HomeMy WebLinkAboutCity Council Packet 08-25-2009 SpecialCITY OF PLYMOUTH
AGENDA
SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING
AUGUST 25, 2009, 5:00 p.m.
MEDICINE LAKE CONFERENCE ROOM
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. DISCUSSION TOPICS
A. 2010/2011 Budget
B. Set Future Study Sessions
3. ADJOURN
Special Council Meeting 1 of 1 August 25, 2009
City of Agenda 2APlymouthNumber:
Adding Qkelity to Life
To: Laurie Ahrens, City Manager
SPECIAL
COUNCIL MEETING Prepared by: Calvin Portner, Administrative Services Director
August 25, 2009 Reviewed by:
Item: Budget Discussion Meeting
1. ACTION REQUESTED:
Provide direction to staff on the 2010 and 2011 budget.
2. BACKGROUND:
This is the fourth council budget session. Another session is tentatively scheduled for
September 1, 2009. The Preliminary Budget and Levy adoption is scheduled for September 8,
2009. The council could decrease the final levy at a later date but cannot increase the approved
Preliminary Levy.
The Mayor and Council received their 2010/2011 general fund budget detail with their packets
on August 7, 2009. Attached are the "Other Budgeted Funds" budget detail to include in your
budget binder. Please insert the attached behind the General Fund detail.
Also included in your packet is the Proposed Budget Memo, which explains the city budgeting
process, budget policies and budget impacts for the next biennium.
Your budget detail utilizes Scenario #2 from the August 11, 2009, Special Council Meeting. As
a reminder, Scenario #2 levies at the State -mandated levy limit without a special levy for un-
allocated Market Value Homestead Credit (MVHC). It also includes a 3% increase in the
general levy for the Street Reconstruction Fund and the Capital Improvement Fund. Scenario
2 is $155,249 less than the amount levied in 2009.
At the last meeting, the council discussed the levy which would result in a zero tax increase on
an average sale price home in Plymouth. Scenario #1 would result in a zero increase on an
average sale price home. Scenario #1 is $384,424 less than the 2009 levy and would require an
additional $229,175 in cuts to the budget prepared for this evening. Staff recommends
decreasing facility and fleet allocations to make up the difference if the council chooses this
option. Please note that Scenario #1 does not include increases in the general levy directed to
the Street Reconstruction Fund or the Capital Improvement Fund.
Scenario #3 includes the maximum special levy for un -allocated MVHC. The council may levy
any amount up to the maximum if they so choose.
Page 1
The 2010 Levy breakdown and the tax impact scenarios are included as an attachment for your
convenience.
The presented budget does the following:
Increases Park & Recreation athletic field fees maintenance ($100,000)
Maintains street seal coating program ($400,000)*
Continues neighborhood park weed spraying ($16,000)
Maintains MSA revenue ($300,000) in the Street Reconstruction Fund
Increases PCC Senior fee revenue ($10,000)
No seal coating would be done without specific council authorization in 2010. In lieu of seal
coating, this money could be directed to street reconstruction, temporary overlays or street
maintenance work.
Also attached are memos regarding adaptive recreation and transit, both of which have budget
impacts.
3. ATTACHMENTS:
Budget Memo
Other Budgeted Funds Budget Detail
2010 Levy Breakdown
Tax Impact Scenario #1
Tax Impact Scenario #2
Tax Impact Scenario #3
Adaptive Recreation Memo
Transit Memo
General Fund Allocation Spreadsheet
Page 2
Irp) City of
Plymouth
Adding Quality to Life
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
City of
Plymouth
Adding Quality to Life
August 21, 2009
To the Honorable Mayor and City Council:
We are pleased to submit the Proposed Biennial Budget for 2010/2011. In 2007, we presented Plymouth's first
two-year or biennial budget. The use of two-year projection for budget purposes assists in long-term
planning and provides a more stable accounting of city revenue and expenditures.
Recent economic challenges, coupled with legislative levy limits, have made long-term planning even more
important. The biennial budget, maintains core services at current levels, reduces non-core services and
protects the investment in public facilities and infrastructure while reducing the overall city tax burden. This
budget is a comprehensive decision-making document, reflecting an accurate description of the city
operations, services and its policies and goals.
Work began on the 2010/2011 Biennial soon after the 2009 Budget Amendment to the last biennial budget.
Staff held three comprehensive work sessions to review department structure, organizational needs, resident
expectations, city revenue streams, programs and activities.
The 2010/2011 Proposed City of Plymouth Biennial Budget provides the city council and residents with a
balanced budget and sound financial plan for 2010 and 2011 that is less than the State of Minnesota
mandated levy limit of 0.83%. The Operating Budget Section is organized by function, which mirrors the
City's departmental organization chart and represents discrete activities within a department. In each
budget section, the department and division statements provide historical information. You will find new
account numbers and a few new account classifications in your budget due to the financial management
software conversion. The conversion presented an opportunity to better organize account structures to
provide improved reporting detail.
The city council held four budget study sessions to provide staff direction in regard to a budget proposal that
meets council goals, maintains core services and reduces the tax burden. Review of the preliminary property
tax levies and budgets is scheduled for September 8, 2009. A public hearing to solicit resident input is
scheduled for December 8, 2009. The public hearing replaces the former Truth -in -Taxation Hearing, which
was repealed by the state legislature. The city council is expected to adopt the final budget and property tax
levies on December 8, 2009.
Please contact me or a member of the Administrative Services budget staff for answers to specific budget
detail questions related to the proposed 2010/2011 Budget at 763-509-5051.
Respectfully Submitted,
Laurie Ahrens, City Manager
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN
CITY OF PLYMOUTH
ORGANIZATIONAL CHART
City of PlymouthribOrganizationalChart
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 2
CITY OFFICIALS
Mayor Kelli Slavik (Term Expires 12131110)
Ward 1 Councilmember Judy Johnson (Term Expires 12131112)
Ward 2 Councilmember Kathleen Murdock (Term Expires 12131110)
Ward 3 Councilmember Bob Stein (Term Expires 12/31/12)
Ward 4 Councilmember Ginny Black (Term Expires 12/31/10)
At -Large Councilmember Tim Bildsoe (Term Expires 12/31/10)
At -Large Councilmember Jim Willis (Term Expires 12/31/12)
City Manager Laurie Ahrens
Director of Administrative Services Calvin Portner
Director of Community Development Steve Juetten
Fire Chief Rick Kline
Director of Parks and Recreation Eric Blank
Police Chief Mike Goldstein
Director of Public Works Doran Cote
Administrative Services Department
3400 Plymouth Boulevard
Plymouth, Minnesota 55447
www.ci.plymouth.mn.us
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 3
GENERAL INFORMATION
Plymouth, Minnesota is an innovative,
forward looking community just ten miles
northwest of Minneapolis.
In 2008, Money magazine named Plymouth
as the Best Place to Live in America. The
city of more than 71,000 residents is known
for its healthy job base, strong schools,
strategic location, array of housing choices
and well planned park and trail system.
Plymouth's location offers residents and
businesses easy access to Minneapolis, St.
Paul and area suburbs. Several major
highways pass through the city. I-494 runs
north to south through the center of the
community. Highway 55 bisects Plymouth
east to west while Highway 169 runs along
the eastern border.
The 36 square mile city includes lakes, streams, wetlands and woodland. Local residents have
placed a premium on preserving open space, developing parks and building more than 100
miles of trails, many of which tie into regional trails. The community's commitment to parks,
trails and protecting natural areas reflects Plymouth's active outdoor culture.
Plymouth has worked to build a sense of community. It is home to several major community
events, including the Primavera spring art exhibition, a summer entertainment in the parks
series, Plymouth on Parade in the fall and the winter Plymouth Fire and Ice Festival. While all
the events are popular, Music in Plymouth, featuring the Minnesota Orchestra in an outdoor
concert, is Plymouth's signature event. The concert draws more than 10,000 people each July.
In addition to being a top choice to live,
Plymouth has been a popular place to
locate businesses. Employers provide
more than 50,000 jobs in the fields of
insurance, high-tech research,
telecommunications, light manufacturing,
printing and publishing, and computer-
related industries.
Significant Dates in Plymouth History
May 15, 1955 - Incorporated as a village.
August 1, 1968 - Adopted the council-manager
form of government.
February 7, 1974 - Became a statutory city.
November 3, 1992 — Voters adopted a city charter,
making Plymouth a home rule charter city.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 4
Street Map
01,i; 'X1'.." a7C a 12v.
m mffi 7$9-----8R8.R
s "M. B SRxg-%.
7
45TH AM
ANHAVE
uTH AYE
ApTHAVa:.
5 g
l
P U! M
20 Street Map
OF Aug 2009Pymauth, Minnesota
0-25 0.5 1 1.5 2
Milan
TNI•; REPRESENTS A COMPILATION OF INFORh1ATION: SND DAVI
FRT I CITY. COUNTY, STATE AND OTHER SCRIRCES THAT HAS
NOT SEEN HELD VERIFIED. INFDRMATRNI SHMLD RE FIELD
VERIFIED AND CCWAR'ED VMTH OR MIAL SOURCE DOCAAE+TS
N.1PI_Y_GISiPROJECT515TftEETS'SlrePi Map mxT1
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 5
16Th AYE d
y.
PHONE
41
aE a 33 S'Y;t`$'x5€ tij a wfTo xclyc" `-
el,z'$
gE
W5fS 1st
V -41"T
20 Street Map
OF Aug 2009Pymauth, Minnesota
0-25 0.5 1 1.5 2
Milan
TNI•; REPRESENTS A COMPILATION OF INFORh1ATION: SND DAVI
FRT I CITY. COUNTY, STATE AND OTHER SCRIRCES THAT HAS
NOT SEEN HELD VERIFIED. INFDRMATRNI SHMLD RE FIELD
VERIFIED AND CCWAR'ED VMTH OR MIAL SOURCE DOCAAE+TS
N.1PI_Y_GISiPROJECT515TftEETS'SlrePi Map mxT1
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 5
Demographics and Economics
In 2005, the median age for Plymouth was 36.1. The City's population is older than the median ages
of Hennepin County, the State, and the nation averages of 34.9, 35.4, and 35.3 respectively. In 2000,
the City's population for people 65 years of age or older was 7.6% of the total population (See,
Figure 4). By comparison, the percentage of people 65 years or older in Hennepin County, the State,
and the nation were 11%, 12.1%, and 12.4% respectively.
Data indicates that this trend will continue. Also in 2000, persons under 5 years of age represented
7% of the City's total population count while persons over the age of 18 represented 72.9% of the
City's total population count. By comparison, the percentage of persons over 18 years of age in
Hennepin County, the State, and the nation were 76%, 73.8%, and 74.3% respectively.
Based on the most recent figures from the U.S. Census Bureau, the City's population is 5.9% of
Hennepin County's total population. Plymouth has experienced an 18.5% increase in residential
growth from 1996 to 2006. There are 29,115 occupied housing units in Plymouth. Of the total
occupied housing units, approximately 71.5% are owner -occupied and 28.5% are renter -occupied.
City of Plymouth's Age Distribution Census for 2000
Persons Age
18-65, -
72%
Persons Over 65,
8%
Persons Under 5,
7%
is Age
5-18,
13%
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 6
74,000
72,000
70,000
68,000
65,894
66,000 64,313
64,000
62,000
60,000
Population Trend
67,824
675
70,238 70,682 70,455 70,676
7 71,536
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Year
Top Plymouth Employers Plymouth Housing Costs
Number of Employees
July 2007)
Carlson Companies 2,225 Average Sale Price Single
Family Home (2009) 366,800
Prudential Insurance Company 1,600
Economics
Qwest Communications 700
Unemployment Rate
Boston Scientific 600 2008)
Honeywell Incorporated 500 Plymouth 6.4%
Minnesota 8.1%
Select Comfort Corporation 475
Upsher-Smith Laboratories, Inc. 400 Median Family Income
all earners) source: ESRI
US Food Service 400
Plymouth 107,295
Fortis Health 390
Hennepin County 70,360
Deltak Corp 370
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 7
Governing Body
Plymouth operates as a home rule city according to a City Charter and ordinances, under a City
Council -Manager form of government.
Policy-making and legislative authority are vested in a City Council consisting of a mayor, two at -
large council members, and four ward council members. Besides representing their individual
wards and responding to public concerns, the City Council's main responsibilities include: passing
ordinances, adopting the budget, appointing committees, and hiring the city manager. The city
manager is responsible for carrying out the policies and ordinances of the council, for overseeing the
day-to-day operations of the city government, and for appointing the heads of the various
departments. The council is elected on a non-partisan basis. Council members serve four-year
staggered terms.
Plymouth Council Wards
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 8
BUDGET PROCESS
Budget Calendar
The City of Plymouth prepares its budget on a calendar year basis as required by the City Charter.
In 2007, the city adopted the biennial budget format. The biennial budget format provides an
opportunity to implement strategic planning into the budget process and allows time for program
review and evaluation.
2010-2011 Biennial Budget Preparation & 5 -yr Capital Improvement Plan
Date Category Description
February 23, 2009 Budget Directors/Manager Priority Session
April 28, 2009 Budget Council Budget Trends Overview
June 7, 2009 CIP CIP Kickoff
June 8, 2009 Budget Budget materials are distributed to Dept Directors
June 15, 2009 Software Install NWS 6.1 Budget Module
June 15 -June 18 Software Test NWS Budget Module and 6.1 (IT/Finance)
June 19, 2009 Budget/CIP 2009 CIP and 2009 Adjusted Budgets are Due
July 1-2, 2009 Software Train Directors/Staff on NWS Budget Module (Tentative)
July 1-10, 2009 Budget Budget Entry - Division Managers
July 14, 2009 Budget Dept Directors promote budget info to Budget Team
July 20-23, 2009 Budget Budget Review by Dept Directors and Budget Team
July 28, 2009 Budget Council Budget Meeting
August 7, 2009 Budget Distribute Revised City Manager's Budget to Council
August 11,2009 Budget Council Study Session
August 25, 2009 Budget Council Study Session
September 1, 2009 Budget/CIP Council Study Session
September 8, 2009 Budget City Council adopts preliminary property tax levy and budget
September CIP Planning Commission Approval
December 8, 2009 Budget Public Hearing on Budget
December 8, 2009 Budget Council adoption of biennial budget
December 8, 2009 CIP Council adoption of CIP
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 9
Fund Accounting
Fund accounting is used throughout the city, both for budgeting and accounting. Under this
system, money is divided into separate accounts, rather than being held in one central account. The
City has 17 budgeted funds. Each fund has been established for a specific purpose and is somewhat
like a separate bank account.
Those funds used to pay for operations, maintenance, and other ongoing activities are like checking
accounts. Generally, revenues flowing into the fund are spent during the same year. Unless there is
a change in service levels, spending is similar from year to year.
Other funds are more like savings accounts. Money is accumulated for periodic capital needs, such
as the replacement of equipment. The balance in those funds grows until expenditures are made.
Spending can vary greatly from year to year.
Basis of Accounting
The budget parallels the City's accounting system. A modified accrual basis is used for general
government operations. Significant revenues are recorded when measurable and available.
Expenditures are recorded when incurred. Records for the City's Proprietary Fund, including the
Enterprise and Internal Service Funds, are maintained on a full accrual basis. For budgetary
purposes, depreciation, accrued liabilities for accumulated leave balances, and market value
adjustments to City investments are not included in calculating fund balances. Building and
equipment repair and maintenance are budgeted for annually. Investments are held to maturity so
market value during the term of the investment is not an issue when allocating resources.
Revenue Management Policies
The City of Plymouth will;
Impose taxes, fees, and rates at appropriate levels to fund their intended purposes
Maintain a reserve balance to provide for a diversified and stable revenue system
Estimate annual revenue using an objective, analytical process
Conduct an annual review costs of activities supported by taxes, rates, and user fees
Set fees and user charges for each enterprise fund based on current and future
operating, capital, infrastructure, and debt requirements
Review new sources of revenue to fund operating and capital costs consistent with
Council's goals and priorities
Reserve Management Policies
The City of Plymouth will;
Establish bond reserves based on requirements of individual bond ordinances
Establish capital reserves which accumulate funds for the planned construction or
replacement of City infrastructure or for the acquisition of capital equipment based
on the five-year Capital Improvement Program
Establish other reserves related to special items as approved by City Council
Maintain the General Fund reserve balance as established by Council resolution
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 10
Investment Management Policies
The City of Plymouth will;
Deposit funds only in financial institutions which are insured by the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation or are approved for full collateralization by the public deposit
protection act or other state statutes
Pool cash from all legally permitted funds for investment purposes
Maximize the investment rate of return and adhere to lawful investment options
Ensure that the safety of the principal is the dominant requirement for City
investments followed by maintaining sufficient liquidity to meet operating
requirements, then yield
Follow the City of Plymouth's investment policy
Debt Management Policies
The City of Plymouth will;
Confine long-term borrowing to major capital improvements that cannot be financed
from current revenues
Repay debt within the expected useful life of the project or sooner
Prohibit the use of long-term debt for operating expenses
Issue debt which is relative to payback ability
Ensure that borrowing does not overburden future taxpayers
When practical, borrow from other funds. Monies borrowed must be repaid with
interest before needed for their intended purpose(s). Repayment schedules and
reserve sources for repayment shall be validated before borrowing from any fund.
Review debt at least annually for repayment or refinance opportunities. A
repayment strategy shall be part of all adopted bond issues.
Accounting, Auditing and Reporting Policies
The City of Plymouth will;
Provide regular information concerning cash position and investment performance
through its accounting system
Establish and maintain a high degree of accounting competency. Financial
accounting and reporting will be done in accordance with methods prescribed by the
Governmental Accounting Standards Board and the Government Finance Officers
Association, or their equivalents.
Present quarterly and annual reports to the City Council summarizing financial
activity as required by City Charter
Maintain financial systems to monitor expenditures, expenses, revenues, and
performance of all municipal programs on an ongoing basis
Provide full disclosure in annual financial statements and bond representations
Use an independent certified public accounting firm to perform an annual audit
Issue a Public Comprehensive Annual Financial Report
Comply with all reporting requirements related to bond issuance terms
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 11
FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Fund Types
The City of Plymouth classifies funds into six types: General Fund, Special Revenue Funds,
Enterprise Funds, Internal Service Funds, Debt Service Funds, and Capital Project Funds. Section
7.10 of the City Charter states that; "There must be maintained in the city treasury a general fund
and the funds required by law, ordinance, the budget resolution or other resolution. The Council
may make inter -fund loans and transfers except from trust or agency funds or where prohibited by
this charter or law."
The General Fund is established to account for all revenues and expenditures which are not
required to be accounted for in other funds. It has more diverse revenue sources than other
funds, including property taxes, licenses, permits, fines and forfeits, intergovernmental,
service charges, rents, and investment interest earnings. The fund's resources finance a wide
range of functions, including operations of general government, public safety, public works,
and general service expenditures.
The Special Revenue Funds are established to account for revenues derived from taxes and
other specific revenue sources. Resources provided by Special Revenue Funds are restricted
by statute, City Charter, or ordinance to finance specific City functions or activities. Included
in this fund type are Recreation, Transit, and the Housing Redevelopment Authority (HRA).
The Enterprise Funds are established to account for the acquisition and operation of Water,
Sewer, Solid Waste, Ice Center, Water Resources, and the Field House. These funds are either
entirely or predominantly self-supporting from user charges to the general public.
The Internal Service Funds are established to account for the financing of goods and services
provided to various City departments on a cost reimbursement basis. The City's Internal
Service Funds are as follows: Central Equipment, Risk Management, Employee Benefit,
Information Technology, and Public Facilities.
The Capital Project Funds are established to account for the resources used for the
acquisition and construction of capital facilities except for facilities financed by the Enterprise
Funds. The City does not include the Capital Project Funds in the Adopted Budget as these
funds are generally established for a short duration and specific purpose.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 12
The Debt Service Funds are established to account for the payment (from taxes and other
sources) of interest and principal on long-term debt. The following schedule outlines debt
the City of Plymouth and its Component Unit are responsible for:
Debt Service Schedule
Description
General Obligation Bonds
Date of i
12/31/2009
Activity Center and Field House Bonds - 1998 12/1/1998 2/1/2014 3.4-4.375 4,500,000 1,805,000
Street Reconstruction Bonds - 2003B 5/27/2003 2/1/2014 2.0-3.5 1,465,000 775,000
Open Space Refunding Bonds - 2003D 11/25/2003 2/1/2011 2.25-3.05 1,355,000 500,000
Capital hriprovement Bonds - 2004A 9/9/2004 2/1/2025 3.0-4.75 7,480,000 6,500,000
Open Space Bonds - 2007A 11/15/2007 2/1/2024 3.75-3.9 2,715,000 2,715,000
Total General Obligation Bonds
General Obligation Tax Increment Bonds
17,515,000 12,295,000
Taxlncrement Bonds - 1998A 1 10/1/1998 2/1/2023 4.15-4.65 2,900,000 2,565,000
Tax Increment Bonds - 2005A 1 4/1/2005 2/1/2023 2.80-4.25 1 1,370,000 1 1,315,000
Total General Obligation Tax Increment Bonds
S pecialAssessmentBonds
4,270,000 3,880,000
Housing Improvement Bonds - 1998B 1 10/1/1998 2/1/2014 5.20-5.90 1 $ 1,030,000 1 $ 450,000
GO Improvement Bonds - 2003C 1 11/25/2003 2/1/2010 2.25-2.75 1 2,895,000 1 530,000
Total Special Assessment Bonds
General Obli ation Revenue Bonds
3,925,000 980,000
GO Water Revenue Bonds -2004B 1 12/8/2004 2/1/2019 3.0-4.0 1 $ 13,140,000 1 $ 9,145,000
Total Bonds Payable i i;
Component Unit (HRA)
26,300,000
Plymouth Towne Square Housing Project
Bonds - 2003 2/20/2003 10/1/2023 1.75-4.5 4,860,000 3,690.000
Vicksburg Crossing Housing Project Bonds -
2005 5/1/2005 2/1/1935 3.75-5.0 10,650,000 10,525,000
Total Component Unit (1112A)
Total Outstanding I -i
15,510,000 14,215,000
40,515,000
Transfers
Because money is budgeted and accounted for in separate funds rather than pooled in one account,
transfers occur among funds. Transfers take two primary forms; allocations and operating transfers.
Allocations - Payments for support services provided by one City department to another.
The charges are direct reimbursements for services provided and are calculated annually
utilizing a cost of service analysis. Examples of support for which direct charges apply
include the Central Equipment and Information Technology Funds.
Operating Transfers - Represent the transfer from one fund to another fund for operational
purposes or for capital outlays without the expectation of any support services in return.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 13
TOTAL CITY BUDGET
The Biennial 2010/20011 budget is balanced and is in compliance with all provisions of the City
Charter and Council Policies.
Council Goals
Each year, the City Council meets to discuss and establish goals. The established goals are the
foundation for annual work plans and for building the annual budget.
Implement Solutions to Economic Challenges. Prioritize and maintain the strong core
services that helped Plymouth achieve its status as Money magazine's #1 City. Seek
additional efficiencies and expand collaborative efforts to maintain service levels within
financial constraints.
Protect Plymouth's Strong Financial Position. Maintain Plymouth's fiscal health through
sound financial management practices. Strengthen long-term financial planning through
continued biennial budgeting and forecasting. Maintain Aaa bond rating and promote
transparency through financial reporting.
Address Transportation Issues. Advance transportation and transit issues to improve the
local economy, promote business growth and development, and improve area roadways and
highways to reduce commuter congestion. Specific emphasis is on maintaining suburban
transit and advancing the following projects: third lane on I-494, study of Highway 169
between I-494 and I-94, and improvements to Highway 55.
Pursue Northwest Greenway and Environmental Initiatives. Continue acquisition of
property for the Northwest Greenway and park land, as directed by voter referendum, and
complete Phase 2 of the Millennium Garden. Collaborate with watershed agencies to ensure
effective progress on water quality mandates. Continue energy conservation efforts in city
buildings.
Continue Proactive Public Safety Initiatives. Build on the successes of fire prevention and
fire service programs as well as proactive policing strategies to promote and enhance
livability.
Protect the City's Infrastructure Investment. Continue to monitor financial resources,
economic conditions and timing with regard to infrastructure needs to ensure that the City
can protect and enhance the useful life of streets and utilities.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 14
The total City revenues and expenditures as shown below are the combined amounts of the
organization, including the HRA. The table below shows the proposed City budget with
comparative prior year totals.
Total Combined City Budget
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Actual Actual Amended Proposed Proposed
Revenue
General Property Taxes 21,424,904 22,349,967 23,398,538 23,472,452 23,919,105
Permits and Licenses 3,508,079 3,842,018 2,264,700 2,288,865 2,288,896
Intergovernmental 9,595,470 10,863,604 8,983,809 9,731,702 8,044,465
Charges for Services 19,228,033 19,863,760 20,928,099 21,762,588 22,844,088
Fines and Forfeitures 929,989 896,876 900,500 912,500 912,500
Contributions 1,555,645 810,227 1,000 400,700 400,700
Billings to Departments 5,816,231 5,278,633 5,515,908 6,538,496 6,686,985
Investment Earnings 2,803,427 1,908,030 1,311,287 1,530,153 1,559,708
Transfers In 6,702,187 1,349,489 5,656,974 5,843,327 4,833,470
Other Revenues 1,222,696 1,138,659 316,924 97,500 95,500
Special Assessments 14,049 3,267
Total Revenue 72,800,710 68,304,530 69,277,739 72,578,283 71,585,417
Appropriations
Personal Services 22,440,485 23,899,074 24,413,604 24,202,133 24,501,065
Materials and Supplies 2,962,997 3,209,133 3,457,826 3,386,232 3,468,921
Employee Development and
Meetings 226,511 218,493 405,673 302,149 304,746
Dues and Subscriptions 344,637 384,674 420,225 377,965 381,971
Contractual Services 18,346,883 18,242,517 20,221,280 20,743,520 20,824,470
Equipment 155,671 256,991 252,379 309,155 237,830
Capital Improvements 524,250 584,485 6,492,700 7,389,500 5,485,776
Other Expenditures 4,864,299 5,679,448 4,623,358 4,994,865 4,943,395
Debt Service 472,725 375,429 1,119,913 1,119,913 1,119,913
Allocations 5,170,574 5,030,764 5,563,158 6,049,133 6,199,559
Transfer Out 7,250,266 6,541,617 2,307,623 3,703,718 4,117,771
Depreciation 5,148,573 5,336,513
Total Appropriations 67,907,871 69,759,138 69,277,739 72,578,283 71,585,417
Less Allocations 5,170,574 5,030,764 5,563,158 6,049,133 6,199,559
Less Transfers 7,250,266 6,541,617 2,307,623 3,703,718 4,117,771
12,420,840 11,572,3 81 7,870,781 9,752,851 10,317,330
Net Appropriations 55,487,031 58,186,757 61,406,958 62,825,432 61,268,087
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 15
REVENUE SOURCES
Each fund is supported by several revenue types. The graphs below show the type of revenues
supporting the total city budget for the 2010 and 2011 proposed budgets, as well as the percentage
of support received.
Property Taxes
This levy is for general operating purposes, street reconstruction, and repayment of outstanding
debt. The General Fund (operating budget) receives the largest share of the levy. The Street
Reconstruction Fund, Recreation Fund, CDBG, Plymouth Housing and Redevelopment Authority
HRA) General, and Capital Improvement Fund also receive an allocation.
Permits and Licenses
License and permit revenues are received from businesses and occupations licensed by the City.
Building permits are a major source of revenues for the City. License fees approximate the direct
and indirect cost of issuing the license and policing the licensed activities.
Intergovernmental Revenue
Revenue received from federal, state, and county sources. The largest item is Police State Aid which
the State of Minnesota provides. Other sources include the highway user tax, grants, and the school
liaison contracts with the school districts.
Charges for Services
Best defined as user fees, Charges for Services provide funding to operate programs and facilities
from those who use them such as utility charges. Utility charges are revenues generated from basic
utility services and are classified within the Enterprise Funds. The City of Plymouth provides four
utility services: water, sanitary sewer, solid waste (recycling), and surface water.
Fines and Forfeitures
This type of revenue is generated primarily by the Police Department for violations of the law.
Hennepin County collects revenue and distributes a portion back to the City of Plymouth.
Contributions
Revenue received typically for charitable purposes and/or to benefit a cause.
Billings to Departments
This type of revenue is from other city funds to pay for the cost of operations or specific uses from
those funds.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 16
Interest Earnings
The cash balances in all funds are invested in interest-bearing investments of maturities appropriate
to the cash requirements of the funds.
Transfers In
This revenue source is for revenue that is transferred from another City fund.
Utter
Refunds and reimbursements, administrative fees, property claims, and miscellaneous revenue are
categorized under this source of revenue.
2010 Revenue Budget - All Funds
by source)
Charges for
Services Fines and Contributions
29.98% Forfeitures0.55%
1.26%
hitgvtl
13.41%
Permits and
Licenses
3.15%
General
Property Taxes
32.35%
Billings to
Departments
9.01%
Investment
Earnings
Transfers hi 2.11%
8.05%
Other Revenues
0.13%
2011 Revenue Budget -All Funds
by source)
Charges for
Services
31.92%
Intgvtl
11.24°/
Permits an
Licenses
3.20%
General
Property Taxes
33.41%
Fines and
Forfeitures
1.27%
Contributions
0.56%
Billings to
Departments
9.34%
Investment
Earnings
2.18%
Transfers In
6.75%
Other
Revenues
0.13%
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 17
EXPENDITURE CATEGORIES
The City divides expenditures into account categories to describe how it is spending its funds.
These categories are Personal Services,, Materials and Supplies, Dues and Subscriptions, Employee
Development, Contractual Services, Equipment, Capital Improvements, Other, Debt Service,
Allocations, and Transfers.
Personal Services
These expenditures include all salaries, the City's contribution towards FICA, Medicare, Public
Employees Retirement Association, Workers' Compensation insurance, and other costs related to
compensation and benefits.
Retirement Costs. All full-time and certain part-time employees of the City are
covered by defined benefit plans administered by the Public Employees Retirement
Association of Minnesota (PERA). PERA administers the Public Employees
Retirement Fund (PERF) and the Public Employees Police and Fire Fund (PEPFF),
which are cost sharing, multiple -employer retirement plans. These plans are
established and administered in accordance with Minnesota Statutes, Chapters 353
and 356.
Public Employees Retirement Fund
Coordinated Plan 1 6.50% 6.75% 7.00%
Public Employees Police and Fire Fund 1 12.90% 14.10% 14.10%
Employers Contribution. The City contributes a predetermined amount towards
benefit coverage. Employees have the option of selecting from a cafeteria plan of
benefits and are required to pay for any benefits exceeding the employer's
contribution.
Workers Compensation. The Department of Administrative Services manages
Workers' Compensation premium costs and claims. Workers' Compensation costs are
partially charged to each department based on past claims history. Claims incurred
are accounted for in the Risk Management Fund.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 18
Material and Supplies
Office supplies, parts, and materials necessary to provide the services funded in the budget are
included within this category.
Dues and Subscriptions
Employee memberships to professional organizations, commissions, and industry specific
subscriptions are included within these expenditures.
Employee Development
Employee development includes all employee training such as conferences and seminars, tuition
reimbursement, and all other professional development related expenditures.
Contractual Services
Contractual Services includes all services provided to the City by outside sources. Examples
include postage, printing, subscriptions, and contracted services.
Equipment
Equipment purchases included within this category are for items that do not meet the City's
capitalization threshold of $5,000.
Capital Improvements
Purchases of items that are more than $5,000 with a useful life of more than one year, and all
infrastructure and building construction projects are capitalized.
Other Expenditures
All other purchases or expenditures are included within this category such as bank fees and other
miscellaneous items.
Debt Service
These expenditures include principal and interest payments on outstanding bonds.
Allocations
Allocations include expenditures used to distribute the cost of operations of Internal Service Funds
to the benefiting departments/divisions.
Transfer Out
The Transfer Out category is for transfers made to another City fund.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 19
The graphs below demonstrate how resources are allocated. It is also important to note that in
addition to providing the total City budget, the two figures incorporate the Capital Improvement
Program totals.
2010 Expenditure Budget - All Funds
by source)
Contractual Equipment Capital
Services 0.43% Improvements
Employee 28.58% 10.18%
Development
Other
and Meetings
0.42% \
Expenditures
6.88%
Dues and Debt Service
Subscriptions 1.54%
0.52%
Allocations
8.33%
Materials and
Supplies
4.67%
Transfer Out
5.10%
Personal
Services
33.35%
2011 Expenditure Budget - All Funds
by source)
Contractual
Services
Employee 29.09%
Development
and Meetings
0.43%
Dues and
Subscriptions
0.53%
Materials and
Supplies
4.85%
Personal
Services
34.23%
lutpment Capital
0.33% Improvements
7.66%
Other
6.91%
Debt Service
1.56%
Allocations
8.66%
Transfer Out
5.75%
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 20
r Plymouth
Adding Quality to Life
BUDGET OVERVIEW
BUDGET OVERVIEW
For 2009, the State of Minnesota implemented a property tax levy limit based upon the rate of
inflation as defined by the Implicit Price Deflator as computed on July 1 of each year. The levy limit
has a rate ceiling cap of 3.9% and no minimum or floor. The legislature also added/expanded a
number of special levies that are not restricted by the levy limit. The City added special levies for
Public Safety and PERA for 2009 and will maintain the Special Levies for 2010 and 2011.
A large State of Minnesota budget deficit resulted in an un -allotment of Market Value Homestead
Credit (MVHC) reimbursements to Plymouth and many other Minnesota cities. MVHC was
intended by the legislature to reduce the property tax burden for certain taxpayers. Plymouth is
required to levy the full amount of the property tax and expects to have an un -allotment for 2010 of
589,795 for the Market Value Homestead Credit (MVHC).
Property Tax
2010 Property Tax Levy Proposal - The proposed budget requires a total property tax levy of
28,192,320 to meet expected operational needs. The result for 2010 is a property tax levy decrease of
0.60 percent, or a decrease of $163,310 from 2009. In addition to the City property tax levy, the city
levies property taxes for the Housing and Redevelopment Authority (HRA). The proposed 2010
budget maintains the HRA levy at the 2009 level of $551,277. The 2010 property tax levy is below
the targeted levy limit mandated by the State of Minnesota, which is currently at 0.83% over 2009.
2011 Property Tax Levy Proposal - The second year of the proposed biennial budget includes a total
levy of $28,725,997, which accounts for a proposed overall property tax levy increase of 1.89% from
2010. The total levy increase is speculative as the levy limit amount will not be determined until
July of 2010 and the economy is too volatile to predict with any degree of confidence.
City and HRA Levies
Tax Le
Increase / %Increase /
2008 2009 eer ase 2010 ecrease
General Fund 21,252,059 22,188,764 13,040,115
PERA 108,728
Police 9,183,835
Market Value Credit Aid 507,000 510,000 589,795
Street Reconstruction 2,303,400 2,458,092 2,531,835
Recreation Fund 658,735 678,497 628,497
Capital Improvement Fund 347,783 358,216 368,962
GO 2003B Street Recon Bonds 182,543 178,355 179,038
GO 2003C Street Recon Bonds 422,017 424,531
GO 2004A Public Safety 594,674 596,354 596,958
GO 2007A Open Space 255,486 255,223
Total City Tax Capacity Levy 26,268,211 27,648,295 5.25% 27,482,986 -0.60%
Activity Center Bonds 429,706 432,016 428,007
2003D Open Space Refiaxling 262,794 267,257 281,326
Total City Market Value Levy 692,500 699,273 0.98% 709,333 1.44%
TOTAL CITY LEVY 26,960,711 28,347,568 5.14% 28,192,319 -0.55
Total HRA Tax Capacity Levy 524,477 551,277 5.11% 551,277 0.00%
TOTAL ALL LEVIES 27,485,188 $ 28,898,845 5.14% $ 28,743,596 -0.54%
Total Tax Rate(Charter Requirements) 1 22.89% 24.34% 25.84%
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 20
Charter Requirement for Levy Adoption
The City Council, in accordance with the City Charter, has adopted an ordinance that requires a
two-thirds majority vote to adopt a tax levy resolution that increases the City's tax rate over the
prior year. This tax rate is defined as the quotient derived by dividing the City's tax levy by the
City's net tax capacity. The tax levy must be adopted by a 5/7 majority vote.
Calculation of Property Tax Levy
The City of Plymouth historically begins the annual budget process by reviewing growth and
inflation, as both of these factors significantly impact our ability to maintain service levels.
For 2010, the Implicit Price Deflator allows for an increase of 0.83 percent to the general levy. With
the adjustment for 1/2 of the household growth and 1/2 of the growth from new commercial /
industrial property, the city will realize approximately $39,000 in new revenue. The city will
maintain existing special levies for PERA and public safety wage and benefit increases. The budget
does not propose utilization of a new special levy for loss of un -allocated market value homestead
credit (MVHC).
Property Tax Impacts
The impact of the 2010 proposed budget on the residential homeowner with at the median property
value of $276,400 is an annual increase of $5.64 for the City and HRA portion of the property tax.
The impact on the 2009 average home sale price of $366,800 is $8.45 or 0.89%.
In 2011, the projected total levy increase of 1.86% is expected to have an impact of a 0.2% decrease in
taxes or $1.37 less than in 2010 on the median valued home in Plymouth.
Estimated Tax Burden on Average Home Sale Value
Estimated Percentage
Estimated Increase / Increase /
2009 2010 (Decrease) (Decrease)
Average Home Sale Value 384,400 366,800
Tax Capacity at l% 3,844 3,668
Combined City Tax & Market Value Rate 24.351% 25.855%
Total City Tax Capacity & Market Value Levies $936.04 $948.37 $12
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483% 0.514%
Total HRA Tax Capacity Levy $18.58 $18.86 $0
Total Estimated Gross Property Tax Levy $954.62 $967.23 $12.61
Market Value Credit (6.94) (11.10) (4.16)
Total Net Property Tax Levy $947.68 $956.13 $8.45 0.89%
When applied to the median value home (all residential properties) the impact is as follows:
Home Value Pct Annual increase
Below Median 250,000 0.13% 0.78
Median 279,400 0.81% 5.64
Above Median 400,000 1.37% 14.23
Commercial/Industrial 1,000,000 0.84% 25.92
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 21
2010/2011 Budget Considerations
As part of the Council's 2009 Goals and Items for Study, the Council identified six specific goals,
three of which have budgetary impacts. The 2010/2011 Budget Considerations used the council
goals as a foundation for the biennial budget.
The following information provides details about service level changes and provides additional
information related to expenditure reductions.
Implement Solutions to Economic Challenges - At the Council's direction, staff completed a
review of internal service funds and their associated allocations. The 2010/2011 budget
begins to address the imbalances in personnel allocations, fleet services, information
technology, public facilities, risk management and employee benefit funds. Ensuring each
fund is sustainable over the long-term. Further, studies were completed on the Water Fund
and the Park Replacement Fund to identify long-term needs.
The economic downturn coupled with near build -out of new residential and commercial
property resulted in a review of city service levels and requirements. The budget reflects the
elimination of 13 positions for 2010, mainly through attrition, in areas such as Community
Development where service demands are reduced, as well as in departmental restructuring
as non-core activities and programs are eliminated or postponed.
Protect Plymouth's Strong Financial Position - The development of the City's second
biennial budget, along with financial management improvements, enhance transparency
with residents and protects the City's Aaa bond rating.
Protect the City's Infrastructure Investment - The proposed budget includes an increase in
the levies for the Street Reconstruction Fund and Park Maintenance Fund and proposes an
ambitious program for street reconstruction, lift station and sanitary system lining and water
main expansion and a new well. In addition, this budget improves the financial position for
Central Services (fleet), Facilities and other Internal Service Funds.
The 2010/2011 Biennial Budget seeks to maintain core service levels with declining general tax levy
revenue. Following are the departmental changes required to meet council goals and resident
expectations.
Administrative Services - After reducing the department by 3 FTE in 2009, Administrative
Services proposes to eliminate an accountant position and 0.5 FTE office support through
work savings following the implementation of new financial and payroll software. They also
eliminated the temporary appraising position.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 22
Community Development - The economic downturn has decreased the workload for
building inspections and planning. The impending build -out of the city also impacts
personnel levels. In 2009, Community Development eliminated one planning position and
for 2010, they eliminate two inspections positions, one planning position, and one office
support representative.
Fire Department - The Fire Department decreased planned Duty Crew hour increases in 2009
and did not fill an approved Fire Captain position. The department will begin allocations for
replacement turnout gear scheduled for 2017 with an annual expenditure increase of $53,000.
They will also begin allocating funds to replace 800 MHz radios, which will need to be
replaced in 2012 at an annual cost of $71,333 in 2010 and $72,760 in 2011.
Parks & Recreation - Parks and Recreation eliminated a Park Maintenance Lead Worker,
Public Works (Ice Arena) position, and an Office Support Representative position in 2009.
For 2010/2011, the department proposes new field maintenance revenue of $100,000. The will
decrease in the Recreation Fund levy by $50,000 and use reserves to decrease costs the next
two years. They also propose the elimination of the Puppet Wagon and Puppet Show
program, the Plymouth Creek Center Aquarium, and outsourced adaptive recreation service.
They propose reducing the recreation brochure, reducing winter warming houses, park
concessions, and park cleanup expenses. The biennial budgets include increases in the
transfer to the Park Replacement Fund.
Police Department - The Police Department proposes to eliminate the following programs
and activities, Bike Patrol, Deer Survey, Best Practices Program, and Animal Licensing. They
also propose to restructure the D.A.R.E. program and eliminate the position of full-time
D.A.R.E. officer and to decrease expenditures for police recruitment. Elimination of the Best
Practices Program will save staff time for other activities/programs and result in an increase
revenue as liquor license fees will no longer be reduced for establishments participating in
the program. The department also has an increased allocation for the purchase of new 800
MHz radios in 2012.
Public Works - Public Works eliminated two office support positions in 2009. Workload
demands have allowed for the elimination of two Senior Engineering Technician positions
through attrition. Further reductions have come from through the elimination of one
Mechanic position and a Streets Lead Worker. The Solid Waste Coordinator position and
duties were reconfigured and the position was filled with an Office Support Specialist. In
2010, the department will oversee a number of infrastructure improvements and additions to
wells, lift stations, water mains, sanitary sewer mains, and neighborhood streets. The Transit
and Solid Waste budgets, as presented, will operate in 2010 and 2011 will operate with
operating revenue transfers from retained earnings. Long-term sustainability will be sought
to reduce the need for operational transfers.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 23
Position Reduction — Municipal services are very staff intensive, accounting for nearly 70%
of the total budget. Early budget preparations included sessions to review services, service
delivery, and future staffing needs. A service prioritization process was developed to review
cores services and search for efficiencies and duplication. In all, the proposed budget reduces
personnel expenditures by over $500,000 through the elimination of 13.6 FTE positions.
The following chart summarizes position elimination in 2009 and 2010.
Position Elimination
2009 Positions Eliminated
Department FTE Position
Administration 1 Payroll Clerk
Administration 1 Finance Office Supervisor
Administration 1 Systems Administrator
Fire 1 Fire Captain
Police 1 Office Support Representative
Parks & Recreation 1 Park Maintenance Lead Worker
Public Works 2 Office Support Representatives
Community Development 1 Planning Assistant
2010 Positions Eliminated
Administrative Services 1 Accountant
Community Development 1 Planning Assistant
Community Development 1 Building Inspector
Community Development 1 Housing Inspector
Community Development 1 Office Support Representative
Parks & Recreation 1 Office Support Specialist
Parks & Recreation 1 Park Maintenance Worker
Police 1 Police Officer - D.A.R.E.
Police 0.6 Community Service Officer
Public Works 2 Senior Engineering Technicians
Public Works 1 Street Maintenance Lead Worker
Public Works 1 Mechanic
2010 Position Adjustment
Public Works 0.6 Solid Waste Coordinator replaced by Office
Support Specialist - Solid Waste
The City had 274.2 authorized regular full- and part-time positions on a full-time equivalent (FTE)
basis in 2008, the first year of the biennial budget. The amended 2009 budget reduced the total
number of authorized positions to 271.2. Nine positions were eliminated or not filled in 2009.
For the next biennium, 13 positions are removed from the budget through attrition or elimination.
As proposed for 2010/2011, the city would provide services with nearly the same number of
employees as in 2003.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 24
The table below shows FTE's, excluding elected officials, seasonal, and/or temporary employees:
Full-time Equivalents
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
General Fund 195.7 198.5 198.5 205.5 209 210 210.75 213.45 211.45 193.1 193.1
Other Funds 51.6 52.2 54.6 55.6 56.45 56.45 58.45 60.75 59.75 58.9 58.9
Total Employees 247.3 250.7 253.1 261.1 265.45 266.45 269.2 274.2 271.2 252 252
Other Items of Interest
Health Insurance - Renewal rates remain unpredictable. After an increase of 24.25% in 2008,
the City renewal rate for 2009 was 3%. For 2010 and 2011 an increase of 10% was projected,
which is an impact of $198,000 in 2010 and $225,000 in 2011.
PERA - Increases are mandated by state law. For 2010, city PERA contributions increase
25% or $7,715. The increase includes adjustment for wage increases due to grade steps, and
collective bargaining agreement as well as the PERA rate increase. PERA is eligible for a
special levy which is not subject to levy limits.
Wages - The city has contracts in place with two of the four unions, Clerical, Technical
Professional and Public Works, both of whom are represented by AFSCME. The 2010
agreements call for 2% increases. The budget does include grade step increases for
employees with steps remaining in their pay grade. The collective bargaining agreements
with the Sergeants Union and Police Patrol (LELS) expire December 31, 2009. The proposed
budget has no cost of living increases for non -represented employees or for police personnel.
Street Reconstruction - The budget includes a 3% increase in the levy to the street
reconstruction fund for both 2010 and 2011.
Information Technology - The IT division has completed the bulk of their infrastructure
upgrades and software implementation plans by year-end 2009. This division raises revenue
through allocations to other departments for overhead, maintenance contracts, and software /
hardware replacement. The budget does not include IT allocation rate increases for 2010 and
2011 as newly negotiated maintenance contracts, more efficient technology and improved
systems software will cost less to operate and maintain.
Debt Service - The city will pay off the 2003C street reconstruction bonds in 2009, increasing
potential revenue capacity by approximately $424,000. Due to levy limits, the city would
need to levy a special levy for un -allocated Market Value Homestead Credit (MVHC) to
realize the revenue enhancement. In the past, the city council considered shifting a portion of
retired bond debt payments to shore up other funds such as Street Reconstruction, Capital
Improvement, and Park Replacement to avoid future borrowing to maintain or replace
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 25
existing assets, however unprecedented economic challenges may make this impossible at
this time. In 2010, the city will retire the 2003 Open Space Refunding Bonds, which would
provide another opportunity for revenue enhancement or tax decrease.
Allocations - Following a review of the Central Services Fund and the Facilities Fund, it was
determined that the fund revenues would not be able to sustain the funds for the long term.
Further, there was an allocation imbalance from the General Fund to other budgeted funds.
The budget includes a phase-in of the allocation increases to correct the imbalance and to
ensure enough revenue was collected to sustain the funds indefinitely.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 26
CONCLUSION
The Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget responds to city council goals and is structured to
maintain existing services, focus on improving core services (i.e., street maintenance and
reconstruction), and redirect resources where appropriate. The budget is also cognizant of the
impact to taxpayers.
The remaining portions of this budget document provide greater detail on the funding sources and
uses. We sincerely hope that all interested parties will find this document useful in evaluating the
City's programs and services. Supplemental information can be obtained from the Department of
Administrative Services.
Biennial 2010/2011 Proposed Budget, City of Plymouth, MN Page 27
P:\Organization\Council\Council Staff Reports\2009 Staff Reports\081109\SCM ADM 2A 1 2010 PROJ TAX LEVY -- 2009
Levy:
End of
Levy
General Fund $12,856,138.00 12,895,429.16 $13,040,115.00 $13,040,115.00
PERA $101,012.00 108,727.61 $108,727.61 $108,727.61
Police $9,231,614.00 9,183,834.79 $9,183,834.79 $9,183,834.79
Market Value Homestead Credit (included in
levy limit) - have to levy and then we get
unalloted $510,000.00 589,795.00 $589,795.00 $589,795.00
WILL
NOT
RECEIVE
Market Value Homestead Credit Special
Levy (1/2 of 2008 & all of 2009)$801,650.00
Street Reconstruction $2,458,092.00 2,458,092.00 $2,531,834.76 $2,531,834.76
Recreation Fund $678,497.00 628,497.00 $628,497.00 $628,497.00
Capital Improvement Fund $358,216.00 358,216.00 $368,962.48 $368,962.48
GO 2003B Street Recon Bonds $178,355.63 179,038.13 $179,038.13 $179,038.13 2013
GO 2003C Street Recon Bonds $424,531.43 2009
GO 2004A Public Safety $596,354.06 596,957.81 $596,957.81 $596,957.81 2024
GO 2007A Open Space $255,486.00 255,223.50 $255,223.50 $255,223.50 2023
Total City Tax Capacity Levy $27,648,296.12 5.25%27,253,811.00 -1.43%$27,482,986.08 -0.60%$28,284,636.08 2.30%
City Market Value levies
Activity Center Bonds $432,016.00 428,007.00 $428,007.00 $428,007.00 2013
2003D Open Space Refunding $267,256.50 281,326.50 $281,326.50 $281,326.50 2010
Total City Market Value Levy $699,272.50 0.98%709,333.50 1.44%$709,333.50 1.44%$709,333.50 1.44%
Total City Levy $28,347,568.62 5.14%27,963,144.50 -1.36%$28,192,319.58 -0.55%$28,993,969.58 2.28%
HRA Levy $551,277.00 551,277.00 $551,277.00 $551,277.00
TOTAL LEVY $28,898,845.62 5.14%28,514,421.50 -1.33%$28,743,596.58 -0.54%$29,545,246.58 2.24%
2009 Amended
2010 LEVY
SCENARIO #1 SCENARIO #2
2010 Projected
levy limit w/max market
value special levy (no
add'l bond)
2010 Projected
reduction to 0 increase for
average sale home
SCENARIO #3
2010 Projected
levy limit - no special levy for
market value or add'l bond
Page 1
8/7/2009 2:53 PM
Residential Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Average Home Sale Value 384,400 366,800
Tax Capacity at 1%3,844 3,668
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.625%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $936.04 $939.92 $3.88
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $18.58 $18.86 $0.28
Total Property Tax $954.62 $958.78 $4.16
Market Value Credit ($6.94)($11.10)($4.16)
Total Net Property Tax $947.68 $947.69 $0.01 0.00%
Tax Impact - Reduction in Levy - Scenario #1
Page 1
8/7/2009 2:53 PM
Residential Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Lower Value Concentration to Median Value 264,400 250,000
Tax Capacity at 1%2,644 2,500
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.625%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $643.83 $640.62 -$3.21
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $12.78 $12.86 $0.07
Total Property Tax $656.61 $653.48 -$3.13
Market Value Credit ($35.29)($38.69)($3.40)
Total Net Property Tax $621.32 $614.79 -$6.54 -1.05%
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Median Value 293,100 279,400
Tax Capacity at 1%2,931 2,794
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.625%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $713.72 $715.96 $2.24
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $14.17 $14.37 $0.20
Total Property Tax $727.89 $730.33 $2.44
Market Value Credit ($28.51)($31.75)($3.24)
Total Net Property Tax $699.38 $698.58 -$0.79 -0.11%
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Higher Value Concentration to Median Value 419,000 400,000
Tax Capacity at 1%4,190 4,000
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.625%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $1,020.29 $1,025.00 $4.71
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $20.26 $20.57 $0.31
Total Property Tax $1,040.55 $1,045.57 $5.02
Market Value Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Total Net Property Tax $1,040.55 $1,045.57 $5.02 0.48%
Tax Impact - Reduction in Levy - Scenario # 1
Page 2
8/7/2009 2:53 PM
Commercial Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Combined City & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.625%
On a $1,000,000 Property $1,051,000 $1,000,000
Tax Capacity 20,270 19,250
less: Fiscal Disparity contribution rate 0.371552 0.371552
Net Tax Capacity 12,739 12,098
Total Property Tax $3,102 $3,100 -$1.93 -0.06%
Page 3
8/7/2009 2:55 PM
Residential Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Average Home Sale Value 384,400 366,800
Tax Capacity at 1%3,844 3,668
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.855%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $936.04 $948.37 $12.33
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $18.58 $18.86 $0.28
Total Property Tax $954.62 $967.23 $12.61
Market Value Credit ($6.94)($11.10)($4.16)
Total Net Property Tax $947.68 $956.13 $8.45 0.89%
Tax Impact - max levy - no market value credit special levy or add'l bond levy -
Scenario #2
Page 1
8/7/2009 2:55 PM
Residential Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Lower Value Concentration to Median Value 264,400 250,000
Tax Capacity at 1%2,644 2,500
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.855%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $643.83 $646.38 $2.55
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $12.78 $12.86 $0.07
Total Property Tax $656.61 $659.23 $2.62
Market Value Credit ($35.29)($38.69)($3.40)
Total Net Property Tax $621.32 $620.54 -$0.78 -0.13%
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Median Value 293,100 279,400
Tax Capacity at 1%2,931 2,794
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.855%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $713.72 $722.39 $8.68
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $14.17 $14.37 $0.20
Total Property Tax $727.89 $736.76 $8.88
Market Value Credit ($28.51)($31.75)($3.24)
Total Net Property Tax $699.38 $705.01 $5.64 0.81%
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Higher Concentration to Median Value 419,000 400,000
Tax Capacity at 1%4,190 4,000
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.855%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $1,020.29 $1,034.21 $13.92
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $20.26 $20.57 $0.31
Total Property Tax $1,040.55 $1,054.78 $14.23
Market Value Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Total Net Property Tax $1,040.55 $1,054.78 $14.23 1.37%
Tax Impact - max levy - no market value credit special levy or add'l bond levy -
Scenario #2
Page 2
8/7/2009 2:55 PM
Commercial Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Combined City & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%25.855%
On a $1,000,000 Property $1,051,000 $1,000,000
Tax Capacity 20,270 19,250
less: Fiscal Disparity contribution rate 0.371552 0.371552
Net Tax Capacity 12,739 12,098
Total Property Tax $3,102 $3,128 $25.92 0.84%
Page 3
8/7/2009 2:55 PM
Residential Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Average Home Sale Value 384,400 366,800
Tax Capacity at 1%3,844 3,668
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%26.661%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $936.04 $977.91 $41.87
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $18.58 $18.86 $0.28
Total Property Tax $954.62 $996.77 $42.15
Market Value Credit ($6.94)($11.10)($4.16)
Total Net Property Tax $947.68 $985.67 $37.99 4.01%
Tax Impact - market value credit maximum special levy - Scenario # 3
Page 1
8/7/2009 2:55 PM
Residential Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Lower Value Concentration to Median Value 264,400 250,000
Tax Capacity at 1%2,644 2,500
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%26.661%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $643.83 $666.51 $22.68
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $12.78 $12.86 $0.07
Total Property Tax $656.61 $679.37 $22.76
Market Value Credit ($35.29)($38.69)($3.40)
Total Net Property Tax $621.32 $640.68 $19.36 3.12%
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Median Value 293,100 279,400
Tax Capacity at 1%2,931 2,794
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%26.661%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $713.72 $744.90 $31.18
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $14.17 $14.37 $0.20
Total Property Tax $727.89 $759.26 $31.38
Market Value Credit ($28.51)($31.75)($3.24)
Total Net Property Tax $699.38 $727.52 $28.14 4.02%
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Higher Value Concentration to Median Value 419,000 400,000
Tax Capacity at 1%4,190 4,000
Combined City Tax & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%26.661%
Total City & Market Value Property Tax $1,020.29 $1,066.42 $46.13
HRA Tax Capacity Rate 0.483%0.514%
HRA Property Tax $20.26 $20.57 $0.31
Total Property Tax $1,040.55 $1,086.99 $46.44
Market Value Credit $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
Total Net Property Tax $1,040.55 $1,086.99 $46.44 4.46%
Tax Impact - market value credit maximum special levy - Scenario # 3
Page 2
8/7/2009 2:55 PM
Commercial Property
Estimated Estimated Percentage
2009 2010 Increase Increase
Combined City & Market Value Tax Rate 24.351%26.661%
On a $1,000,000 Property $1,051,000 $1,000,000
Tax Capacity 20,270 19,250
less: Fiscal Disparity contribution rate 0.371552 0.371552
Net Tax Capacity 12,739 12,098
Total Property Tax $3,102 $3,225 $123.35 3.98%
Page 3
MEMO
PLYMOUTH PARKS & RECREATION
3400 PLYMOUTH BLVD, PLYMOUTH, MN 55447
DATE: August 21, 2009
TO: Laurie Ahrens, City Manager
REVIEWED BY: Eric Blank, Director Parks and Recreation; Diane Evans, Superintendant of
Recreation
FROM: Erica Chua, Recreation Supervisor
SUBJECT: Adaptive recreation update of REACH for Resources services
HISTORY
Under the Americans for Disabilities Act (ADA), the City is required to provide inclusion services.
The City is not required to provide adaptive programming. Inclusion services provide
participants with a disability reasonable accommodations to allow their participation in
mainstream programming. An accommodation is "reasonable" when it does not result in a
fundamental alteration in the nature of the activity as defined by the ADA. Plymouth currently
provides inclusion services in house, it does not pay a contractor for these services. Adaptive
services include programming designed specifically for individuals with disabilities. These
programs are not mainstream and typically have a higher staff to participant ratio. The City
currently contracts with REACH for Resources to provide adaptive programming.
REACH for Resources is a non-profit organization that the City has contracted with to provide
adaptive recreation opportunities for residents since 1988. REACH was founded in 1980 and
has been serving communities for 28 years. In addition to adaptive recreation services REACH
also provides inclusion services, mental health services, education and advocacy along with
information and referral services. The primary populations that REACH serves are adults with
developmental disabilities such as downs syndrome, cerebral palsy, mental retardation and
individuals from group homes that cannot participate in programming independently or require
specialized attention.
Page 1
Plymouth currently pays $17,442 (2009) in contractual fees to REACH for a membership in the
eight city REACH consortium for adaptive programming. Six of the eight member cities pay an
additional fee for inclusion services. REACH consortium member cities include: Brooklyn Park,
Brooklyn Center, Crystal, Golden Valley, Maple Grove, New Hope, Robbinsdale and Plymouth.
The consortium membership fee provides Plymouth residents the following benefits: priority
registration and classification as residents. Resident classification affords Plymouth
participants a $5 discount per program. Plymouth participants still pay a fee for REACH
programs. Listed below is an example of a REACH program and price structure.
KID -FU
Martial Arts programs for kids! Come and learn the moves of Jackie Chan.
Location: Bass Lake Shelter, 5450 Northwest Blvd, Plymouth
Dates: April
2nd —
May
21St
Time: Thursdays, 6:00 -6:45
Fee: $56 residents, $64 non-residents
CONCERNS
The current REACH contract brings up four major concerns; high cost of REACH services, REACH
program quality and their interaction with the City, duplication of services currently provided in
the area and the possible dissolution of the REACH consortium due to participating cities
withdrawing.
The high cost to provide a small discount for REACH programming is making it increasingly
difficult to defend Plymouth's participation in the eight city consortium. The attendance for
REACH programming has fluctuated over the past three years, but the cost of REACH services
has continued to rise. The chart below illustrates the number of participants and the cost of
the programs offered by REACH.
Yearly REACH budget numbers and cost
Page 2
Youth Adults Total program Average number of City's cost per
participations programs participants Cost participant
per year per year by individual per program
2005 24 33 252 4 14,712.00 58.38
2006 47 100 233 1 14,646.96 62.86
2007 N/A N/A 238 N/A 16,309.18 68.53
2008 24 58 308 4 17,442.40 56.63
2009 N/A N/A 59 thus far N/A 17,442.40 N/A
winter numbers only) Frozen from 2008
17,965.67 (proposed)
Page 2
The cost of programming has risen almost $3,000 in the last three years, and REACH is
providing the same programming with 75 more participants. Without freezing the current
consortium membership fee there would have been an estimated $1,000 increase for 2009.
We have negotiated a lower fee for 2010 at $10,000. This fee is still too high for services
provided.
The high cost for REACH services is not justified by the quality of their programming. REACH
offers approximately eighteen programs each quarter and many of these programs have not
changed in more than five years. In comparison, Plymouth programmers offer approximately
30 or more programs each quarter. Due to a low number of program offerings, there are not
many programs offered in the City of Plymouth, which forces participants to travel in order to
participate in REACH programming. Currently, there are 82 Plymouth residents, based on 2008
numbers (24 youth and 58 adults) that are taking advantage of the REACH programs and there
is only one program offered by REACH that takes place in Plymouth. In addition REACH does
not provide the City with up to date financial and participant information on a monthly basis,
which makes it difficult to track progress and verify information. REACH provides financial and
participation information on a quarterly basis after the programs have been completed.
There are four other adaptive service providers in the Plymouth area. Contracting with REACH
is duplicating existing services. As you can see from the attached grid, all four local adaptive
options provide adult programming, and two of them provide youth programming. The
majority of the participants with REACH are adults that would have programming opportunities
with Windows of Opportunity through the Robbinsdale School District, Project SOAR through
the Hopkins, Minnetonka, St. Louis Park and Wayzata school districts, Courage Center located in
Golden Valley and ARLE through the Parks and Recreation departments of Bloomington, Eden
Prairie, Edina and Richfield. Both ARLE and the Courage Center also offer youth programming
opportunities. In addition to these options, the City has offered adaptive programming
contractually through MacPhail Center for Music and Upstream Arts. The City also has an art
instructor on staff that is able to provide adaptive programming.
The eight city consortium has been meeting over the past year to determine how to move
forward with REACH due to economic concerns. Over the course of the past year four of the
eight cities have expressed interest in withdrawing from the consortium or only contracting for
inclusion services. If these cities do opt to withdraw, the cost of adaptive services could rise
substantially.
Page 3
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
Based on the number of alternative options available to Plymouth residents with adaptive
needs and the other concerns surrounding the REACH consortium membership, there are two
options for your consideration:
1. Continue to contract with REACH at the estimated rate of $10,000, or a higher rate that
will most likely be in place for 2010 due to lower community consortium involvement
2. Withdraw from the REACH consortium and direct participants to other local adaptive
programming options as well as provide some adaptive programming through Plymouth
Parks and Recreation
Enclosed: Adaptive Services grid
Page 4
ADAPTIVE SERVICES
We currently contract with Reach for Resources at an annual cost to the city of $17,000, this fee helps to subsidize REACH programs. As a Reach member city our
residents get a $5 discount on programs along with a priority registration date over non Reach members. Below are other options.
SERVICE PROVIDER CITY COMMENTS YOUTH I PROGRAMS ADULT PROGRAMS CONTACT INFO. COST TO USER
Reach for Resources 17,000 We pay a consortium fee for Yes Bowling, dances, Yes Bowling, Social reachforresources.org Program costs
year round yearly fee our participants to receive a $5 trips, kid fu, active nights, on the range from $5 -
programming) discount per program. adventures, town programs, Becca Stenzel 350 for
yoga, 952-988-4176 res/non-res fee
structure. As a
NARC member,
Windows of no cost to Windows of Opporunity serves Ages trips, plays, arts and Yes trips, plays, arts ced.rdale.com Program costs
Opportunity the city the Robbinsdale School District 16-18 crafts, computer and crafts, range from
year round 281: New Hope, Brooklyn Park, classes, bike outings, computer classes, AI Ickler Exec Dir. 5-$55 flat fee - no
programming) Brooklyn Center, Crystal, bowling special bike outings, AI_lckler@rdale.org res/non res rates
Golden Valley, Plymouth, events bowling special
763-504-8028
Robbinsdale events
Project SOAR no cost to Project SOAR serves four No Yes trips, dances, minnetonkacommun Program costs
year round the city school districts: Hopkins, BINGO, arts, ityed.org range from
programming) Minnetonka, St. Louis Park and crafts, cooking Myra Wicklacz 5-$19 flat fee- no
Wayzata computer classes 952-401-6898 res/non res rates
Courage Center no cost to They have locations in Yes camps, swim classes, Yes swim classes, couragecenter.org Program costs
year round the city Burnsville, Golden Valley, driving instruction, sports, support range from
programming) Forest Lake and Stillwater sports, support groups, work and 763-520-0520 5-$138 flat fee -
focuses on physical groups career skills no res/non res
disabilities, but rates
serves those on the
spectrum and
cognitive delays
Adaptive Recreation no cost to ARLE is a collaboration with the Yes Softball, Fishing, Yes walking club, ci.bloomington.mn.0 Program costs
and Learning the city Park and Rec Depts of Lawn Games, softball, water s range from
Exchange Bloomington, Eden Prairie, MacPhail Music aerobics, disc golf, 6-$138 flat fee -
year round Edina and Richfield and classes, Garden Club, trips, art and no res/non res
programming) Community Ed of Bloomington water aerobics, music classes, rates
They hold programs in these Saturday night out garden club
host cities
Page 1
rp) City of
Plymouth
Adding Quality to Life
SPECIAL
COUNCIL MEETING
To:
Prepared by:
August 25, 2009 Reviewed by:
Item:
1. ACTION REQUESTED:
Agenda
Number:
Laurie Ahrens, City Manager
Doran Cote, Director of Public Works
2010 and 2011 Budget — Metropolitan Council Transit
Funding
Provide staff direction for 2010 and 2011 budget preparation.
2. BACKGROUND:
The Metropolitan Council staff has determined that the $7,000,000 gap in state funding for transit
over the 2010-2011 biennium will be covered by withholding the discretionary or supplemental
Motor Vehicle Sales Tax (MVST) from the suburban transit providers from July 2009 through 2011.
Based upon the state's MVST forecast, this withholding creates an $18.5 million savings for
Metropolitan Council ($8.4 million in 2009 and another $10.11 million in 2010) and additional
savings in 2011.
In a letter written to Mayor Slavik dated August 5, 2008, Tom Weaver, Metropolitan Council
Regional Administrator offered several explanations for staff withdrawing funds dedicated to
suburban transit, one of which is that the suburban transit providers have saved money for operations
and capital expenses beyond what Metro Transit staff has reserved. Metropolitan Council staff is
withholding the discretionary MVST and the supplemental (general fund) which we have previously
received, in order to lower the reserve funds of the suburban providers and enabling Metropolitan
Council to balance their budget.
Staff is currently working with our transit partners to develop a consensus of funding priorities and
policies. Philosophies vary between the Metro Transit staff, Metropolitan Council staff and
suburban transit providers. The cities and boards reserve funds for planned operating and capital
expenses and emergency contingencies. The Plymouth Transit Fund has a written guideline of
maintaining one year of operating funds in reserve. Metropolitan Council tends to spend down their
reserves. Metropolitan Council and Metro Transit assume suburban transit providers only use their
reserve funds for operating expenses.
Plymouth transit revenue comes from Motor Vehicle Sales Tax (MVST), Metro Transit fare
reimbursement, the State General Fund, and National Transit Database Funds. In February 2009, the
State forecast a decrease in MVST revenue for 2009, 2010 and 2011. Plymouth received $3,390,000
in MVST in 2008. Metropolitan Council estimates that Plymouth will receive $2.8 million in MVST
Page 1
Page 1
2009 and $2.3 million in 2010 and 2011. Plymouth received $669,000 in supplemental MVST in
2008 and will receive an estimated $500,000 in supplemental MVST in 2009. Plymouth received
283,000 from the State General Fund in 2008. In 2008 and 2009, Metropolitan Council withheld
fare reimbursements and MVST payments for eight months without notice.
The combined elimination of revenue from the State General Fund and the supplemental MVST
means an approximate loss of $780,000 in 2010 and again in 2011. In addition, there is an
anticipated reduction of base MVST revenue and fare revenue due low sales of new vehicles and to
lower ridership.
In addition to the revenue changes, Metro Transit proposes to reallocate the fare reimbursement
based on actual revenue collections for Upass, Metropass and College Pass effective January 1,
2010. Revenue allocation for other fare media (stored value cards and 31 -day passes) will remain
unchanged. This revenue allocation is based on originating boarding and assumes continued
regional transfer reciprocity. For example, Plymouth Metrolink would not receive fare
reimbursement for a Upass transferring from downtown to Plymouth. Plymouth would be
reimbursed for fare if a passenger boards in Plymouth to disembark downtown and transfer to
another provider. Plymouth would only receive the amount from passenger boardings originating in
Plymouth. During the first six months of 2009, Plymouth would have lost an estimated $150,000 of
fare reimbursement.
In anticipation of these revenue reductions, the City Council approved increased efficiencies and
reduction of transit services. These changes will be effective December 14, 2009. These changes
will create an annual savings of $405,000, however this savings does not result in a reduction in the
cost of transit services from 2009 to 2010 since that cost was conservatively expected to increase
over $600,000. The net increase in transit service costs is $200,000.
3. BUDGET IMPACT:
The proposed 2010 and 2011 Transit budget has been prepared contemplating the above
described revenue reductions, fare redistribution and service reductions and resulting cost
reduction. The budget includes approximately $1,800,000 of revenue from reserves in both
2010 and 2011 in order to balance the budgets. Continued use of reserves at this magnitude
will cause the fund balance to be depleted by 2012.
4. ATTACHMENTS:
Page 2
Page 2
GENERAL FUND BUDGETED ALLOCATIONS - YEARS 2003 THROUGH 2009
P:\Organization\Council\Council Staff Reports\2009 Staff Reports\082509\10 SCM 2A 7 Allocations.xlsx
2003 '03-'04 2004 '04-'05 2005 '05-'06 2006 '06-'07 2007 '07-'08 2008 '08-'09
Annual %Annual %Annual %Annual %Annual %Annual %
Budget Amount Increase Budget Amount Increase Budget Amount Increase Budget Amount Increase Budget Amount Increase Budget Amount Increase
Allocations
9000-100 Photocopying $112,076.00 2.94%$115,371.00 0.00%$115,371.00 0.00%$115,371.00 -24.05%$87,630.00 3.00%$90,259.00 3.00%
9000-101 Information Technology $955,738.00
7.82%
1,030,499.00
5.50%
1,087,223.00
7.39%
1,167,598.00
4.57%
1,220,929.00
15.50%
1,031,732.00
2.59%
9000-102 Facilities Management $520,181.00 11.41%$579,521.00 32.63%$768,647.00 5.43%$810,365.00 0.17%$811,778.00 5.00%$852,367.00 5.00%
9000-104 Mobile Phone $43,449.00 19.28%$51,825.00 2.25%$52,990.00 51.81%$80,445.00 3.00%
9000-105 Security $51,011.00 14.69%$58,507.00 0.03%
9000-106 Telephone $59,009.00 83.05%$108,018.00 2.05%
9000-108 Internal Rental Charges $1,261,829.00
3.95%
1,311,626.00
2.25%
1,341,168.00
3.95%
1,394,118.00
3.92%
1,448,741.00
3.07%
1,404,197.00
12.70%
Total Allocations:$2,849,824.00 6.57%$3,037,017.00 10.50%$3,355,858.00 5.47%$3,539,277.00 5.45%$3,732,088.00 -2.86%$3,625,525.00 7.03%
ALLOCATION % CHANGE
9000-100 Photocopying -17%
9000-101 Information Technology 11%
9000-102 Facilities Management 72%
9000-108 Internal Rental Charges 25%
Central Equipment)
OVERALL PERCENTAGE CHANGE FROM 2003 - 2009
Page 1
GENERAL FUND BUDGETED ALLOCATIONS - YEARS 2003 THROUGH 2009
P:\Organization\Council\Council Staff Reports\2009 Staff Reports\082509\10 SCM 2A 7 Allocations.xlsx
Allocations
9000-100 Photocopying
9000-101 Information Technology
9000-102 Facilities Management
9000-104 Mobile Phone
9000-105 Security
9000-106 Telephone
9000-108 Internal Rental Charges
Total Allocations:
ALLOCATION
9000-100 Photocopying
9000-101 Information Technology
9000-102 Facilities Management
9000-108 Internal Rental Charges
Central Equipment)
OVERALL PERCENTAGE CH
2009
Annual
Budget Amount
92,968.00
1,058,423.00
894,987.00
82,861.00
58,525.00
110,235.00
1,582,470.00
3,880,469.00
Page 2
rp) City of
Plymouth
Adding QoaWy to Life
REGULAR
COUNCIL MEETING
August 25, 2009
Agenda BNumber:
To: Mayor and City Council
Prepared by: Laurie Ahrens, City Manager
Item: Set Future Study Sessions
1. ACTION REQUESTED:
Review the pending study session topics list and set study sessions or amend the topics list if desired.
Attached is the list of pending study session topics, as well as calendars to assist in scheduling.
Page 1
Pending Study Session Topics
at least 3 Council members have approved the following study items on the list)
Joint meeting with Environmental Quality Committee (fall)
Discuss Leap -Frog Development and History of Temporary/Private Lift
Stations
Other requests for study session topics:
Update with the City Manager (fall)
Meet with prosecutor for update (fall) (TB)
Consider incentives to encourage tree preservation
Lake sediment deltas report
Architectural guidelines (fall)
Page 2
vPlymouth
Adding Quality to Life
September 2009
Modified on 08114109
Page 3
1 5:00 PM 2 6:00 PM 3 7:00 PM 4 5
SPECIAL COUNCIL HRA SPECIAL HUMAN RIGHTS
MEETING MEETING COMMISSION
Medicine Lake Room Medicine Lake Room MEETING
Budget Study Session Parkers Lake Room
7:00 PM
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
6 7 8 9 10 11 127:00 PM 7:00 PM 7:00 PM Autumn
REGULAR COUNCIL ENVIRONMENTAL PARK % REC Art Fair
MEETING QUALITY ADVISORY COM- Parkers Lake
LABOR DAY Council Chambers COMMITTEE MISSION (PRAC)
EQC) MEETING MEETING
CITY OFFICES Council Chambers Plymouth
CLOSED Ice Center
13 14 15 16 7:00 PM 17 18 19
PLANNING
COMMISSION
MEETING
Council Chambers
ROSH HASHANAH
Begins at Sunset
20 21 22 2 3 2 4 25 26
7:00 PM 7:00 PM 7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL PLYMOUTH HRA MEETING 1:00 PM
MEETING ADVISORY Medicine Lake Room Plymouth On
Council Chambers COMMITTEE ON
Parade Celebration
City Center Area
TRANSIT (PACT)
MEETING
Medicine Lake
Room A
27 28 29 30
YOM KIPPUR
Begins at Sunset
Modified on 08114109
Page 3
vPlymouth
Adding Quality to Life
October 2009
Modified on 08114109
Page 4
1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
6:30-8:30 PM 7:00 PM 7:00 PM
Volunteer PLANNING PARK ft REC 12:00-4:00 PM
Recognition Event COMMISSION ADVISORY Fire Dept.
Plymouth Creek MEETING COMMISSION Open House
Center Council Chambers PRAC) MEETING Fire Station III
Plymouth Creek
Center
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
7:00 PM 7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL ENVIRONMENTAL
MEETING QUALITY
COLUMBUS DAY
Council Chambers COMMITTEE
Observed EQC) MEETING
Council Chambers
PLYMOUTH PUBLIC
WORKS DIVISION
CLOSED
18 19 20 7:00 PM21 22 23 24PLANNING7:00 PM
COMMISSION HRA MEETING
MEETING Medicine Lake Room
Council Chambers
7:00 PM
PLYMOUTH
ADVISORY
COMMITTEE ON
TRANSIT (PACT)
MEETING
Medicine Lake
25 26 27 28 29 30 317:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL 5:30-8:30 PM
MEETING Halloween on
Council Chambers the Creek
Plymouth Creek
Center
Modified on 08114109
Page 4
vPlymouth November 2009
Adding Quality to Life
1 2 3 4 5 6 7Daylight7:00 PM 7:00 PM
Savings PLANNING HUMAN RIGHTSEnds
Set Clocks Back COMMISSION COMMISSION
1 Hour MEETING MEETING
Council Chambers Parkers Lake Room
8 9 10 11 12 7:00 PM 13 147:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL PARK Fr REC
MEETING ADVISORY COM -
Council Chambers VETERANS DAY MISSION (PRAC)
Observed MEETING
Council Chambers
CITY OFFICES
CLOSED
15 16 17 18 7:00 PM 19 7:00 PM 20 21
PLANNING
COMMISSION HRA MEETING
MEETING Medicine Lake Room
Council Chambers
7:00 PM
ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY
COMMITTEE (EQC)
MEETING
Medicine Lake Room
22 23 24 25 26 27 287:00 PM 7:00 PM
REGULAR COUNCIL PLYMOUTH ADVISOR
MEETING COMMITTEE ON
Council Chambers TRANSIT (PACT) THANKSGIVING THANKSGIVING
MEETING HOLIDAY HOLIDAY
Medicine Lake Room
CITY OFFICES CITY OFFICES
CLOSED CLOSED
29 30
F-
Page 5