Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCouncil Information Memorandum 01-11-1991PCITVF PLYMOUTH+ CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM January 11, 1991 0 RECYCLING CASH DRAWING NO WINNER Next Week: $500 UPCOMING MEETINGS AND EVENTS.... January 22 7:00 P.M January 28 6:30 P.M. January 28 7:00 P.M. Town Meeting, Area 3 City Council Chambers Plymouth Forum City Council Chambers Regular Council Meeting City Council Chambers 2. PLANNING COMMISSION -- Wednesday, January 16, City Council Chambers. The Planning Commission Forum will begin at 6:45 p.m., with the regular Planning Commission meeting following at 7:00 p.m. Agenda attached. (M-2) 3. FINANCIAL TASK FORCE -- Thursday, January 17, 4:00 p.m. The Financial Task Force will meet in the City Council conference room. 4. MEETING CALENDARS -- Meeting calendars for January and February are attached. (M-4) 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM January 11, 1991 Page 2 FOR YOUR INFORMATION..... 1. LEAGUE OF PLYMOUTH VOTERS -- Representatives of this group have requested and we have supplied 2,500 voter registration cards to be used in conjunction with the petition efforts as reported in the Plymouth Sailor. To minimize duplicate registrations, Laurie Rauenhorst has supplied the attached voter registration data sheet. (I- 1) 2. OBSERVATION OF LEN BUSCH LIGHTING -- Following the January 7 Council meeting, Blair Tremere accompanied Councilmember Zitur to the Len Busch Roses, Inc. greenhouses to observe the lighting. There they were met by Councilmembers Helliwell and Ricker and by Mr. Busch and an associate. Their observation followed the sequence in the memorandum which Blair had earlier distributed on the subject. The weather was overcast which is a necessary condition for proper evaluation of the lighting effect. They observed the lighting from separate vehicles on Medina Road, as well as from Amber Woods. Blair and Chuck Dillerud met Councilmember Vasiliou at the site on January 10 and they were joined by developers Peter Pflaum and Bill Pritchard and by Amber Woods residents, Mr. and Mrs. Jacobitz and Bob Held. The same sequence was followed and included observation from the Jacobitz home. Blair will complete the observation with Mayor Bergman in the near future as weather permits. Following that, the Council can review the proposed Len Busch agreement provisions in relation to the observations made at the site. 3. DEVELOPMENT IMPACT ANALYSIS: 1) In accordance with earlier Council direction, David MacGillivray of Springsted, has submitted the attached letter. The letter confirms that Springsted will conduct the Plymouth study for $3,200. The City would not be bound to use Springsted as its advisor in the 1991 bond issue. Since this letter is responsive to the Council's January 7 concern, and because it is essential that we move forward with this project without delay, I have instructed Springsted to proceed to complete the study. If this action is contrary to the wishes of City Councilmembers, please contact me. 2) Attached is the revised assumptions report based upon the City Council's January 7 input. Please provide your comments about the assumptions to David MacGillivray or Dale Hahn (550-5101) by January 18 so the study can proceed. CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM January 11, 1991 Page 3 3) Also attached is a letter from Mark Ruff, Development Consultant, Publicorp, Inc., concerning their December 21 letter. (I-3) 4. PLYMOUTH COMMUNITY LIBRARY -- In accordance with the January 7 City Council direction, I have written a letter (attached) to Robert Rohlf, requesting the Library Board's official minutes designating Site 3 for the Plymouth Community Library. I am told that this formal action will be taken at the Board's January 24 meeting, and I will be provided with a copy of those minutes. Jim Thomson will be providing me with the names of one or more land acquisition specialist he believes would be appropriate to use in acquiring the proposed site. Councilmember Helliwell reported that she met with Mr. Cavanaugh on Tuesday, January 8. She believes the meeting as very successful. Mr. Cavanaugh indicated that the $9 to $10 per square foot price, which he has alleged to have requested, is not accurate. According to Carole, Mr. Cavanaugh favors a library on this site, but he does not feel that the Board needs the entire site. They spent some time discussing the parking layout and building square footage. Mr. Cavanaugh has indicated a desire to deal with Councilmember Helliwell and the Library Board staff, and not a land acquisition specialist. Councilmember Helliwell is in the process of scheduling a follow-up meeting with Mr. Cavanaugh and David Kramer of the Library Board staff early the week of January 14. Once I have a date, time, and location, I will share this information with Councilmembers. (I-4) 5. NEWLY ELECTED OFFICIALS CONFERENCE -- The League of Minnesota Cities will hold its annual newly elected official conference on Saturday, February 2. Information on the conference is attached. If you would like to be registered, please contact Laurie. (I-5) 6. MINUTES: a. Shingle Creek Watershed Management Commission, November 8, 1990. (I-6) 7. LEGISLATIVE REPS -- Attached is the new roster of Plymouth Federal and State legislative representatives for your use. (I-7) 8. CUSTOMER SERVICE LINE -- Documentation on a call received on the Customer Service Line is attached. (I-8) 9. IMPACT FEES -- The attached article, "Impact Fees on the Rise" is taken from the December issue of Zoning News. (I-9) CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM January 11, 1991 Page 4 10. WASTE TRANSFER STATION -- The status report on Hennepin County's application for a waste Transfer Station is attached. (I-10) 11. PLYMOUTH EMPLOYEES: a. Housing Inspector Appointment -- Effective February 1, Community Service Officer Warren Kulesa will be assigned to the new position of Housing Inspector. During Council budget discussions, a transfer of a Community Service Officer to the Housing Inspector position was approved. The position is experimental and the Council will be provided with feedback as to the needs of the community as it relates to housing inspection services. Warren will work CSO -type duties when there is no housing inspection requests. 12. CORRESPONDENCE: a. Letters to various organizations and agencies from Laurie Rauenhorst, confirming the Council's 1991 appointments and designations. Also attached is the 1991 listing of City Council appointments. (I -12a) b. Letter sent to Hennepin County Board of Commissioners from City Council regarding fiscal disparities. (I - 12b) c. Letter to William Brown, Postmaster of Minneapolis, from Blair Tremere, on the naming of the proposed new postal station in Plymouth. (I -12c) d. Letter to Chuck Dillerud, from Bruce Halgren, Executive Director, Academic Service, Wayzata Schools, concerning the District's use of four relocatables at Birchview and Greenwood Elementary Schools. (I -12d) e. Letter responding to John Schueller, former Plymouth resident, from Daryl Sulander, regarding water service billing for 435 Queensland Lane. (I -12e) f. Letter from Mike McGoldric, 17035 24th Avenue North, to Mayor Bergman, on the extension of Council terms. (I -12f) g. Letter from Russell Woolery, 2835 Garland Lane, to Mayor Bergman, on the December 17 Council meeting. (I -12g) h. Copy of letter from Pat Katzmarek and Carol Herby, to Pat Murphy, Union City Mission, requesting a meeting with Union City Mission representatives. (I -12h) CITY COUNCIL INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM January 11, 1991 Page 5 i. Letter from Mary Ellen Kochevar, 14603 County Road 6, to Mayor and City Council, regarding the proposed bike path on County Road 6 from Juneau to Fernbrook Lane. (I -12i) j. Note of appreciation from Lois Ziegler, to Milt Dale, Blair Tremere, and City Council. (I -12j) k. Letter to Robert Navara, 2510 Urbandale Lane, from Dick Carlquist, responding to Mr. Navara's concerns with all -terrain vehicles and snowmobiles speeding on Urbandale Lane and on private property. Councilmember Vasiliou had received the complaint from Mr. Navara and requested staff investigation. (I -12k) 1. Letter from Gordon Voss, Chief Administrator, Metropolitan Waste Control Commission (MWCC), on a recommendation before the MWCC to moderate debt service increases in 1992 through 1994. (I-121) m. Letter to Schmidt Lake Road property owners from Fred Moore regarding landscape screening along Schmidet Lake Road. (I -12m) n. Letter to Charles Hayes from Fred Moore concerning vacant lot in Bay Pointe on Mooney Lake Development. (1-12n) Frank Boyles Assistant City Manager PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA WHERE: Plymouth City Center M_ a. WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 16, 1991 3400 Plymouth Boulevard CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS Plymouth, MN 55447 CONSENT AGENDA All items listed with an asterisk (*) are considered to be routine by the Planning Commission and will be enacted by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a Commissioner, citizen or petitioner so requests, in which event the item will be removed from the consent agenda and considered in normal sequence on the agenda. PUBLIC FORUM 6:45 P.M. 1. CALL TO ORDER 7:00 P.M. 2. ROLL CALL 3.* CONSENT AGENDA 4.* APPROVAL OF MINUTES 5. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Ryan Construction Company. MPUD Plan and Conditional Use Permit Amendment to increase wall signage at Waterford Park Plaza located at the northeast corner of 6th Avenue North and Revere Lane (90078) B. Builders Development, Inc. Rezoning from FRD to R -1A; Preliminary Plat for a 39.9 -acre tract for 47 single family homes; and, Subdivision Variances located west of County Road 101, approximately one-quarter mile north of County Road 24 (90095) C. Gonyea Land Company. Rezoning from FRD to R-2; Preliminary Plat for a 49.4 -acre tract for 64 multifamily homes; and, Variances located at the west side of West Medicine Lake Road at 45th Avenue North (90105) D. I.S.D. 284/St. Philip the Deacon Church. Conditional Use Permit to allow church services in the Wayzata Senior High School located at 305 Vicksburg Lane North (90106) E. Ray Wedin. Conditional Use Permit for a Home Occupation to operate a woodworking/cabinetry shop at 16831 12th Avenue North (90108) F. Zoning Ordinance Amendment regarding Planned Unit Development Attributes. Continuation of Public Hearing from December 5, 1990. 6. OTHER BUSINESS 1. 1991 Meeting Dates 7. ADJOURNMENT CSP im 11 '91 p� r OD tL! N � � N n Z .�- N N QI H t0 >• t0 r N N i0++ m t! O ' ^ N Cc F W a N LL O a O N f 2 M O n Q O N '' N Q � m 1tf N Qf r N N t0 O Z • N N Q�1 ~ m Q a N U W O p O f N Of t0 N N 1 M-4 Q p � Q � cn N CO x LO N Q p CC LL L.1 J . r� w N v �•� � xa. xa xa. � xa. za°'7o °' ¢o ¢o ¢o ¢o n. -:4 Fo oo pC) N ,r .. a� a v •• a v a� M a� ccH r, a M N O A O U z W 1 W z W I z W za-dw ¢ Q ¢ d¢ �z z �zo"c �za o ¢� e—a Mx�xo �u ow a �u ow Nc:u.. x Mu o�Z. Q Ln M: p -Ir o 0 z 1 z z LU C ct C=) M z N CY)�CDa N M a� r9 o a U � yr H A p? H O O W 1 O p+ D x H LLJ LO �— 00 r—N a l� N >- a O F a• a. ¢ cn a '' Q Cn� �O HO zZ ,�•� H a Y Q HO U O p a H%. X W 4 U•• C fs A i A WO W u. O V] O Z a z O C.7 I -a O V I omzo U� x� p• LO O C/7 C7 W V Mgog W 7 too C7 C7 S a m N CN a Q z X11-91 D ! Cfl r- N N I ' N LL a N o� O N Q1 tp M O O ^ N N N N p n N N 1 j D O N N N M-4 Q N Qf t0 M O td N l"f N �► � N N Of ~ 2 Q z a ao a O N � I ' N LL a N o� O N Q1 tp M O O ^ N N N N p n N N 1 j D O N N N M-4 CIM JPA! 11 r91 Q � Q � N M N O c~7 z_ Q x N ; Q w cc O C7 U - In N r— 00 N o � H a O Z o M om C4 00 N Q N Z a Z i z w z a � Ho zo 3 M z o 19 0 r.,Az — Cfl w N N a 0 z z H N Q o c a a o� A ~O LD � r— N 0 wo La ZOU W I g AH 0 O O ra oa wox E-4 tn W4 v L r C) CVa�0.i Q Z V/ CY) N CIM JPA! 11 r91 1-1 VOTER REGISTRATION Eligible to Register: A person who on election day will be 18 years old, a citizen of the United States, and a resident of Minnesota for 20 days, and is not under guardianship of a person, has not been found by a court to be legally incompetent to vote, and has not been convicted of a felony without having their civil rights restored. (This is the oath the person signs at the bottom of the card.) A person should complete a voter registration card if: 1) They have changed their name; or 2) They have changed their address; or 3) They have not voted in the last four years; or 4) They have never voted before. If they have voted in the last four years and their name and address are the same, they are already a registered voter. The items marked with a red 'X' on the registration card must be completed. Other information on the card is optional. If information marked with a red 'X' is not completed, the card will be returned to the individual. The information in the upper right-hand corner of the card indicating types of identification can be ignored. This is only used for registration at the polls on election day when identification must be provided. No proof or identification is required for pre -registration. Completed cards can be returned individually or in a group, by mail or in person to: City Clerk City of Plymouth 3400 Plymouth Blvd. Plymouth, MN 55447 For questions, please call Laurie Rauenhorst, City Clerk, 550-5014. GIM JAN 11 '91 500 Elm Grove Road Suite 101, P.O. Box 37 Elm Grove, WI 53122-0037 (414) 782-8222 Fax: (414) 782-2904 2739 Second Avenue S.E. Cedar Rapids, IA 52403-1434 (319)363-2221 Fax: (319) 363.6999 January 8, 1991 Mr. James Willis, Manager Plymouth City Hall 3400 Plymouth Boulevard Plymouth, MN 55447 Re: Development Impact Analysis Dear Mr. Willis: SPRINGSTED PUBLIC FINANCE ADVISORS 85 East Seventh Place Suite 100 Saint Paul, MN 55101-2143 (612) 223-3000 Fax: (612) 223-3002 512 Nicollet Mall Suite 550 Minneapolis, MN 55402-1017 (612) 333-9177 Fax: (612) 333-2363 I-3 135 North Pennsylvania Street Suite 2015 Indianapolis, IN 46204-2498 (317) 684-6000 Fax: (317) 684-6004 6800 College Boulevard Suite 600 Overland Park, KS 66211 (913) 345-8062 Fax:(913) 345.1770 We have reviewed our position on this study based on the comments made at last night's meeting. We concur with your basic contention that it is appropriate for the City to examine the work product of Springsted and compare it with the City's past advisory service. We also want to re-emphasize that working with Plymouth has been and remains one of our highest priorities. In order to be fair and to provide the City with the opportunity to review our service, we do not believe the City should be placed at a perceived financial disadvantage. Therefore, we will perform this study for $3,200 as if Plymouth was a long-standing Springsted client. Furthermore, the City is not bound to use Springsted as its advisor on its 1991 issue. We do ask the City to be fair and keep an open mind in deciding which firm will serve as its advisor for the 1991 issue. We repeat our offer contained in the initial proposal that we would reduce our fee on the 1991 issue by 50% of the fee for the study. The brief selection process did not permit us to present fully our firm and its extensive credentials in working with suburban municipalities. There are definite reasons why we serve as advisor to the vast majority of Twin City suburban municipalities of a comparable stature to Plymouth, and why in increasing numbers these jurisdictions have terminated their relationships with other advisory firms and initiated work with Springsted. If the City would want a full presentation of our experience and credentials, we would be pleased to provide one. The City can be assured the study will be thorough, objective and of a high quality. We want to again express our appreciation to the City in giving us this opportunity. Sincerely, David N. MacGillivray 1 Vice President mjh pa Cal JAN I 1 19 1 500 Elm Grove Road Suite 101, P.O. Box 37 Elm Grove, WI 53122-0037 (414) 782-8222 Fax: (414) 782-2904 2739 Second Avenue S.E. Cedar Rapids, IA 52403.1434 (319) 363-2221 Fax: (319) 363-6999 January 10, 1991 Mr. James Willis, Manager Plymouth City Hall 3400 Plymouth Boulevard Plymouth, MN 55447 SPRINGSTED PUBLIC FINANCE ADVISORS 85 East Seventh Place Suite 100 Saint Paul, MN 55101-2143 (612) 223-3000 Fax: (612) 223-3002 512 Nicollet Mall Suite 550 Minneapolis, MN 55402-1017 (612) 333-9177 Fax: (612) 333-2363 Re: Development Impact Analysis Revised Assumptions Dear Mr. Willis: 1-3 135 North Pennsylvania Street Suite 2015 Indianapolis, IN 46204-2498 (317) 684-6000 Fax: (317) 684-6004 6800 College Boulevard Suite 600 Overland Park, KS 66211 (913) 345-8062 Fax: (913) 345-1770 Based on input received during our workshop on Monday, January 7 with the City Council and staff, we have revised the objectives and assumptions listed in our letter of January 3, 1991. If the Council members or staff have questions or concerns regarding the revised assumptions, please contact Becky or myself by Friday, January 18. Any comments received and incorporated into the study will be communicated to all Council members and City staff. As we discussed during the workshop and in our earlier letter, it is crucial to achieve a concensus on the assumptions to assure a credible final report. If we do not receive any comments from Council members or City staff by Friday, January 18, we will assume the Council and City staff agree with the Objectives and Assumptions in this letter. OBJECTIVES The study will focus on the property tax impact to an existing Plymouth homeowner living in the Wayzata and Robbinsdale School Districts. The City Assessor estimates the average market value of a typical Plymouth residence at $144,600 in 1990. This study will calculate the property's tax bill before and after development occurs in the study areas. To determine this representative tax bill, we have developed the following objectives: The primary objective is to determine the financial impact on residents of Plymouth of constructing the Northwest and North Central sewer trunk facilities with specific focus on the property tax impact. The four subcategories are: 1) to determine the capital construction financial impact on the City from installing these trunk facilities; C'M JAN 11 '-Q- 1 1-3 City of Plymouth, Minnesota January 10, 1991 Page 2 2) to determine the operational financial impact on the City from associated development of the areas; 3) to determine the capital construction financial impact on the school district(s) from associated development of these areas; and 4) to determine the operational financial impact on the school district(s) from associated development of these areas. The property tax impact will be calculated for four separate sewer trunk facility phases described below under Study Area. Within each phase, the impact will also be detailed by commercial/industrial and residential development impact, including a comparison of the cost associated with the improvement and the taxes generated by the new development. As a final refinement, the property tax impact will be shown separately for city and school district taxes. A principal determinant of property taxing levels will be the City's levy limitation. Current State law stipulates that levy limits for cities will be removed for taxes payable in 1993. There is a probability that this elimination of levy limits will be changed. Therefore, this study will examine the situation both with and without levy limits. STUDY AREA The City staff has defined the four subject areas for future development: North Central, Northwest Phase I and Il, and Northwest -17/19. The attached map indicates these areas. ASSUMPTIONS Jointly with the City staff, we have determined a listing of major assumptions. We have grouped these assumptions into categories to address specific study areas. Overall Assumptions 1. Term of Study We assume the term of the study will be from 1991 through 2000. To the extent allowed under the absorption timeframe, the study will focus on the years 1991-1993, but the study will extend through the year 2000. 2. Property Tax System We assume the current property tax system will remain in effect over the term of this study. 3. Funding of Cities We assume the current system of funding cities will remain unchanged, i.e., the relative shares of operational revenues will remain unchanged, fiscal disparities will continue, etc. The one exception is the State funding of Homestead and Agricultural Assistance (HACA). We will perform a sensitivity analysis for possible changes in HACA levels. �tt►� JAN 1-3 City of Plymouth, Minnesota January 10, 1991 Page 3 4. City Tax Base Growth We believe the City's present tax base will not grow at historical levels. We assume the growth in the present tax base will be determined upon consultation with the City Assessor, and will be at a level below recent experience. Also, the estimated future tax base will be amended to allow for termination of existing tax increment districts. Development Assumptions 1. Residential Development Residential densities reflect base -line units per acre according to current Plymouth guidelines. Since a negligible amount of multi -family residential is allowed in the North Central trunk area, the focus on the residential usage will be on single-family construction. 2. Household Size The average household size of 2.72 is assumed, based on the Metropolitan Council's most current estimates. The 1990 census household size estimates are not yet available. Springsted Incorporated will verify this assumption with the Wayzata, Robbinsdale and Osseo School Districts. 3. Commercial Development Office/commercial and industrial square footage projections are based on the Metropolitan Council's assumptions regarding net square foot of developable area per acre. 4. Developable Land Areas The size of the undeveloped land areas are based on measurements made by the City of Plymouth and reflect updates of the Barton Ashman Report. The land area is net of undevelopable areas such as wetlands, easements, etc. 5. Building Permit Data Past development activities are reflected by building permit reports provided by the City for the years 1982-1990. The permit activity includes new residential building permits/single-family detached and attached; remodeling building permits/residential; new residential building permits/multi-family four units and over; new permits/non- residential; and building permits for alterations/non-residential. This information provides a historical perspective rather than a basis for a trend analysis. JAIL 1 I ''�) z- 3 City of Plymouth, Minnesota January 10, 1991 Page 4 6. Values for New Development New residential and commercial values are based upon recent permit values and information from the Plymouth tax assessor. City Assumptions Infrastructure Construction 1. Construction Cost This study will include all City public improvements in the subject development areas. We assume the City Public Works Director will establish a project expenditure and revenue budget for each improvement expressed in future dollars. This project budget will include existing improvements which were constructed with a capacity to serve subject development areas. 2. Construction Funding We assume the City Public Works Director's project revenue budget will incorporate current City policies on the funding of improvements. 3. Special Assessments We assume that either no delinquencies will occur in the payment of special assessments or, if delinquencies occur, they are covered fully by developer liquidity guarantees or other City funds. We assume in no event will property taxes be levied to meet delinquencies. 4. Utility Fund Improvements Certain improvements relate to the subject development areas utility user fees. From discussion with City staff, we assume no will exist which relates directly to the subject development areas. Operation Funding 1. Operational Expenditures which are funded from rate increase exists or The City has recently received the final report by Tischler & Associates which forecasts the City's operational fiscal position for the term 1991-2000. The City staff, upon review of this document, is in agreement with the report's conclusions. We assume this study will use the Tischler report's conclusions on operational cost estimates with the following discussion: Cts JAN I 1 'Q 1 3:.3 City of Plymouth,. Minnesota January 10, 1991 Page 5 a.) Per Capita Cost Additional cost to the City's general fund due to growth are based on per capita cost estimates prepared including the City's 1990 budget. The general fund costs are estimated by the following six major cost categories: administration, community development, parks and recreation, finance, public safety, and public works. b). Service Levels It was assumed in the per capita cost estimates that these estimates will result in the continuation of the 1990 service levels. c). Adjustments There are minor adjustments to the Tischler cost estimates which may be made based on concurrence of the City staff. One area of adjustment may be the method of allocating operating expense for a new public safety building. 2. Operational Revenues The assumption on funding of cities listed in the "Overall Assumptions" category will apply to Plymouth's future operational funding. We assume the General Fund Revenue shares used in the 1991 City budget will continue over the term of the study. School District Assumptions 1. Need For New Building(s) Independent School District 284 has its own demographer to forecast student populations and building needs. Based on our projections of development absorption rates, we assume that the demographer would apply current student ratios to determine the need for new buildings. 2. If New Buildings, Construction Cost Estimates Independent School District 284 has recently completed the construction of three new elementary buildings, and they have an ongoing relationship with the EOS architecture firm. We assume the architect would be able to provide a construction cost estimate for any new building(s) needed as a result of assumption 1. We also assume that the construction costs will be stated in future dollars. 3. Increased Operational Costs Independent School District 284 maintains an operations cost accounting system on a per building basis. We assume that based on the composition of a new building(s) we would apply their cost experience for comparable buildings to any new building(s). 1-3 City of Plymouth, Minnesota January 10, 1991 Page 6 4. Operational Revenues We assume the current system of State funding of school districts would continue over the term of this study. We also assume the present revenue structure would remain unchanged over the term of the study. 5. Cost Allocation We assume that any new buildings may serve an area greater than the subject development area. If this assumption is correct, then for capital construction and operational costs, the pro rata share of capital construction and operational costs allocable to the subject development area will be based on market valuations. 6. School District Tax Base We assume for determining property tax rates, the School District's tax base will increase at 50% of the historical five-year rate (1985-1989) over the term of this study. 7. Robbinsdale School District (281) Upon verification with District 281 staff, we will assume the subject development will require no new buildings to be constructed by District 281. There may be increases in operational costs which will be incorporated into this study. We look forward to receiving your final comments on these revised assumptions. Respectfully submitted, David N. MacGillivray Vice President rls cc: Mr. Sid Inman, Publicorp Enclosure elm JAIN 11 191 Publicorp Inc. 364 Century Plaza 1111 Third Avenue South Minneapolis, MN 55404 January 8, 1991 Mr. James Willis City Manager City of Plymouth (612) 341-3646 FAX (612) 341-4148 3400 Plymouth Boulevard Plymouth, MN 55447 _t Dear Mr. Willis: Enclosed is a copy of our letter, dated December 21, 1990, addressed to you and copied to all city council members, city attorney, and our clients from Mr. Sidney Inman of our firm. You have indicated that the third page of the letter was not transmited over the fax machine and that your mailed copy was not received. I take responsibility for these ommissions and apoligize for any confusion which may have resulted. I spoke to our secretary regarding this matter. She produced a copy of the mailing labels which were sent with the copies of our letter which is also enclosed. Your name is not on the mailing list, but the names of each city council member are on the mailing list. If any of the city council members did not receive the documents in the mail, please alert us. However, your mailed copy is the only one which may not have been sent. Please call with questions or concerns. Sincerely, Mark Ruff Development CO6sultant Attachments GIA JAN 11 '91 Publicorp Inc. 364 Century Plaza (612) 341-3646 1111 1 hird Avenue South FAX (612) 341-4148 Minneapolis, MN 55404 December 21, 1990 Mr. James Willis City Manager City of Plymouth 3400 Plymouth Boulevard Plymouth, Minnesota 55447 Dear Mr. Willis: A consortium of property owners in the City of Plymouth has requested that our firm, Publicorp, Inc., serve as a consultant to them regarding the City's proposed fiscal impact analysis for trunk facilities in the Northwest Sewer area. This group of property owners in the Northwest Sewer area, consisting of representatives of U.S. Homes, Builder's Development, Inc., Hans Hagen Homes, Inc., James Development Company, and Lundgren Bros. Construction, Inc., wish to assist the City and its fiscal consultant in any way possible to provide accurate data, explore all underlying assumptions, and offer immediate and open feedback for the analysis. To meet these goals in an expedient and efficient manner, the property owners have asked our firm to serve as its representative in the study process. You may recognize our firm from our involvement in other developments in and around the City. We are a consulting firm representing local governments and developers in residential, commercial, and industrial projects throughout the state of Minnesota, as well as in North Dakota, Wisconsin, Arizona, and Florida. Approximately fifty percent of our client base consists of local governments and organizations and fifty percent consists of private individuals and companies. Our public clients include the Cities of Brooklyn Park, Duluth, Maple Grove, Richfield, Sauk Rapids, and the Dakota County HRA, the Washington County HRA, and the Brooklyn Center School District. We are not a fiscal consulting firm by trade, but we do focus on a broad range of public finance issues. We project infrastructure costs and negotiate development agreements for cities and developers, we represent a variety of public entities at the state Capitol, and we conduct research for organizations such as the League of Minnesota Cities and the Mesa (Arizona) Economic Growth Association Corporation. Our full resume is attached to this letter for your review. C'm JAR, i 1 '91 T.• 3 We have reviewed both of the proposals to the City from Springsted and Ehlers & Associates with our clients. As a first step in offering the City our assistance, we would like to share the following general comments regarding the proposed study: 1. We believe that the study should concentrate on Phase II of the Northwest Sewer Trunk area. If the City chooses to study the North Central Trunk Sewer Area, we believe it should be done in a separate report. 2. It is our opinion that the analysis should include, as a baseline, an estimate of the developments' costs and benefits assuming the Phase II of the Northwest Trunk Sewer Area is installed in 1991. 3. The analysis should also include an evaluation of the financial impact upon the City and the school district of the expenditures already expended and the expenditures as proposed if the Phase II services are not installed in 1991. 4. The analysis on the impacts upon the school district should first isolate the school district's current needs without the extension of sanitary sewer to the Phase II of the Northwest area. Once this data is gathered, the study should attempt to measure the individual impacts of Phase I and Phase II of the Northwest area and the North Central Area upon the school districts capital and operational needs. 5. The fiscal consultant and City may wish to consider the economic spin-off effects of residential growth in the City upon retail sales, job creation, and commercial and industrial development, if the project goes forward. 6. The study could also measure the opportunity costs of spin-off effects if the project does not proceed. These costs could include the effect upon property values, the effect upon commercial and retail development in the City, potential employment, and the City's reputation in the development community. We would like to request that we be involved in any meetings involving the collection and discussion of data and assumptions. Our role in these meetings would be simply as observers; we would provide information only as requested by the City and not participate in deliberations during preliminary meetings. Additionally, it is our understanding that we and our clients will be able to review draft copies of the final report prior to the publication. Finally, both of the fiscal consultants' proposals refer to the Tischler & Associates study on operating expenses of the City. We have not yet seen a copy of the report and would like to reserve comments on that report until we have reviewed it. Page 2 C'M JAN! i 1 '91 We look forward to hearing from you regarding this matter. Sincerely, Sidney C. Inman Director, Development Consulting DELIVERED BY FAX AND MAIL Resume Attached cc: Kim M. Bergman, Mayor (with attachment) Carole J. Helliwell, City Council Member (with attachment) Lloyd Ricker, City Council Member (with attachment) Maria Vasiliou, City Council Member (with attachment) Robert Zitur, City Council Member (with attachment) Jim Thompson, Holmes & Graven (with attachment) Peter Pflaum, Lundgren Bros. Richard Sathre, Sathre-Berquist Rick Murray, Builders Development, Inc. William Pritchard, U.S. Home Bruce Malkerson, Popham, Haik Jim Steilan, Popham, Haik John Herman, Leonard, Street, & Deinard Page 3 1-3 CIM JN 11'91 KIM M BERGMAN MAYOR CITY OF PLYMOUTH 13930 - 60TH AVENUE NORTH PLYMOUTH MN 55446 CAROLE J HELLIWELL CITY COUNCIL MEMBER CITY OF PLYMOUTH PO BOX 42183 PLYMOUTH MN 55442 LLOYD RICKER CITY COUNCIL MEMBER CITY OF PLYMOUTH 17015 - 14TH AVENUE NORTH PLYMOUTH MN 55447 MARIA VASILIOU CITY COUNCIL MEMBER CITY OF PLYMOUTH 1775 BLACK OAKS LANE PLYMOUTH MN 55447 ROBERT ZITUR CITY COUNCIL MEMBER CITY OF PLYMOUTH 12185 - 48TH CIRCLE PLYMOUTH MN 55442 C!M JAN 11 'g 1 JIM THOMPSON HOLMES & GRAVEN CHARTERED 470 PILLSBURY CENTER MINNEAPOLIS MN 55402 PETER PHLAUM LUNDGREN BROS 935 EAST WAYZATA BLVD WAYZATA MN 55391 RICHARD SATHRE SATHRE-BERQUIST 150 SOUTH BROADWAY WAYZATA MN 55391 RICK MURRAY BUILDERS DEVELOPMENT INC 1055 E WAYZATA BLVD PO BOX 637 WAYZATA MN 55391 WILLIAM PRITCHARD US HOME 300 SOUTH HIGHWAY 169 SUITE 870 ST LOUIS PARK MN 55426 1-3 cf M JAS' 11 191 BRUCE MALKERSON POPHAM & HAIK 3300 PIPER JAFFRAY TOWER MINNEAPOLIS MN 55402 HANS HAGEN HANS HAGEN HOMES 2353 RICE ST PAUL MN 55113 JIM STEILAN POPHAM & HAIK 3300 PIPER JAFFRAY TOWER MINNEAPOLIS MN 55402 JOHN HERMAN LEONARD STREET & DEINARD 150 SOUTH 5TH STREET #2300 MINNEAPOLIS MN 55402 1-3 elm JAIL 11 '91 January 8, 1990 Mr. Robert Rohlf Director Hennepin County Library 12601 Ridgedale Drive Minnetonka, MN 55434 t -y CIN OF PLYmouTR SUBJECT: CONFIRMATION OF SITE 3 FOR PLYMOUTH COMMUNITY LIBRARY Dear Bob: This letter confirms my telephone conversation with David Kramer. At their January 7 meeting, the Plymouth City Council directed that a letter be sent to you requesting the official minutes confirming the Library Board's selection of Site 3 for the Plymouth Community Library. You indicated that this formal action will be taken at the Board's January 24 meeting. Upon receipt of the minutes, it is my understanding that the Council will entertain a proposal to have a professional enter into land acquisition efforts for this site. Let me know if you have any questions. My phone number is 550-5013. Sincere , Frank o e Assis t City Manager FB:kec cc: Mayor and City Council CAI uM.` 1 1 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 11 League of Minnesota Cities January 7, 1991 183 University Ave. East St. Paul, MN 55101-2526 (612) 227.5600 (FAX: 221.0986) Z -S To: Newly Elected City Officials Mayors, Managers, Councilmembers (% City Clerk) From: Darlyne Lang, Director, Conference/Building Subj: Newly ELected Officials Conference On Saturday, February 2, the League has scheduled a Conference for Newly Elected Officials. This is a valuable tool for those who have recently taken office, or for those who didn't have an opportunity to attend when they took office. We encourage you to enroll your newly elected officials as soon as possible. The program offers the opportunity to become familiar with the League's services and staff. They'll learn about: . What councils can and cannot do . Personal liability and conflict of interest • Open Meeting Law and Data Practices Act • Budgeting and Finance • Planning • Personnel and labor relations Detailed information is available in the attached brochure. Also attached is a registration form for the conference and hotel accommodations, if required. We look forward to meeting you. C'M JAN 11 '91 I- S Start public service on the right track and attend the League of Minnesota Cities Conference for Newly Elected Officials Saturday Radisson Hotel South February 2, 1991 Bloomington Now that the elections are over, it's time to take your seat on the council and meet the growing challenge of governing your city. Recognizing the tough job and serious respon- sibilities confronting you, the League of Minnesota Cities is offering a one -day Conference for Newly Elected Officials to ease the transition. Registration The registration fee for this Conference is $60 per person including tuition, materials, continental break- fast, luncheon, and breaks. The "spouse" fee of $25 includes all the above except materials. See registration form at right. Hotel accommodations at the Radisson Hotel South, Bloomington are $65 for single or double occupancy. Date and Location Saturday February 2, 1991 Radisson Hotel South, Bloomington 7800 Normandale Blvd. Bloomington, MN 55435-3899 Topics • Councils: What they can and cannot do • Personal liability and conflict of interest • Open meeting law and data practices act • Survival tactics for the newly elected official Break-out sessions for cities with populations under 2,500; 2,500-4,999; and over 5,000. • Budgeting and finance • Planning • Personnel and labor relations Meet the staff 0 A special early morning pre -conference welcome hosted by the League of Minnesota Cities and the Association of Metropolitan Municipalities is sched- uled for 7:15 a.m. Come meet the folks who work for you. LMC and AMM staff and board members are anxious to get to know you. This session presents a way for you to learn more aboutwhat they provide: research and inquiry service, lobbying activities, 4M Fund investment opportunities, insurance trust, and more. Special pre -conference sessions on Friday, Febru- ary 1, 1991 presented by Government Training Service Two special seminars are scheduled the day before the conference for newly elected officials and vet- erans. Take advantage of these opportunities to learn some of the techniques that will help enhance your effectiveness in public office. • Hanging tough in tough times 8:30 a.m.-4:30 p.m. • Using your personal style to make an impact on the council 7:00-9:15 p.m. Contact GTS, Suite 401, 480 Cedar St., St. Paul, MN 55101, (612) 222-7409 or Minnesota Toll Free (800) 652-9719 for a direct mailing. ""' JAN 11 '9 1 �• s League of Minnesota Cities Conference for Newly Elected Officials Saturday February 2, 1991 Radisson Hotel South, Bloomington ...................0000. 0* 0 0 0 0. Conference for Newly Elected Officials February 2, 1991 ; Radisson Hotel South, Bloomington • Advance Registration • (Deadline January 25) City: • Contact Person: • Telephone # • A.C. Name • • • Title Address • • City, State, Zip Code • Spouse ' Registration: City officials $60 • • Spouse $25 • • Make checks payable and • • MAIL THIS PORTION TO: ' • League of Minnesota Cities • : 183 University Avenue East ; • St. Paul, MN 55101 • ............................... ...... 0 0 0# 0* ...... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0• Housing Reservation Form League of Minnesota Cities ; Conference for Newly Elected Officials February 2, 1991 Name : Representing ; Address 0 ' : City State Zip ; :1 / l l � l • • month liIIX I= Atrivel Tme m,anjl DAY Ytu • • Arrival Date Departure Date • Check in time 3:00 p.m. . Check out time 12:00 noon • To insure space/rate availability, please respond • :prior to January 18, 1991 ' • $65.00 + Tax Single (One Person) • • $65.00 + Tax Double (Two People) • • I will arrive after 4:00 p.m. Please guarantee the • reservation with: • • o (Credit Card) Number and Expiration Date • • Phone ( ) c'm JAN 11 ,91 : MAIL THIS PORTION TO: ; • Radisson Hotel South • 7800 Normandale Blvd. : Bloomington, MN 55435-3899 • (612) 835-7800 ................................ 1.-4 SHINGLE CREEK WATERSHED MANAGEMENT COMMISSION 3030 Harbor Lane • Plymouth, MN 55447 (612) 553-1144 M I N U T E S November 8, 1990 A meeting of the Shingle Creek Watershed Management Commission was called to order by Chairman Neil Johnson on Thursday, November 8, 1990, at 1:00 p.m. at the Saint Andrews Club, 8700 Edinbrook Crossing, Brooklyn Park, MN. Present were: Sy Knapp, Brooklyn Center; Neil Johnson, Brooklyn Park; Bill Monk, Crystal; Gerry Butcher, Maple Grove; Jacob Burggraff, Minneapolis (non-voting); Mark Hanson, New Hope; Gene Hakan- son, Osseo; Fred Moore, Plymouth; Lee Gustafson, Robbins - dale; Bill Weidenbacher and Dale Claridge, JMM; Curt Pear- son, attorney; and Judie Anderson, recording secretary. 1. Minutes. Butcher moved and Moore seconded a motion to approve the minutes of the October 11, 1990 meeting. Motion carried. 2. Treasurer's Report. Moore moved and Hakanson seconded a motion to approve the Treasurer's Report. Motion carried. 3. Approval of Claims. Moore moved and Hakanson seconded a motion to approve claims totaling $3,242.71. The claims were approved by roll call vote: ayes - Knapp, John- son, Monk, Butcher, Hanson, Hakanson, Moore and Gustafson; nayes - none; ab- sent - Minneapolis. 4. Correspondence. The Commissioners reviewed the Communications Log. No action was re- quired. 5. Twin Lakes/Ryan Lake Improvement Proiect. Gustafson and Claridge gave an update on the progress of construction of the improvements which began at the end of October. Minneapolis has completed the storm sewer extension alongside 49th Avenue. Pearson reported that ease- ments from the Soo Line Railroad have been received. M JAN 11 '91 SCWMC Minutes November S, 1990 page 2 6. Other Business. Moore reported on the first meeting of the Task Force on 509 Rules. The members are considering proposed rules for second generation management plans. Butcher moved and Hakanson seconded a motion directing that projects which require land use amendment be submitted as project reviews for adminis- trative approval. Motion carried. JMM will provide a water quality program report in January. The Twin Lakes Association has been in contact with the cities of Brooklyn Center and Crystal re a grant for water quality improvements. Results of the current study could be used as a baseline for such a program. There being no further business before the Commission, Monk moved and Gustaf- son seconded a motion to adjourn. Motion carried. The meeting was adjourned at 1:35 p.m. Respectfully submitted, cl—L Judie A. Anderson Recording Secretary JAA:tim PLYMOUTH LEGISLATIVE REPRESENTATIVES 191 STATE SENATE DISTRICTS Senator Judy Traub - District 45 235 State Capitol 3605 Oakton Ridge St. Paul, MN 55155 Minnetonka, MN 55343 (Precincts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, Home: 939-0199 12 & 14) 297-8064 Senator Patrick McGowan - District 48 129 State Office Building 12231 - 69th Ave. N. St. Paul, MN 55155 Maple Grove, MN 55369 (Precincts 1, 2, 11, 12, 15 & 16) Home: 425-8758 296-2159 HOUSE DISTRICTS Representative Ron Abrams - District 45A Room 209 State Office Building 2211 Austrian Pines Lane St. Paul, MN 55155 Minnetonka, MN 55343 (Precincts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8) Home: 546-5356 296-9934 Representative Peggy Leppik, District 45B 225 State Office Building 7500 Western Avenue St. Paul, MN 55155 Golden Valley, MN 55427 (Precincts 9, 10, 13, and 14) Home: 546-3328 296-7026 Representative Warren Room 301 State Office St. Paul, MN 55155 (Precincts 1, 2, 11, 296-5502 Limmer - District Building 12, 15, and 16) 48A 12057 N. 62nd Place Maple Grove, MN 55369 Home: 553-0578 3RD CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT Congressman James Ramstad U.S. Representative 1026 Longworth Office Building Washington, D.C. 20515 (202) 225-2871 U.S. SENATE Senator David Durenberger 154 Russell Senate Office Building Washington, D.C. 20510 (202) 224-3244 Senator Paul Wellstone 506 Hart Senate Office Building Washington, D.C. 20515 (202) 224-5641 8120 Penn Ave. S. Bloomington, MN 55431 Office: 881-4600 1020 Plymouth Building 12 So. 6th Street Minneapolis, MN 55402 Office: 370-3382 P.O. Box E 5588 St. Paul, MN 55165 Ohl JAN, 11 '91 CUSTOMER SERVICE LINE January 4, 1991 ANONYMOUS 1-8 PROBLEM: Caller registered his opposition to the City's new policy of charging $5 for dog licenses during the month of January. He stated he believes the waived license fee during January served as an incentive to those dog owners who consistently complied with city ordinance by licensing their dogs. He said charging a fee at other times of the year was acceptable. A second item he addressed was the community center. He said that in reading the local newspapers, he has gotten the impression that the community center issue is being resurrected. He stated his opposition to the community center and said he would like to see the issue laid to rest. (1/4/91, 9:04 a.m.) SOLUTION: No response was possible because this call was anonymous. Ord JA,4f ZONING NEWS - DECEMBER 1990 Impact Fees on the Rise A survey by the Growth Management Studies center at the University of Florida found that the use of impact fees is spreading and that the amount charged is also rising. The study documented impact fees in 1988 and 1990 in 33 jurisdictions across the country. (See Tables 1 and 2.) According to the study, the average impact fee for residential uses has increased by 39 percent since 1988. The average fee for each single-family home is now $3,001. The fees help cover the costs of roads, parks, public facilities, police, fire, libraries, and schools. Impact fees for water and sewer facilities pushed this amount up to $5,729. The average fee for water was $1,261 and for sewers was $1,467. Increases in fees for other uses were equally significant. Industrial development fees experienced an 80 percent increase, meaning that the average fee is $968 for each 1,000 square feet in a facility. The average office development impact fee per 1,000 square feet of floor area went up 50 percent to $2,165, far outstripping fee increases for retail development, which rose only 17 percent to $3,321. But retail uses have historically been hit with higher fees than any other use, especially for road improvements and construction. For that reason, the comparably low increase could simply mean that the burden is being spread more evenly. During the same period, however, retail prices increased by approximately 10 percent. Thus, impact fees are increasing at a rate far in excess of consumer prices. Water and sewer impact fees for these three categories of uses were also surveyed, but, because of a tremendous variation in the fees charged, no generalizations could be made about overall changes. Looking at some of the fees in detail, fire protection seems to have benefited the most. Fees covering those services saw average increases of 78 percent for single-family homes, 162 percent for industry, 198 percent for offices, and 217 percent for retail uses. The local park systems received a boost with single-family homes experiencing a 136 percent increase in the average park impact fee. The average road impact fee showed a substantial increase of 53 percent for single-family homes. Industrial development experienced the greatest increase in road impact fees -87 percent. Road impact fees for office and retail development rose 49 percent and 14 percent, respectively. The relatively low increase in road impact fees for retail projects contributed significantly to the overall low increase for retail development impact fees. While these services benefited from increases in fees. public facilities suffered average losses of 11 percent for single-family homes and 11 percent for retail. There was also a decline of seven percent in impact fees assessed retail uses for police protection. It is interesting to note that retail impact fees declined for both of these services. The highest impact fees are found in California, specifically in Orange County, California, where road impact fees alone are frequently over $5,000 for a single-family home. Other southern California communities levy impact fees in excess of $15,000 per single-family home. S. L. 9"� 1-9 Public Facilities 107 Thble 1.1988 National Averages for Lnpact Fees, by Type 82 General General General Single -Family Industry, Office, Retail, Home Per Per Ppr Type of Impact Fee Per Unit 1000 sq.ft. 1000 sq.ft. 11000 sq.ft. Road $1,009 $427 $1,230 $2,526 Parks 223 no fee no fee no fee Public Facilities 107 33 82 130 Police Protection 51 49 79 111 Fire Protection 76 29 50 70 Library 90 no fee no fee no fee Schools 606 no fee no fee no fee TOTAL $2,162 $537 $1,441 $2,837 Source: James C Nicholas with Kellie Ruscher, 'Impact Fees on the Rise" Growth Management Studies Newsiener, June 1990, 1. Table 2.1990 National Averages for Impact Fees, by Type Single -Family General General General Industry, Office, Retail, Home Per Per Per Type of Impact Fee Per Unit 1000 sq.ft, 1,000 sq.ft. 1,000 sq.ft. Road $1,547 $800 $1,840 $2,881 Parks 526 no fee no fee no fee Public Facilities 95 37 87 115 Police Protection 53 55 89 103 Fire Protection 135 76 149 222 Library 86 no fee no fee no fee Schools 559 no fee no fee no fee 'DOTAL $3,001 $%8 $2,165 $3,321 Source: James C Nicholas with Kellie Ruscher, "Impact Fees on the Rise" Growth Management Studies Ne"Ieaer, lune 1990, 2. CIA, J4�V' 11 '91 MEMO CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 DATE: January 11, 1991 TO: James G. Wil C1 Manager FROM: Charles E. D 1ud, Community Development Coordinator, through Blair Trem omunity Development Director SUBJECT: HENNEPIN/'COUNTY WASTE TRANSFER STATION CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPLIC ION (89057) The City of Plymouth received 10 sets of plans on October 29, 1990, in response to our letters of August 24, 1990, and August 31, 1990. The Development Review Committee reviewed the revised plans on Wednesday, November 7, 1990, but did not yet have the benefit of comments from the City's engineering consultant. On November 13, 1990 the Development Review Committee again considered the revised plans --with the engineering comments available. On November 14, 1990 Hennepin County requested amendment to their Site Plan to add a classroom facility. A DRC Stage II letter has been sent to Hennepin County reviewing deficiencies remaining and also requesting plan revisions reflecting the classroom addition. There has been partial response to that letter of November 20, 1990, which was reviewed by the DRC December 14, 1990, and a letter was sent to the County on December 20, 1990 with comments on these partial responses. No additional County responses to our November 20, 1990 letter have been received. Attachments: 1. December 20, 1990 DRC Letter (cc/cd/89057:dl) CtM Jar .� January 10, 1991 Municipal Legislative Commission Messerli & Kramer 1500 Northland Plaza Blvd. 3800 West 80th Street Minneapolis, MN 55431 Dear Sir/Madam: I-1010'.. . On January 7, the Plymouth City Council appointed Carole Helliwell, Councilmember, and James G. Willis, City Manager, to the Municipal Legislative Commission for terms to expire December 31, 1991. They can be reached as follows: Carole Helliwell P.O. Box 42183 Plymouth, MN 55442 Phone: 557-1530 V.M. : 550-5066 James G. Willis, Manager City of Plymouth 3400 Plymouth Blvd. Plymouth, MN 55447 Phone: 550-5011 FAX 550-5060 If you have any questions, please call me at 550-5014. Sincerely, Laurie Rauen orst City Clerk Enc. 014 JAWN 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (61?� 550-5000 CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou The following members were absent: Mayor Beraman Councilmember Ricker introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-52 APPOINTMENTS TO MUNICIPAL LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Carole Helliwell and James G Willis are appointed to the Municipal Legislative commission expire December 31, 1991. Plymouth that hereby for terms to The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Zitur and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. C!", Jim; 11 '91 January 10, 1991 Greg Moore Northwest Suburbs Cable Communication 6900 Winnetka Avenue North Brooklyn Park, MN 55428 Dear Mr. Moore: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reappointed James G. Willis to the Northwest Suburbs Community Access Corporation for a term to expire February, 1993. If you have any questions, please call me at 550-5014. Sincerely, Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk Enc. C'M &i' 1 i 'c1 ^400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH.. MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 x -+aa. CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou. The following members were absent: Mayor Beraman Deputy Mayor Vasiliou introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91- 48 APPOINTMENT TO NORTHWEST SUBURBS COMMUNITY ACCESS CORPORATION WHEREAS, the City has been requested to appoint an individual to the Northwest Suburbs Community Access Corporation. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that James G Willis is hereby appointed to the Northwest Suburbs Community Access Corporation for a term expiring February, 1993. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Ricker , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou. The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. January 10, 1991 Association of Metropolitan Municipalities 300 Hanover Building 480 Cedar Street St. Paul, MN 55101 Dear Sir/Madam: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council designated Kim M. Bergman, Mayor, and Bob Zitur, Councilmember, as its legislative contacts for the Association of Metropolitan Municipalities for 1991. They can be reached as follows: Kim M. Bergman 13930 60th Avenue North Plymouth, MN 55446 Phone: 557-7030 V.M. : 550-5065 Bob Zitur 12185 48th Circle Plymouth, MN 55442 Phone: 559-3728 V.M. : 550-5069 If you have any questions, please call me at 550-5014. Sincerely, �LL. Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 Jim Stromen Holmes and Graven 470 Pillsbury Center Minneapolis, MN 55402 Dear Mr. Stromen: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reappointed Fred Moore as Director and Kim M. Bergman as Alternate Director to the Suburban Rate Authority for a term to expire January 31, 1992. Enclosed is a copy of the approving resolution. If you have any questions, please call me at 550-5014. Sincerely, Laurie Laurie Raueuenho�st City Clerk Enc. CPO JAN 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 I- tato,, CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January , 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou. The following members were absent: Mayor Bergman Councilmember Zitur introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-49 DESIGNATING DIRECTOR AND ALTERNATE DIRECTOR TO THE SUBURBAN RATE AUTHORITY WHEREAS, the City has been requested to appoint a Director and Alternate Director to the Suburban Rate Authority for 1991. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that Fred Moore is hereby appointed as Director and Kim M Bergman is hereby appointed as Alternate Director to the Suburban Rate Authority for a term expiring January 31, 1992. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by _Councilmember Helliwell , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. C"I" J,G�! 11 '91 January 10, 1991 Independent School District 281 Administrative Offices 4148 Winnetka Avenue North New Hope, MN 55427 Dear Sir/Madam: T- loao'.. On January 7, the Plymouth City Council appointed Councilmember Bob Zitur as its representative to the District. Please send any mailings to: Bob Zitur 12185 48th Circle Plymouth, MN 55442 Sincerely, 'st-Y-Lc Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk GIM JSP; I 1 '91 3490 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 January 10, 1991 Independent School District No. 270 Administrative Offices 1001 Highway 7 Hopkins, MN 55343 Dear Sir/Madam: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council appointed Councilmember Lloyd Ricker as its representative to the District. Please send any mailings to: Lloyd Ricker 17015 14th Avenue North Plymouth, MN 55447 Sincerely, Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk CIM JAN 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOI 1 FWARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 January 10, 1991 Independent School District No. 279 Administrative Offices 11200 93rd Avenue Maple Grove, MN 55369 Dear Sir/Madam: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council appointed Councilmember Carole J. Helliwell as its representative to the District. Please send any mailings to: Carole J. Helliwell P.O. Box 42183 Plymouth, MN 55442 Sincerely, Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk C'm ; "v 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 January 10, 1991 I- la a. ciN of PLYMOUTFF Independent School District No. 284 Administrative Offices 210 State Highway 101 P.O. Box 660 Wayzata, MN 55391 Dear Sir/Madam: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council appointed Councilmember Lloyd Ricker as its representative to the District. Please send any mailings to: Lloyd Ricker 17015 14th Avenue North Plymouth, MN 55447 The Council also reappointed Mary Patterson Bisek as the representative to the District 284 Community Education Advisory Council for a term to expire July 1, 1992. If you have any questions, please call me at 550-5014. Sincerely, yl - Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou The following members were absent: Mayor Bergman Co ncilmember Zitur introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-51 APPOINTMENT TO SCHOOL DISTRICT 284 COMMUNITY EDUCATION ADVISORY COUNCIL BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that Mary Bisek is hereby appointed to the School District 284 Community Education Advisory Council for a term to expire July 1, 1992. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Helliwell , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Zitur, Ricker, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None . Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. Cis" i• �a� January 10, 1991 CITY OF PUMOUTR John Derus, Chairman Hennepin County Board of Commissioners Hennepin County Government Center Minneapolis, MN 55487 Dear John: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reappointed Mary Gabe to the Urban Hennepin County Citizens' Advisory Committee for a term to expire June 30, 1992. If you have any questions regarding this appointment, please call me at 550-5014. Sincerely, Laurie Rauen orst City Clerk Enc. 0114 J41Y 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 I -10a CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou. The following members were absent: Mayor Bergman Deputy Mayor Vasiliou introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-53 APPOINTMENT TO URBAN HENNEPIN COUNTY CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMITTEE WHEREAS, the City has been requested to appoint an individual to the Urban Hennepin County Citizens' Advisory Committee. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that Mary Gabe is hereby appointed to the Urban Hennepin County Citizens' Advisory Committee for a term to expire June 30, 1992. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Zitur , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell. Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. CIM im 11 191 January 10, 1991 Judie A. Anderson Executive Secretary Elm Creek Watershed 3030 Harbor Lane Plymouth, MN 55447 Dear Ms. Anderson: Management Commission On January 7, the Plymouth City Commissioner and Vern Peterson Elm Creek Watershed Management January 31, 1992. Enclosed is resolution. Sincerely, 1 Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk Enc. "I-Iav�" . Council reappointed Fred Moore as as Alternate Commissioner to the Commission to terms expiring a copy of the approving CIM PI! 11,91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou The following members were absent: Mayor Bergman Councilmember Zitur introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-50 DESIGNATING DIRECTOR AND ALTERNATE DIRECTOR TO THE ELM CREEK WATER CONSERVATION DISTRICT WHEREAS, the City has been requested to appoint a Director and Alternate Director to the Elm Creek Water Conservation District for 1991. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that Fred Moore is hereby appointed as Director and Vern Peterson is hereby appointed as Alternate Director to the Elm Creek Water Conservation District for a term expiring January 31, 1992. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Helliwell , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. GIM JAN, I 111 January 10, 1991 Marcy Shapiro, Director West Hennepin Human Services Planning Board 4100 Vernon Avenue South St. Louis Park, MN 55416 Dear Ms. Shapiro: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reappointed Anita Vogel to the West Hennepin Human Services Planning Board for a term to expire 1/93. Enclosed is a copy of the appointing resolution. Sincerely, Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk Enc. �H-ml 1�• 3400 PL",'MOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 January 10, 1991 Anita Vogel 3410 Sycamore Lane N. Plymouth, MN 55441 Dear Ms. Vogel: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reappointed you to the West Hennepin Human Services Planning Board for a term to expire January, 1993. Enclosed is a copy of the appointing resolution. The City Council appreciates your service on behalf of the City of Plymouth to this important Board. Thank you. Sincerely, Laurie Z t City Clerk Enc. C'm im, 11 '91 ^400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 I• la ol.. . CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur,_ Deputy Mayor Vasiliou . The following members were absent: Mayor Bergman Deputy Mayor Vasiliou introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-46 APPOINTMENT TO WEST HENNEPIN HUMAN SERVICES PLANNING BOARD WHEREAS, the City has been requested to appoint a representative to the West Hennepin Human Services Planning Board. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that Anita Vogel is hereby appointed to the West Hennepin Human Services Planning Board for a term to expire January 31, 1993. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Zitur , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. January 10, 1991 Patricia Wilder, Director Northwest Hennepin Human 7323 58th Avenue North Crystal, MN 55428 Dear Ms. Wilder: Z-talo4, f E& CIN OF PLYMOUTFF Services Council On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reppointed Linda Dieleman to the Northwest Hennepin Human Services Council Advisory Committee for a term to expire December 31, 1992. Enclosed is a copy of the approving resolution. The City Council is in the process of soliciting applications from citizens interested in appointment to various boards and commissions. In March the Council will consider an appointment to fill the vacancy on the Advisory Committee for a term to expire December 31, 1991, as well as an appointment to the Executive Committee. Sincerely, c�- L urie Rauen orst City Clerk Enc. 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 Linda Dieleman, Advisory Committee Northwest Hennepin Human Services Council 7323 58th Avenue North Crystal, MN 55428 Dear Ms. Dieleman: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council reappointed you to the Northwest Hennepin Human Services Council Advisory Committee for a term to expire December 31, 1992. Enclosed is a copy of the appointing resolution. The City Council appreciates your service on behalf of the City of Plymouth to this important Committee. Sincerely, Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk Enc. CIM JAN 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 I- M c" CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou. The following members were absent: Mayor Bergman Councilmember Zitur introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-47 APPOINTMENT TO NORTHWEST HENNEPIN HUMAN SERVICES COUNCIL WHEREAS, the City has been requested to appoint representatives to the Northwest Hennepin Human Services Council. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that the following appointments are made to the Northwest Hennepin Human Services Council for the terms indicated: Linda Dieleman - term expires 12/31/92 The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Helliwell , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Vasiliou The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. C'm JAN 11 '91 I-Iao� PCITVF January 10, 1991 PLYMOLaR Dr. Doug Lowin Park Nicollet Clinic 3007 Harbor Lane Plymouth, MN 55447 Dear Dr. Lowin: Thank you for agreeing to serve as the Health Officer for the City of Plymouth again in 1991. Enclosed is a copy of the appointing resolution. Sincerely, La rie Rauenho st City Clerk Enc. cry JAI" 11 `91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 =-1a CITY OF PLYMOUTH Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Plymouth, Minnesota, was held on the 7th day of January, 1991. The following members were present: Councilmembers Helliwell, Ricker, Zitur, Deputy Mayor Vasiliou. The following members were absent: Mayor Bercrman Deputy Mayor Vasili� introduced the following resolution and moven its adoption: RESOLUTION NO. 91-44 DESIGNATING CITY HEALTH OFFICER FOR 1991 WHEREAS, State Statute requires that the City appoint a Health Officer. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Plymouth that Dr. Doug Lowin, 3007 Harbor Lane, Plymouth, be appointed to act as Health Officer for the City of Plymouth for 1991. The motion for adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Councilmember Ricker , and upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof: Helliwell, Ricker, Vasiliou, Zitur The following voted against or abstained: None Whereupon the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted. QW, JAN 11 '" 1 January 9, 1991 Gregory Ptacin General Manager Minnesota Suburban Publications 7831 East Bush Lake Road Bloomington, MN 55439 Dear Mr. Ptacin: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council designated the Plymouth Sailor as its official newspaper for 1991, effective January 28. We will contact Meridel Hedblom for assistance with our legal publications and, as in the past, Jay Maxwell for our news releases and miscelleneous coverage needs. We look forward to working with you and your staff in 1991. Sincerely, Laurie Rauenhorst City Clerk Enc. 0114 JAN 11 'J 1 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-50nn January 9, 1991 Brigitte Kay Reuther Weekly News, Inc. 240 S. Minnetonka Avenue Wayzata, MN 55391 Dear Brigitte: On January 7, the Plymouth City Council designated the Plymouth Sailor as its official newspaper for 1991, effective January 28. Designation of the official newspaper is done at the first regular Council meeting of each year. The Council invites the Weekly News to submit a proposal for consideration as the City's official newspaper again next year. Thank you for your help in 1990! affidavit procedure for the City minute notice" was appreciated. Sincerely, Z Lau ie Rauenh rst City Clerk Your willingness to amend the and adjust deadlines for "a last 0*1 JAR, 11 'q1 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONIP (612) 550-5000 I-Iaa 1991 CITY COUNCIL APPOINTbMNTS COUNCIL COORDINATING REPRESENTATIVES 1. Independent School District No. 279 Carole Helliwell Annual 2. Independent School District No. 281 Bob Zitur Annual 3. Independent School Districts 270 and 284 Lloyd Ricker Annual 4. Park and Recreation Advisory Commission Lloyd Ricker Annual 5. Planning Commission Maria Vasiliou Annual 6. Board of Zoning Adjustments and Appeals Kim M. Bergman Annual AGENCIES AND BOARDS 1. Special Assessment Committee Carole Helliwell James G. Willis Annual Bob Zitur Fred Moore 2. West Hennepin Human Services Planning Board (2 yr. terms) Anita Vogel 1/93 Joy Tierney 1/92 3. Northwest Hennepin Human Services Council (2 yr. terms) Vacant - Executive Committee 12/31/91 Linda Dieleman - Advisory Committee 12/31/92 Vacant - Advisory Committee 12/31/91 4. Sewer Service Area #1 Advisory Board Fred Moore Ongoing 5. Northwest Suburbs Cable Communication Comm. Kim M. Bergman (Council representative) Ongoing James G. Willis (Staff representative) 6. Northwest Suburbs Community Access Corp. (2 yr. terms) James G. Willis 2/93 Helen LaFave 2/92 C/Al AN 11 'q I 7. Minneapolis Police Recruitment System Dick Carlquist (Director) Ongoing Dennis Paulson (Alternate) 8. Suburban Rate Authority (1 yr. terms) Fred Moore (Director) 12/31/91 Kim M. Bergman (Alternate) 12/31/91 9. Bassett Creek Water Management Commission (3 yr. terms) Fred Moore (Director) 1/31/93 John Sweeney (Alternate) 10. Elm Creek Watershed Management Commission (1 yr. terms) Fred Moore (Director) 1/31/92 Vern Peterson (Alternate) 11. Shingle Creek Watershed Management Commission (3 yr. terms) Fred Moore (Director) 1/31/93 John Sweeney (Alternate) 12. School District 284 Community Education Advisory Council (2 yr. terms) Lynes Getten 7/1/91 Mary Patterson Bisek 7/1/92 13. School District 281 Joint Powers Agreement Eric Blank Ongoing 14. School District 284 Joint Powers Agreement Lloyd Ricker Eric Blank 15. Lake Region Mutual Aid Association Lyle Robinson 16. North Suburban Mutual Aid Association Lyle Robinson 17. Fire Training Center Joint Powers Agreement Lyle Robinson 18. League of Minnesota Cities Study Committees Public Safety and Personnel - Frank Boyles Land Use, Energy, Environment and Transportation - Blair Tremere Revenue Sources - James G. Willis 19. MuniciRal Legislative Commission (1 yr. terms) Carole Helliwell James G. Willis Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing 12/31/91 12/31/91 20. Association of Metropolitan Municipalities Study Committees General Legislation - Frank Boyles Transportation - Frank Boyles Housing - Blair Tremere Municipal Revenue - James G. Willis Solid Waste (with LMC) - Dick Pouliot 21. Association of Metropolitan Municipalities Legislative Contact Kim M. Bergman Bob Zitur 22. Citizens Advisory Committee, French Reg, Park Bob Zitur Ongoing Ongoing Ongoing 23. Wayzata/Plymouth Area Chemical Health Commission Maria Vasiliou Ongoing 24. Staff/Council Recycling Committee Bob Zitur Dick Pouliot Ongoing Helen LaFave Fred Moore Maria Vasiliou Frank Boyles 25. Urban Hennepin County Citizens' Advisory Committee Mary Gabe 6-30-92 26. West Suburban Mediation Center Board Vacant 27. Environmental Cities Coalition Carole Helliwell 28. Plymouth Civic League Kim M. Bergman Ongoing 1/92 1/92 11", JAA�' 1 I'.9 i January 4, 1991 Hennepin County Board of Commissioners A-2400 Government Center Minneapolis, MN 55487 SUBJECT: FISCAL DISPARITIES Ladies & Gentlemen: Z- lab Thank you for supplying copies of "Is the Share Fair?" for the Plymouth City Council. It is a concise, well done publication which clearly identifies the impact of Fiscal Disparities on the County and communities like Plymouth. We wholeheartedly agree that something must be done! As Commissioner Jude suggested, it is time for us to join forces in a major way to reduce the inequities associated with the Fiscal Disparities Law. We suggest that a meeting be scheduled between County Board members and "loser" communities to discuss the most effective strategy to use in hopes of making Fiscal Disparities more equitable. Please telephone City Manager Jim Willis at 550-5011 to arrange for a meeting so that we can get this effort underway. And thank you for taking the lead on this important issue. Sincerely, Kim M. Bergman, Mayor 0 Councilmember Vasiliou C-ouncilmember Zitur KM:kec a,�, 4 Councilmemb r Helliwell Co lmember Ricker �.�11 t31 �'� 5' 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 I- I ae. January 7, 1991 CITY OF PLYMOUTR Mr. William J. Brown Postmaster of Minneapolis 100 South 1st Street Minneapolis, MN 55401-9998 Dear Postmaster Brown: Mayor Kim Bergman asked me to thank you for your time discussing the matter of the name of the proposed new postal station in the City of Plymouth northerly of Rockford Road and westerly of State Highway 169. The concern is that the preliminary or tentative name is the Medicine Lake Station and that is not appropriate for a variety of reasons which focus on accessibility and ease of identity, especially since the City of Medicine Lake is a couple of miles south of this area. The City appreciates the opportunity to propose an alternative name for the new station which will be a welcome addition to the community. We will promptly undertake a local effort to solicit an appropriate alternative name and we will forward it to you. My department has been working with a representative of the postal service relative to the review and approval of the site plans for the facility and thus we are cognizant of the timing for this development. Please contact me if you have any questions or suggestions regarding this. Since ly, Blair Trem Community Development Director cc: Mayor Kim M. Bergman and City Councilmembers File (pl/bt/brown:jw) onnn PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH. MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 Z as PUBLIC SCHOOLS pendent School District 284 / JAN 4 19911- cL C1 TY 0o Pr`.YMMTH COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT. DISTRICT ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES 210 COUNTY ROAD 101 NORTH P.O. BOX 660 WAYZATA, MN 55391-9990 (612) 476-3100 FAX: (612) 476-3214 January 4, 1991 Charles E. Dillerud Community Development Coordinator CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 Plymouth Boulevard Plymouth, MN 55447 Dear Mr. Dillerud: The Wayzata School District has experienced significant census growth at the elementary school level over the past four years. During this period elementary enrollment increased by 1074 students. To accommodate this increased student population, the District has built two additional elementary schools (Plymouth Creek and Kimberly Lane). During 1991-92 we expect elementary school -aged population to increase by at least 230 students. To accommodate this number of students, we will need a total of 189 classrooms. With the opening of Kimberly Lane Elementary School in Fall 1991, the District will have 197 rooms including the relocatables at Birchview and Greenwood. We expect to use these extra eight rooms in the 1992-93 school year, based on current demographic data. If the City of Plymouth does not continue authorization of the conditional use permit on the four relocatables at Birchview and Greenwood, the School District will experience the following problems: 1. Birchview will have no classroom space for a Home Base (Latch Key) Program. 2. A total of 106 sixth grade Birchview students will have to be accommodated in a classroom pod designed for 85-90 students. 3. All available classroom space at Greenwood will be fully used. Depending on what decisions are made regarding future city water and sewer service, this elementary school could be impacted by new housing development. The administration and Citizens Advisory Council recommends that the two relocatables at Greenwood be used as reserve space for future growth. CPA JAN 11 `91 _- 1 a d January 4, 1991 Page 2 The School District requests use of the four elementary relocat- ables until the District builds its next elementary school (projected 1995-96). If this is not acceptable, the District would like to use the elementary relocatables a minimum of two years, or through the 1992-93 school year. This would allow us to see what happens with future development in Plymouth and its impact on enrollment. Loss of the relocatables will likely necessitate changing elementary attendance boundaries. Since this becomes a very emotional issue and we are changing boundaries for the 1991-92 school year, the District urges avoidance of any such action next year. Relocatables at the high school will be used as a back-up in the event that remodeling work is not completed by the start of the 1991-92 school year. The District does not anticipate a need for these relocatables beyond 1991-92. I trust this information will prove useful in your decision making process. Please give me a call if you have any questions. Many thanks for your time. Bruce Halgren Executive Director Academic Services ENRLMNT:Growth ON, Ahi 1 i 191 January 8, 1991 John P. Schueller 37 Tammy Hill Trail Randolph, New Jersey 07869 PCITVF PLVMOUTf+ Subject: Water Service Billing for 435 Queensland Lane, Plymouth Dear Mr. Schueller: Your letter of inquiry regarding water service at 435 Queensland Lane was given to me today for investigation. The billing in question was prepared as of the requested cut off dated August 30, 1990. The meter reading taken on that date was 778,500 gallons. This reading resulted in a final bill of $92.52 due on October 3, 1990. On September 25, 1990 our cashiers office received payment of $46.00 for the final billing, not the $92.52 as billed. Your statement, "paying the final billing in full", based upon the meter reading taken on August 30, 1990 is not correct. Your statement that additional charges have been added to your bill is not correct. At this time an unpaid balance of $46.52 remains on your bill for service cut off as of August 30, 1990. The balance due is a result of the billing for $92.52 you received, less the $46.00 payment you made. In the table below I have outlined your water usage based on quarterly readings taken for 1988, 1989 and 1990. You will notice that during the summer months your water volume is substantially higher than during other periods of the year. Upon researching your payments, we found a note written on the back side of your payment stub. We did not find the note at the time your $46.00 payment was remitted. I apologize for missing this note. Had we seen the note we would have responded to you to explain the charges on the final billing. CtM J4, A, 11 '41 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 1988 1989 1990 Jan. - Mar. 21,100 28,500 27,000 Apr. - Jun. 85,700 27,300 18,600 Jul. - Sept. 103,100 80,000 119,300 Oct. - Dec. 22,800 26,600 0 209,900 162,400 164,900 Upon researching your payments, we found a note written on the back side of your payment stub. We did not find the note at the time your $46.00 payment was remitted. I apologize for missing this note. Had we seen the note we would have responded to you to explain the charges on the final billing. CtM J4, A, 11 '41 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD. PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 Z- lac Page Two January 8, 1991 Our normal follow-up procedures generated the reminder notice of the unpaid balance of $46.52 which we sent to you on December 12, 1990. Your prompt payment would be greatly appreciated to close out your account. The unpaid balance remaining represents a lien against the property. Therefore, clear title cannot be transfered to the new owner per your sales agreement. If you need any further clarifications on your billing, please do not hesitate to contact me by phone at (612)550-5119 or in writing at 3400 Plymouth Blvd., Plymouth, MN 55447. Sincerely, _L�� L Daryl Sulander Assistant Finance Director cc: Dale E. Hahn, Finance Director James G. Willis, City Manager Mayor and City Council 423 % §14 W Icy- ci 0 > O'z 4 <r I , U2 m , L o a: Cc () jCL =) wo Lr) UJ >- t. LL (LZ) _jCL o -.0 'z -C, O0 Ln op C. 'o LU W U U_ LL) cc Z LU tL co Icy- <r Mfw. . Lr) -.0 Ln op C. 'o U_ Z 1Q John P. Schueler 37 Tammy Hill Trail Randolph, NJ. 07869 December 28, 1990 City Manager City of Plymouth 3400 Plymouth Blvd. Plymouth, MN. 55447 Dear Sir/Madam; After twenty-one years of paying water bills when due, I do not need to be receiving past due notices for an incorrect amount. See attached. Upon moving out of your service area, I paid the final bill (in full) based upon the meter reading taken on August 30, 1990. Since that time your finance people have added additional amounts to my bill. This seems a bit unreasonable as well as questionable. Please eliminate this charge. Thank you. zA' ' John P. Schueler CI&I ju, 11 '91 of Lf IV CIM JAh 11 '91 c« JAN I 1 '9t r P ear__ MG��� let van L47 DeLenjLef ?o,\�\t , 0 f\^\ coas o' A _ �ac\o a e,�c� �;�y COV all or\L y wtiri, �e(t;b i,�W o�k 1�a,�C���� 1C : V, CA Oi 611 vJ" ') 'I y-ec\r � y��, U ��sely �r�e� �o 'n In e\Jcryo>>e Ll -:1,o tU�v��a ��� FxPU\1S�Ch c7� 11\C Vvt�n� c« JAN I 1 '9t s 1 a.1L Jan. 4, 1991 Pat Murphy, Executive Director Union City Mission, Inca 3401 E. Medicine Lk.. Blvd. Plymouth, MN. 55441 Dear Pat, Since the Council Meeting of 12/10/90 RE: Conditional Use Permit for Transitional Lodging Facility, we have not been contacted by anyone from Union City Mission, Inc. In accordance with the terms of the ammendment to the abovermentioned conditional use permit, we request a meeting with the representatives of Union City Mission. The representatives of this neighborhood are most anxious to begin the discussion of possible solutions to the problems this area has experienced as a result of Union City Mission. We also feel it is very important to meet with the various people involved with the Transitional Lodge Facility: The director, program director, and supervisory personnel, etc. This is an area of immediate concern to the residents. We would like to have the Transitional Lodge Facility be the first area of discussion. We, in turn, will relate back to the neighborhood those ideas which you feel are important toward a better understanding of Union City Mission. We sincerely hope these discussions with neighborhood representatives/Union City Mission will be beneficial to all. Those listed below are the neighborhood representatives: Norbert & Carol Herby 3430 E. Medicine Lk. Blvd. Plym. 55441 #546-3749 Dick & Pat Katzmarek 3520 E. Medicine Lk. Blvd. 55441 544-4368 Walter & Shirley Shulz 3530 E. Medicine Lk. Blvd. 55441 545-1391 Sheila Goldstein 11515 37th Ave. No. 55441 559-8773 Barb Bartos 10720 36th Place No. 55441 544-9431 Janet Sullivan 11355 36th Place No. 55441 559-0767 Please contact the representatives to set the time, etc. of the meeting. We await your reply. Sincerely. c��� ease `)4� Pat Katzmarek - - - Carol Herby Neighborhood Representatives cc: Bergman - Ricker - VaAliou - Zitur -.. Helliwell Carlquist Jewett CIM ,SAN 11 '91 January 3, 1`='91 1460 County Road Plymouth, MN 55447 TO: The Mayor- t_ Cit:` Counci lmember=. ATTENTION: Bob Z i t u r Regarding: The Proposed Eike Pati', on County Road - from _runea.0 Lane to Fernbrook Lane Dear Mr. Zitur, My husband and I and several of our County Road 6 neighbors attended the Planning Commission Meeting on October 30 to discuss the Possibility of a. path in front of our houses to go to Fernbrook Lane and to a. tunnel under the Freeway to nowhere? We have had construction in front of our houses for the past t_ years noir: and have at least one year to completion of the widening of County Road 6 to four- lanes. We all had very strong objections to the Faith ---not the least of which was the danger of the curve. Tf,:.lo of the neighbors have driveways at an angle to the road and have a. hard time getting out of their• driveways now --let alone 1:':ihen bikers or walkers are going by the house. We have a. large cottonwood tree in front of our house that the city saved from destruction but i:':+i l l it withstand paving so close to it or is the city planning cin coming into what's left of our yard? We all had objections, which we voiced, loud and clear. The Planning Commission listened a.nd was very sympathetic, but the; had already Trade up their minds bef ir'e we even got there, which seems to be the way things are done in Our fair city. We knew that they would decide that the walking -bike traffic should have what the city thinks they want. We have i i ved here for 21 rears (some of our neighbors have been here even longer) and we know what ha.ppens around our area. We are aware of the tact that very little traffic goes by our homes on foot or on bikes, but =•o what We have had many dealings with THE CITYar d we all know that they dc what they :_rt, where they want and when the; want. The reason that was given to us in favor of the bike path ;•'•!a.s that the CITY will be bu i 1 di ng a. tunnel under the fr•eeway i424% to connect the Maths. The cost wi l l probably exceed $1.,000,000,00. 1s this necessary? After the last two council meetings, I''m afraid that our wishes will be falling On deaf ears. THE HOMEOWNERS C iN COUNT`( ROAD 6 FROM JUNEAU � LANE TO FERNBROOK LANE A1C i NOT WANT PLYMOUTH TO SPEND MONEY ON A BIKE PATH THAT WILL NOT BE USED DUE TCi HEAVY TRAFFIC. Sincer.el.r:•our=., Mary Elul en Kothe a.r. _ . C . Mayor Kim Berman Cou n c i l membe r Maria Va _• i t ou Coon i lmember Lloyd Ricker Counc i t member Carole Helliwell Parks °_ Rec--Eric Blank ■/��y[4! F r' Fred Moore Vi Gti+� Joel 1, i I 4- C! to .,AN 11 '91 January 10, 1991 Robert Navara 2510 Urbandale Lane Plymouth, MN 55447 I.- yak SUBJECT: EXTRA PATROL ASSIGNMENTS CONCERNING MOTOR VEHICLE SPEEDING ON URBANDALE LANE AND SNOWMOBILE VIOLATIONS ON PRIVATE PROPERTY Dear Mr. Navara: I have scheduled special enforcement assignments for the area in which you live. I'm not sure if we will be so lucky to "catch" both speeders and snowmobile operators violating the City ordinance at the same time. It would be nice! We will schedule at least two radar assignments between the hours of 3:30p.m.-6:30p.m. during the days when school is in session. I have also copied this letter to Bob Ford, a representative of the Northwest Trails Snowmobile Club. I am asking that his membership pay special attention to the area in which you live for snowmobile violations. With regard to the snowmobile violations, if you can obtain a number on a machine it would be helpful - but, I know how difficult that can be. In reviewing my snowmobile complaints from the general vicinity of your home, it appears we have two phantom operators who are generating all kinds of complaints from nearby residents. I would encourage you to call 9-1-1 anytime that you have a complaint regarding snowmobilers operating illegally. Although we do not have a compliment of snowmobiles at our disposal on the Police Department, we sometimes can apprehend violators or identify them from other witnesses. If you would like to discuss this matter further, do not hesitate to contact me at 550-5151. Sincerely, Richard J Carl ist Public Safety Director Plymouth Police Department Clio 'Im 1I'91' cc: James G. Willis - City Manager 3,", ?.,%` ,: )UTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447, TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 -I4LK CITY OF PLYMOUTH 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447 DATE: January 8, 1991 TO: Dick Carlquist, Public Safety Directo FROM: Frank Boyles, Assistant City Manage SUBJECT: PUBLIC SAFETY RELATED COMPLAINT Councilmember Vasiliou has received a complaint from Bob Navara, 2510 Urbandale Lane, Plymouth, home phone 475-4173, work phone 332-2980. Mr. Navara lives in Imperial Hills. He has had problems with all -terrain vehicles driving over his lawn as well as with snowmobiles speeding in his area. I would appreciate it if you would contact Mr. Narvara to inquire about his problem as well as to advise him to call us next time he has a problem. Could you document your actions so that we can put it in the information memorandum as a follow up to Councilmember Vasiliou's concern: Thanks Dick. s• �a � Metropolitan Waste Control Commission Mears Park Centre, 230 East Fifth Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101 612 222-8423 January 10, 1991 r= 4 TO: Mayors and Township Chairpersons ,1 Municipal Managers and Administrators Municipal Finance Officers This letter is to inform you of a recommendation before the Metropolitan Waste Control Commission to moderate debt service increases in 1992 through 1994 by using revenue in excess of operating expenditures in 1990 to pay for future debt service payments to the Metropolitan Council. Both the new Mission Statement adopted in 1990 and the Implementation Plan issued in 1989 affirm that water quality is a dominant, but not the solitary concern of the MWCC. Public expectations, the concerns of agencies which regulate environmental quality and our own professional judgments expand our focus to the broader issues spelled out in the Mission Statement and the Implementation Plan. In the 1991 Operating Budget, expenditures were limited to the same level as 1990, indexed by price changes. Any initiatives to tackle expanded responsibilities had to be budgeted within these limits. As a result, a number of challenges were deferred to future budget years. The challenge areas are forecast to increase the program budget by seven percent in 1992. This would be an added $6.4 million in program costs. The single largest challenge area increase is operating the expanded regional wastewater treatment plants. Additionally, we are facing an $11 million increase in debt service in 1992, for debt issued in prior years. Debt service of $41.4 million in 1991 is scheduled to increase to $52.0 million in 1992, to $56.4 million in 1993 and to $62.9 million in 1994. These increases add up to a 13.2 percent increase in forecast costs for 1992. The challenge is to absorb these increases --as well as the customary price increase -- while moderating the impact on total expenditures and on sewerage rates. A priority for fiscal planning is to develop methods that would moderate the major increases scheduled in 1992 and 1994. One alternative is to pay debt service early to the Metropolitan Council from excess revenues. This recommendation is before the Commission at the current time. If you have any questions or concerns about the financial challenges that lie ahead for the Metropolitan Waste Control Commission, please call me at (612) 229-2099. Sincerely, vw� 4, Li Gordon O. Voss Chief Administrator GOV:kmw L1891.GOV Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer CINI 1 'a 1 _- %a rr\ January 11, 1991 Sir FirstName LastName Address MENU CITY OF PLYM0UTFF SUBJECT: LANDSCAPE SCREENING ALONG SCHMIDT LAKE ROAD CITY PROJECT NO. 705 Dear Sir LastName: By letter dated December 28, 1990, I provided you a copy of a proposed landscaping plan along the southerly side of Schmidt Lake Road. At the information meeting which I held with the property owners, four property owners were in attendance. Since the meeting, I also received a call from one additional property owner. The City Council, at their January 7, 1991 Council meeting, approved the installation of the landscape material in accordance with the proposed plan. The City will be hiring a contractor to do the work and will be specifying that the material be installed this upcoming spring or early summer. Because of questions raised by property owners at the City Council meeting, the City Council also adopted the following motion regarding the maintenance of this boulevard area: "The City will maintain the area as best it can and that the City replacement guarantee will end after one year." This means that the City will install the plant material and guarantee its survivability for one year after planting. After the one year, the adjacent property owners will be responsible for the upkeep and maintenance of the plant material. If you have any questions regarding the City Council decision or the landscaping plan, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, Fred G. Moore, P.E. Director of Public Works FGM:kh CIM JAN 11 '91 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 The attached letter was sent to the following listing of people on •i• January 11, 1991 Mr. Larry Gyermon 10400 49th Avenue N. Plymouth, MN 55442 Mr. Tim Ferrara 10410 49th Avenue Plymouth, MN 55442 Mr. Robert Mattson 10420 49th Avenue N. Plymouth, MN 55442 Mr. Charles Ekstrum 10430 49th Avenue Plymouth, MN 55442 Mr. Sam Runnakko 10440 49th Avenue Plymouth, MN 55442 Mr. James Campbell 10500 49th Avenue Plymouth, MN 55442 Mr. Tom Stenoien 10510 49th Avenue Plymouth, MN 55442 elh jm' l 1 1 rJ 1 January 11, 1991 Mr. Charles Hayes 18540 25th Avenue Plymouth, MN 55447 SUBJECT: BAY POINTE ON MOONEY LAKE DEVELOPMENT (89005) Dear Mr. Hayes: I am responding to your letter dated December 10, 1990, and addressed to the Mayor and City Councilmembers. Your letter concerned the vacant lot immediately west of your property on 25th Avenue. First, I would like to apologize to you if you received any incorrect information from any employees or officials of the City of Plymouth. The lot adjacent to your home was created as a building site at the same time your lot was created with the Imperial Hills 4th Addition. Because the lot west of your house was lower than the other land within the development, sanitary sewer could not be provided economically to that property when it was developed in 1970. When the City Council approved the development in which your home is located and also the vacant lot to your west, a condition was established that this vacant lot could not be built upon until sanitary sewer was available. The sanitary sewer to serve this property needed to come from the west or the Reiser property. With Lundgren Brothers Construction Company purchasing the Reiser property for development and installing all the necessary utilities within that development, sanitary sewer is now available for the last remaining lot within the Imperial Hills area. As you state .in your letter, this lot was owned by the State Land Department. The reason they owned the property was because the original developer and property owner did not pay the taxes and it went to the State. I can recall that over my 12 years of employment with the City, I received several inquiries from builders or real estate people about building on that lot. My answer was always the same that it would not be buildable until sanitary sewer was constructed to the property. During their development of the plat, Lundgren Brothers also learned that this lot was owned by the State Land Department. Since they would be responsible for installing all of the sanitary sewer to serve this property, they inquired about purchasing this vacant lot. The purchase of State owned tax forfeiture land is administered by the Hennepin County Tax Forfeit Department. Lundgren Brothers did purchase this lot from the State of Minnesota. 3400 PLYMOUTH BOULEVARD, PLYMOUTH, MINNESOTA 55447. TELEPHONE (612) 550-5000 1-10(K Mr. Charles Hayes January 11, 1991 Page Two The City of Plymouth never had any ownership in this vacant lot. In your letter, you referred to the City donating park land to Lundgren Brothers. The City did not donate any park land to Lundgren Brothers with the development of their subdivision and, in fact, Lundgren Brothers was required to donate park land to the City of Plymouth. This donation also included a strip of land 30 feet wide for permanent trail access immediately west of this vacant lot. Part of the confusion in this matter may have arisen from the fact that the trail which the City constructed several years ago to provide access from 25th Avenue to the neighborhood park was not constructed within the legal easement which the City acquired from the Reisers. The actual trail construction was in the boulevard area of 25th Avenue, then partially within the vacant lot, and finally crossed the Reiser property into the park. The incorrect location of the trail was discovered as Lundgren Brothers began the grading and installation of the streets and utilities within their development. As part of their development, they then relocated and reconstructed the trail at its proper location along the west property line of the vacant lot and within the 30 foot land donated to the City of Plymouth as part of the development for the trail. If you would like to know what Lundgren Brothers had to pay to acquire this tax forfeit piece of land, you should make an inquiry to the Hennepin County Tax Forfeiture Department. From the standpoint of the City of Plymouth, they were responsible for and had to pay the cost to extend the sanitary sewer to this vacant lot. If this sewer had not been required by the City, they would have been able to eliminate approximately 100 feet of sanitary sewer construction. Also, Lundgren Brothers was responsible for constructing and paying the total cost to complete 25th Avenue from Walnut Grove Lane westerly to the Reiser property. This portion of uncompleted street was approximately 155 feet in length. Based upon the cost which the City pays when we construct streets, I would estimate that their cost was approximately $15,000. As can be seen by the cost that I have listed, the developer will make substantially less than the numbers you used in your letter. Again, let me apologize for any misinformation which you may have received from City officials on this vacant lot. This vacant lot has always been a' buildable lot once sanitary sewer was available to the property. If you have any additional questions or would like more information, please do not hesitate to contact me. My phone number is 550-5080. Sincerely, Fred G. Moore, P.E. Director of Public Works FGM:kh cc: James G. Willis, City Manager Blair Tremere, Director of Community Development Cit and Mayor y y Council . --c- , X TO: City of Plymouth Council Members FROM: Charles Hayes (476-4548) DATE: December 10, 1990 z• Mr., Over the past year visible work has been accomplished by Lundgren Brothers on their development on Mooney Lake. During the planning stages of the development, and at hearings before the City, Peter Pflaum indicated the lot next to my house at 18540 - 24th Ave. No. was owned by the State and could not be built on. Additionally, inquiry was made to the City and it was also indicated it was not a legal lot for building, and -it was owned by the State. Rick Sather was asked about the lot and he also indicated it was owned by the State. The lot is not shown on any preliminary development plan as part of Lundgren's Mooney Lake development. It is shown as State owned property. Now, I an told that Lundgren Brothers purchased the lot from the State for taxes, the City of Plymouth donated park land to Lund- gren Brothers, so that the lot is now a legal building lot --and to and behold (!) I discover, without notification, that there will be a house next to me, in spite of assurances from the builder, the engineer and the City that I need not worry! Myself and others would like to know how this could happen. By the City exchanging property with the builder, a lot is created that is legal to build on, and the builder stands to make $100,000 without compensation to anyone He has the lot listed for 40 to 60K, and he will make at least $50,000 on the building of the house. The least the City could have done is get one-half of the profits. I request an investigation of how this can happen, and if I am correct, a reversal of all actions that created a very question- able legal and ethical problem. Thank you for your time. I look forward to hearing from you as soon as possible. CIM �4IV 11 ,91