata5-e opt" 494 and Co. 1.5. Chinn. questioned as to whether that stripOflandcouldbedevelopedmedau-aa density. *- Pei,ckert Suggested. orienting thi; awaay .prom Fer;LbrOok and toward Harbor Lane. 'axe open strip along the East sideofHarr !bane. The buildi ,s would be oriented toward Ferbrook and loaking towardthehcPkaaont%$ fest side of Harbor Lane. The patron was voted on and wasdefeatedwithCom.. irchaff voting aye and eve`-yone else `roting nays i
di,-scussf.on Was held on the park along the freeway with Flrannex 31'i T OFNCt,6 ANI) 50r, explaining that in ns -V eases: planners encourage parks on tht`t ' 0 edge of free iaye. ` ere were ,no more questions.
Chinn. %381 suggested that the p 6, the triangle formedSO CTS NO. 6 y x3taaxv a at No. , bay the railroad tracks and No. 6.., Com., Xroskin oin:ted out that EAST OF 494there: is siaagle t amily to the Southeast, Beacon sights area is atthenortherlyenjandsandw,10hed in between, is 'high density. It. isaIrt,a.dy zoned industrial, 1=r. PAckeru stated 3n part that the railroad tracksarethemostlogical; division with light industrial south of the tracks. if theamecharacteriscaarrielthroughfromeYom' - xt will be taken care of, ;« ked for ' fth
any other points .for direction in this area and stated that the Co missionhasalette:tTfrom Prograanaed Land in regard to zoning is the area. The, -Lastpaxagxephoftheletterisaafo-uows:
Ove respeotfull.y request e oi` plCossian
that the Village y aout h Council and planningin, consul:tatioza with its planners., revi8w the ComprehensiveI?evelopmsnt Plan., reconsider the ossa proposed for air64acre tract9 modifyitbyolimi,nating the Park area, to the West Of the two ponds bordering Beacon Hei'giatsandprovideforhighdensityusesuitableforthreestoryapartmentdevelopmentina20acrestripbetweenthemedium €aensity residenti a1 to the East, and
liglo
industrial. area to the West." ht
This was disoussed as to where to terjUnaate the Beacon Heights area with Mr. pe ckertstaati.nta that the swamp area is the natural, termination point for the area;. Cium. man aaked plainer far his opinion to which lair. Eergly replif.,A that they were oftheyfeelingthattheneighborhoodshouldbeextendedsomewhattothewastwiththan, buffering toward Xen um., He explained, that the land is .interestim and that wa haveaprettystrongstartofasneighborhoodhereandwehavethedevelopmentofthe; neighborhood piL jected west in the plats we have had presented. .A disa;tssi.on followedMtheindustrialarea. Some of 'tine coax ssionexs were botiaared by industrial in thearea... 'The roadways were also discussed.
MYTIOIN BY 0CM1. 1-014LOM TO ADCFAi I-Cj By Cob,. iscasNion an the motion followed with the Motion being amended to change thegeneralindustrial. to l.,iCht inaustrial.. Motion passed as a:.iended by six ay;M vote. with Chun,, %-tm votin nay,;
Meeting adjourned by motion at 11445 pm.
P: ar g Co ;fission Ydnutea -- 5/28/69 ;- 4
has gathered. this co,- -A ttee will be charged with _1 responsibility of furni to ingthis .ea soon as possible with are help of, the planner and the ergineer. Mr. 4i dseth
Vas sc concerned 14th cont Luing the comprehexisive . th had be an on the
easter edge of the Village, Coxa. Xroskia stated th.st. he had gotten the topographystudysotheycouadgoaheadwiththestudy.
Chinn. gx reported `on his meeting with, `1,1r. Baratz. This would probah'l-y Rkr:
x
OLLIE
be ,rrred until alter the public hearing on the East Modica.ns Lake isAVu,i Z
StWdy, ACTION DEFMOW.
Planner Rergly reported on Creentreo earth ,h ich had been dalorred at R& BOAT
the April, ;30th xeeti .. he stated that any plats that we got in vi.11, tie GUL:IC' N,
in with other areas. Alsc what their revisions Mould concur: with our G.RMFREE NOIRTH
suggestions. Discussion on tae location of 'he collector streets.., Platxner Bergly stated t tat he ).ought it, oculc. go to the. Council In. ita ACTION.- AFF1,0VED
revised s" ate.
fOTICX by Con. Pollock that the prelimir:ary plat be approved subject to the bra root
right of way .for s street and also more direct access through the plat by a B street
Emd culwa.-saccing street. Com. Chapzact seconded. Motion passed by a unAminoueayeGrote,
CLmn. Eg z requested the Co nission ` o hold a Special 1loeting ou June 111 1969) rat. S;CO p.m.
N N
Chmn. Egan named three committees, tuo standing cormittees. and one spacial corgi ttee..
Spacial Judy of o-ttr thoroughfare s stem 1%a I CCbm. Pollock ' a m. afner, hran., tom. Chapman and
andirg 0-mitteo cn Zoning, Com.. Nedtke., Chmn., Com. Prekker,; Co-Chmn. and Cori. dafnex .
Standing Corazattee an platting, Com. Pollocx, Chinn., Corn. Xro k.n and. Com, Chapman.
The CoMmiss an, then returned to discuss some of the public hearings that had bsenheldearlier. She following Faction was taken:
It'OTION by Com. Chapman to refer to committee. the zoning changes from. R_Q and R_ltoB-3, 1-11t I-2 and on property in the vicinity south of Nig;njjay No 55, NorahofCo.. Rd. 6 and Eastof Via ara ,Lane =d Vest of Fernbroo;k Lana-'etitio ersGeo. C. holm,, Lee-o:Lm 1,.Itg o. and Gary x'r eundGontpany-„ Cora. ,oedtkeseconded. t passed by a unaminous aye
d
o
eattd
development
MOTION By Com. Redtke to deny rezottjn,; • from ILO, to 1-2 on property as described intheNoticeorRetringandlocatedinthevicinitycfBassLakeRoadacidCo. Rd 10, Petitioner - hewtl tt L. Peterson, becauso it does not conform to the current om-
prehensi Fe plata. Cox.. polloek Seco. ded. otion passed by a unam i.nous Ye vote,,.
MOTIONT by Com. Haener uh t we Ind%icale gene al Approval of t o gl n as abtn adUtzpxpert' ,',n the v c zai y lthve:zuaarth anccxest ler e F scarmaxedones, uteri Land near onestutsubjecttofurtherstudy- by the l,anner on accessnotanlytothat, particular plat br,-" other plats. l=otion died for lack of second.
Planning Co mission Minutes - /28/69 Fa,::e 6.
MOTION by Com. ChFapm= that the developer (scot- Junes., Fred +ones, United Laud1nr, } get together with the Planner for furthher studyregarding site plan an
circulav oq as it Seems to go along, with the ode plan Cora., Prekker 'seconded, Motion, pawse4 by uuaminous aye, vote.
Meeting a4iourled at 12=37 a.m.
Respectfully-ubmjtted.,
Ckamna lannin_g Corrmassion
teetg
Recording r.
i