HomeMy WebLinkAboutCity Council Minutes 03-19-1990MINUTES
REGULAR CGUNCIL MEETING
March 19, 1990
The regular meeting of the Plymouth City Council was called to
order by Mayor Bergman at 7:03 p.m, in the Counc'1 Chambers of
the Cit! Center at 3400 Plymouth Boulevard on March 19, 1990,
PRESENT: Mayor Bergman,
Vasi 1 i ou , Zitur
ABSENT: None
Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker,
STAFF PRESENT: City Manager Willis, Assistant Manager 3uyl es,
Publ is Works Di rector Moore, Community
Development Director Tremere, City Attorney
Thomson, and City Clerk Rauenhorst
PRESENTATION
Mayor Bergman presented a $600 check
Warhol family for winning the "That's
recycling contest.
CONSENT AGENDA
a
t1 the Wallace and Mary
Not Trash, It's Cash"
Items 8-J (No Parking on various streets), 8-V (consultant
agreements), and 8-W (video equipment replacement) were removed
from the Consent Agenda.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
Councilmember Zitur, to approve the Consent Agenda as amended.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MINUTES
MOTION was made by Counc i I member Vasiliou, seconded by
Councilmember Zitur, to approve the minutes of the March 5
Council meeting.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
PUBLIC HEARINGS
Mayor Bergman opened a
of SuperAmerica #4341,
non -intoxicating liquor
was closed at 7:06 p.me
11
hearing at 7:06 a.m, on the application
5750 Nathan Lane Nortl,, for an off -sale
license. No one appeared. The hearing
Recycling Winner
Item 4
Consent Agenda
I tern 5
Minutes
Item *6
R
U
0
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 87
MOTION was made by Councilmeml)er Vasi1iou, seconded by
Cosincilmember Ricker, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-200 APpkOVING
OFF -SALE NON -INTOXICATING LIQUCR LICENSE FOR BIRCH BRU, INC.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
Public Works Director Moore uescr4';eo the proposed 1990 Street
Reconstruction Program. Thr Program was adopted b; the Council
ih 1988. This will be the secind year of construction.
City Engineer Faulkner reported that three public informational
meetings were held on the proposed $2.8 million program for
1990. Fifty-nine (13%) of the 458 affected property owners
attended the meetings. He outlined a report with residents'
detailed comments and staff responses. The 1990 project will
cover four districts (4, 89 10, 11) of the Street Reconstruction
Study.
Engineer Faulkner stated that all of the streets within the 1990
Program areas have been built to City standard widths, except in
District 8. Streets in Di stoict 8 also have no concrete curb
and gutter. It is propospd to totally reconstruct streets in
District 8 to a width of 33 feet (back of curb to back of curt)
and construct concrete curb 4^;' gutter. Drain tile is also
prcposed at low points. 1istrict 10 requires concrete curb and
gutter installation, as well as recor.'Xitruction, Districts 4 and
11 require r.-tconstruction only.
lick Moore, Short, Elliot, Hendricksc,n, explainer! that it is
more cost effective to maintain infrastructure rather than
allowing 'it to decline to a condition that requires complete
reconstruction, He stated that. Districts 4, 8, 10, and 11 are
in need of reconstruction in 1,190. The feasibility study for
the project determined what exactly reeds to be done to each
street to bring it back to excellent condition.
Sue Mason, Short, Elliot, Hendrickson, described the work
proposed in each district. She stated that construction would
be done from June through October, and she would be workinq
closely with the contractor and residents to minimize problems.
Engineer Faulkner explained she Street Reconstruction Policy
under which residents are assessed 3Ut, end the City pays 10';,
of the total project cost. Estimated assessments for a 100 foot
wide lot are: District H - $3,423; District 10 - $1,74-13;
Districts 4 and 11 - $923.
Manager Willis state) the exact amounts to be assessed will riot
be known until construction is completed. Residents will be
mailed notice of the exact assessment amount and the issossinent
hearing date.
RESOLUTION N0, 90-200
APPRUVIRG OFF -SALE
LIQUOR LICENSE FOR
SUPERAMERICA
Item 7-A
1990 Street
Reconstruction Program
Project No. 001
Item 7-8
L]
Regular Counc i 1 ileeti ng
March 190 1990
Page 88
Mayor Bergman opened the public improve"ent hearing at 7:20
p.m. on the 1990 Street Reconstruction Program, Project No. 001.
Stephen laumann, 3730 Trenton Lane, asked what the assessment
cost would be if the total cost were allocated to each property
in tre City. He stated that all residents should share in the
reconstruction coat.
Engineer Faulkner stated the cost would be about $150 per lot.
Bob Scri bror, 2015 Lancaster Lane,
is doing something to improve this
project. He presented a letter
Medicine Lake Blvd., also supporting
said he is glad the ".ounc i 1
area and is in favor of the
from Len Larson, 1?40 E.
the project.
Michael Ellis, 9610 25th Avenue North, stated the profosed
widening of 25th Avenue would cause a number of p oblems
including a less safe environment for children rnd increased
traffic.
Don Carolla, 3765 Trenton Lane, stated the total projec-: cost
should be spread to all properties in the City, rather than to
the adjacent properties, because the entire City will ultimately
benefit from the improvements. He suggested that an additiunal
amount be ass_ssed to each hos,sehold for the remaining ye.lrs of
the reconstruction program, and then discontinued.
Sharon Carolla, 3065 Trenton Lane, stated the street is damaged
partially due to school bus traffic, and her children don',: ride
the school bus. Therefore, the street reconstruction will
benefit other residents. She asked why the improvements are
necessaey when her street is usable.
Di recto l Moore stated the purpcse of the program is to bring the
street :ondi tion to an excellent cuodi tion with a 20y ear life.
Some st•eets only require resurfacing to regain this condition;
others require complete reconstruction.
Dennis Gatenby, 18001) 27th Place North, stated he has he d n .f
problem with his street that would necessitate the proaose;i
project and expenditure. He particularly stated his obje!:tion
to the addition of curb and gutter where none existed before.
Engineer Faulkner stated concrete curb and gutter is recommainded
because it would properly carry drainage water to the storm
sewer system and would prevent standing water and seepage into
the street subgrade. He stated it is difficult to get water to
drain with bi tumi no.is curb, in addition, concrete curb
preserves landscaping.
is
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Palo 89
Councilmember Vasiliou stated there H:*ve been previous
situations where the Council has allowed bituminous curb, She
asked if bituminous is still an option,
Engineer Faulkner stated bituminous curb is an option, but that
concrete is better for snow plowing purposes.
Councilmember Vasiliou asked wno is responsible for curb damage
done by a snowplow that is contrActed by the City.
Director Moore stated the contractor is responsible for sod and
property damage only,
Peggy Gatenby, 18000 27th Place Nc rth, stated reconstruction is
not needed because there is no large equipment or heavy traffic
on her street.
David Crozik, 18005 27th Place North, stated there is no problem
with the existing street and he does not want increased
traffic. He said the residents of 27th Place want to retain the
country setting, and presented a petition from residents opposed
to the project.
Dwight Charles, 1812 E. Medicine Lake Blvd., stated that curb
and gutter would not be an improvement to his property. He
owns property on 18th Avenue within a block of the proposed
construction and stated he did not receive notice of the
hearing.
Gary Mason, 2540 Lancaster Lane, stated much of the traffic on
Lancaster Lane is due to the apartments across from his home.
He stated the assessment formula 's not fair oecause his
estimated assessment cost is $32,,69 per month for a single
family home and the cost is $2.17 pets month for an apartment
unit on the same street.
Jack Patterson, 9600 24th Avenue North, stated if 24th Ave mje is
widener,, about 7 J percent of the large trees will be destroyed,
He explained that three homes are currently served by a gravel
lane and no improvement is desired,
Ann Oslund, 9605 24th Avenue North, agreed that no improvement
is necessary, She said 24th Avenue North would be dangerous as
a through street due to a sharp curve and Dill. Ms. 05',jnd
presented a petition from residents in favor of keeping the
dead-end on 24th Avenue,
Pat 3irois, 1470 Lancaster Lane, stet -ad opposition to wideninq
Lancaster Lane due to the potential atfact on the grade and
length of her driveway.
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Nage 90
Paul Camarote. 1''155 27th Avenue North, stated there was a
Poocensus at the informational meetings that no construction is
o,ssi red. He stated potential damage to curbs due to snow
pl wring is not a reason to require concrete rather than
aspnalt. Mr. Camarote asked why two years ago he was assessed
for the Dunkirk project and now 1s being assessed again. He
skated the assessment policy for reconstruction should be
changed by the Council 1f possible.
Director Moore stated Mr. Camarote was assessed for storm sewer
i.i the Dunkirk project because his property was benefited by
area drainage improvements.
Councilmember Vasiliou stated the assessment policy can be
changed by the Council, and that money earmarked for the
peoposed Community Center cou.d be used to pay for ail or a
portion of the reconstruction costs. She stated the Council
niaeds to rear what service levels residents desire.
Ouncilmember Zitur agreed that the reconstruction assessment
policy should be reviewed.
Kim Johannessen, 9535 18th Avenue North, objected to widening of
the streets. He stated trees will be lost that currently aid in
erosion control. and curb and gutter is not needed.
Roger Williams, 2745 Queensland Lane, stated he was informed by
the City engineering division last year that his street was not
planned for reconstruction. He has now received notice that it
is scheduled for 1990 reconstruction. Mr. Williams stated there
is one very large puddle in his street; however, It is not due
to street conditions. Water drainage has been a problem since a
watermain break. He noted that concrete curb and gutter does
not always resolve dralaage problems and cited the area of 36th
Avenue and Plymouth Blvd. as an example of poor drainage where
concrete curb ano gutter exists.
James A. Baker, 9540 24th Avenue North, stated that in 1984 he
petitioned to keep 24th Avenue North a dead-end street, and he
still feels the same.
Larry Carlston, 20SU Lancaster Lane, stated the adjacent
property owners will] prim,obily benefit from the improvements and
should be assessed for a portion of the cost. He has lived at
this residence for 17 years and this is his V rl,t assessment for
street improvement.
Carla Carl stun, 2050 Lancaster Lane, stated there is standi nq
wat-ar in the street. She does not want the street widened !coo
0
L
Reguisr Council Meeting
11brc h 19, 1990
Page 91
much and does not want additional traffic. However, currently
with one vehicle parked on the street, a second vehicle cannot
get through.
Tim Reece, 1800 E. Medicine Lake Blvd., stated nis property is
near the proposed 18th Avenue improvement and across from the
City beach. He asked if street parking will be allowed if 18th
Avenue is widened. He is opposed to allowing street parking.
Engineer Faulkner stated the street width would be narrowed at
some points to save trees. Parking on one side of the street
would be anticipated with the widening.
Mayor Bergman closed the hearing at 9:00 p.m•.
NOTION was made ' Counc i l wk i -iter Va si l i ou, seconded by Mayor
Bergman, that thi project be reeviluated by the Special
Assessment Committee and staff to Ponsider the information
presented at the hearing, and that a revised recommendation be
presented.
MOTION to amend the main -notion was
Ricker, seconded by Mayor Bergman, that
renotified of the date the project will
the Council, and that the Council will no
and gutter where no concrete curb and gut
made by Councilmember
affected residents be
next be considered by
support concrete curb
ter currently exists.
Councilmember Zitur stated he will not support street widening
to the point where large trees would be removed.
Motion to amend carried, five ayes.
Main motion as once amended carried, five ayes.
Attorney John B. Bellows Jr., 1075 Landwark Towers, St. Paul,
represented Richard Whiting's request for a conditional use
permit Vo exceed the height restrictions of the R-2 District for
a 7r' amateur radio antenna at 5780 Rosewood Lane (89104) (R?UO
88-5). Mr. Bellows explained many public service activities
Mr. Whiting has been involved in using amateur radio. He stated
Mr. Whiting has been nationally and internationaliy recognized
as a Lechnical expert.
Mr. Bellows stated that Mr. Whiting i
the high 'requency packet radio network
Federal Emergency Management Agency, ani
to participate in the project because o
the tooter, A retract -ala antenna is no
a named parts c i p Nnt in
establ i shed thro .gh the
he is currently unable
his inability to erect
a workable alternative
Table Action on 1990
Street Recons*buction
Pvogram
Item 7-B
Continued
Consideration of
Request for Condi-
tional Use Permit for
Amateur Radio Anter na
89104)
Item 8-A
s
0
Rtgular Counts1 Meeting
March 19, IW,
Page 92
bec&L-se the antenna must be above the tree line at all times.
He stated Mr. Whiting's original application was a substantidi
compromise because the mini num satenna height was proposed. A
number of mediation sessions haves been held between the Glynn's
and Whiting's since the last Council session and they have
agreed to disagree." No compromise was reached on the height.
Mr. Bellows reported on a Boulder,
no correlation between property
towers. He stated that legally the
restrictive means in considering the
Colorado, study that showed
values and amateur radio
City must utilize the least
application.
CounjIlmember Zitur asked about relevant court cases and the
mediation ss:ssions. Mr. Bellows cited some court cases and
described the conclusions of the mediation sessions.
Ri;:k Wati ti ng, 5780 Rosewood Lane, stated two mediation sessions
were held with West Suburban Mediation Services. A balloon test
was cor. ducted to determine the visibility of the proposed
tower. The test determined that the tower could be seen from
the Glynn's but the antenna would only be visible above the tree
line. Mr. Whiting st.ted he would be willing to reduce the
antenna elements by one-half to accommodate the Glynn's
concerns.
Barbara Whiting, 5780 Rosewood Lane, explained that amateur
radio is important to their family.
Donna Glynn, 5730 Rosewood Lane North,
Council would ,.revelop standards to insure
will not occur again. She questioned Mr.
an amateur rat.i t expert, in purchasing a
with 70' trees aed then fi n fl nn the need
and antenna such as that propose d.
stated she hoped the
this type of situation
Whiting's judgment, as
home on a wooded lot
to erect a radio tower
Attorney Thomson o pi ai ned His written opinion which was
previously presented to the Council. He stated there are
several federal court case. where it was determined that. the FCC
regulatiins prohibit tht City from unreasonably regulating
amateur radio operations. The City has the authority to
regulate amateur radio operations, but the regulations rm,st he
reasonable.
Counci lmember Vasi 1 l .)u asked : F the ,unci 1 could regulate the
height of the antenna.
Attorney Thomson stated yes, but in his opinion the antenna
height could be restricted only to a point where tha r is
still operable in order to ;eaionably ac:cogwdate the
l:
6
Regular Council Feting
Narch 1:. 1990
Page 93
Councilmembtr Ricker asked if the Glynn's were interested in
Nr. Whiting's offs:., to reduce the element% of the antrnna.
Mrs. Glynn stated the antenna wi 1 ; still obstruct their view.
She suggested in the futuNN the Council limit tower height to
35119 so that it is a person`s responsibility wten puochasing a
home to ensure that there are r,o trees :.igher than 3a' and the
radio will be usable.
Counci lwmber Ricker also suggested that the Council could
reasonably exclude a concentration of ontennos from a given
area. The key is the reac-onableness of the City reg0 rements.
NCTION was nude by rountilmember
Councilmember Helliwell , to adopt
APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE! PERMIT FOR
AMATEUR RADIO ANTENNA AT 5780 ROSEW000
Ricker, seconded by
RFSOLi1T;ON NO 90-201
RICHARD WHITING FOR AN
LANE ( 8x3104) .
Councilmember Vasiliou stated she is very di sapp„i nted that a
person wotil d fore the negative effects of this use on a
neighbor,
Further discussion ensued relative to the decrease ;n the
antenna array (number of elements reduced froT 7 to 4)0
NOTION to amend the main motion was made by Councilmember
Ricker, seconded by Councilmember Helliwell, that the a nten:!.,
array be decreased to four eloWnts.
MDtion to amend carried, four ayes, Vasiliou n. -y,
Cor;ncilmember Zitur stated he is concerned that Mr. 'Whiting's
real for informed the Whitings any amateur radio antenna desired
wool J be allowed. He thanked the Whitings •ind Glynns for
partici pati ng in the mediation process.
Councilmember Vasiliou stated recourse, is available for
homeowners rr:eivi ng false i nfen"mation from real tors, Perhaps
In more situations the homeowner should seek rNcsiurse from the
realtor, rather than relying on `h(% City to correro. the problem,
Main motion carried on a Boll call vote, four ayes, Vasiliou
nay.
Director Tremer! presented the staff report on the Preliminary
Plat/General Devel opmr°nt Plan and Rezoning appl i Za ti on of Hans
Hagen Hames for property located at the southwest corner of
Dunkirk Lane and County Road 24 (89U9,)), He state.: the Planning
Commission foijnJ that the design Features of the plat involvinq
direct access to County Road 24 end NP jai na Road, i ne ;)mpl ete
RESOLUTION N0, 90-201
CCRDITI I PER T
FOR RICHARb WHITING
FOR RADIO 'NTENNA
6 104)
It*m 8-A
Pre' . V1 at/Rezor, nq
Hans Hagen Homes
144040)
tem R -H
I
6
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 94
right-of-way at the, proposed intersection
Medina Road; and design it -consistent with
Element of the Comprehensive Plan were
recommendaticn .
of County Road 24 anti
the Parks and Trails
reasons for a denial
Director Tremere states the Planning Commission wants the
Cnuncil to be advised of their determination that alignment of
County Road 24 and Medina Road is critical to the orderly
development of the property south of Medina Road on either side
of proposed County Road 24; that the intersection can be
determined without predisposing where County Road 24 crossct
Highway 55; and therefore, the Planning Commission recommends
that the determination of that intersection be undertaken as
part of the study of Medina Road,
Hans Hagen explained his development proposal and presented a
revised layout. He stated that County Road 24 is likely to be
realigned. Mr. Hagen stated that ultimratels Garland Lane should
be conn 2cted to Medina Road, which couldn't be accoM 1 i shed if
County :toad 24 is not moved. However, Garland Lane coy i d be
moved north with temporary access to existing County Rodd 24.
He cited the benefit of this to Mr. Dahl who platted nearby land
but who is constrained due to lack of easements. Mr. hagen
requested that the Council consider allowing one access from his
development to County Road 24,
Mr. Hagen requested that final action on his application be
deferred and that it be remanded to the Planning Commission with
direction for approval of temporary access through the Dahl
property, Medina Road aligned as proposed, and one access to the
commercial property to the north between CcAunty Road 24 and
Medina Road. The matter of trail location should be whatever is
best for the City, but the preferred location i s on the north
side of County Road 24,
Lee Bakewell, 1846 Delaware, stated development in the area will
be heavily impacted by the chosen County Road 24 alignment, Ha
believed the issue should bp studied as there are possible
alignments other than the one suggested by Mr. Hagen,, Mr.
Hagen's proposal may require construction of interchange ramps
on develowd property, He presented an alternative concept and
encouraged the Council to direct further study of the road
design.
Manager Willis stated a traffic analysis of the intersection
area is needed, The public interest would be better served if
the City undertook a study to determine vhat options are
available. Then the affected property owners could advise the
Council of their interests,
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 95
Dave Dahl 4255 Kin sview Lane, stated he i s the owner and
developer of Plymouth Meadows. He said expediting the process
to determine the most appropriate location of the "ounty Road 24
and Medina Road intersection wil', assist him and other affected
developers.
Councilmember Vasiliou questioned the process for a study of the
intersection, and how long the study period would be.
Manager Willis responded that a study would involve Hennepin
County, Minnesota Depar'cment of Transportation, and Department
of Natural Resources (DAR). Mr. Hagen's proposal could be
approved, denied, or defeMred until the study is completed.
Mr. Hagen stated in 30 days he will lose the option to the
property. He believes his development will work whether or not
County Road 24 is realigned because the alignment of Medina Road
is certain.
Manager Wfillis stated it is staff's opinion that the alignment
of Medina Road is not certain and that is one of the reasons for
more detailed study.
Bill Pritchard, Orrin Thompson Home;, stated he has no objection
U Mr. Hagen's proposal, but encouraged the Council to conduct
efurther study on future alignment.
Director
by state
City can
requested
Tremere stated t
law to act on the
extend the time
deforral.
hie Council is under a time constraint
preliminary plat application, but the
for review and action since Mr. Hagen
Mr. Hajan reiterated that action on his application be deferred.
MOTION was made by Councilmember
Councilmember Zitur, to defer actio.
application to the Planning Commis•
before the Council aad the need for a
1n this area.
Vasiliou, seconded by
id to remand Mr. Hagen's
n noting the discussion
tiidy of the road layout
Motion carried on a roll call vote, foiir ayes, Helliwell nay.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by Mayor
Bergman, to authoriz.: establishment of a study to review area
road alignment issues of Medina Road/County Road 24
i ntersec ti on.
Motion carried, five ayes,
6
C!
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 96
MOTION was made by Councilmember Zitur, seconded by
Councilmember Vasiliou, to adopt ORDINANCE NO. 90-05 AMENDING
THE ZONING ORDINANCE TO CLASSIFY CERTAIN LANDS IN THE NORTHWEST
QUADRANT OF BERKSHIRE LANE AND COUNTY ROkD 9.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Zitur, seconded by
Councilmember Vasiliou, to adopt RESOLUTION N0, 90-202 APPROVING
LOT CONSOLIDATION/DIVISION FOR TRAMMELL CROW COMPANY FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED NORTH OF COUNTY ROAD 9 AND WEST OF BERKSHIRE
LANE (90005).
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Zitur, seconded by
Councilmember Yasiliou, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-202A
APPROVING SITE PLAN FOR TRAMMELL CROW COMPANY (90005).
Mahon carried on a roll call vote, five ayes .
MOTION was made by Councilmember Zitur, seconded by
Councilmember Vasi;tou, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-203 SETTING
CONDITIONS TO BE MET PRIOR TO PUBLICATION OF ORDINANCE REZONING
LAND LOCATED IN THE NORTHWEST QUADRANT OF BERKSHIRE LANE AND
COUNTY ROAD 9 (90005).
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Zit1Jr, seconded by
Councilmember Vasilou, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 9U -203A SETTING
CONDITIONS TO BE MET PRIOR TO FILING AND REGARDING LOT
CONSOLIDATION/DIVISION AND APPROVING VARIANCE FOR TRAMMELL CROW
COMPANY FOR PROPERTY LOCATED NORTH OF COUNTY ROAD 9 AND WEST OF
BERKSHIRE LANE (90005).
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, Seconded by
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90 -?04 APPROVING
PRELIMINARY PLAT FOR EIDEN CONSTRUCTION, INC. (90006).
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmemher Ricker, Seconded by
Councilmember Vasiliou, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-205 APPROVING
FINAL PLAT AND DEVELOPMENT CONTRACT FOR MADPATT ENTERPRISES FOR
FISCHERS POND (89039)0
Notion carred on a roll call vote, five ayes.
ORDINANCE N0, 90-05
BERKSHIRE LANE AND
COUNTY ROAD 9
90005)
Item 8-C
RESOLUTION NO, 90-202
CONSOLIDATION/DIVISION
FOR TRAMMELL CKOW CO.
90005)
Item 8-C
RESOLUTION NO. 90-202A
APPROV14G SITE , AR
FOR TRAMMELL CROw CO.
MOW
Item 8-C
RFSOLUTION NO. 40-203
BE MET PRIOR TO
PUBLICATION
90005)
I tern A -C
RESOLUTION NO, 40-203A
BE MEI PRIOR TO FILING
90005)
Item 8-C
RESOLUTION NO, 40-204
APP G PRELIMINARY
PLAT FOR E lf)FN
CONSTRUCTION (9000b)
Item *A-0
RESOLUTION NO. 40-205
APPRnVI FTM -1y[ -AT
AND DEVELOPMENT
CONTRACT F Oh F I SCHFRS
POND (89034)
Item A-E
1
0
6
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 97
MOTION was made by Councilmember Ricker, seconded by
Councilmember Vasiliou, to adopt RESOLUTION 40. 90-206 SETTING
CONDITIONS TO BE MET PRIOR TO FILING OF AND RELATED TO FINAL
PLAT FOR MADPATT ENTERPRISES FOR FISCHERS POND (89039).
Notion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was
Councilmember
ASSESSMENTS,
ADDITION.
made by Councilmember Ricker, seconHed by
Vasiliou, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-207 A;OPTING
PROJECT N0, 027, WATERMAIN AREA - FISCHERS POND
Mot'on carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Ricker, seconded by
Councilmember Vasiliou, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-208 ADOPTING
ASSESSMENTS, PROJECT NO. 026, SANITARY SEWER AND WATERMAIN
1"TERAL PREVIOUSLY DEFERRED - FISCHERS POND ADDITION.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-209 ADPROVING
FINAL PLAT AND DEVELOPMENT CONTRACT FOR LYMAN LUMBER COMPANY FOR
PARKVIEW RIDGE (88018) (RPUD 88-3).
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made b
Councilmember Zitur,
CONDITIONS TO HE MET
FINAL PLAT FOR LYMAN
RPUD 88-3).
y Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
to adopt RESOLU'ION NO. 90-210 SETTINri
PRIOR TO FILING OF AND RELATED TO PPUD
LUMBER COMPANY FOR PARKVIEW RIDGE W018)
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
Attorney Michael London, representing Jerome and Betty Beqin,
requested ttat their appeal of the Buard of Zoninq Ruling
02-03-90) be deferred to April 16,
MOTION way made by Counci',member
Councilmember Zitur, to defer action on
o1 Zoning ruling (02-03-90) by Jerome
Ili as requested.
Motion carded, five ayes.
Vasiliou,
the appeal
seconded by
of the Board
and Betty Begin to April
RESOLUTION NO. 90-206
3ETTI G CON9TTIONS TO
BE MET PRIOR TO FILING,
89039)
Item 8-E
RESOLUTION N0, 90-207
ADOPTING 1olERT
FISCHERS POND (89039)
Item 8-E
RESOLUTION N0, 90-208
ADOPTING ASSESSMEN
FISCHERS POND (890301
Item 8 -E
RESOLUTION NO. 90-200
APPROVING FINAL PLX7
AND DEVELOPMENT
CONTRACT FOR PARKVIEW
RIDGE (88018)
Item R -F
RESOLUTION NO. 90-210
SETTING J
BE MET PRIOR TO FILING
83018)
Item R -F
Defer Appeal of Board
of Zoning Ruling for
Jerome Arid Betty Regi n
02-03-90)
Item 8-G
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 98
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION NO. 90-211
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION N0, 90-211 AUTHORIZING RELEASE OF SITE
RELEASE OF SITE PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE FOR RIC -WIC INVESTMENT FOR PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE
MINNEAPOLIS GLASS COMPANY (A-789). FOR MINNEAPOLIS GLASS
CO, (4-789)
Notion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes. Item *8-H
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION NO, 90-212
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-212 DECLARING ACCEPTING PETITMVW,0
ADEQUACY OF PETITION AND ORDERING PREPARATION OF REPORT, STREET ORDERING REPORT.
LIGHTING - STEEPLECHASE 7TH ADDITION, STREET LIGHTING IN
STEEPLECHASE 7TH ADDN.
Motion carried r,n a roll call vote, five ayes. Item *8-I-1
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION N0, 90-213
Cnonciia*mher Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO, 90413 RECEIVING RECEIVING REPORT AND
REPORT ANU ORDERING PROJECT - STREET LIGHTING, STEEPLECHASE 7TH ORDERING PROJECT -
AODITIOW, STREET LIGHTING, IN
STEEPLrCHASE 7TH AOCt',
Notion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes, Item *8-I-1
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION N0. 40-2141
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt REsnLIITION NO. 90-214 DECLARING ACWTING PETITTMFVTn
ADEQUACY OF PETITION AND ORDERING PREPARATION OF REPORT, STREET ORDERING REPORT,
LIGHTING - FOX RUN SAH ADDITION. STREET LIGHTING IN FOX
RUN 5TH AW I T I ON
Motion carried on roll call vote, five ayes. item *8-I-2
MOTION was nide by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION NO, 90-215
Councilmelaber Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-215 !L:CEIVING ` ETVIRG REPOR77A
REPORT AND ORDERING PROJECT - STREET LIGHTING FOX RUN 5TH ORDERING PROJECT -
ADDITION. STREET LIGHTING FOX
RUN 5TH ADDITION
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes. Item *8-1-2
Councililember Vasiliou asked why placement of "No Parking" signs
is recommended as requested by residents in several areas, when
Installation was riot done in response to a previous request near
Green Oaks l irk
Manager dill:; stated the previous request by Green Oaks park
residents was to only prohibit parking for park users, not area
residents, The residents did not desire "No Parking" that would
apply L(- everyone,
MOTION was made by Co:incilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTinN NO, qO-216
Coul.ci lmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-216 APPROVING 7LFPROVTI4;''No -p711ZRTAI;"
Tlit PLACEMENT 1jF "NO PARKING" SIGNS ON VARIOUS STREETS, SIGNS
4otion carried oi, a roll call vote, five ayes,
teen >1
r;
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 99
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION NO. 90-217
Councilmember Zitur, ta adopt RESOLUTION N0, 90-217 AUTHORIZING AUTHORIZING EASEMERr
THE MAYOR AND CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO AN EASEMENT AGREEMENT AGREEMENT WITH
W17m THOMPSON LUMBER COMPANY, CITY PROJECT NO. 833, THOMPSON LUMBER CO.
FOR PROJECT 833
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes. Item *8-K
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION NO. 90-218
Councilmember Ricker, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-218 REVISING REVISING AGREEMENT AN
CONSTRUCTION COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT, COUNTY ROAD 6, COUNTY APPROVAL OF PROJECT
PROJECT NO, 8642, FERNBROOK LANE TO COUNTY ROAD 101, CITY NO, 829
PROJECT NO. 829, Item 8-L
In response to a question by Councilmember Vo si 1 iou, Director
Moore stated the County erred in omitting two i.emaphores in the
agreement.
Motion carried cn a roll call vote, five ayes,
MOTION was made by founcilmember Vasiliou, ,--onded by RESOLUTION NO, 90-2#4
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-219 ' ;'TING A AMENDING
POLICY RELATIIJG TO THE ISSUANCE OF ON -SALE INTOXIC41 4G LIQUOR ISSUANCE OF ON -SALE
LICENSE, INTOXICATING LIQUOR
LICENSES
Motion carriel on a roll call vote, five ayes. Item *8-M
MOTION was made by Counc i I member Vas i l i ou . second% -4 by RESOLUTION NO, 90-.220
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION NO, 90-220 AWARDING OF AWARD TO PTM)'rfW
BID FOR 1990 REFORESTATION PROPOSAL, REFORESTATION
Item *8-N.•1
Notion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by CounciInember Vasiliou, seconded by RESOLUTION XO. 90-221
Councilmember %.i tur, to adopt RF UJTIIN NO. 90-221 AWARDING BID AWXRDING BID FOR jqqr)
FOR THE 1990 DISEASED TREE A STUMtj REMOVAL., DISEASED 'REE k STJMN
REMOVAL
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes. Item *8-N-2
MOTION was made by Cou nc i I membe r Vasiliou, seconded by ORDINANCE NO, RO-06
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt ORDINANCE NO. 90-06 RELATING TO AMENDING CITY CnDE
SUBSECTION 600.21 OF f4E PLYMOUTH CITY CODE RELATING TO REF11SE RELATING TO REFUSE
HAULERS, HAULERS
Item *8-0
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 10
MOTION was made by
Councilmember Zitur, to
GARBAGE HAULER LICENSES
30, 1991.
Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-222 APPROVING
FOR PERIOD OF MAY 1, 1990 THROUGH APRIL
Motion carried cn a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt ORDINANCE N0, 90-07 RELATING
PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE, AMENDMENT SECTION 1215.01 OF
PLYMOUTH CITY CODE AND AUTHORIZING STATE LOTTERY TICKETS TO
SOLD ON LICENSED PREMISES.
RE SOL U i I ON N11, 90-222
HAULER LICENSES FOR
PERIOD 5-1-!) TO
4-30-91
Item *8-P
by ORDINANCE NO. 90-07
TO AUTHURIZINri
THE LOTTERY TIC:ETS TO BE
BE SOLO IN LIQJOR
ESTABLISHMENTS
Item *8-Q
Notion carried on a roil call vote, five eyes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION N0, 90-223 APPROVING;
DISBURSEMENTS FOR THE PERIOD ENDING FEBRUARY 28, 1990.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
Councilmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION N0, 90-224 AUTHORIZING
THE PRIVATE SALE OF TAX -FORFEITED LANDS.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
Assistant Manager Boyles stated that on February 9, the
Metropolitan Transit Commiseion (MTC) appealed the Council's
pie,:i sion to award a twelve-month extension of the existing
transit contract to Medicine Lake lines (MLL). The appeal panel
heard the appeal on February 23 and affirmed the Council's aws..-d
to MLL. On March 2, staff was advised by MLL that they had
entered into a letter of intent to sell the business to Laidlaw,
In,-,
Assistant Boyles stated he has contacted Laidlaw to ask if they
would approve asci gr,ment of the contract to Laidlaw, and MTr, to
see if they would provide a one year proposal. Laidlaw has
agreed to accept assignment of the contract, but not as executed
by MLL. The cont oac t signed by MLI. makes the cornp.iny
responsible for the revenoie strei:ai (the compan;1 may receive a
maximum amount of 1652,651). This amount is reached by
subtracting the total arnual operating cost of $959,857 from the
expected system revenues of $207,000. As a new provider,
Laidlaw do not agree to this contract provision. They desire
that the contract allow them to collect up to $859,857,
Assistant Boyles explained that the Laidlaw proposal would be
the least disruptive to service; however, the City is entirely
6
RESOLUTION N0, 90-221
APPROVING
DISBURSEMENTS FOR
PERIOD ENDING 2-28-90
Item *84
RESOLUTION N0, 90-224
AUTHORIZING SALE OF
TAX -FORFEITED LANDS
Item *A -S
Transit Contrast
Item A -T
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Pale 101
responsible for the -•evenue stream. The MTC proposal provides
nr:wer vehicles and 1 o)1 ds the City's liability a t S652,859. if
awarded the one year contract, MTC has agreed to drop their
appeal against the City. The MTC proposal does not provide a S5
million insurance ?olicy, but rather provides S200,000/56009000
self insurance crierage with a hold harmless guarantee, for any
remaining liabil'fy. The MTC proposal also r 's*.c the: question
of appropriateness of marginal cost proposal.
John Capell, representing the MTC, stated they are interested in
operating the system, MTC will guarantee uninterrupted
service, Mr. Capell noted the MTC proposal was initially
reconsaended by staff and the consultant.
Jing Johnson, Medicine lake Lines, stilted $400,000 in outstanding
bills for she Plymouth Metrolink service is one reason MLL is
contemplating a sale to Laidlaw. He stated the Regional Transit
Board (RT8) is substantially responsible for not releasing these
funds to MLL.
Ed Kouneski, Manager of Programs for the RTB, stated a contract
was executed by MLL and the RTB in 1989 which established
subsidy levels, There was a substantial increase In subsidy,
and following an audit, the RTB felt it was important to hold
further payment for the 1989 contract until ML. provided
Justification for the higher subsidy. The RTB will iipprove the
payment if appropriate documentation is provided by MLL on the
1989 contract.
Mr. Johnson stated the RTB is trying to delay the process, The
money held since the audit is not reasonable.
Assistant Boyles stated MLL accounting practices were questioned
by Mn00T and RTO and as a result of the audit, the City withhele,
funds,
Counc i l membt-r Ricker stated the Council had previously di rec ted
that suffi4ient funds be withheld so the City would not suffer a
loss,
Mickey Johnson, Vice President of Laidlaw, Inc., d. rc:ribed thc-
company and expressed willingr,is to rnnt+n;jA eprvico for the
City.
Deboreh Cari s, 2610 Comstock !ane, stated MLL custo.icers +ire
pleased with the service provided. Sh,: stated MTC drivers are
rude and encouraged the Council to as?ogn ervlCE to Laidlaw,
Counc: i I member Helliwell asked if MLL drivers would be rete i rigid
by Laidlaw,
7
R
Regular Council Meeting
March 199 1990
Pa ge 102
Mickey Johvison stated It is the intent of La: dl aw to keep the
MLL drivers and staff.
Mayor Bergman asked if the contract Is awarded to RTC, would it
affect the sale of MLL to Laidlaw.
Jim Johnson stated that it would affect the issue of what to do
with the buses currently used for the Metrolink service, out
would no: void the sale. He stated no matter what action the
Council takes, MLL will provide service to the end of March.
Councileamber Ricker stated if Laidlaw is willing to acquire the
contract, it should also guarantee the revenues,
Ciuncilmember Vasiliou stated she also has cr.acerns with
Laidlaw's unwillingness to guarantee revenues, ai6 notified MTC
that the Council will monitor customer service ,uri ng the next
year.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Rick"•., seconded by
louncII%mher Helliwell, to adopt RESOLU.ION NO. 90-225
AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY MANAGER TO ENT,: R 100 A CNE YE -IR
AGREEMEN f WITH THE MTC FOR THE PROVISION OF pL YMGUTH METROLINK
SERVICES.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
Manager Millis requested that the Council review and approve the
City plan for 1990 water conservation/restriction efforts.
Councilmember Vasiliou reported that Mi
handheld watering of gardens and car wa
at;ked if the Council would be 1 ntere
permitted uses to the Plymoath plan,
ietonka is allowing
oi ng this year. She
ted in adding these
Coun.i linember Ricker stated he has no objection to adding those
uses; however, he suggested the Council continue the program for
one year to fairly determine its effectl ticness.
Councilmember Zitur stated the
possible inclusion in next year's
residents watering from a private
they are using private well water.
issue Should be studied for
program, as well as regjiring
wel' to elect a sign stating
MOTION was made by Councilmembe-
Councilmember Vasiliou, to approve th
restriction efforts as proposed by st
Kition carried on a roil c'i11 vote, t
Ricker,
1990 water
IN ayes,
seconded by
conservation/
RESOLUTION N0, 90-225
AUTHORTZC W-VEAX"
CONTRACT WITH NRC FOR
METROLINK SERVICE
Item A -T
Water Restriction/
Conservdtloq Progrda'
Item 8-'1
n
U
Regular Cawxi1 Meeting
larch 19, 1990
Page 103
Councilmember Vasiliou asked why aeparate ag'eetaents are Park C,onsttltait
proposed for park design services, ant if there i!; not a model Agreements
agreement which could be used, She also stated that safety Item 8-V
Issues are not addressed in the proposti agreements,
Park Director Blank stated safety issues will be trddrissed at
the design phase.
Attorney Thomson stated he is working lvith staff to develop a
uniform agreement,
The Council directed that future park design proposals should
include a recommendation from the Risk Management Coordinator,
MOTION was nmde by Councilmember Vasillou, seconded by Mayor RESOLUTION NO, QO-2!6
Bergman, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-226 1PPROVIN6 CONTRACT WITH APPROVING AGREM.Rr—
BAR70N ASCHMAN FOR SWAN LAKE NEIGHBORHOOD PARK, FOR SWAN LAKE
NEIGHBORHOOD PARK
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes. Item 8-V-1
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by Mayor RESOLUTION NO, 90-227
Bergman, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-227 4PPROV:NG PROFESSIONAL APPROVIRG
SERVICES FOR BASS LAKE ARD PARKERS LAKE PLAYFIELDS, FOR BASS LAKE AND
PARKERS LAKE PLAyFIELh
Notion carried on a roll call vote, five ares. Item 8-Y-2
The Council directed the City Manager to e.cheuule a meeting for
the City Council to con.0 der how futcre monies should be
allocated In the pari, and recreation area,
Counci lmembPr Vasiliou stated that recently at a Town Meeting u
large number of residents indicated thej watch City Council
meetings on cable, However, they stated trey do not watch other
local programming, Coune0imember Vasiliou stated she would
prefer that money for video equipment neefled to cablecast City
Co!incil meetings come from a reduction in -p,cial programs,
MOTION was made by Councilmember Vasillo,i, seconded by Mayor
Bergman, to direct staff to review sche%uled productions and
make a recommendation to the Council on curs In progr tuani ng,
Motion carried, five ayes.
Manager V' i i i s stated the Ci ty wi 11 bi d tw.. or threi cameras and
then consider the number to purchase based on the bid received,
i
Reg..lar Council Meeting
Marco 19, 199
Page 104
ItTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by Mayor
3ergman, to adopt RESOLUTION N0, 90-228 AUTHORIZING THE
SOLICITATION OF BIDS FOR VIREO EQUIPMENT NEEDED TO CABLECAST
CITY COUNCIL '`'1G:.' I"GS.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
Manager Willis provided the Council with information from Evil ers
and Associates regarding a proposal Ay Bob Boisclair fav -
development of senior ci tize; housing. Manager Willis suggested
Vie Council consider whether to explore the feasibility of
having a senior citizen housing project buil4 and owned by the
City through ttP Housiag and Redevelopment A•ithority (NRA). If
this approach werR taken, it would eliminate consideraciin of
the need for tax increment financing proposrd by Mr. Boisclair.
Manager Willis stated t:.e senior project must stand or fall
independent or the townhom- project propo;ed by Mr. Boisclair.
Sta re:ognizes that toe two projects are related in a
financial senile, but they are not related In a planning sense.
Bob Boisclair explained the status of his proposal, and the
correlation of the townhome pruj K t and the senior housing
project.
Cosinci liaember Ricker reported that the HRA is interested in
considering a renior housing Project, He questioned whether
there is sufficient support for a zoning amendment to
accommodate %.he Boisclair priposed townhoine project.
Councilmember Ricker suggested
into an agreement to purchase
property wound De su.rendered
building senior housing. The
with Mr. BoNsJ air, as well
development of senior housing.
s
tnat the City Council could enter
the s?nior nousing site. The
to the HRA for the purpose of
HRA could continue to negoti .i to
as ti study other options for
MOTION was made by Councilmember Ricker, seconded h; Mayer
Bergman, to authorize the HRA to pursue development of senior
hnusi nq, with the condition that if a bond sale Is :lel d% the
City would be refunded for the cost nf land nurcnase, SAC
01 ge%, park dedication fees, etc. It wou'I be the HRA's
di scretion witetner to conte nue to negoti ate a 1%&) K : wi th Mr.
Boisrlair or whether to develop a proiect with .ether funds.
Counc'lmembar Ricker stated the Council should p-ovide Mr.
Bo:scldlr wi`h direction of whether at this point they favor
c -,mbining the senior housing project with the townho-ise project
u Ing tax increment financing.
RESOLUTION n. 90-229
AUTHURTZING '
SOLICITATION OF BIDS
FOR VIDEO EQiPMENT
Item A -W
Senior Citizen Housinq
Item 9-A
Regular Council Meeting
March 190 1990
Page 105
Mr. 6oisclair agreed thall the townhouse project snould stand on
its own planning merits. " statel he 1 ntends to proceed wi th
the townhouse project separately if the Council rejects the
senior housing proposal.
Counci l6member Rick to stated the levy capability of the HRA would
replace the need fir tax increment fig anc'ng.
Motion carried on a roll call vote, five ayes.
TION was made by Councilmember Ricker, seconded by
rouncilmember P tur, to state the sense of the Council that the
City does not favor combining the senior housing project it1 th
the townhouse projcac t using tax increment financing.
Ittion carried f .e ayes.
Counc i l.aember Vass i 1 ou stated soe would like the Boi sc 1 ai M
proposal to still be considered.
Manager Willis stated nothiig would preclude Mr, 4uisclair from
we rki ng with the MRA to propose a project, err from pursuing ;
housing prujec t on another site.
Manager Willis recommended the City Council confirm the Legal Services
appointment of Holmes A Gravea Chartered as attorneys for the Item 9.8
City of PI.Mouth,
Councilmember Vasiliou said se does not support the retainer
system and an itemi4.ed b+lline of which departments are
utilizing the Attorney shouiu be available, She stated that a
major disservice is done to not look at various options for
legal services. She asked what the term of appoint.nent is.
Manager Willis stated it is an on-going appointment. He and
Atto-ney 111wmson will discuss a method of 1 oggi .g and reporting
the attorney's time by department.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Zi tur that each employee track
the number and length of call made to the attorney and file the
information with the finance department for reference. Motion
failed for lack of a second.
Mayor Bergman stated that at the February 8 migting staff was
instructed to receive oposal s and no proposals were received.
MOTION was made by Councilmember Ricker, seconded by RESOLUTION NO, 90-229
Councilmember Helliwell, to adopt RESOLUTION NO. 90-229 APPnINTRNT nF CJTT"
APPOINTING THE ..AW FIRM OF HOLMES A GRAVEN CHARTERED AS THE CITY ATTORyEY
ATTORNEY, Item 9-8
Regular Council Meeting
March 19, 1990
Page 106
r
Motion carried on a roll call vote, Aelliwell, Zitur, and Ricker
ayes; Vasi 1 iou and B ,rgman nays.
The Council directed the City Manager to develop a system to
track depart gents ` use of the City Attorney and report back to
the Cvunci 1.
The Council received the Public and Capital Improvement Project
Status Reports.
AOTION was made by Councilmember Vasiliou, seconded by
Cound lmember Zitur, to adopt RESOLUTION N04, 90-230 APPROVING
THE TRANS"•ER OF FUNDS FOR PROJECT #801, #8170 #834, #9059 '.ND
912.
Mation carriqad on a roll call vrite, five ayes.
Manager Willis provided a legislative update.
The meeting was adjourned at 1:10 a.m.
Project Status Reports
Item 9-C
RESOLUTION N0. 90-230
RWECT FUNDING
APPROPRIATION
Item *9-D
Legislative Update
I tem 9-E
9