HomeMy WebLinkAboutCouncil Information Memorandum 01-25-1985t'
CITY OF
PUMOUTR
CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
January 25, 1985
UPCOMING MEETINGS AND EVENTS......
1. COUNCIL/STAFF DINNER MEETING -- Monday, January 28, 6:00 p.m.
Council staff dinner meeting in the City Council Conference Room.
2. SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING -- Monday, January 28, 7:30 p.m. Special
City Council meeting in Council Chambers.
3. HOUSING & REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY -- The Plymouth Housing and
Redevelopment Authority will meet on Monday, January 28 at 6:30
p.m. Agenda attached.
4. 1985 LMC/AMM LEGISLATIVE ACTION CONFERENCE -- Tuesday, January 29 -
Wednesday, January 30. The 1985 League of Minnesota Cities
Association of Metropolitan Municipalities Legislative Action
Confeien;;,; -ill be held at the S*_ Paul Radisson Hotel. Agenda
attached.
5. METRO COUNCIL "STATE OF THE REGION" DINNER -- The Metropolitan
Council's annual State of the Region event is scheduled for
Wednesday, January 30 at the Hilton Inn, 1330 Industrial Blvd. with
panel discussions beginning at 4:00 p.m. and dinner at 6:30 p.m.
6. TWINWEST CHAMBER LEGISLATIVE BREAKFAST -- Friday, February 1, 7:30
a.m. at the Golden Valley House, 4820 Olson Highway.
7. COMPARABLE WORTH INFORMATIONAL MEETING -- The League of Minnesota
Cities and Minnesota Chapter of the American Society for Public
Administration will be sponsoring an informational meeting on
Comparable Worth on Tuesday, February 5 from 3:00 - 6:00 p.m. in the
Metropolitan Council Chambers. Attached is a copy of the flyer
announcing the meeting.
8. FEBRUARY CALENDAR -- A copy of the February calendar of meetings and
events is attached.
9. 1985 CITY COUNCIL MEETING SCHEDULE -- A revised copy of the 1985
City Council meeting scheduled is attached.
3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800
CITY COUMCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
January 25, 1985
Page 2
FOR YOUR INFORMATION......
1. MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION -- Thursday evening the MLC held
its annual dinner reception for our legislators and members of the
Metropolitan Council. Mayor Davenport, Councilmember Pat Hoyt Neils
and I attended. Prior to the dinner meeting, the Board of Directors
held its meeting and adopted the 1985 legislative platform of the
MLC. Copies of this document are attached for your information.
Also attached to this memo are copies of the Board minutes of
October 24, as well as the 1984 financial report of the MLC.
The MLC has adopted a statement of general principles dealing with
local government aid. The proposed League of Cities LGA formula is
not entirely consistent with these principles and I anticipate that
this may be a "rub" point at the League of Cities legislative meet-
ing next week in St. Paul.
2. HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY - GLACIER MEADOWS PLAT -- Early
next month the HRA will be moving a house onto one of the three lots
in the Glacier Meadows plat. The house was originally acquired by
the City as part of the extension of County Road 61. The home was
originally constructed in 1978 and is a split-level three bedroom
structure. Milt Dale is sending a letter to all residents within
approximately 500 feet of the plat informing them that this home
will be moved onto the site. It is anticipated that additional on
site improvements will be made in the spring, and, the home offered
for sale by late summer or early fall.
3. ASSOCIATION OF METROPOLITAN MUNICIPALITIES LEGISLATIVE PROGRAM -- We
have just received a copy of the AMM's 1985-86 legislative program
which was adopted by the membership at their annual meeting in
December. This document is 64 pages and I am therefore not
attempting to copy it. It will be on file in our offices for your
review. If you would desire your own copy, please let me know and I
will see that you are provided one.
4. PROPERTY TAX DISTRIBUTION - 1985 -- Attached are four graphs depict-
ing the distribution of property taxes for the several taxing juris-
dictions in Plymouth. The City's share of the property tax dollar
varies as a result of the school districts respective levies. The
City's levy as a percentage of the total is as follows: Wayzata
School District - 14.99%; Robbinsdale School District - 13.64%;
Osseo School District - 14.3%; and Hopkins School District - 15.63%.
5. BURGESS INDUSTRIES PROSECT - SMALL CITIES ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT GRANT
PROGRAM -- On December 18 the Council held a public hearing on the
request of Burgess Industries for a Small Cities loan to provide for
working capital. We subsequently worked with the applicant and
submitted an application to the Department of Energy and Economic
Development. We were seeking on behalf of Burgess Industries to
obtain a $230,000 low interest loan. The loan would have come from
CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
January 25, 1985
Page 2
a $6 million appropriation made by the legislature. I was informed
yesterday that the application will not be funded as the State has
now committed all of the $6 million. I have informed Mr. Burgess of
this fact and he has indicated that he will continue to seek to find
ways to acquire the former Pako Division in order that he can
relocate the business to Plymouth.
6. COMMISSION ROSTERS -- Attached are commission rosters for the
Planning Commission, Housing and Redevelopment Authority, Park and
Recreation Advisory Commission, and the Board of Zoning Adjustments
and Appeals.
7. PUBLIC SAFETY DEPARTMENT YEARLY REPORT -- The Public Safety Director
has prepared the attached memo highlighting statistics that were
generated within the police and fire divisions during 1985. The
Department's 1984 annual report will be published in the March issue
of Plymouth on Parade.
8. PLYMOUTH FORUM NOTES -- Notes from the January 21 Plymouth Forum are
attached for your information.
9. OLIVEWOOD DEVELOPMENT -- The Minnesota Housing Finance Agency has
informed us that the Olivewood proposal has been selected for
mortgage processing under the Agency's Family Graduated Payment
Program. The proposed development contains a total of 135 units and
is proposed to be located at the SW corner of 14th Avenue and Olive
Lane. The developer is Sohn Schuett, Golden Valley.
10. EMPLOYEE APPRAISALS -- The attached article from the Wall Street
Journal provides some helpful advice on conducting employee perfor-
mance appraisals.
11. SEMINAR ON WORKING WITH METROPOLITAN AGENCIES AND STATE LEGISLATURE
-- Mr. Gene Franchett, of Gene Franchett and Associates, will hold a
seminar for local officials and others who work with the Metro-
politan Council and State Legislature on Saturday, February 23. The
seminar entitled, "How to Work with Metropolitan Agencies and State
Legislature" will be held at the Holiday Inn Plymouth. Mr.
Franchett served as Executive Director of the Metropolitan Council
from 1979 to 1983, and Executive Director of the Association of the
Association of Metropolitan Municipalities from 1972 to 1974.
Attached is further information on the seminar. If you are
interested in attending, please contact Laurie so reservations may
be made.
12. TORT CLAIM -- Attached is a copy of a notice of tort claim received
this week from Bradley J. Gunn, attorney representing Clarence and
Marilyn Gordon, 410 Zinnia Lane, for the destruction of trees on
their property in conjunction with the County Road 61 project.
CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
January 25, 1985
Page 4
13. AREA 4 TOWN MEETING FEEDBACK RESPONSES - Attached are staff
responses to resident feedback forms received at the Town Meeting
for Area 4.
14. CORRESPONDENCE:
a. Letter to City Manager from Paul Ridgeway, Carlson Companies,
indicating his willingness to serve on the Plymouth 2000
project.
b. Letter from from Mayor Davenport to dim Kemp congratulating him
on his election as Chair of the District 284 School Board.
James G. Willis
City Manager
JGW:jm
attach
A G E N D A
PLYMOUTH HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
ANNUAL MEETING (CONTINUED)
January 28, 1985
6:30 p.m.
I. Roll Call
II. Approval of Minutes for January 7, 1985 Meeting
III. Oath of Office for Gerry Neils
IV. Nomination and Appointment of Officers
V. Year End Status Report on the Section 8 Program
VI. Year End Status Report on the Housing Rehabilitation Program
VII. Year End Status Report on the Scattered Site Home Ownership Program
VIII. Adjournment
1985 LMC LEGISLATIVE ACTION CONFERENCE
January 29-30, 1985
St. Paul Radisson Hotel
Kellogg Boulevard
TUESDAY, JANUARY 29
10:00 a.m. REGISTRATION - lower lobby at foot of escalator
11:00 a.m. WORKSHOP - "Development Tools for Cities: The Future
Course of State Legislative Policy"
Panelists: Senator Larry Pogemiller
Representative William Schreiber
12 Noon LUNCHEON - Opening Session
Finance and Tax Issues in the '85 Session
Speakers: Representative David Jennings, Speaker of
the Minnesota House of Representatives
Senator Roger Moe, Majority Leader,
Minnesota State Senate
1:45 p.m. LMC LEGISLATIVE POLICY ADOPTION
1984 LGA Policy Development and the LGA Formula:
Explanation and Recommendations for Change
Presentation by: Diane Loeffler, LMC Legislative Counsel
Presentation and Adoption of 1985 LMC Policies
Mayor Mary Anderson, LMC President, presiding
5:00 p.m. ASK THE LOBBYISTS
Question and Answer Period re: LMC/AMM Legislative
Issues for '85 Session
5:30 p.m. RECEPTION FOR CITY OFFICIALS AND STATE LEGISLATORS
7:30 p.m.
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 30
8:30 a.m. CONTINENTAL BREAKFAST
Speaker: Senator Donald Moe
The Future of PERA: Proposals for Merger of Public
Pension Systems; Supplemental Defined Contribution
Proposl; Health Benefits for Pension Retirees.
9:30 a.m. WORKSHOP: "The Future of Stare -Local Fiscal Relations"
Panel:
Julia Friedman, Professor of Economics and Urban Studies,
Macalester College: formerly Senior
Economist, Minnesota Tax Study Commissionn
Jay Kiedrowski, Deputy Commissioner of Finance
Rep. William Schreiber, Chair, House Tax Committee
Senator Douglas Johnson, Chair, Senate Taxes Committee
11:15 a.m. LMC LEGISLATIVE BRIEFING
League Lobbyists
Presentations on LMC Legislative Priorities
11:45 a.m. LMC LOBBYING DAY ON THE HILL
City Officials Meet with Local Lawmakers
on LMC Legislative Program for 1985
Conference sponsored by League of Minnesota Cities and Association of
Metropolitan Municipalities
Comparable Worth: The Challenge of the 80s
February 5, 1985
3 - 6 p.m.
Metropolitan Council Chambers
3:00 - 3:20 Commissioner Nina Rothschild, State Dept. of Employee Relations
3:20 - 3:40 Mayor Mary Anderson, Golden Valley, and President, League of Minnesota
Cities
3:40 - 4:00 Karen Olson, Labor Relations Associates
4:00 - 4:20 BREAK
4:20 - 4:40 Jeanette Sobania, Personnel Assistant, City of St. Paul
4:40 - 5:00 Frank Madden, Attorney, Heuer, Madden & Gruesner
5:00 - 6:00 Questions and Comments from the Audience
Free and Open to the Public
Sponsored by the Minnesota Chapter of the American Society for Public Administration
and the League of Minnesota Cities
For further information contact:
Vera Vogelsang -Coombs, President -Elect, MnASPA, 612/641-2900
David Unmacht, City Administrator, Belle Plaine, 612/873-5553
Joel Jamnik, Legislative Counsel, LMC, 612/227-5600
l
N
�
M■+
W
-
Cl
�.
n0C000
b
l7d r,
�d
9z
z
C) H
novo
b
�jy
tv � -�
r•
,
o
=J
CrJ H
r
Ln
En
r�
n •
y
H
z
r�
PO
M
MH
9 �
N
N
~
0�
r�z
r�z"
W
n �
w O
Wn
C)
M •d
10
b
(� Vcc
r:b
C.) y
`>
H
z
m
Lz7
m
vi
�
D
cc
N
V�
W
Q�
Z
0
n
O
0
m
cn
0
m
Z
m
0
C
0
C/)l
< ad
ro
o �
1985 CITY COUNCIL MEETING SCHEDULE
* Council/Staff Dinner Meetings - 6:00 p.m.
1985: Jan.
REGULAR
SPECIAL
TOWN
MEETINGS
JOINT
MEETINGS
OPEN
MORAY
HOLIDAY
1985:
JANUARY
7, 21
28*
14
---
_--
22
FEBRUARY
4
25*
19
---
---
18
MARCH
4, 18
*
11
---
APRIL
1, 15
22*
V
8
29 (PRAC)
---
---
MAY
6, 20
---
13
---
-_-
27
JUNE
3, 17
24
---
---
10
---
JULY
1, 15
22*
---
29 (PC)
8
-_-
AUGUST
5, 19
26
---
---
12
---
SEPTEMBER
16
9, 23, 30*
---
---
--_
2
OCTOBER
7, 21
28
---
---
14
---
NOVEMBER
4, 18
25*
---
---
---
11
DECEMBER
2, 16
---
---
---
9 23 30
---
1985
MEETINGS 22 11 5 2 7 4
* Council/Staff Dinner Meetings - 6:00 p.m.
1985: Jan.
28
Park and Recreation
Feb.
25
Community Development Task Force
Mar.
25
Public Works
Apr.
22
City Manager
July
22
Community Development
Sept
30
Finance
Nov.
25
Public Safety
MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION FUND
BALANCE SHEET
December 31, 1984
Assets
Cash and Investments $ 10,093.25
TOTAL ASSETS 10 093.25
Liabilities and Fund Balance
Accounts Payable
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren $3,877.12
Christopher Miller 20.50
Media Services 505.25
$ 4,402.87
Fund Balance $ 5,690.38
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCE $ 10,093.25
STATEMENT OF REVENUE EXPENDITURES AND CHANGES IN FUND BALANCE
FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY 1, 1984 - DECEMBER 31, 1984
REVENUE - CITY CONTRIBUTIONS:
Maplewood
Burnsville
Shoreview
Woodbury
Roseville
White Bear Lake
Plymouth
Minnetonka
Eagan
Maple Grove
Eden Prairie
Edina
Brooklyn Park
Bloomington
Mounds View
Blaine
Total City Contributions
City Conference Reimbursements
Interest on Investments
TOTAL REVENUE
$ 6,945.00
9,395.00
4,707.50
2,915.00
8,980.00
5,627.50
8,845.00
10,000.00
6,270.00
6,057.50
4,925.00
10,000.00
10,000.00
10,000.00
3,200.00
7,597.50
-1-
$115,465.00
1,350.24
4,446.20
112.1,261.44
MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
MINUTES - BOARD OF bIRECTORS MEETING
WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 24, 1984
FOX AND HOUNDS RESTAURANT
10:00 A.M.
Chairperson of the Municipal Legislative Commission Board of Directors Mayor
June Demos of Roseville called the meeting to order at 10:00 A.M.
Members present were Jim Lacina, Woodbury, Jim Spore, Burnsville, Don Pauley,
Mounds View, Jim Miller, Minnetonka, Jim Willis, Plymouth, Mark Bernhardson,
Edina, Mark Sather, White Bear Lake, Elwin Tinklenberg, Blaine, Steve North,
Roseville, Barry Evans, Maplewood, Lyle Olson, Bloomington, Doug Reeder, Maple
Grove, Don Ramstad, Maple Grove, Jim Krautkremer, Brooklyn Park, Wolfgang
Penzel, Eden Prairie, Greg Dawson, Eden Prairie, Gene VanOverbeke, Eagan, John
Pidgeon, Bloomington, James Lindau, Bloomington, Richard Johnson, Blaine.
Also present were Debbie Grant and Bob Renner from Larkin, Hoffman, Daly R
Lindgren, Tom Davies from Christopher Miller & Company and D. J. Leary from
Media Services.
Motion by Member Pauley, seconded by Member Penzel to approve the minutes of
the July 26, 1984 Board of Directors meeting. Motion passed unanimously.
The first item of business presented for discussion was a resolution regarding
the MLC's position on the current situation at the Public Employees Retirement
Association. Two resolutions were presented for consideration by the Board of
Directors. After considerable discussion there was a motion by Member
Pidgeon, seconded by Member Krautkremer to adopt a resolution addressing the
current issues and concerns of the MLC with the appointment of the acting
executive director and the activities of the Board of Directors of PERA. A
copy of said resolution is attached to these minutes.
The next item considered by the Board of Directors was an update by Bob Renner
on the Minnesota Tax Study Com fission. He indicated that the study would be
published soon for public review.
Member'Pidgeon then reviewed the Local Government Aid Working Group. Mr. Lyle
Olson from the City of Bloomington summarized the activities of the Technical
Committee. Member Pidgeon noted that the group was still working with the
various formulas. A brief discussion ensued relative to the philosophy of a
formula for local government aid which addresses MLC cities concerns. It was
decided that this discussion would be taken up at a future meeting of the
Operating Committee.
The next item of consideration was the legislative reception. The reception
was set for the 5th Wednesday in 1985, January 30th. Additional information
will be transmitted on this as final arrangements are made.
MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
MINUTES - BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING
WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 24, 1984
Next Member 'Willis reviewed the 1985 Legislative agenda. A copy of the agenda
is attached as part of the minutes indicating the issue and the priority
and/or action on the subject by the Municipal Legislative Commission.
A brief report then followed on the MLC meeting with the City of Minneapolis
officials. Mr. Renner indicated that there seemed to be a spirit of
cooperation between the organizations and urged that the MLC continue its
discussions with all the other lobbying interest groups so that coordination
could occur where possible and that open channels of communication remain.
The MLC public relations consultants then reviewed for the Board of Directors
the direction of the public relations activities over the next few months.
The treasurer's report was presented by Member Lacina. A copy of that report
is attached as a part of the minutes.
Motion by Member Demos, seconded by Member by Member Pauley to approve the
treasurer's report. Motion passed unanamiously.
Members of the Board of Directors requested that bills for the 1985 dues be
sent out early in December.
Chair Demos indicated she would be selecting a nominating committee for the
election of the MLC officers at the January meeting.
The next item of consideration was the legislative surveys. Mr. Renner
reviewed the responses from the legislative candidates.
Member Lacina reviewed for the Board of Directors the study presently under
consideration by the Legislative Auditor on the Metropolitan Council. The
legislative audit division is completing a study which focuses mainly on
accountability to and direction from the legislature and the activities of the
Metropolitan Council with respect to their enabling authority. He indicated
that any members who are interested in commenting on this should contact the
legislative auditor's office.
Mr. Willis then reviewed a tax increment financing issue relative to the City
of Minneapolis and their proposal to refinance tax increment issues. He
indicated he would keep the members present regarding this issue.
The next meeting of the Operating Committee was set for November 29, 1984.
The meeting adjourned at 11:45 A.M.
- 2 -
WHEREAS, the MLC member cities raise property taxes which
are contributed to PERA as the employer share of retirement benefits
for municipal employees; and
WHEREAS, the several appointed and elected trustees on the
PERA Board have raised significant legal questions regarding the
appointment process used to hire an acting executive director of
PERA;
WHEREAS, these questions raise grave concerns for the long
range integrity and security of the retirement programs of our public
employees;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Municipal Legislative
Commission demands the removal of the acting director and the immediate
initiation of an open selection process for a new PERA executive
director; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Legislative Auditor conduct
a five year compliance audit of the PERA fiscal operations; and
t
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that 16 member cities of the Munici^al
Legislative Commission will not enter into any services offered by
PERA (such as life insurance or auto insurance programs) until it
is clear that the management of PERA is consistent with good public
policy;
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the 16 members of the Municipal
Legislative Commission will begin placing the employer's contribution
to PERA in escrow on February 1, 1965, if there has not been a satis_`actor-7
resolution of this serious matter. j
BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED, that the ;unicipal Legislative Co T.^,i ssion
urges all governmental units that contribute to PERA to place their
contributions in escro,.., until these issues have been satisfactorily
resolved.
MUNICIPALf \
7903 Xerxes Avenue youth
Suite 1500
LEGISLATIVE
Bloomington. Minnesota 55431
ng
COMMISSION
(612) 338-6610
.
WHEREAS, the Municipal
Legislative Commission (MLC) is a group
of
16
suburbs which has over
2,500 municipal emolovees who are members
of
the
Public Employees Retirement
Association (PERK); and
WHEREAS, the MLC member cities raise property taxes which
are contributed to PERA as the employer share of retirement benefits
for municipal employees; and
WHEREAS, the several appointed and elected trustees on the
PERA Board have raised significant legal questions regarding the
appointment process used to hire an acting executive director of
PERA;
WHEREAS, these questions raise grave concerns for the long
range integrity and security of the retirement programs of our public
employees;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Municipal Legislative
Commission demands the removal of the acting director and the immediate
initiation of an open selection process for a new PERA executive
director; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Legislative Auditor conduct
a five year compliance audit of the PERA fiscal operations; and
t
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that 16 member cities of the Munici^al
Legislative Commission will not enter into any services offered by
PERA (such as life insurance or auto insurance programs) until it
is clear that the management of PERA is consistent with good public
policy;
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the 16 members of the Municipal
Legislative Commission will begin placing the employer's contribution
to PERA in escrow on February 1, 1965, if there has not been a satis_`actor-7
resolution of this serious matter. j
BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED, that the ;unicipal Legislative Co T.^,i ssion
urges all governmental units that contribute to PERA to place their
contributions in escro,.., until these issues have been satisfactorily
resolved.
( 7900 Xerxes Avenue South
TD
MUNICIPAL
'a Suite 1500
1,T LEGISLATIVE Bluomin�ton. hlinncsota 55431
COMMISSION `b►`'sss E610
PROPOSED 1985 LEGISLATIVE
AGENDA
10/18
ML.C- Legislative Committee
Issue
Priority/Action
1.
IRB's/Tax Increment Financing
Meaium/Active role
if necessary
2.
Local Government Aids
Hich/Active role
3.
Coy ,tined Sewer Overi lova
Payment Method and
Impact on Sewer Districts
Hich/Active role
4.
RTB Legislation
Medium/Monitor
5.
Parks and Open Space Funding
50% support for Regional Paries
from State Source (undetermined)
Medium/Monitor
6.
Property Tax Plan
Hich/Monitor-
Governor's Tax Study Commission
Become Active If
Necessary
7.
Levy Limits
Me-ium/Monitor
8.
PERA Legislation
a.Invest Own Funds instead
of the State Board of
Investment
High/Actively Oppose
b.401 (a) & (k) Alternatives
Lo,...,/Monitor
League should take
lead
9.
Fiscal Disparities
High/Monitor
Become Active
if necessary
10.
Primary Election Date Change
Le -.;/None
1.1.
Other
4.- MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION FUND
BALANCE SHEET
September 30, 1984
Assets
Cash and Investments
TOTAL ASSETS
Liabilities and Fund Balance
Fund Balance
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND FUND BALANCE
$ 24,473.83
S 24,473.83
$ 24,473.83
S 243473.83
STATEMENT OF REVENUE EXPENDITURES AND CHANGES IN FUND BALANCE
FOR THE PERIOD JANUARY
1, 1984 - SEPTEMBER 30, 1984
REVENUE - CITY CONTRIBUTIONS:
Maplewood
S 6,945.00
Burnsville
9,395.00
Shoreview
4,707.50
Woodbury
2,915.00
Roseville
8,980.00
White Bear Lake
5,627.50
Plymouth
8,845.00
Minnetonka
10,000.00
Eagan
6,270.00
Maple Grove
6,057.50
Eden Prairie
4,925.00
Edina
10,000.00
Brooklyn Park
10,000.00
Bloomington
10,000.00
Mounds View
3,200.00
Blaine
7,597.50
Total City Contributions 5115,465.00
City Conference Reimbursements 1,350.24
TOTAL REVENUE S116,815.2^-
c
MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION FUND
BALANCE SHEET
9-30-84
EXPENDITURES:
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
S 7,500.00
Decathlon Athletic Club
1,461.03
City of Woodbury - Postage
12.09
Christopher Miller & Company
50.72
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
879.06
Christopher Miller & Company
2,500.00
Radisson Plaza South
1,167.86
St. Paul Hotel
1,904.38
Media Services, Inc.
500.00
City of Woodbury - Postage
7.22
Christopher Miller & Company
2,500.0'
North Star Printing
549.50
Christopher Miller & Company
2,500.00
Media Services, Inc.
505.00
Christopher Miller & Company
1,394.33
Radisson Hotel South
516.45
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
7,500.00
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
16,077.50
Media Services
- 500.00
Radisson Inn, Plymouth
570.17
Decathlon Athletic Club
371.64
Christopher Miller
1,089.41
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
15,966.60
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
15,875.00
Christopher Miller & Company
3,000.00
Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren
6,427.50
Christopher Miller
1,000.00
Christopher Miller
15.90
TOTAL EXPENDITURES S 92.341.41
Revenue Over (Under) Expenditures S 24,473.83
Fund Balance - January 1, 1984 -0-
Fund Balance - September 30, 1984 S 242473.83
-2-
Ar_
k-
1985
DISTRIBUTION OF THE TAX DOLLAR
CITY OF PLYMOUTH
WAY,ZATA SCHOOL DISTRICT
VoCATIDNA L
MILL RATES
School District CKayzata) 46.507*
Hennepin County 29.262
City of Plymouth 14.538
Miscellaneous
5.181
Vocational School 1.490
TOTAL 96.978
*Includes 4.000 mills from referendum
1-18-85
S. Mauderer
JE
).34%
I
1985
DISTRIBUTION OF THE TAX DOLLAR
CITY OF PLYMOUTH
ROBBINSD4LE SCHOOL DISTRICT
281
D 15TiZIGT
52.640
�1ENNE�IN GoUNTY
.27.46%
1-18-85
S. rIauderer
JE
MILL RATES
VoCAT►DNA L
JcttooL
1.400
G ITY of PLYMOOTH 1
1%
13.64%
4.860
School District (Robbinsdale)
56.100*
Hennepin County
29.262
City of Plymouth
14.538
Miscellaneous
5.181
Vocational School
1.490
TOTAL
106.571
*Includes 8.500 mills from referendum
1985
DISTRIBUTION OF THE TAX DOLLAR
CITY OF PLYMOUTH
OSSEO SCHOOL DISTRICT
D�jTRIGT # 279
50.360
VOCATI oNA L
5cttoc �
1.460
G ITY of PLYMXTH 1
t1ENNE'PIN CWNTY 14.300
28.78° 5.100
MILL RATES
School District (Osseo)
51.199*
Hennepin County
29.262
City of Plymouth
14.538
Miscellaneous
5.181
Vocational School
1.490
TOTAL
101.670
*Includes 6.000 mills from referendum
1-18-85
S. Mauderer
JE
1985
DISTRIBUTION OF THE TAX DOLLAR
CITY OF PLYMOUTH
HOPKINS SCHOOL DISTRICT
VoCATI ONA L
i- L - ,., i
0
MILL RATES
School District (Hopkins) 42.567
Hennepin County 29.262
City of Plymouth 14.538
Miscellaneous
5.181
Vocational School 1.490
TOTAL
•1-18-85
S. ?lauderer
JE
93.038
1
1/85
PLANNING COMMISSION - CITY OF PLYMOUTH
Name and District
Telephone No.
Term Expires
Paul Steigerwald
Chair
R.
546-6075
1/31/88
120 Magnolia Lane
0.
370-0611
Plymouth 55441
Michael Stulberg
District #1
R.
478-6831
1/31/87
6010 Troy Lane
0
932-1656
Plymouth 55446
Clark Magnus
District 2
R.
476-0389
1/31/87
18520 - 27th Ave. N.
0.
639-4216
Plymouth 55447
David L. Pauba
District #4
R.
559-3680
1/31/86
12520 - 58th Ave. N.
0.
533-2164
Plymouth 55442
Sohn Wire
At Large
R.
559-5401
1/31/86
4130 Quaker Lane
0.
828-7132
Plymouth 55441
Richard G. Plufka
At Large
R.
559-2347
1/31/88
3675 Sycamore Lane
0.
372-8510
Plymouth 55441
Blair Tremere, Director of Planning and Community Development
Meetings are held the second and fourth Wednesday of the month at 7:30 p.m. in the
Council Chambers of the City Center. A Public Forum is held the first meetinq of
the month at 7:15 p.m. Members are appointed for three-year terms expiring January
31st of that year. The Chair and Vice Chair shall be appointed by the Mayor from
among the members of the Commission and shall serve for a term of one year.
1/85
PLYMOUTH HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Name
Telephone No.
Term Expires
Del Erickson, Chair
R.
559-4772
1/31/88
2317 Kirkwood Lane
0.
292-0411
Plymouth 55441
Harold Bakke, Vice Chair
R.
473-7653
1/31/87
815 Kingsview Lane
0.
333-7101
Plymouth 55447
Gerald Neils, Secretary/Treasurer
R.
545-2679
1/31/90
3890 Orleans Lane
0.
330-6052
Plymouth 55441
Rod Hillstrom
R.
559-3094
1/31/89
12510 - 25th Avenue
0.
828-4521
Plymouth 55441
Patricia Hoyt -Neils
R.
545-2679
1/31/86
3890 Orleans Lane
Plymouth 55441
Meetings are held on the fourth Monday every other month at 6:30 p.m. in
the Council Chambers. Members are appointed for five-year terms expirinq
the 4th Monday in January.
C
I
PARK
& RECREATION
ADVISORY COMMISSION - CITY
1/85
OF PLYMOUTH
Name & District
Telephone No.
Term Expires
Betty Threinen
Chairperson
R.
559-9271
1/31/86
5860 Lawndale Lane
0.
473-7321
Plymouth 55446
Steve Chesebrough
Vice Chair
R.
559-0059
1/31/88
3615 Evergreen Lane
0.
540-7146
Plymouth 55441
Judy LaTour
R.
473-8183
1/31/88
1500 Weston Lane
Plymouth, MN 55447
Carol Beach
District #2
R.
473-8245
1/31/88
325 Merrimac Lane
0.
473-8245
Plymouth 55447
John C. Mullan
District #3
R.
559-9205
1/31/88
11845 - 28th Ave. N.
0.
332-0421
Plymouth 55447
Barbara Edwards
District #4
R.
545-1912
1/31/87
3935 Orleans Lane
0.
559-8000
Plymouth 55441
John Reed
R.
559-2523
1/31/86
1751 West Medicine Lake Drive
0.
559-5632
Plymouth, 55441
Eric Blank, Director of Parks and Recreation
Meetings are held the second Thursday of the month at 7:30 p.m. in the Council
Chambers. Members are appointed for three-year terms expiring January 31st
of that year. The Chairman shall be appointed by the Mayor from among the
members of the Commission and shall serve for a term of one year.
1/85
BOARD OF ZONING ADJUSTMENTS AND APPEALS - CITY OF PLYMOUTH
Name Telephone No. Term Expires
Larry Marofsky (Chairman)
R.
544-9685
1/31/86
2835 Medicine Ridge Road
0.
535-2122
Plymouth 55441
Ted C. Victor (Vice Chair)
R.
553-1460
1/31/86
2861 Black Oaks Lane
0.
473-4334
Plymouth 55447
Kenneth W. Quass, Jr.
R.
559-0578
1/31/97
12725 - 30th Avenue No.
0.
926-7635
Plymouth 55441
Dennis Cornelius
R.
559-7472
1/31/97
3970 Balsam Lane
0.
936-4432
Plymouth 55441
Olene Bigelow
R.
559-3106
1/31/96
11600 37th Place N.
0.
333-6655
Plymouth 55441
Steven Musatto
R.
475-0588
1/31/87
18805 - 4th Avenue No.
0.
473-0909
Plymouth 55447
Richard G. Plufka *
R.
559-2347
1/31/95
3075 Sycamore Lane
0.
372-8510
Plymouth 55441
Al Cottingham, Associate Planner
Meetings are held the second Monday of the month at 7:30 p.m. in the City Center
Council Chambers. Members are appointed for two-year terms expiring on January
31st of that year. One member is a member of the Planning Commission and shall be
appointed for a term coinciding with his/her term on the Planning Commission.*
The Chairperson shall be appointed by the Mayor from among the members of the
Commission.
CITY OF PLYMOUTH
3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD., PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447
TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800
MEMO
DATE: January 15, 1985
TO: James G. Willis, City Manager
FROM: Richard J. Carlquist, Public Safety Directo
SUBJECT Public Safety Yearly Report
The 1984 yearly report for the Department of Public Safety will aoain
be published in the Plymouth on Parade magazine that will be mailed
to residents in March. This memo will highlight some of the statistics
that were generated within the police and fire divisions during the
year 1984. I have enclosed the year end tabulations for both of these
divisions with this memo.
POLICE
Overall the number of service calls increased in 1984 by 8.3 percent.
This was the first time that the number of service calls handled by
the police department has reached the 15,000 level. With respect to
reported crime listed in class I and II there was really no appreciable
change. The major increases in police activity in class III are
under the headinqs of personal injury and property damage accidents.
In class IV significant increases were found under the headings of
lock outs, warrants served, traffic details, and suspicious/information.
With respect to increase in the latter item, hopefully our neighborhood
watch crime prevention programs are contributing to the increase in citizen
calls in this category. It may be too early to make an optimistic statement,
but I believe the decrease in domestic calls may have some bearing on our
domestic abuse program and our overall participation. A decrease may have
been the result of less recidivism on this type of service call.
The number of citations issued in 1984 increased significantly. By the
time the December fine revenue is recieved from Hennepin County Municipal
Court, I believe the total for the year will be in excess of $300,000.00.
In 1984 we started our community relations program. I have enclosed a listing
of public relations programs that were presented through December of last
year. In the most recent edition of the Police Chief magazine I noted with
interest that studies shown that law enforcement programs presented within
the school setting by police officers make a significant difference on
reducing crime and delinquent acts.
FIRE
The total number of fire calls in 1984 increased significantly. This
increase was due mainly to more response to false alarms. The number of
confirmed calls only increased by five over the previous year. Please
note that health care institutions represent an overwhelming number of
false alarms. The fire inspector is currently working on this particular
problem and we hope to have it resolved in the very near future. The total
estimated loss for fires was increased substantially during the month of
December because of the Hanus Bus fire. Otherwise, we were running behind
in the.estimated loss column when compared with 1983. The bulk of the fire
calls continues to be in the 12 hour period from 8:00 a.m, to 8:00 p.m..
The number of fire calls received during the daytime continues to be high
and our staffing at these times remains a major consideration.
During the month of December a major recruitment drive for more firefighters
was initiated. We believe that our efforts were very successful. We will
be adding approximately 20 "new faces" in 1985 and will also see at the
same time several of the "old timers" retiring. Our net effect to the
department will obviously be less than 20. We are preparinq for the future
for both fire station 3 and the eventual retirement of older personnel.
The addition of a full time fire chief in 1984, has, in my opinion, aided
in an orderly administrative process of preparing for the future. We also
trained five volunteer firefighters to assist in our fire prevention efforts.
These persons perform inspections for us on a very limited basis. Their
participation is gratifying in that it brings together the part time and full
time personnel as well as instilling the concept of public safety within our
organization. Morale on the fire department is high.
RJC:tsw
r-1
I
N
N
d
J
V
Z
O
N n 01
CC
Q
LL
LLJ
S
O r, O
Q
� r O
W 00 OO
S
00 n
I --
-:x ¢ M 1
J
C' M M
go
m
J
00 M
'= M Ln
N N r
VI
4
T
OC
W
m e M
m
R
W
CL
4 V1
W
� 1"1
OD co
OA OA
r r
LA N
M M
r-1 r-1
Go co
r r
-CC Ln
M
O O J
►- 1- U
ti O
W Cl V1
= M M
r
0
� T
WU
Ix N e
C
MC,
N
N U
Q n
J J
3tn Ln
O Goe
V1 O
W H
N =
W U O O
LL
1-4
O Q
LL
L
z
J
� O O
Q
L
U
C .y
Z O �
N
W
N
NW M M
LL
LL
O
�+ Z
F- O
Vf .-
CL 1-
N
O V)
GL Z M N
{Q W
3 LL
LL
O
rNr
Q Lr) Q1
o e e
Z
T
Z W
W
J W QD N
O- C
N OC
Cl
1
J
W H
N Z
m f
Z
W
O
U-
LD
r=r
W
W
Ip tff
O W N N
z
O
coILI
OD
OA cn
r r
K
00
e
O
•O
be
%C
�O
M
00
r-1
Co Go
CA CA
.y.
J J N
0 0
C)
N
f
U W
Z
Z
O O
J LL ti N
�= z
N Aw N
W
� CL
O_ O)
U Q Op
N
Z 5 n Q
= LL N
N M
N
C O
f-
� J �
W �
.Uw J
LL rLrn
LL dxr,M
W tl!
F O
cc
Z W
OCW M V)
3
OC
S T
O Z O O
W
M
V)
N
a
Y N M
pooN
0 O
cr
W
3
O � O
OL'
Ol
W)co
O e
a J ONi m
W Q
J J_
t� M
_ Q e M
Lj e
Z W
d O
U
N
W � n
8
M Q
co co
r r
M
co
t
K K
e O 'O N
• e O
M M
N N
cc ao W oD
o+ rn c o*
O
W
CL'
d
W N
J J
U J
V7 U
N LL
W O
LL w
LL W
O]
J �
¢ Z
Z
O
U F --
PLYMOUTH FIRE DEPARTMENT
MONTHLY REPORT
TYPE OF REPORTED INCIDENTS BY TIME OF DAY
MONTH JANUARY - DECEMBER 1984
0001 0401 0801 1201 1601 2001 CONFIRMED FALSE
0400 0800 1200 1 1600 2000 2400 CALLS ALARMS
17 32 7 49 35
PRIVATE DWELLINGS
9
5
14
3
2
1
11
4
11
24 19 11
12
68
APARTMENTS
4
1
1
1 1
0
5
6
1
7
2
HOTELS AND MOTELS
12
136
ALL OTHER RESIDENTIAL
1
277
7
21
2
1
2 1 1
3 3 1
8 7 5
2 1
1 4 1
p
2
11
2
3
3
2
4
4
53
1
8
PUBLIC ASSEMBLY
1
1
SCHOOLS AND COLLEGES
1
HEALTH CARE INSTITUTIONS
6
8
PENAL INSTITUTIONS
1
STORES AND OFFICES
3
INDUSTRY, MFG.
3
8
21
24 9 6
31
40
2
2
0
STORAGE IN STRUCTURES
3 1
2 2 1
7 7 6
2
7
8
35
2
p
0
5
p
SPECIAL STRUCTURES
1
1
1
2
FIRES OUTSIDE OF STRUCTURES
1
FIRES IN HIGHWAY VEHICLES
3
9
8
FIRES IN OTHER VEHICLES
5
19 11 11
3 6
44
13
4
1
FIRES IN BRUSH, GRASS
2
3
2
FIRES IN RUBBISH, DUMPSTERS
ALL OTHER FIRES
MEDICAL AID RESPONSES
MALICIOUS FALSE ALARM 4
MUTUAL AID OR ASSISTANCE 1
ALL OTHER RESPONSES 5 1
TOTALS 53 1 43
*(INCLUDED IN FALSE ALARM TOTALS)
YEAR TO DATE 1983
CONFIRMED CALLS 269
FALSE ALARMS 193
TOTAL 462
ESTMATED LOSS $685,050
0
15
0
84
80
5
2
6
15
55
4
11
71
2
7
8
40
2
14
4
3
15
8
254 1 531
ESTIMATED
LOSS
$185,600
2,325
5,000
255
250,020
732,980
1,500
1 .500
25,110
75,500
65
1,900
1 .285,0
3
1
3
2
1
3
1
4
5
1
0
4
1
1
1
8
13
6
15
7
39
12
136
125
62
277
0
15
0
84
80
5
2
6
15
55
4
11
71
2
7
8
40
2
14
4
3
15
8
254 1 531
ESTIMATED
LOSS
$185,600
2,325
5,000
255
250,020
732,980
1,500
1 .500
25,110
75,500
65
1,900
1 .285,0
Z
O
a
a�
W
w
1
1
t
I
1
rzr= E E
•E
i
E E
Ln o o In
1
00 C,
. . . M
N
W
t
CCC c cc c
{-� i-. i••i %•� it f•. f•. 1~ %•� � �
t
• • •�- .r •r • •r • • • • • • r •r • • • .• •
E E E i E i i i i i E E i i i r E i –E
I
L L L L L .CLL LLL L
rl Ln N ri r-1 r-1 ri ri
t
O O LnO O u•> LSA U)
1
ryriNNq*l _4(n . gzrcn en Wt -4'r4•*Nqo'
1
1
1
1
�
1
LC
1
a
1
m
W
r ^
V) Ln
I
1
Lu
LL
. -..-.
V) N N rn
1
••
f� fd
r0 to rO r6
to
1
Z
'fit Ct M N
Q
1
�
Z
'
Nrl Ln LO v')t-opO
'
NC7>O^OctLc'SI-,tDNOI--IptD<ntnMOOO
W
ri N r -I r-1 N [� ri N ri N
I
ri ri 1-1 1-0 N %n m N .-1 rti t0 M Ln Cr r4 R*- N
I
C
1
t7:
Q
1
1
C
•r
1
E
�
O
�
I
O
C)
1
r
p7
rl e- I U
I
i-) •r `.
1
F) Y i
�*r
LC
1
•r N O
•S� bA i•).0 i_
r -
W
Lu
o bC V)
9
i
a o
V
C4 V) z a
+J U +J i- +- Z
_'4 4 J
4-L) 4J +) \ 0 Q) 0 O •V)
I
Y + Y
i- ) +J C +3 +J 4-3 4-J +J i- � CJ +J +- Q) +
H
bl)•ri O •ri ••ri pQr ri V) -H1
1
•r N •r •r (n CJ •r C)-- •r •r •r •r •r r •r •r M— •r
O C a L C i a •r -C t7 L L L C'L L •r C:L
LL•�•�
r-1 V) '� m m N ri b 'C1 O
(
N O N V) O O 0 r N N N N V) N 'O N N r N
'az.4zzz�rxrx?z
1
C) i C) C) i rO C) L C) C) O C) C) C) •r CJ C) L •r C)
Z3ZZ�JZ=ZZZZZZ�ZZS�Z
c
i
1
1
r
I
O �-•
O O O
t
O L O H U•
O O .H
'
•r U O +3 L •U
14
1
+�(nL C rrr C1prrL >
00
i
m U (1) 0 0 0 •r — O O U •r t�
r♦ O O Ln V) U V)
'
L U L N i 0 0 0 4 2 O O i 0 C
-5
r0 LLLO a)-COrS
.b�
1
i'O•rL d U U US • C) U UL i i
V) to to W -H
1
1
O W S m f L CN (n Ln i i (n Ln L)– r0
Z •r N N O V) O 7 H C.O 4•3 i-
I
� M 4-1 4- r 4.3 -0 � C -0 -0 >) N N
_ � �
C) +•) C » U O O O O ro L M O O +-) C)
OU OU OU
1
J 4-)+
r •r O CO 0 0 O O O O � C O O.- i 0 U)
Q
M � Z Z 4J'i rte
1
M C L ++ U U A U 3 3 3 = •r 3 3 C •r +- C
Ln LOQ �
1
' O i- M In Ln i to C C C L O C C C 0 4- M •r
N N rO Q) Q) C) U E i C1 O EE L` Y C
E>)
�.b r�
L L� a C) O C) i rO C) N E E C i
O 0 0 0 RS d
j
LiUQ3UL-) uLDcmC3J0-_jcz 0 u(
V
VC7WN�ZC,��3U�•-)
1
--)m
1
1
1
cz cz
1
4-)C) N N C C) Cl) C) +•> C) C) C) C) C) CJ C)
cwC 3 •� cid
'
w 4- i i O 4- 4- 4- rO 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- U 4-
a) U
I
r r0 C) Q) •r r0 rO r6 3 rO to m r6 r0 •r b
'L7 \ \ a pQ b
I
N i i h- N N fn cN V) f/7 L/) Cn 4-3 r/7
Cli O O O Cn b0 O
'
O O C \\\\\\\\ N\
1
> Ln O rn fn fn Lf) V) rJ to
O C OV) V) C.
r•i Fes+ C -H � $-r
1
_
L •r X X N > > == > > > > > O
,,QOq
cc3 O Q Q V) i-1 O
'
i 4-) LAJ LLJ i •O L L i L L• 0 .O .0 C) .G
a
1
O+1 d QQ¢ OGQQGQ rQ
O
V) F•+ Mr -4 r -r I•+ W •rl >. b0
'
L N U U
_.4 :� •q •q �,,,� .� �,,,� •�
1
1
0) �•r •r i i E i r r r C)r r r r• r- i C) r-
•r r r > > •r O •r •r •r •r •r •r •r •r •r > > •r
�"
-0
0 0���U�-_UU
E°yaE°yzE�t�E_L)1144=z
;
zmaa0 UL -)F-
1
1
t
1
W
'
1
t
Ori %C n t� qIld, w4T Ln \O 00 r -I
'
M M ct Ln lD t�, r -i .--1 N N 1� Ct1 M
Q
rl-i NN NN N M
I
ra•'•rMNNr m r•1•--Irr.-r.--i NNNNNNN
vr)ri
r r r 1 r r r
I
I i l l i l l l l l l i l 11l l l l
���..)��-„)�..)r„)�,,,��,..)�r.,1
1
NNNNNNNNNNc”,NNc\11NNNNNN
Q
11
}
Z
O
a
W
m
O
0
S: i L L L
M N N N M
Vf to N N N
Y Y Y Y Y
1
►-�
ro ro ro ro ro
I
d
I
M N N N M
S
I
H
1
O000u')
O
tf) C Ln U') N
I
C C
1
•r •r
1
E E
i
O o
ui
c
1
C C C c
•r •
E i
1
I
•r • • • • • • • •r •r • • • • .r
E L L L i L i L E E L i L L i E L i
Lf')
1
Ln Lo O U)
N
1
R*- qZr --4N.1MMKrrn CnMMN.-•1
I
1
I
I
1
1
W^
1
^ ^^^ N N N
n
Y
I
1
S
to N N N YYY
Y Y Y Y r r r
r-
I
U
r r r r ro ro ro
Z1
-JI +.� }t
Q
41 4 -)4
Mm M
aI
N
1
N MctM
I
Z1
F-
O O
1
Z
OOII)OOL(7OLn l0 -4rn000O LnOct
W
N OC\j;
C)
N CD ::t �Nq.-+ri .-iO�-'r mm --�
I
�
1
a
'
1
1
t
1
I
1
•r •1•�
1
Y +-)
M
1
N •r
ii
W
_>)
1
•r 3 Z
4-) +J
i
4J a) Ili +-3 Y 4J +-) +) +J+ Y Y +J +J +) +-) Y 4J
LL
•r •r
i
•r Z r •r In •r •r •r •r C71 N N •r •r •r •r •r •r
O
1
�\ CJ» C��� �•r C C��.G� > B
U.to
N
1
N >)-0 to O (n N (n N r O O N N (n N C (n
aJ a)
1
a) ro •r () i a) a) a) (1) s L L (3) a) (V a) ICS a)
I
^
I
I
v
i
•
,
�. O C
Ut
1
UL •r
• C7)
1
• (T a) a) i-) r r r a
D •r
I
•r L U U ro 0 0 0 (n
••=
1
S "� C C r- U 0 0 0 a) O
I
() O O O O O = -r- = = F-
L
I
L • +) Lt_ Li O O O U U U O d
ro L
1
ro S- (n c s s N (n W (n (n Ln V) 2 a)
4J
4J r) ro 4J +-I U U U +•) +) +' L C
(/)
t
N W C C (N Ln V) >> >> > 3 3 3 .0 ro J
t
1
L •r •r 0 0 +' O a) a) a) Q)
(J) +-
I
0) +-) (O E E 10 -0 10 U U'- U •r •r •r = N
O
C O
1
C O +W L L 0 0 0 (A Ln C Ln >>> ro� E
•r
1r)
aL
ICS Cl)aN ) 0 0 0 O S S L C C
C
1
C E CL (= 3 3 3 r r EE U U U ro a) C7)
i >> >> (Z a Y Y Y L L E S. L L L> L r-
O r
�a-
1
I
�r�c r ro a) (V ro ICS ro • •r O •r •r •r •r (p ro •r
2_ a3 da00000CDu(DmmmUaa
1
1
1
1
2 �i�� � 4�
ice( >>
I
>>C +��� U
Q) 4J
i
a) -- W a) () a a) a) a) a) a) a) 41
4- Q)
1
4- a 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- ro
ro •r
1
ro •r a ro ro ro ro ro to ro to ro 3
N U
I
(/) U ICSNLnN(nN+) N N NN
\ O
1
\ O J \\\\\ a) \\\-V
v
a) N
N
1
I
a) N a) a) a) a) a 4- m a) () a) O a)
0 C N N N N N to C N (n N O V1
O C
I
O C •r O> 0 0 0 V) •r > 0 == O
-0•r
1
•r .a -0 a .D -0 � .G M M L
a
Q�,
Q000Q QQQo Q
LQw
m U N 'D"o"as Ln
O-0
r• r
1
•- • r N r r- r r r >,, i >> L r- r r (T C71 r
•r r
I
•r r- S-
0 rot .0 LLL •r O ro 0 -C C a) i s
0
Ud
I
UdUUUUUUmHM F-UUUZMU
1
1
1
1
W
'
1
H'
f�- co
1
N N M CJ) N C1 Ln l�- (T
QNN
1
9--1N(pr-4(T(O^r4r4r4r4NNNNNNN
1 1
I
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
N N
1
M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M M
Q
S: i L L L
M N N N M
Vf to N N N
Y Y Y Y Y
+J +•) -W
4j+jYY +W
r •r •r •r •r
O > >
V1 N C C N
a) a) ro ro a)
Z Z S S Z
+�-( 4-) �
4- 4- 4 -
cc to ro
N N N
N (n N
> > O
Q Q Q
N N -O
r O O •r
t L i L L
N M M -c:t d•
I I I 1 1
ci'-c:rCFI'll Rd,
•-
►-�
ro ro ro ro ro
d
Q
M N N N M
S
H
O000u')
O
tf) C Ln U') N
1-4 ri 1-4
+J +•) -W
4j+jYY +W
r •r •r •r •r
O > >
V1 N C C N
a) a) ro ro a)
Z Z S S Z
+�-( 4-) �
4- 4- 4 -
cc to ro
N N N
N (n N
> > O
Q Q Q
N N -O
r O O •r
t L i L L
N M M -c:t d•
I I I 1 1
ci'-c:rCFI'll Rd,
a
1�
W
w
z
M
O
1
1
1
t
C c c
1
E E E
i
O O O
W
C C C C C
,
1
M M M
C C
. • • • •r' • •f- • •r' • • •r • •1-
L L L L i E i E i L E L i E L E
I
I
• • • •r • •r
L L L E L L E L L L L L i
t�
1P) to to U-) O
I
Ln Ln t
47 N N cr N f�)
1
V" N N -Cd- r'-1 r4 tf N LO Ln .� .-4 �,{ M
r
1
1
1
1
tJ-t
i
a
W
N Vf
Y Y
1
1
N to N N N
Y Y Y Y Y
as
V
r r
1
r r r r r
z
to
to ro ro to
x
4-.) 4
i
i-) 4-3 d-) ;„t 4)
a
� N
1
N Ln L!') -01 M
1
OZ
W
LnOOLf)00a) LI)Lf)InCn00ONN•-+O
CONLr) MV LDrl riri N
t
It�NMt�
Z �t �tr-0Ou>OO) Ln U)OOOO
NNLnLr) OM
r•i
I
r+ N N N N
i
1
1
I
I
I
I
I
•r 4-5
1
V)
Y 4-)
1
L
C
1
i
W
o )
3 Z
\ \
t
1
x
X
4Y+J�4-3Y4-3+»-le ��4-3Y C) i�
1
C 4=\ YY 4)4-)4) Q) (1)4)4-)
•r •r•r•r•r V1•r•r•r LI) •r•r•r Nr•r
1
f� •r tT tT CTN N•r •r •rrr •r •r
•r •r •r C 0) O
■
L1 -0.0 C .0 .C.0 C -0 -0.0 C CT -0
N C Vl VI fn 0 VI 0 0O V1 Vf 0 N
1
1
E .0 pC -0 .0 -0 .O
L (A r r r C i
Q) 'o a)ii
O m O O O i O O CU L W Q) Q) •r O
1
Q) O C s t L 1 O Q)
1
1
l
1
O O .0 •^ O O
1
0 0 0 0 0 0
O O U •r O
1
^^ 0 0 0 0 0 0
LrL L aL; 4-) .0
1
• • L CLLL.0
U O U O O • O td U
I
U U L)
C'; C;
V)
1
VL)
Q N N
O O O
Q) U Q) N U N U-CC7 E 'a r C)
I
^ 2 vv Q) N N N (fl N N
C N C Y to i> C N LLJ O 0)
1
N •
to ro m CL O O L O •r
I
?� Q) U 4) 0 V) ro r r r- r r (C
J 3J0•rt i N� Q) CT3 S Q)
I
O C O O J•r•r•r•r•r J
Q) •-- U Ur •r Q 41 r O CC Y
1
CC O= O V{ 2 2 S S 2
E •r E C r i 0 •r •r •r C O t6 tC{
1
-J U Q) L L +)
+
'r"' i •r O •r 0 3 0 3 C A L L) J
I
+ Ln tp row +) ) ) L
N +) ++) +
O
S- t L •r r- QQ O 2 C= Y\ •o ro
1
L S C�� .r C) Q) W O C) ro
C
M U IT N CL C r O E a t\ r- N V1
L 4--1 i-) •r >) VI
1
W U Y � 3 E In N N N N t
O L S- L O • • S C C C C C U
r L '- LA r 3 (L E C)
•r •r •r 4-3 O •r Q) i O i r�, (A .0 to to
1
I
•r to b •r L 4) +) U O O O O O to
I1 codmLnm3ZC-7UUM-4U3 m
I
F- 0- CZ M LnCntnCnLnLnCnCn N
I
1
1
%>
>1>1>1�� �
Z •� U U+) +1 +) U U U U
1
U ��-) U4-)4J�4-34J4J
Q) d 4-) -P O N N i-� +) i-) +)
1
+)C) Q) +) Q) C) Cl) C) Q) C)
4- 4- to M 4- 4- N 4- m fu to M
1
O 1- 4- m 4- 4- 4- 4- 4- O-
ro to 3 3 ro ro as ro 3 � 3 A 3
1
3 �, ro to a m mro tts to ra
V) V) V) Ln r Ln ++>
1
O +) N N to to Ln In to V)
\ \M M V1 \ O M •a C) TI
1
d QJ
Q) O O ME Q) = CTO O O •r 0
I
C) 'D 4- O Q) O C) Q) w C) CU Q)
v
0 rn O O C C O O O U o
1
O O to 0 O 0
> > .0 L •r t6 > >1•r .0 t .0 O .0
1
L Q' N >> t O O O O O O
) ) i i i N L
4J r .0 ++
I
L p L a 0 0
a
¢ ¢ o o4-3c:C 4-) 0 0 0 o
t
o Q) (v ¢Q oQ¢¢¢Q¢
� .G •r \ C •r .G � � C .L1
1
� r r .a
N•CLt N 4, N.Ct.0 •r .0
1
2C U U O �L•t3 �����
O•C
r FJ) r tJ) CT >14-- r tT Q tT L CT)
�
1
L-
O •r U U •r •r •r •r •r •r •r •r •r
:3
i L Q) Q) rots O r6 QJ Q) Q) O to Q)
I
O O •r •r O t
.0
U�UZZ.C�H0O0�ZZZF-J Z:
1
F- ZCflCaF•- UUZUUUUUU
U
1
1
1
1
W
1
1
00 �NMMcttCt)Ot17COLOCD
1
i
--tl� MN
Ln lf) M e -r •--1 ri •--I r -i •-•I ri T" -4 N N N N
I
.•'I N Ln I� 01 CT r t e -d 00 CX7 [71 N N
a
I i t t t l l l t l l l l l i t
1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
to In LI') L!•) to Ln L!') LA u7 t17 l!') LC) Lf') lI')
Ch
Z
O
a
J
W
w
z
D
O
HN ri ri r-4 V••r N
c c c c
•r
•r •r •r
E E E E
O O o O
W
M M M M
!-
L i i i i i
Z
L L L L L L
HN ri ri r-4 V••r N
U U U
rot! r4C ?s 3 3 3
NN4->
\ Q) 'C 'C
(L) � O O O
rn (n to 0 0 0
> > N L L L
L L
a¢ Q CV O O O
r L .G
�� ULLL
•r •r U •r •r •r
L L •r 4) Q) (L)
U U m Z Z Z
W
M CV)
QN N N N N M
1 1 1 1 1 1
0
Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln
c c
•r •r
E ES
Ln Ln
WO, 4cr N
W
4J
00
tw
LC
Z
!-
a
Z
NN
OZO
Ln Ln o0 O Ln
W N M N r -r �4 ri
LLr
N •r •r •r
L c•rLLL
LLr/1
0 r O N (A
a
U U U
rot! r4C ?s 3 3 3
NN4->
\ Q) 'C 'C
(L) � O O O
rn (n to 0 0 0
> > N L L L
L L
a¢ Q CV O O O
r L .G
�� ULLL
•r •r U •r •r •r
L L •r 4) Q) (L)
U U m Z Z Z
W
M CV)
QN N N N N M
1 1 1 1 1 1
0
Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln
c c
•r •r
E ES
Ln Ln
WO, 4cr N
W
4J
00
-as
LC
W
W
V4)•\
NN
4) 4->+)
LLr
N •r •r •r
L c•rLLL
LLr/1
0 r O N (A
O LL Q) CU Q)
O
Z3•ZZZ
U U U
rot! r4C ?s 3 3 3
NN4->
\ Q) 'C 'C
(L) � O O O
rn (n to 0 0 0
> > N L L L
L L
a¢ Q CV O O O
r L .G
�� ULLL
•r •r U •r •r •r
L L •r 4) Q) (L)
U U m Z Z Z
W
M CV)
QN N N N N M
1 1 1 1 1 1
0
Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln
c c
•r •r
E ES
Ln Ln
WO, 4cr N
W
1
00
-as
U U
�
NN
�L
IL
c c O O Y
roro ZZro
J J J
y 0 0
r 4-)
OQ)
i i •r ro ro �
ss3cc•E
U U O
ro ro i 0) (1) U
0
N N Cn LL. LL. N
U U U
rot! r4C ?s 3 3 3
NN4->
\ Q) 'C 'C
(L) � O O O
rn (n to 0 0 0
> > N L L L
L L
a¢ Q CV O O O
r L .G
�� ULLL
•r •r U •r •r •r
L L •r 4) Q) (L)
U U m Z Z Z
W
M CV)
QN N N N N M
1 1 1 1 1 1
0
Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln Ln
c c
•r •r
E ES
Ln Ln
WO, 4cr N
W
1
1
�
1
1
Z
Ln tC N 1
Z
(%j r-+ CO
.-� N 1
O
1
M 00
r••r N N
1 1 1
tO tO to
•-r co CT
1 t 1
c
•r
E
O
•M
C C
•r ••r
EE
O O
M ri M
L
4j
oO
E to
a s
U
Y ro
tzLn
m ~ 4J
a r
rNj }a
Ln tD
1 1 1
co CC) Co
z
W
a
a
W
0
a
W
m
O
U
Ix
W
m
W
F�-
d
W
N
S
z
O
2
I
1
1
1
1
c c
•E •E
1
1
O O
• • •
1
• . . M . • M
W
C.
c c c c
I
c c c c c
L E E L E L E
I
L L E L L E L L E L E E L L t.- L L. L i
Ln U-) Ln Ln
1
OU-) LLQ O O
Iwo
•--t � � N Ct .-1 R '
1
M r -I M r- 4 1-4 � N v-4•� •--4 M M N N rti N N
1
I
1
1
1
1
W
1
' `
1
W
N N
v
1
m
Y Y
1
C)
r r
Z
I
U
4-)
1
O
a
1
M N
1
Z
I
f -
O Ln000Lnt.D
I
Z
OOLnmLnNq::tNmtf)NInLnOLnMM O
W
M MtiM m.-
LC) ON Ln M N OM rtR* 00M-4 r -t
I
H
I
1
I
a
I
1
1
1
I
1
U •r
1
c Y
1
4-3
i
C
1
o
Wfa
J 3
1
Q)
\ \
I
Z Q)
4-3 4-) 4-) 4-t 4)
1
\ •r 4-) 4-) 4 •r 4-3 4) 4-) U 4-3 4 >> 43 •r 4-)
4 -)i -)4J
4-3 4-J4JY4J4-J4J C4)4J Q)4J-le Y+�
•r •r •r •r •r •r
I
•r C7) N •r M.- •r N •r •r •r Q) •r -r r •r •r to •r
LLLL a L]
1
>•r cam• --0 CLL i.pL CnL > CL
L
000000U.
1
C r O to r- N N O N N N O to o-aN c O to
Q) Q) Q) Q) Q) Q) Q)
1
t0 L L Q) L Q) Q) i Q) Q) Q) tp Q) ty •r Q) t6 L N
O
ZZZZZZS
1
S=� Z=ZZS ZZZJZZtYZS3 Z
1
i
1
1
�
1
U r-
1
• t� O
1
O L
1
• 4-) O L U
N
I
i CL r- O S U Q)
r N
1
''7 Q tO O O N 1-
O •r N r
1
N •r L Q N- Q 1
O t0 r r
1
4J r- .X L U O .O r- CLO >1 L
CLL
ii
L r •r
U H .0 •r" N S N
1
1
N to L Q) N fn N S () O r- O O) S to O
CO i •r Q) 4-) 2 4-3 U r •r t1 •r L r -
N O S 4) 4-)
to r- O r O
1
1
W Q) L7 i O O 'O N O O tC U S S t- d N U
-0 U ox: O N O 'O r- C r- fn N
3 U a 0 to O
i
m RS L U O O U •r G. Vs C O mQ) O to
O
O O L U •r U
1
4-J L Q) 3 to +, 3 L (n N .-C L 4-) 'O L L •r
O OL N tO Lr) L (n
1
M Cn O O N C U Y Y C -r L t6 Q) Q) U C
CC3
0- C L Q)
Y •r O U L CLL
1
1
N C r r- •r (L) r- O (L) (O to N r C m
>>'O O r L L Q) -0 L Q) (1) to E_ >) C1 M-0 3
_3
O U J N U U
I
CL U3 L) U) = LD U U Y m u_ -c Y
1
1
I
1
L L L
1
L >) >> >)
U U >) U
I
U 4) 4-) 4-) U O D U c U 4-)
4-3 4,) 4-) 4-)
1
4-) Q) (LQ) 4) U 4-) 4-3 W 4-) Q)
•>33
3 �^fu•a)y
I
>,3 ry t`+o to 4)3 33 to
N N to (1) L m N
O O
1
O -a \ \ .--a Q) 'O 'O J 'O
O N O
1
4- O Q) Q) 0) U O In 0 0 O O
v
4'O
Oa O O
to O to c O O O O C O c O
N Ni
Li
c- i O r
t
LL.r
L -a +t L 4J >
a
O La_ O O
1
Q) O c 0 •r 0 0(n O 4.3 Lt_
r L L W.0
1
r L •r' •r L C .G .O L -0 •r
OO
L L U L
O M- L
1
I
N U L 'C-0 N C +> =-C= Q)L to to Q)
L >) C» i t r- >) (A 0) 4- tT Q) CJ) m >> E
L•r •r •r r- •r O
U Q) L Q) O O O
1
I
O O U •r O •r •r .n 3 •r Q) •r •r i •r O L •r
L O.- Q) O L L m m Q)
V)F-1
GF--mZ1-UUmJZI--UZZUZ�o�U
1
1
1
1
W
1
t
1
OOOtGoONMMt-n LntOC10
r -i Opq*%D I,-
t
Lt)M wm mrt r-ir-ir-ir-tNNNNNNNNM
Q
N
1
1 1 1 I 1
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
m 0) 01 Q1 01 Q1
1
r-/ r-1 r -t r -t r -i r1 rt 1-4 •-i r -t r -t -4 .-i r-4 1-4 r -i -4
Q01
1
1
1
1
•
1
.
•r
E
1
.,.1
8
LCA
1
to
.�
W
.r . . ..r . . . . •
sst rssss
1
.0 .L .z.s=��
o LO
I
try O
-4 r! rl .-4 N .--1 . q
ICN
1
1
Q'
I
W
Z
CO
1
W
W
W
�
1
Z
W
�
I
w
V
�
U
W
••
1
A
,
{S
a
•
I
H
Z
a
O
Z
1
0 0 0 �O 0 0
Q
I�MOO000cfr�CDL)
I
'
a
1
r
1
W
a
'
1
�
1
C +.)
t
tp to
I
r• •r
1
LC
N cr
1
W
o e
Z
U
1
1
4-1 .r •r }-) +)•r i-) •r
1
JJ �J iJ 1J rl
O
4-)Y Y �C i-) 4J 4 i-) Y i-)
I
11 JJ JJ ♦J x
C C C C G
1
rl .O G r>
v1 0 0 N Ln N O to O N
i
y L m m m O >, G
CU i i 4J N 0) Z O i 4J
1
c
Z Z Z 3 Z 3 Z
Z 3 3z
I
z z Z
A 3 x
3
I
a'
+J to
1
Z •
1
'.1 ,.1 In
J
p
E O N
�I
1
0 0 0 $s
Q
O O x O
o�
cd u�
W
o
bo
v E
w
r N 4- = d
1
4J G1 m O
N 4 ' O C iN-> N N L
ccco H x fA fA d U1
N to O Y = 7 Y In U
1
� .b y� y> }J
tiiOU3ro�OUoS-3
0
1
•r- U N C CO y t/� U O
I
>Nv30OH0
M
ii
4 •r S- "0
1
m m 0. C V] G t/]
'R
Q) -0 r•
4J W i N i N •r
C) UC3-4UUMCC3
1
�
moi
U U + $4 .G .O !U) -0
U
N N U W U Q U
I
�
1
Z
'
4-3 4-) U 4-) U
1
JJ JJ U U rl
4) JJ
o 4- 40- rO 4- ro
I
.4 4-4
N 3
i
ca 3 3 � a
roo cn to >-jy
rnQ, a•r O C7no
0
o C N Z O C O
1
1
61
a m O O u m
L•r O O C .r L
1
.0
O- +) -0 U O i +-) Z
1
3 Z== W i 0
r.
H4-)
6 d n
IL+
Q O LJ_ 04-)O
1
0 I6
O
�•r N •r
N QJ .0 N .J=
I
1
'd 'C7 .1r .a b G m
O
4-.0 = •r- C •r =5 •r •r
1
ri rl r1 rl -H M C
mmOsbiow a,
I
C. sr w w= O s+ m
V)M-UO]UF-Z.C'OZ
;
U U 2 Z U H 6 Cn
1
1
1
W
t
1
OONCO
NM%0P.- NNNN
1
11 I I I I I I
1 1
I l l i l l l 1t l
1. 1
i
N N N N N N N N
.-i r! r1 .--1 .� r r1 .
I
-4 _4 .-_, .-r -4 .-4 -4 .--i
Bosses: Don't Be Nasty hand Other Tips
For Reviewing a Worker's Performance)
IV CAROL HYMownz
Stqff Reporter of Tfu wAia. STP.EET JovxNAL
Richard Dugan has learned a lot about
appraising an employee's performance
since a staff member broke down in tears
under his criticism. "I've really botched
this," he recalls thinking.
Mr. Dugan, managing partner of Ar-
thur Young & Co.'s Pittsburgh office, says
it took a long time for him to learn how to
give "helpful criticism without being
nasty." Now he says he isn't afraid to tell
an unsatisfactory performer, ",'You'll
have to do this and this to succeed here or
you should perhaps consider another kind
of work.' It's my obligation to give guid-
ance. And most employees don't want a
nice guy, they want to know where they
stand."
A majority of employees believe their
bosses botch appraisals of their work, if
they give reviews at all. Psychological As-
sociates Inc. of St. Louis, surveying 4,000
employees at 190 companies recently,
found that 70% believed review sessions
hadn't given them a clear picture of what
was expected of them on the job, or where
they could advance in the company. Only
half said their bosses helped them set job
objectives, and only one in five said re-
views were followed up during the ensuing
year.
"It's a tough job, the equivalent of
walking up to a person and saying, 'Here's
what I think of your baby,' " says Robert
Lefton, president of Psychological Associ-
ates, a consulting company that has pro-
vided training on how to give reviews to
over 100 large companies. "It requires
knowing how to handle fear and anger and
a gamut of other emotions, which a lot of
managers aren't comfortable with," he
adds.
Increasingly managers must do a better
job of appraising employees—not only to
help employees mature but to increase
productivity and company loyalty. Com-
prehensive performance reviews also re-
duce the chances that a fired employee
who has been warned of unsatisfactory
performance will sue the company.
Employees have a right to expect a per-
formance review at least once a year, per-
sonnel experts say. A manager should lis-
ten to an employee's self -appraisal before
offering his own evaluation, then give a
balanced picture of the employee's
strengths and weaknesses, discuss differ-
ences and offer specific suggestions on.how
to improve. And he or she should work
with the employee to develop goals.
. These guidelines are simple enough and
yet often forgotten by managers in the
thick of a review. Mr. Lefton of Psycholog-
ical Associates recalls observing one chief
executive who talked nonstop for three
hours to a senior manager during a re-
view. Then he turned to Mr. Lefton and
said, "Aren't we having a great ex-
change?"
Before doing reviews, managers must
analyze their styles of confrontation, Mr.
Lefton believes. Some managers take a
"let me tell you approach," imposing their
A majority of em-
ployees believe their
bosses botch reviews of
their work, it they give
them at all. `You don'
want to inflict pain,
says one boss.
of an employee, not the employee him-
self.
"If you bark, 'You have a bad attitude,'
to your receptionists, for example, you'll
likely find yourself facing a very defensive
employee. You'll probably get better re-
sults if you say, 'When someone steps up
to your desk, I'd like them to get the dis-
tinct impression that you're delighted to
see them.' "
Of the outstanding employee who has
one minor flaw, such as repeatedly —i
Ing staff meetings, experts say don't ig-
nore the problem. Instead, they say, con-
front the employee in a positive way ("I'm
concerned about this"), state the conse-
quences ("The group isn't getting your
views") and then ask for help ("What can
we do about this?").
Reviews shouldn't contain many sur-
f prises, such as springing new standards on
employees, says Jerome Abarbanel, man-
ager of organization and management de-
velopment at General Electric Co.'s Credit
Corp. unit. A GE manager in one case
planned to give an employee who did out-
standing work only a satisfactory perfor-
mance rating because he asked too many
questions. But Mr. Abarbanel says that
rating is unfair unless the employee knew
in advance how much his boss valued inde-
pendence.
Personnel experts also have tips for
what not to do during a review. Don't try
to become a therapist to employees with
marital, drinking or other personal prob-
lems, they advise managers. Instead, refer
those employees to programs within the
company or to outside help.
It's also best not to discuss salaries dur-
ing reviews, they say. For one thing,
whether or not an employee gets a raise of-
ten depends not only on his performance
but on the financial condition of the com-
pany and the economy, and wages paid by
competitors.
When Monsanto Co. years ago tied com-
pensation to a structured review process in
which employees set their own goals, "we
found it didn't work," says Mr. Reass. Em-
ployees, afraid to set goals they couldn't
meet, instead set easy -to -reach goals. "We
found we were sealing our own medioc-
rity," he says.
Often the most helpful advice an em-
ployee can receive during a performance
appraisal has to do with his personal
standing in _ the company. Mr. Reass at
Monsanto says he is still grateful to a boss
who criticized his style of speech. A native
New Yorker, Mr. Reass says he has "a
Brooklyn accent that comes on strong
when I'm under pressure or am tired." His
boss told him: "Watch that accent of
yours. It doesn't go across well in this Mid-
western company."
own ideas without regard to subordinates.
Others mechanically go through the paces
of a review but, their underlying message
is that discussing performance can't make
a difference, and they offer no solid infor-
mation to employees. And then there are
managers who say, "Gee, everything is
great," and avoid all problems.
Bosses admit they are often reluctant to
criticize an employee's work. "You don't
want to inflict pain," says an executive of
a Midwestern manufacturing company.
She agonized for weeks about what to say
to one employee who was "technically ex-
cellent but threw temper tantrums and
was obnoxious to work with."
Anxious to avoid a fight, she finally
gave the employee a choice. "I told him,
'you will have to change the way you be-
have, or if that's difficult for you or you
don't want to change, I'll give you a sever-
ance package.'" He chose the sever-
ance.
Other managers must tackle employees
who won't listen to criticism. When Bob
Reass, manager of strategic operations in
sales at Monsanto Co., told an employee to
better manage his own subordinates, the
employee became angry and the review
session turned into a screaming match.
Mr. Reass suggested a "cooling -off pe-
riod," which proved the best solution.
When he reconvened the review session
several days later, the disgruntled em-
ployee apologized.
Marilyn Moats Kennedy, managing
partner of Career Strategies, a manage-
ment -consulting company in Wilmette, Ill.,
says it's important to critique the behavior
NOTES
PLYMOUTH FORUM
January 21, 1985
PRESENT: Mayor Davenport, Councilmembers Crain, Vasiliou, Schneider and
Neils, Public Works Director Moore and Assistant City Manager
Boyles.
Mayor Davenport announced that Mr. George Wilson had elected not to attend
the Plymouth Forum meeting as invited.
He welcomed Mr. Vern Peterson and Mr. Howard Hunt. Howard Hunt stated that
his problem is that no one accepts responsibility for the maintenance
problems in the Elm Creek area. When he approaches the City, the City
refers him to the Storm Water Management organization, which refers him to
the Department of Natural Resources. Because nothing happens, sedimentation
continues to grow worse in this area and the drainage problems become
exacerbated. He wants to see some form of progress.
Fred Moore stated that 90% of the problem Mr. Hunt is experiencing is in
Maple Grove. Fred has talked to Gerry Butcher, the Maple Grove City
Engineer, who, within the next week, will be proposing a maintenance project
to the Maple Grove City Council. This storm water drainage problem is
complicated by the fact that Elm Creek is a natural waterway. The City
Attorney states that it is not the City's responsibility to maintain natural
waterways. The City must obtain permission for any areas of maintenance.
Howard Hunt stated that he believes the storm sewer improvement district
funds should be appropriate for providing Plymouth's portion of partici-
pation in the Maple Grove project.
Fred Moore stated that at least two options are available. The first is
that the City will attempt to enter into a joint project with Maple Grove.
If Maple Grove rejects this proposal, the only other option is for the
property owners to bring suit.
Mayor Davenport asked that the following actions take place:
1. The Public Works Director should write a letter for the Mayor's signa-
ture to the Maple Grove Mayor outlining Plymouth's position with
respect to this matter. The letter should encourage Maple Grove to
enter into a joint project with Plymouth in order that this problem
can be resolved, as well as outlining the legal aspects of the
question. Finally, the letter should encourage prompt action since
work on this project must be gompleted before Spring.
2. The Council should be provided with a copy of the letter and this item
placed on the agenda for February 4 for a status report.
Howard Hunt stated that he was happy with this proposal provided that
resolution of the problem stayed on track.
GF
A
Dear
GENE FRANCHETT 6 ASSOCIATES
January 9, 1985
With increasing frequency you, your council and your -staff
are called upon to deal with one or more of the metropolitan
agencies as well as the state legislature. Would you like to have
your city become more effective -in dealing with both of these
institutions? Would you like to have your people know more
about how these systems work?
If the answers to these questions is yes, then I invite you
to join me in a seminar in this second series on how to deal with
metropolitan agencies and the state legislature. You will learn:
how to get the greatest impact for your efforts, how metropolitan
decisions are really made, and how to turn what may appear to
be a hindrance into a help to your city.
You will gain insights on how to more effectively work
with the Metropolitan Council and state legislature. Interestingly
the strategies and techniques for dealing with both are similar.
You will benefit from my several years as Metropolitan Council
Executive Director, as well as my experience directing the
legislative lobbying of the League of Metropolitan Municipalities
and the Association of Metropolitan Municipalities. In short,
you will increase your city's effectiveness.
Participants at the December seminars commented consistently
that the seminars were very informative and very helpful.
Enclosed are information/registration material for you,
your staff and council persons, to be distributed to them as you
deem appropriate. Registration forms should be returned at
your earliest convenience. Attendance is limited.
Thank you. I hope you choose to benefit from one of the
seminars.
Sin )erel'y,,-
e 7`ranchet
.O. Box 24311 . Minneapolis, Minnesota 55424 . (612) 925-0727
P5� 10 BACK BY REQUEST
INSTITUTE FOR METROPOLITAN STUDIES
presents a
SEMINAR
HOW TO WORK WITH
METROPOLITAN AGENCIES
STATE LEGISLATURE
for local officials and others who work with the
Metropolitan Council and the State Legislature
... Learn to use your power
... Improve your effectiveness
... Find out how to impact decisions
... Learn to get your point across
... Find out who to see for what
SEMINAR to be conducted by GENE FRANCHETT
Executive Director of the Metropolitan Council
from 1979 to 1983
and
Executive Director of the
Association of Metropolitan Municipalities
from 1972 to 1974.
Thursday, February 21
9:00 a.m. to 12:00 Noon
Holiday Inn -Roseville
2540 Cleveland Ave.
Roseville, MN
(Southwest of 1-35 & Hwy. C)
TWO LOCATIONS:
SEE OTHER SIDE
Saturday, February 23
9:00 a.m. to 12:00 Noon
Holiday Inn -Plymouth
3000 Harbor Lane
Plymouth, MN
(Northwest of 1-494 & Hwy. 55)
OLSON, G STD SERAN, Ltd.
31 ' Bulldlnp
LAW OFFICES 730 and Avenue South
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402-2473
612 339-8846
Ms. Laurie Houk
City Clerk
City of Plymouth
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, Minnesota 55447
Re: Notice of tort
Dear Ms. Houk:
Our office represents Clarence and Marilyn Gordon, of
410 Zinnia Lane North, Plymouth, Minnesota, in connection
with the tort claim set forth below. By this letter I am
serving you with the formal notice of such claim required
under Minn. Stat. §466.05.
On or about August 17, 1984, the City of Plymouth
caused the destruction of two blue spruce trees and one fir
tree, which were located on the Gordon's homestead at 13513
County Road #15. The destruction of these trees occurred as
a part of the City's expansion and construction of County
Road #61. The City was in the process of acquiring the
Gordon's homestead for this project.
It is our belief that the City had no authority to
enter upon the Gordon's property and to cause these trees to
be destroyed. We therefore demand treble damages for such
destruction, pursuant to Minn. Stat. 9561.04, in the total
amount of approximately $30, 00.
Please see that this notice is forwarded to the City
Council or other appropriate body, and keep us advised of
any developments. If no action is taken within the next
couple of weeks, we will be forced to begin legal proceedings
to protect the Gordon's interests.
Very truly yours,
OLSON, GUNN AND SERAN, LTD.
Y ,
Bradley J, Oun i
BJG:tlb
cc: Clarence and Marilyn Gordon
Wayne H Olson Alonzo B Seran Harold H. Sheff Bradley J Gunn
Richard J. Gunn David R. Knodell Michelle J. Ulrich
January 23, 1985
Gary Mittelbusher
11525 37th Ave N
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Mr. Mittelbusher:
I
CITY OF
PUMOUTR
Mayor Davenport has forwarded your resident feedback form to me for review
and comment. Your concern deals with snowmobiles running along 36th Avenue
to and from French Regional Park. It is my understanding that the regional
trail along the east side of Medicine Lake will not permit snowmobiles
or horses on this portion of the trail. It is the County's intention,
I believe, to limit the trail corridor to cross-country skiing, jogging,
walking, biking, etc.
I will forward your concerns to them so that they are aware of them when
they begin planning and implementing this regional trail corridor. I also
assure you that you will be notified with regard to any future planning
meeting about this subject.
I appreciate that you took the time to attend the
that you found it informative. If I may be of any
please do not hesitate to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
/np
cc: gimes G. Willis
Marty Jessen
town meeting. I hope
help in the future,
34-7(-; =LY MOUTH BOULEVARD °LY MOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE ;6?2 559-2800
January 23, 1985
Steven Smarjesse
10020 31st Ave N
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Mr. Smarjesse:
S
CITY OF
PLYMOUTR
Mayor Davenport has forwarded your resident feedback form to me for review
and comment. On your form, you have indicated that you would like the natural
area at the end of 29th Avenue to remain and the City not to develop a road
in this area. You would prefer the City to purchase the property for preser-
vation. At this time, the property which you are addressing is not indicated
on the Comprehensive Park System Plan as a future site for acquisition. I'm
sure you are aware that there are literally hundreds upon hundreds of small
wetlands and basins throughout the 36 square miles of Plymouth. If the City
were to attempt to purchase all of these areas, we would have a tremendous
capital investment in these particular wetlands. The normal procedure for
saving these wetlands is that the developer is required to dedicate these areas
for storm water holding basins at the time of platting. The developers are
also restricted by all rules and regulations of the Water Conservation District
and the Department of Natural Resources.
Our comprehensive trail plan does not contemplate a trail running through this
particular area. This would commonly be referred to as a Class III area where
we designate residential streets because of their low volume and low speed
of cars. This allows for safe bicycling, jogging and hiking on the roadway.
If, for some reason, a street was deemed not appropriate to be built in this
area, but that a connection was still desirable, I'm sure at the time of plat-
ting of the vacant property, the City would give every consideration to explor-
ing the possibility to build such a trail.
I'm sorry that I cannot be more encouraging at this time, but I'm sure you would
rather that I be up front with you and explain that I think the chances are re-
mote that the City would purchase this property for a preservation area. I
can assure you that I and members of my staff do everything in our power to
influence the preservation of wetlands when we are reviewing residential
and/or commercial sites throughout the City.
Thank you for taking the time to attend the town
found it informative. If I can be of any help in
hesitate to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
meeting. I hope that you
the future, please do not
/np
cc: Ja es G. Willis
n pt_ ( MOUTH BOULEVARD, PL(YOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE 612) 559-2800
January 23, 1985 CITY OF
PLYMOUTH+
Steve Loe
11500 38th Ave N
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Mr. Loe:
Mayor Davenport has forwarded your resident feedback form to me for review
and comment. Your form indicates that you are in support of the City's
plan to help the Hennepin County Park Reserve District develop a regional
trail along the east side of Medicine Lake. I hope the Park Reserve
District, within the next few months, will begin preparation of concept
plans for the development of this trail. I will forward your comments to
them, so that they will be aware of your preferences. I also will keep
your informed of any future planning and review meetings that will be held
with regard to the planning for this regional trail.
Thank you for taking the time to attend the town meeting. I hope that
you found it informative. If I can be of help in any way, please do not
hesitate to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
/np
cc: gimes G. Willis
Marty Jessen
3400 P_ O.IOUTH 50ULE`J4RD. PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE ;512) 559-2800
January 23, 1985 �s CITY OF
Audrey Friedman PLYMOUTR
2500 East Medicine Lake Blvd.
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Ms. Friedman:
Mayor Davenport has forwarded your resident feedback form from the January
14 town meeting to me for review and comment. The concern that you raised
in your feedback form deals with the east beach asphalt bicycle path and
the play area. In designing this area, we were attempting to come up with
an area that would not only be attractive and pleasant, but also functionally
useful for the pedestrian and bikers using this particular area. Part of the
raised platform area that is completed at this time, is designed for the
installation of bicycle racks. We have tried to space the bicycle racks
around the beach and play areas so that we do not end up with one large
parking area for bikes dominating any portion of the park. The issue
of safety is another matter and a valid one. Although to date, we have not
experienced any particular difficulty or had any calls or complaints on the
safety of this area, we will proceed this spring to sign both the bicycle
trail and the pedestrian boardwalk to notify people that there is a crossing
ahead, and that they should be on the look -out for children crossing the
bike path. I will ask my beach staff to monitor this situation with regard
to the path and the cross -walk. If it appears that we do have a serious
safety problem, I would not hesitate to consider re -constructing the bike
path in a different location.
Thank you for taking the time and effort to fill out the resident feedback
form. I hope that you found the meeting productive. If I can be of help
in the future, please do not hesitate to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
/np
cc: gimes G. Willis
400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. °LYMOUTH MINNESOTA 554-17. TELEPHC'JE �312i 5592000
January 23, 1985
CITY OF
Louwanna Kl uck PUMOUTR
2660 East Medicine Lake Blvd.
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Ms. Kluck:
Mayor Davenport has forwarded your resident feedback form to me for review
and comment. In reviewing your feedback form, your concern deals with the
future development of the regional trail along the east side of Medicine
Lake. Primarily, you are concerned with snowmobiles and horses. It is my
understanding of the regional trail going southerly from 36th Avenue along
the east side of Medicine Lake, easterly into Golden Valley and Theodore
Wirth Park, that this portion of trail will not permit either snowmobiles
or horses. It would, therefore, be limited to walking, biking, cross-country
skiing, rollerskating, etc.
In the months ahead, we do expect Hennepin County Park Reserve District to
begin preliminary concept plans for this regional trail. I will forward
your name and concern to them, and I assure you that you will also be
contacted with regard to the public meetings which will be held to discuss
and review all plans with regard to this regional trail. If you have any
further questions, or if I may be of help in any way, please do not
hesitate to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
/np
cc: 4,Ja'mes G. Willis
Marty Jessen
',;T' PLYMOUTH POULEVARD RLYMOUTH MINNESOTA 55-147. TELEPHO".= 512) 559-2_,-D
January 23, 1985
y CITY OF
Steve Muck PLYMOUTH+
2660 East Medicine Lake Blvd.
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Mr. Kluck:
On your resident feedback form, you discuss the problem of trash on Medicine
Lake. In the past, we have attempted to make barrels available at the
entrances to the lake in hopes that those people going to and from the lake
will deposit their trash in a proper manner. Your concern is a valid one
and has been raised by Medicine Lake residents at our task force meetings
with regard to the use of Medicine Lake.
I'm sure you can understand that the users of Medicine Lake come from many
different locations, and that it presents an almost insurmountable problem
with regard to enforcement in our efforts to get people to comply with
proper rules of behavior. Whenever groups have contacted the City for
permission to hold ice fishing contests on the lake, one of the conditions
is that they supply proper trash containers for disposal of all of their
debris during their event. We then follow up the next day, at the con-
clusion of their event, to make sure that the portion of ice they were
using was left in a clean manner. With regard to the issue of debris
left by the ice houses, this again is a subject which the DNR has discussed
at our Medicine Lake Task Force Committee meetings. They do have a staff
member who attends all of our meetings, and at this winter's meeting, we
will once again address this issue and try and come up with a solution
that will be more practical and helpful to all those concerned.
If I can be of help in any other way, please do not hesitate to give me a
call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
/np
cc: GCames G. Willis
3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD PLYMOUTH, MiNNFSOT^ 55441'. TELEPH.C14E :12� 559 28C
January 23, 1985
Florence Larson
2930 Medicine Ridge Road
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Ms. Larson:
CITY OF
PLYMOUTFF
Mayor Davenport has forwarded your resident feedback form from the January
14 Town Meeting to me for review and comment.
Your concerns dealt with a number of matters, but the one that I will address
is the regional trail issue. Because we have talked on numerous occasions,
and I know you are well aware of all the trail corridor plans and other
issues involved with the east side of Medicine Lake, I'm afraid there's
very little information I can share with you in this letter that you do
not already know. As I stated at the Town Meeting, I hope that the
Hennepin County Park Reserve District will have a concept plan prepared
for the regional trail along the east side of Medicine Lake sometime in
the next three to four months. I know you are very concerned regarding
this issue, and, therefore, I will make every effort to communicate
with you if and when the County proposes a plan, so that you and the rest
of your neighbors will have an opportunity to review and discuss proposed
plans with the Park Reserve District and the City Council.
I would like to take this opportunity to personally thank you for all
of your efforts to beautify and enhance the environment along the east
side of Medicine Lake. If we had more residents as caring and dedicated
as yourself, we would certainly not be experiencing some of the careless
acts that we experience around the lake.
I'm glad that you had the opportunity to attend the town meeting, and I
hope that you found it informative and worth your time and effort. If I
may be of any help in the future, please do not hesitate to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Parks and Recreation
/np
cc: udames G. Willis
Marty Jessen
3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. r-LYMCUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE X5112! 559 2300
January 24, 1985
CITY OF
PLYMOUTR
Katherine Weaver,
3720 Evergreen Lane
Plymouth, MN 55441
Dear Ms. Weaver:
Your resident feedback from from the January 14 Town Meeting has been
forwarded to me for review, and comment.
The area you refer to is known as Upper Mission Park, which is currently
undeveloped. Early this past summer, the City did plant bare -root
shade trees in the park, and, unfortunately, due to lack of maintenance
personnel, watering was not done on a consistent basis, and several
trees died. These trees are scheduled for replacement in the spring
of 1985, and we anticipate that a regular watering schedule will be
followed to assure their successful growth.
Thank you for calling this matter to our attention and for taking the
time to fill out the resident feedback form. I hope you found the
Town Meeting informative.
If I can be of any assistance to you in the future, please feel free
to give me a call.
Sincerely,
Eric J. Blank, Director
Park and Recreation Dept.
cc: James G. Willis—
Steven J. Cook
3400 PLYkIOUTH BOULEVARD. P'-YMOUTH, ".11NNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800
Carlson ComfiWJ7ieslnc.
Nfar�(dfif�aof�ua�l�rs, LVM _%*/5/*hmvy_V MWAM a% c .Vinnesda MW
January 21, 1985
Mr. Jim Willis
City Manager
City of Plymouth
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, MN 55447
Dear Jim:
As we discussed on the phone, I would be willing to serve on the
Plymouth 2000 project per the request of Mayor Davenport and
yourself. I think the progressive attitude that Plymouth has
in looking at the future, potential issues, and problems and
solutions is most admirable.
I would be honored to serve in this group, and since you have
told me the time involved would be "moderate" that certainly is
helpful.
It's our feeling at Carlson Companies that Plymouth is not only
a progressive city, but one that responds and plans for both
problems and solutions. The Carlson Companies shares a group
commitment to the continuing growth and well-being of the City
of Plymouth, and I consider it an honor to be asked to serve on
this Plymouth 2000 project and hope that I can be of some assis-
tance in providing help in the future need of our community.
As your letter stated, the group would be organizing the spring
of 1985, I look forward to hearing from you when we can begin
our project. I will also be thinking about both the ideas you
outlined in your letter to me and possible individuals or organi-
zations that could be used for resources and be invited to a full
day seminar in the future.
Best wishes and warmest regards.
n
Si_ dereZ,
�6
I -- -
Paul Ridgeway
Director of Environmental Development
612/540-5223
PR/hm
CC: The Honorable Dave Davenport
Curt Carlson
• ;T�
CITY C�
PUMOUTR
January 22, 1985
Mr. Jim Kemp, Chairman
District 284 Board of Education
Wayzata School District
P. 0. Box 660
Wayzata, MN 55391
Dear Jim:
Congratulations on being elected Chair. I especially
appreciated your comments about moving forward and mini-
mizing the role of personalities in your deliberations.
I trust you will give it your best and I hope that each
and every member of the Board will join with you in a
renewed spirit of cooperation.
Please acc t A -b t wishes.
1 /
Sincerey,
David J. bavenport
Mayor
DJD: cap
cc: Dr. Shirli Vioni
3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 559-2800,
r�
IMUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION
' 1985
I
LEGISLATIVE PLATFORM
11
1
'7900 Xerxes Avenue South
MUNICIPAL Suite 1500
LEGISLATIVE Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
I
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
METROPOLITAN GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY
LEGISLATIVE ISSUE:
' 1. Creation of a Legislative Commission on Metropolitan
Affairs
' The MLC supports legislation which would create a Legislative
Commission on Metropolitan Affairs. The duties of
the commission would be to review plans and policies,
' annual work programs, budgets, and reports of the Metropolitan
Agencies, Boards and Commissions; to oversee and report
on the activities of the Metropolitan Agencies, Boards
' and Commissions; to study and make recommendations
it deems appropriate to assist the legislature in formulating
policy and legislation affecting metropolitan affairs;
' and to review and evaluate proposed legislation affecting
metropolitan affairs. The committee would be comprised
of members from each chamber of the legislature.
I
POSITION:
The Municipal Legislative Commission endorses legislation
' creating a Legislative Commission on Metropolitan Affairs.
The MLC deems a separate commission as a positive step in
providing accountability to the legislature for Metropolitan
' Commission and Agency activities. The MLC urges that the
membership be made up of members of the House and Senate
from the seven county metropolitan area. In the alternative,
the MLC urges the leadership in the House and Senate to
' re-establish a full Committee on Metropolitan Affairs.
LEGISLATIVE ISSUE:
2. Elected versus appointed Metropolitan Council.
There has been recent discussion regarding the merits
of an elected Metropolitan Council versus the present
process of appointment.
POSITION:
The Municipal Legislative Commission opposes the creation
of an elected Metropolitan Council or any zther elected
metropolitan agency or commission.
1
I
L( MUNICIPAL
LEGISLATIVE
COMMISSION
LEGISLATIVE ISSUE:
3. Metropolitan Council Operating Entity
POSITION:
7900 Xerxes Avenue South
Suite 1500
Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
(612) 338-6610
January 1985
The Municipal Legislative Commission opposes any efforts
by the Metropolitan Council to expand its role to the extent
it become a metropolitan government operating agency. The
MLC believes that the Metropolitan Council should adhere
to its original charge of being a planning and coordinating
agency for issues of metropolitan significance.'
LEGISLATIVE !SSUE:
' 4. Legislat-ive Oversight of the Metropolitan Council's
Budget
' The current funding mechanism of funding the operations
of the Metropolitan Council falls entirely on the property
tax. There are no state tax dollars appropriated.
Although the mill levy is small it increases property
' taxes in the seven county metropolitan area by $23
million per year. Currently these dollars are collected
and spent without any other governmental unit providing
' an oversight function. This reduces accountability
and may lead to unwise and/or wasteful spending decisions.
' POSITION
The MLC supports legislation which would create a legislative
' oversight function to review and make recommendations on
the Metropolitan Council's budget. This oversight function
would increase accountability and assure that the property
tax dollars of residents in the seven county metropolitan
area are spent in a cost effective manner.
7900 Xerxes Avenue South
MUNIICl/�PAL7 Suite 1500
'
LEGISLATIVE
V E Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
STRUCTURAL AND ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGES
' AT THE METROPOLITAN WASTE CONTROL COMMISSION
Issue
1. Composition of the membership of the Metropolitan Waste
Control Commission
2. Wages and benefit packages of MWCC employees
3. Part-time chair
Position
1. The MLC supports legislation which would restructure
the appointments of members of the MWCC to require
' membership to be reflective of constituent communities.
2. The MLC supports legislation which would provide MWCC
employees with the same wage and benefit settlements
as other state and metropolitan agency employees.
Bargaining units for the MWCC should be placed under
' the jurisdiction of the State of Minnesota.
3. The MLC supports the continuation of a part -
time chair
of the MWCC and will oppose legislation which would
make this position full-time.
L
1
77
LJ
1
TMl1
MUNICIPAL
V 7900 Xerxes Avenue South
L �,1 ISLATI 7� L Suite 1500
Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION ( January
338-6610
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
STRUCTURAL AND ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGES
AT THE METROPOLITAN WASTE CONTROL COMMISSION
The Municipal Legislative Commission strongly supports legislative
action to restructure the Metropolitan Waste Control Commission
and its operations. The Municipal Legislative Commission has followed
and participated closely in the Boland Commission Study of the Metropolitan
Agency and strongly supports the adoption of -legislation which accomplishes
two major changes.
1. The Municipal Legislative Commission feels it is essential
that constituent communities be given membership on the
Metropolitan Waste Control Commission. We suggest that a
certain number of seats, at least 50 percent, be reserved
for individuals representing the constituent communities.
It is our firm belief that accountability can only be enhanced
when the communities which ultimately pay the bill for services
of the MWCC have representatives on the Commission.
2. The Municipal Legislative Commission strongly encourages
efforts in future contract years to align the MWCC wage
settlements with those of the State of Minnesota and other
metropolitan agencies, and suggests that MWCC bargaining
units be placed under the jurisdiction of the State of Minnesota.
We believe that legislation is needed to address the spiraling
costs of wages and fringe benefits which currently exist
at the MWCC and have the potential of drastically increasing
the operating costs of this agency beyond what we, the constituent
communities, deem appropriate.
With one exception, the Municipal Legislative Commission
endorses the recommendations made by the Boland Commission and encourages
legislation what will adopt those recommendations. The one recommendation
on which we disagree is the creation of a permanent chair for the
MWCC. It is our belief that the professional administration of
the agency will be best served by a citizen chair that is a member
just like the other members.
In conclusion, the Municipal Legislative Commission believes
that it is essential to effect changes in the MWCC organization
and structure to avoid disproportionate cost increases and to maintain
an agency which can effectively serve its constituent municipalities.
It is our firm belief that the changes suggested will make this
agency more accountable to its public and, of necessity, more efficient
in its operations.
L( MUNICIPAL
LEGISI.ATIVE
COMMISSION
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
I
Issue:
7900 Xerxes Avenue South
Suite 1500
Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
(612) 338-6610
January 1985
The Metropolitan Council is proposing legislation which
' has as its objective, the elimination of landfilling unprocessed
municipal waste by 1990. The Council proposes to do this
by requiring cities, townships, and counties to adopt ordinances
' by January 1, 1988 that would require homeowners, businesses
and others to separate recyclable materials from other wastes,
and prohibit the disposal of yard waste (leaves and grass
clippings) with mixed municipal waste. The remaining unprocessed
' municipal waste would be incinerated or converted to refuse
derived fuel by 1990.
I
POSITION:
Although the MLC commends the Council for being farsighted
regarding the solid waste disposal problems that will face
'
our cities in the future, the MLC must oppose this legislation
at this time.
Before mandatory recycling is imposed the MLC philosophically
believes that voluntary programs should be implemented.
Only if compliance is not achieved through a voluntary program
should mandatory recycling be considered. The MLC supports
landfill abatement but cannot support legislation which
mandates compliance prior to attempting voluntary efforts.
Should any additional costs for recycling programs be incurred
by cities, the levy for these expenses should be outside
'
the levy limits.
1
n
J
MUNICIPAL 7900 Xerxes Avenue South
Suite 1500
IL(
LEGISLATIVE Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
COMBINED SEWER OVERFLOW
Legislative Issue:
1. Funding of sewer improvement projects (separation)
to eliminate overflow problems due to combined storm
and sanitary sewer systems in Minneapolis, St. Paul,
and South St. Paul.
POSITION:
The MLC endorses the No Interest Loan Option that was developed
by the Metropolitan Council. Simply stated this option
would fund the cost of sewer separation by having the Metropolitan
Council issue $107.5 million in General Obligation bonds.
All principal would be repaid by Minneapolis, St. Paul,
and South St. Paul. The interest payments would be covered
by funds appropriated by the state legislature and the income
earned from investment of these funds. This option is restated
below:
1. The Metropolitan Council would issue $107.5 million
in General Obligation bonds. The bonds would be issued
over a 10 -year period in blocks of $10.75 million.
The bonds would be used to provide loans to Minneapolis,
St. -Paul, and South St. Paul for half the total cost
of separation.
2. An investment earning rate of 10 percent is assumed.
Each bond issue would be for a term of 20 -years with
a balloon refinanced for 10 years.
3. Two alternatives were examined. Under the first, 12
appropriations totaling $107.5 million would be made
by the state to cover the interest portion of debt
service. Under the second, five appropriations totaling
$48.4 million, would be made.
4. Minneapolis, St. Paul, and So. St. Paul would pay the
principal portion of the bond debt service in the form
of payments on their sewer bills, which would keep
it from being long-term debt to these cities.
' 5. Minneapolis, St. Paul and So. St. Paul would match
the loan funds with $107.5 million of their own money
over the 10 -year construction period.
LI
'7900 Xerxes Avenue South
MUNICIPAL Suite 1500
LEGISLAHV E Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION ( January 338-6610
1985
Minneapolis So. St. Paul
$7.7 million $2.6 million $.45 million
$4.0 million $1.375 million ---
$6.0 million $2.1 million ---
$13.7 million $4.7 million ---
$11.7 million $3.975 million ---
NET
IMPACT TO STATE, METROPOLITAN COUNCIL, MINNEAPOLIS,
'
ST.
PAUL; AND SO. ST. PAUL
'
Expenditure
State
state pmts)
The
state would appropriate $107.7 million over 12 bienniums
'
or
$48.8 million over 5 bienniums out of the General Fund
to
cover the interest on the loans.
state pmts)
Metropolitan Council
Total (12
a.
If the state failed to appropriate money to cover the
interest, the Council would have to cover it using
(5
state pmts)
regional property taxes.
b.
The Council would issue $10.75 million in bonds per
year for 10 years.
The
Cities
Cities
maximum annual cost would be:
Minneapolis So. St. Paul
$7.7 million $2.6 million $.45 million
$4.0 million $1.375 million ---
$6.0 million $2.1 million ---
$13.7 million $4.7 million ---
$11.7 million $3.975 million ---
'
Matching Annual
Expenditure
Maximum Loan (12
state pmts)
Repayment
(approximate)
'
(5
state pmts)
Total (12
state pmts)
(5
state pmts)
Minneapolis So. St. Paul
$7.7 million $2.6 million $.45 million
$4.0 million $1.375 million ---
$6.0 million $2.1 million ---
$13.7 million $4.7 million ---
$11.7 million $3.975 million ---
1
MUNICIPAL 7900 Xerxes Avenue South
Suite 1500
LEGISLATIVE
ML( Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
MINNEAPOLIS CONVENTION CENTER FUNDING
Legislative Issue:
1. Proposed metropolitan tax on liquor and lodging to
help finance the $145 million convention center in
downtown Minneapolis. This tax would apply to hotel
and motel rooms and to liquor sold by the drink in
the seven -county metropolitan area.
D-ci 4-i -
The Municipal Legislative Commission opposes the proposed
seven -county metropolitan area hotel/motel/liquor tax to
finance the convention center.
Legislative Issue:
2. A one percent sales tax increase in the metropolitan
area to pay for the convention center in downtown Minneapolis.
IPosition:
1 77
1
The Municipal Legislative Commission opposes any type of
seven -county metropolitan tax dedicated to finance the convention
center.
1
MUNICIPAL
ISL LEGISLATIVE
COMMISSION
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
INDUSTRIAL REVENUE BONDS
Issue
7900 Xerxes Avenue South
Suite 1500
Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
(612) 338-6610
January 1985
Minnesota's Industrial Revenue Bond allocation formula.
Position
The MLC supports legislation which will assure an orderly process
by which the state's $150 per capita Industrial Development Revenue
Bond allocation under the Federal Deficit Reduction Act can be allocated
between state and non -state agency bond issuers. The Minnesota
Federal Limitation Act of 1984 should be amended by the 1985 legislature
to:
1. Eliminate all unnecessary recording and administrative
procedures that place an unreasonable burden on cities;
2. Entitlement communities should be permitted to apply
for competitive pool funds after preliminary authorization
is given to the entire municipal allocation. Under
present law entitlement communities may not apply for
funds from the competitive pool until its entitlement
allocation has been sold;
3. Eliminate the 19 point criteria established by the
1984 law for ranking requests for competitive funds
and replace with a first come, first serve philosophy
for bond requests that otherwise meet state and federal
statutory criteria. Should the point system be retained
by the legislature more weight should be given to population
and cities should be allowed to continue trading allocations
under a joint powers agreement;
4. Amend the statutory deadlines enacted in 1984. The
present September 1 deadline for entitlement communities
should be advanced to July 1 to give communities sufficient
time to apply, receive approval, and sell competitive
pool funds. The deadline for applications for competitive
funds should be lengthened by one month, from October
20 to November 20.
The above position statement is almost identical to the position
taken by the Municipal Caucus. The MLC is in general agreement
with the Municipal Caucus' position on the Industrial Revenue Bond
' formula and will be working closely with this group during the 1985
legislative session.
Ll
MUNICIPALISL L���
COMMISSION
' Issue:
1 1.
J
1
1
D^0; a-; -%r..
1985 POSITION STATETMENT
REPEAL OF LEVY LIMITS
7900 Xerxes Avenue South
Suite 1500
Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
(612) 338-6610
January 1985
Levy limitations imposed on local units of government
by state statute.
The MLC opposes levy limits and will support legislation
that repeals this state imposed limitation. The levy limit
law is not working. In fact, in certain instances this
law increases the amount a city will levy rather then limit
it. MLC members strongly believe their elected officials
have been accountable to their constituents. Property taxes
for city services will be levied at a level taxpayers will
accept or these officials will be removed from office.
Artificial taxing limits placed on local units of government
by the state are irritating and ineffective, and therefore
should be repealed by the 1985 Legislature.
MUNICIPAL 7900 Xerxes Avenue South
LEGISLATIVE Suite 1500
Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
January 1985
Issue
Anci i -i nn
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT ASSOCIATION
Recently there has been substantial controversy surrounding
the management of the Public Employees Retirement Association
(PERA). This controversy has shaken the confidence public
employees and retirees have in Minnesota's retirement programs.
Changes should be enacted by the 1985 Legislature to restore
the confidence of these employees by assuring that PERA
is managed in a competent and professional manner.
1. The MLC supports an amendment to the law which would
require PERA board members to resign if they no longer
work for the group they were appointed to represent.
2. The law should be amended to require minimum experience
and educational requirements for PERA's executive director's
position.
3. The MLC will oppose any change which would give PERA
the authority to invest any pension contributions.
4. The present law should be clarified to eliminate any
doubt that PERA is subject to the Minnesota Open Meeting
Law and the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act.
7900 Xerxes Avenue South
MUNICIPAL Suite 1500
LEGISLATIVE Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
�l
REGIONAL PARK MAINTENANCE & OPERATION FUNDING
1
Issue
1. State funding of regional parks for operations and
maintenance.
2. Source of funds for operation and maintenance costs.
3. Bonding for capital costs and land acquisition.
1
Position
' 1. The MLC opposes a state or regional appropriation to
defray the cost of operating and maintaining the regional
park system in the seven county metro area.
r2. The MLC opposes the use of a dedicated tax to provide
regional park funds.
3. The MLC supports the Metropolitan Council's bonding
request of $25 million for capital improvements and
land acquisition.
r
r
r
r
1
r
r
F
11
1
i
1
11
MUNICIPAL 7900 Xerxes Avenue South
LEGISLATIVE Suite 1500
IL( Bloomington, Minnesota 55431
COMMISSION (612) 338-6610
January 1985
1985 POSITION STATEMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENT AID DISTRIBUTION FORMULA
The present local government aid formula has become complicated,
unequitable and flawed state policy by rewarding inefficiency and
penalizing frugality. Therefore, a complete overhaul of the distribution
formula should be a top priority of the 1985 legislature.
Any new formula should be devised using the following general principles:
1. The formula should be simple. It should have clear
assumptions and be explainable to the average person.
2. The formula should be separate and apart from school
aids and aid to counties.
3. The formula should contain built-in incentives to promote
efficiency and provisions which reward or subsidize
inefficiency should be eliminated.
4. The formula should not be used to equalize local government
mill rates.
5. The formula should recognize differences in needs and
preferences. Flexibility of local government should
not be inhibited, but others should not have to pay
for such differences or exercise of such flexibility.
6. The formula should not be considered in a vacuum; it
should be considered in relationship with homestead
credits, federal, county and school aids, property
tax refunds, etc.
7. The formula should be equitable.
8. The formula should not be expenditure driven.