HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlanning Commission Minutes 01-12-1967Nf" A.&..V
w^
xM'4 rila a.f f,ar. a l.t%A:a st
a Wes TM.`)Iled o 44rd,-i-yam .. -
1M. Thore r re no ..}enda items- for the w oama
t", s'+ '',iit'# a L "w: I ;S p 0 )issio1nor E",uflp d, CaNrwiaU$,11after,
i Ohhoff and WillIenbring..
0",i iosionara AP-4t ce, Z(indset;j and Fotersca#
a)ticxq by t`a: Ti`r s, a" ,. "",%*2*i: t #. ;ml" ftd. by, Co.'i°. +k'.ta"ty.lto a per, ortitrhe
i4i tCs Of tat x"''. oe t3;:rq of Deeemtsr 13, 1966. Z;*otAte a passed
y all ' -.otalver;, ;,.resent voting ayo#
2; h'earin t consider 4" 1 21' 0 "rc'!"iza
014$;'i .c,uticn '.I#O.M X-sidtMtial u)POa a i eloP: tint to ndust "ia for
v."" at 10 RR}}ltr s aa 112- acrit-ei n. "the Dyo.
ye129' . ,
06 (Notiyc
le^`} ''`
earing tT 4 2
Line d.
l.ar ry ari'iffi#.xi !or ilrx ai:. atI.ia'"ebaker orp-
ration. rovosodk use - plc'c V t _"nd office facilities for the :?'s'1mfoG` ure
el,oc rical-;QilOruto s and other , r ztwIvs.,
Til .otants ;, Larry riftPith s, o s in favor )f the prod used ' r
v`esreZr-, Bcri3on and M.41vcas, fee Ci`x"£.er8'.,
of the proIVerty, end R6,4h rt -tts en, Qa4A r e resentrative, It rds
adicf_t=gid t4at x. i,%Ilb, rg of IWl,lserC, trifgo, Co., adjacent north-
erly proterty ovner, ras in pit endtnoe and in favor of the propoavi.
It ;e Q4 brdu,.Iht out in discussion t.3 t access to the property r ould
bz froom $ th e. tWld u. d. 18 6.1d that construction dates
huvko nest yet been wtabl; i shod
e 4earin-"' '.as dealQred closed at 3= 0 ,P.r ..
j w :m. ,pi le ;sarin;, O*n:.m, or the Larking Committee, rr.,;avrted that the
3:'a;oomi.ertdo4t apnxr ,!l ` t to roque tQ, rozL;aing 'eariui1ngen`
u n pati s Ra,;t ary access, rhieh q zestiHon had been anar"e-red in the Hearing.
by v=. Willenb ink, aecoad by C=4 i'aafner, to recommend re•-
0nirZ 11 s dt l tr al, »3 Pet t'iszed «nor Ox'1a`a?--Studebeaka 'Q'oi`pC1rotion' , INMSTRIAL CNINq
tho PrOP"Orty as described in the '"oticc of Hearing and located south ;T 49T.Ii & I
the, Soo Line 'Tracks at Co. Rd. 11,1. a,'orion passed by all 10,ornatisalohers :XZR *
resent ,tin; uye.
It oza d susai on that the aide lan" indicates in- It ,ras rp; i
dus,',Xtal use for the urea and that the Pl.nans,ng o.,,ssion had re-
vi usly r,_CIO 3 ed inaustr ai re onin5 oOL the property as requested
y )-:e ason 2- ud 2v ns, 4t tl,: „caj %tim- no se-eeifics r#'.t,e proseated.
n.. ,xaa opened a : Ublic llsarlr._" to consider the preliwinary, plan R"4: Z7
ci.at of lnduatri.al . &rk 494 bein8 t1 at part o. th l S"N Z V, 49
Ond the xNNV4 or the «a44 of 4,oc. 2_'2'_ili5R22 lying, Southerly Of State
Hwy. 5.5 and "Oe3te a.y o." Intersto e 94 tevol.opers - Fran1C W.
eUa a n -4nd 1 titer Zuiipev.
e r l n:inx y i,.Wt :.:i*gid history z.re retieved with -ruce lull.*y,
ine+ar armor tae The Flearing vias declared cloyed at 5':45 -m—
h+-n« z ru crred the plat to he Pint V0onz ttee for study and ,reg
u1951 - fA
gar x.
ya
0t,'CXd t- idthh- '' trusts tad ossilt . re- e- u:
55y LT iip
qq3`
forfo i+ai'w+'n 'u o ral. roo inrs.M l.J a'i:
Z er 3 mny' N crb Schaper, Schaper RB:
fo.7. o.IA-t K., ivo - ,4. prq sed industrial ...Yr L}:".aL. of part CYi! A:TC e't
1 tE: "ed ad' Garvey N* . 921. slrnpnrty located sout
Off` ".;ruI.-un Zt e , r: st of Co., IC, IC,, and north o.0 Ply—,,cute Avemue.
nd at d they wotild ivldIng the a Prox. qS scres ia 0
r, a. T"tuestioziel Via poasitle exte aaL)n of Zlym>kk.lth Weixe from
0. i'4. l-x to . S'ore Delve and yore advised by the
t-he ' TM=aa Petition for such axteasiozl*. Were advised ti: p ')teed ;lith
the 4 d.zza4a:Arator ar4d A«tt nOY as to Platting and other, rsgarer nts.
it t V"On'ni ttee edvxsnd that the scheduled site inspection of the l0,MV:; ,,
rt`3 s'+ t' ii1t X .%s t3Gt i d3a snaed out'*.$>• s
w4, 3'r blr Qn h!:! #10 P'M elimia arJ , Z k.,'aGts Fare defeii$i*.Aed u:itil Cal ee aiex. 4F ICY? r-AS./.1'Gi-% ® A4'"5IC.
repreaeztinS L:, HaT, re-subnitted the Starling Tflo f
I:rzot Ic"t 4 A/t x rc-d,X` wi of the Oul-de-aaa nccoCtd'3,€,may to Bn. tr or
ae trc: a r c ..e ad t z s ;s per let ter o . e.e e'r 1?} 1900..
advised they hL4 nom contacted by xN*ei1. $,, q;U
C..
b e"
Vi Y} ht("y'YFl>' { re ki \'\'y 9 M a report .C.o a submitted 0,0 {y *p ± a+{ Y ri+li Ltit 4 brd F.W .4M Afi J. t,n. yL ii G iA1 r(Mar 4'v.J' 'J M`YS If A+a4?i `iwM V A.a MSF W .4f SeMttC4,ed o then
r<t. ` k i r °l :at north of "c . d,. 9. Vuns de Tatz en "Xf t;1e roposal
deferral until .uhtrae.r i oatea; by tie petitieaer.
s' r I nw:KtwxY+.xt++++..r.r•.
Mthat m1. ,. r1ia, lv:'.,a re,j:eA thhe u::°,i';.$°.. .Y,+ .Wa. re-,riww he 01 rc Susi 4 ice:
g'q`pyy ##t .. M-r ., ,$ CC y."'f +j+'3[C WWyy$ .+yyryyyy yy au ty$ y yy 4+y t^ n,,ee^$-C.
CC
C }+}+ y Li"MG.7JwkiL'nct Nw q3 y4,# ar.. w{.,y.<i;. Re-I.:$saa5,+t'x..Vlas Tide..' :roeeYrtires fo*Xt the attin
01.Lax..N! 3 wa+'rx Vill.a,;e A.ii; x:'l«. ov$F.t l
ijiiet fo"+e Jii wz Z'A4I,M-'h 4G t'.^.Ld V+epu4"
qq
SkMaC+l Utd
Pose ;Tlf final *yc4.7nda3 ions on hp *Zyopoed y;,"-:try26
r
Crw'#A .:JtdL tid{r.{ ZL Li'Ce4`G.1 kAnd `s arzr+C edM the meting, was td jcu.k nen at J.ai:IG i .wr[•.
OF "M9 v'G-ixiIMM
1. The "Proposed" `oninala map and the 11 on. prehonsive Gu, le i'lantt Jna the
amount of Propertg shovn lndu trialIj or COMMoroir.lLy, zoned on and
in relation to the
10 xd anta ou ter d:ra Zvantnr,00 Cid' zoning beforo rezontnry in 3."Qqtaortt &
for n opeoifie uca,
3. 'Strip 7onint) vs cluster development of industrial and commercial areas.
The --0 zoning olegsifjcation. It Vao hzroup ht out by the Planhin.;,
COMMinCien th t tho point of disapTeoment on the "Proposed Zoning Qxd inanco", rasuliixtr in a 4 to J vote for recd t orxdod approval, was tba
R-0 1=ifi, 1cati.on r irtority and aSor t;y repaxto to ba praaot yon
a•, t«. Pc l r ee ting.
The Attorney oarmented that from a logal standpoint they "Proposed Zoning
rd', aancu,a was well w-ritten. lie su6*j.€ao 4ed tea title 11111;,mouth Zoning Ordin-
ancol't tt4 brourht up a few points for consideration for chango ingludiia ; the
hof-, ltion of ?n Accessory "ilk lding Cubdiv. 2,, F"alre ?y, and the on.ng o
land undor Nbdiy. , , Vu lure Annexation, ?aj,:,e 10.
r ft..vazuux,x.<r•a'_Yk#nYx+w+ua..u+rr.«x+k#n.K.q '+.skws+.ay`+•-'.ar?.»wbr.:... .. . w w - . d _hi++a. ww.e,.ewalmr+'N'e<nw{:1ivw.o-.W?S+.Mf!*mbf. -
ori` t:ao x`a,l..,,r, Rva'x'tll and the "t:irorty Hek- )rtn on the "Proposed
0%:"Ap- O di n: well wore p-ros', " t lyy7' io dent r C *'"a C1rJ ead h}oy i+ r,,,-In .,t+n E
w.tsk 11, V
k.?.
j" Xa. -'Oad ;;` r` vt3. aw w ». s a F r,.. 7 t t,ty e;e .
tion. `,on q" ze. twon by 1 Mayor. t Atucr~n t)y A4t ^ t crx n,.,,Ls c ro t..at the a `da lot a. 0a, nc,,UAIa ;ion vould 3r
Ae cG:.,l: t`3 a3 rt,,rt ef a general elan for thf3 orderly +Cevelop, ;ent Of
e", k 3
m 1'urther c-div .z-C tht-t, aay C'.han,—!o Get =i ng .requires a votev
c-ti* 4i o canon recelt3t +;ata ' !ar- it q* 04 nt t ¢ t cutY , "'h ,#. nraan. o a 33.t>n. oin,ra. c that
it the KR-C "10o 3ifioauion t,s noluded in 'he ily=uth `bo ra; as
belly adopt id, the iCrdinance should be :ori ar,ed to the County %*per,,rk)or of
aye"ears u"cr c Sze cle.:°a x a: cl' a.aver, tax rate for t«e lands included in the
a:wiic 'atian lso sae:rted: 1 cierxi„ the to"al Ordinance :ba
3ticticlll
Ota ito 2.) awm j"1' ; € the text and tht- zon nit classifications
h p,.e a"e'tic 311' bo ogre rE.vj , t"'b the zoning. ma Cpo F'`'y} s" !,a y r tot pointedr1M34sTYAo `< i ri. #µ,Vi V. 4t .e :.b map- 4N AJ..,.s yf.'a yJ i.nV Y i! pj} yy}}
ryry
scut thAt tiro s,y0 G,
l
pay alfica t{a9
on
yayo the s=M, yas any
op'
yhe+
y `
ylynr ifip(,n}ti ny
re
yt}
4ir- ir ro -. xnin-, in
hat
dr. Ewspec , vnd that it A w old Civ e.., pase,4 to. iL F1...Ga U.F Y'X b's 4
iF dCvC, F "'r v* zliy to detri?ncwntal to i,ho eW-ire Villatre.. It %jus brau!x,h,t Couto
and su4i ed up by k:ayor *taples thata l) Pereolat oa tfats asrecd°uirpd by
Ordinance 6-13 rill control. !rha:e ctos oola ron't Vora; and e6nitar s?r'er
in not aIv" lE?:1 Q o 2)a3: ' n."i37 iiia + i i t" i:z` services 7 rbC "i nek€cil "6aeihili ty may
r moil ccatrol devolop-=qt cf ea area. SPhe .-0 District to b! furtha
oonsidore . or the »1 in,le VCI-ill Residence District and the ane acre
lct urF °t:.':zl ti an led to conc.Itv,%,oa that cora deretion s ho 4 we given to
drop the 0,18''lir cati on. i aa Zlennins, 'Oonwtl Cant edvi ed that the 18 3siff
ca- tion '4`dn`i' Aot feasihlu or "nto.dea for Ocie ate ' yp,-.' mooning V1hich =tld
develop privately by who use of, re",,triwt,ve coGre narits.
t oksy rav
icLw ,}p
V r[esse{d { tn z zypy t h"
a y 4-
j.
0 /
yand
w R- I Glasaiific a tionoy,{ }
u
y.
a
ytoy the
R- included
Y A+Aya W.^ an..".x°il '91"a%.#4ieiS,NL, A±€iatr ikF Zi 6+%ka a.S V t dW 1i U Si A e #f del sJ #iii $SJ P`4Y;1
J 1. ``' `" 43 - private awi=iriq p ocln not required to
be in :_tsilcatac naether oeid#§
nceDistricts, in ce -L5, 4u4b 1. 4, eft. l nak ,.Ild read acce, tatle ryr V
fenco in the -P iiesi onco
w`6:ts c fYAtiel. i?ae.^ a.iaih 4^.]:d.Ls'sdi.i' w.:.. t°d.:x
9;16
i...'-Nti"..Y.a 4}+9:.yy yi M*Y4a`.c., id .:.Y.}
Ls,
iIhw`» {
L«°
a o["1 2
49r
Rx+yy.. ot.j 00YM+ L.
ia`
a`
y8b
a'
µ!
e
c4x$. t"'.
0ap',
GB
AtxFx ".
r1l8`
ro"'.
t1tl. rc1wri+o
rtYa #=
tVkywi!A.^\."gdj.
s
ll
xnzAivlop
y}p!w F4q-na of ho C
nw micl: u-n roe,on+- r ,, kio
Item=
di
ks
tu+ur^ o
nooalin" t q R Ye. y-s,S - 1 Y6 `4 +V
Awa wa y; , x;# $or ! +v zion for 35 foot front
yard k !+'a% W^K 1, t i-` n .l. now F-yS`a`t LY .: Lm"rl av Ey .f.+#. iii my". .i,. 4eM V
kSWCiS44 « a vt°. " .C1 `s.,Z'I.a.s"-'E'"«.` i'.''";.5'. r .Y;C4 r`t:i "`i`';": P>L?+*
orodl M root Z
otbao 217r,-o mo i f %'taiv,Iten 5 - nrovlloion for IONIC, fctotx * t lot ar Y :
tf n tl o z cA- -oma line. Mnro=nl roll., all C ural lm"nn pry?;:eat f4.vo:'
od 110 Plot nini,muzzi lot
iii .
Pt+To 1Y+ bi=l V. 7 amO.
44aty 1 #. eryj 34 Poi -o 19a ubi Vi. .on Unit
o, 2runte41-,.b4}n r"
i#
ollL1xv -,Ac.tio, of "ho zr'-Al4saaiz U10 -Zomen otr:Z,
pG
My#a Fol.# 1:10. P_ I llzm^_r Ps*ao..0onnuAAl i.ry 2JoSRtf.
rJnde ,
4t
ityt G' ,i .. of
s $+t y yy ++{ pl
m. {#
x y1.Ty^I. ra y
g..}.
1xC+yt»
y'
i,yy:
l..X't,,
r,.
y.
C+
r,
yt'kY Q4.t <.
o'
1p t4x5 -1. V. "+LP i.' 1, 7.it r5 'e% tit a44K:. d M+x'1Jfcrptk he 0.t.w.,tAVL 4f t..a.AI of ?
x+.
at<l ix t\
ar
iio i
x.j. JAI+,: ..`4Qi:4 z'ii. oil, to lam+ ,C.,. Ya 4+".AEa dig d '1yr - h P1"--. r -MMA
MA w Hca 0114 ; Mot 11 `f ;-Ve.. a`
tro
y ! x !-iX 4Ar., t. Y't`'-'E';r, ° • •, .. ,} tee. '> .: P"`t'"' ""'K r"tf."t' :'•'r'.t32 ""''E3 a':4' .t'i`p-»
R
ah,.
u. yxA't mra v.rtimionAJni3OtM" n (,x, Gam" :xnm t,n.on tau L%,r 't t..{.aa 1, tlh "` Norris, F . tYt4.2,k. A « Sf # • ds #. #Y i/i l .4 t.} t .tw.i.
7aa . t,i .t. LL Y'"S'Y !YY
rY1iYi.x4 lM+ F-4xW .. J YTd! V4i .ie4i! w$ \`..# i.J y!'.i..t.[,lb \i... t
iR n u'G` V':r:.i..':;t`. 4x:ti+ tI\.ii Y?.r'C`,t n: YC .dt :.° rr a i n g ;`-..i a i r Iza,
i.(, t, { y ''t +} Gi i"'x .h scih "Yi
I14 i.
ti`
Nttbo »'q+ .Ss .Z1,. au
elmi'+..,}
a. iT iMtwi o +..in{ j '
i.%^..{^.
pvy{-
Zi': fi1..
1+
pigF,. /i m +`4 w.•4 i.4 s.i+SaG S..a .il4 lA ..#d A
x'
tYi ..? S.• lot e *14-Ao •r•
Y,*/ •V la'.k'w: 1 :w:'i .lnk ;$x'4. a.x .s .4. it ,`..A. <+l SJei.0
w t. i. , ..! iunv, ::=r a.s. 47 L',
ov3n21coolr' =non ''Y' :<v `'s.m.o'.'o ,, .43" 11 ry) yY(+{ " rsl ,, tw.lr. u!3 .w h m+ 66. !%V .}. S. i.a t..1 k1 Y1.rla4
a r a v,10«Y.'}_.':%f"i : afa ° fOoit rii, 1he Zi-ot'xY#«4x,k:4."s.oc.1.
than. line, e4ilof not
m\
tt+s MhnA wx'•" i'a rIi
smy t,{ry° yoh acotl uY *mac ^
im'
Iy'Jkr 44
i:' T
p ,t y 04 aa:.r o, ?0- incv+.+`10 wR<o '
rovlvlont,.
yu'
t.%
yooyid. c.S.t.`<
a.
Y(,'i):it.
e
c.L'
A
p4:
a1. Y S '*'1 M +7 Y' r'1 'd` H tY ) 1 •, Y r•+ ,3
1 } mV}..
tw.i. i.t J la #a3"r.+. 3 '.. t.s$ S, <#8i. ,L n"3,4 r U\•r:+ i A4-k,+J V+g x o S..nd
f. yl- I. Tato nnin ' ^`f 1a!$-lF-lw-cnt ono„iiad
ondnolti^..
onm of a sop. rt to knot-
jon on To-mz to '.o bofo'o .:ocu3,on Iv, - :ctltiple Fcm:l
t rr
onco I!+!F ?MSuk 3 ... :>5W'flni V Ti,:%ot v.0 n :FV 4ada a6. A.'i+4 n .'w.Ecus o nhj'+Jttl e 011tma3,"a x.k toeiR'.
be 122rce or
Mori tAYeW !.t'dWNM vYlu:Y•a+k c:.:'n4t>L.bv 141^ .. . 4iw..scn
r:.. .... aotjgt i .Y R,- Two Varma, ResS.de aca District, and section 10 .- 13-4
Pzultiple
p'.. Family lieside;ie District of the O roposed Zoning CrdinOnee'a rare revie-
med vith embe, , , the Planning Commission present and the Planning
Consultant, Moms p,arti .rly discussed as n,as4».S further consideration and
changes de are &s
follows x3 4 0N 9 R-3 VIC FA.;C:LY RMMZ1104
DISTRICT aea 22, 20 Pt. 2 delete aA gra r-,
tam• r a s 23t Item (a) uAdOr rt;.- 2* .Su'Ix iV- 5 a. discussion of f'r'ont ysrd
depth feat. 1==721?'+' r.'Gt` second by `',r1.%stE,'eOPb or,' 50 root "G"'"`us 5 -
Staples, d"tit1.Q! yeC) 13at $1 th 35 fort aeptn as ;specified in the 'ropased "
tonin rd an: w 3 bti= rasaod by a three yea vote. Trustee Hs;,ren voted
nov. Z "o 223,, Pt. 6v Pub,,,iv. 5 -! =0211 by Trustea get,. necoad by :Fayar
m Stziplos to :spetAfy that a tqo fa i y &selling shall here a nAnizim
width of P%t loss then , feet at the "huilditg setback line. ,lotion passed
by a fo€tr yea
W44,ZRCf Z+:;teF
n .MOTw, 10,;R- to be Section 11-R MT11nZ VA:!ttY E-.V, V
1. 14a5a. 24, Subdiv. 2,t, 2 - V'O I by Aa"t+st333 Runner, second by Trusteeaa , to del..ta sn n :3 e. * X-Ot on passed by n three yea vote. ayor Staples abaaained
2. Rage 244 Subdiv, 31 rtaa,, 2
aso 26, a.toM (b) under Pt, 3j Subdiv. 5 » delete this pavagr ph.
4 Za cc, 206,
Item (2) under b)-5 should read s 200 sq., ft. per dwelling unit.,
age 28, ubdiv. 81 pt. 2 - include the regulation, to be item (d) haat all' uti.litios including Vire and telephone systems rays to be under +sand, endre-letter p ra6zephs (,d) and i
dvtAaax;.+..$^,..>;Ua +
r ,74, vection 16). His;guest- ion was in rem to the amerti ation
ohe Lae for eliminating aaon-coxiforming uees. Ho stated that this provisioz
i tlao proposed ordin oo h been uphold y pr y ,appro timatel;y or the r
omtstato omr;a decisiona and that there was no Minnesota deoisjtOns on this
Matter, Rni&t felt ,it was worth the chafes to have this provi ivil in
thO r t c1a, Re thouent that if it Wero Uphold at a later date Jkt trey d
to the VillaCmls .dva''-a ,-a to have it an the ordin=oa now.
tr' Letlor explained the prese-. V% siga C vdinauce w, -d explained the differomeas
both on it and the sib o aticans in the Proposed Zoning Orcli4auce, The
difference lies in the mora liberal sign size regmiations allowed by
preo-umt Win=ce in the areas zoned -Res-eutial--Open (R -C), The Vro-
fie od omlinEance treato arcszoned (R-0) Rezidential. Opon =d R=1 ref4idaeia
4-eas nm tie sat o« Y.Vortuplvn. ,asked that Pla a:ixig Ca fission -to ra%riow
t da area end roturt 4ith a pooifi recti erdatlozs
r* rles< pointed cut that thare were no definite sign helight regulations
in the rcaln; ue and that definite heighto should be set., ,meter
diocusaion cohcera ig the proper ael.ezat, placaatssort d other regulationatioza
Off° vigmq Wlong, frees* f Rayor Staples ata ed the Kanning Commisojola to
roview this Zroa an"i mcle a Moommensam'10A.
r ui:t :su .o 'Ateca zo t lata :fmating on thor aughta nes, through the Build -,z,
Ceder be re it d to rxtall, dr,iveisa tutor-- =Mounds on the lot to eL m:imito
01' vehioloa carat* onto the thoroughfare, They 'or , gge sleti 4 I
t,gmed mat the ve ired off-street pex)U on page 67t 14 (€) and (b) ba
oha to two spi4cesq (o) to 1:5 off street spaces; .onnj town-
tmmla should ' ve Um Spar= per unit*
Ira ou=i ,- pap 68 c,,' the ,proposed ordinance, Xr, Knight stated khat
v i tiorml tbou jht should- ba &Omen to reducing the parl'ing ratios fQZ' larATO
hop uinq ceynterb = resconnt rtimi%i revealed that this might be poosible>,
nifty t ssa stcd that the Pl.anninG Commisshat study thin 'furthor.
r Staples axnl all present m6 eed that taro golf course parking rec ire ento
iwr too lorr 4 -ml, thtty e;h mld be studied farthar.
Both 00=cil =4 Flanniar Comiazieva member^a tied the fQIlowits points
cs be aivea further std
1. Page 67# sacw,iou (): OPublis Parks and Reoreation &.rsas" hould,
be removed,*
2. P section v zxe s r rtbi'rercl=cation.
r ago 68, sect.o re.ia° .1mmto Mould be inorea sedgy
4* PIlv 7a, section `'Ij v 'tho d tsscreaeoll should be ohWod to 'rbuffe-,11'
w to review thea definition of the zgord Elbu'ferkc
Not